John
> On Tue, 19 Oct 1999 20:03:29 +0100, "Lawrence Edwards"
> >It's interesting you raise the false start issue - where Mikka got away
with
> >it because he didn't gain an advantage (apart perhaps from surprising the
> >rest of the grid.) I think that the fact Ferrari didn't gain any
significant
> >advantage is pertinent again with the bodywork issue. Also, several
drivers
> >have driven through chicanes this year, in fact I think Damon Hill is one
of
> >the worst. They have got away with it so long as they didn't gain an
> >advantage. The same rule should apply for the bodywork infringement IMO.
> The difference there is in proving it - you can easily see that Mika
> had no advantage, and the stopwatch shows what advantage cutting a
> chicane proffers - smart drivers slow down a touch to ensure that
> sector time is slower than normal. In addition the stewards have the
> luxury of time to deliberate and a range of options as a penalty.
Accepted, it may be difficult or even impossible to prove that Ferrari
gained no significant advantage but I honestly believe that 1cm of barge
board couldn't make any significant difference. The wear on the Ferrari
tyres seems to be more of a moot point however. I have to admit to not
knowing what the rules say, I would be interested to know if they specify
what the punishment is for having over-size body work. If the rules
specifically say that dq is the only consequence then I would have to agree
with you that Ferrari should be excluded.
What about when James Hunt had his dq overturned and went on to win the
championship? Surely the governing body does have the option - or are you
just saying that any other decision would be impossible morally?
It's not just Bernie's Wallet that is bulging. I think that all of the big
teams have gained massively from Bernie's antics. Bernie seems to me to have
been very clever in sharing the money around just enough to keep his power
base happy.
I would enjoy a show down in Suzuka but I agree that the long term interests
of the sport are more important.
They can still tell Ron where to go :-)
Lawrence