rec.autos.simulators

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

Steve Smit

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Steve Smit » Sun, 26 Jan 2003 22:00:41

Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
CART Precision Racing, anyone?


Vintoo

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Vintoo » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 00:14:51

NONONONONONONONO! NOT MORE TALK ABOUT CART!

AAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH!

Vintook


> Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
> CART Precision Racing, anyone?



> > If it happens this could mean good things for Papy's racing sims.

> > http://www.gamepro.com/lofi/article.cfm?article_id=27923

Fillyourboot

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Fillyourboot » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 00:20:40

"Steve Smith" ...

Sure, CPR wasn't great. But if M$ are to give Papy a lifeline then i can see
the sense in that - provided they're allowed to do their own thing without
interference from 'upstairs' or buying key team members to work on train
sims.

__
Si.

David G Fishe

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by David G Fishe » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 05:46:07

MS has put out a lot of excellent racing games.

David G Fisher


> Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
> CART Precision Racing, anyone?



> > If it happens this could mean good things for Papy's racing sims.

> > http://www.gamepro.com/lofi/article.cfm?article_id=27923

Steve Smit

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Steve Smit » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 06:14:29

The Ultimate Microsoft Anecdote is what they've done to sales of the new BMW
7-Series.  My jaw dropped when I heard BMW boasting that the GUI in the next
7-Series would be "powered by" Windows.  Now the votes are in: everybody
hates it - the critics, the owners - everybody.  Not only is it impossible
to decipher, it has a learning curve steeper than the North Face.  And once
you think you've got it handled, it exhibits all the horrors we FDUs have
hated it for since the previous century.  One woman complained the
(alledgedly) voice-controlled radio would come on for no reason, at top
volume.  The only way it could be turned off was to pull over, turn off the
ignition, wait 10 seconds, then restart the car.  I don't want these people
making my operating system, I don't want them mucking about with my car, and
I sure as hell don't want them messing with my simulations!



> MS has put out a lot of excellent racing games.

> David G Fisher



> > Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
> > CART Precision Racing, anyone?



> > > If it happens this could mean good things for Papy's racing sims.

> > > http://www.gamepro.com/lofi/article.cfm?article_id=27923

Positive

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Positive » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 06:27:12

Yes and I suspect MS designed every aspect of it!
BMW didn't have any say at all...

Put the blaim where it belongs please.


Gerry Aitke

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Gerry Aitke » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 06:59:06


> MS has put out a lot of excellent racing games.

CPR? Yeah right!! You would know an excellent racing sim if you caught
it screwing your girlfriend!
Goy Larse

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Goy Larse » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 11:20:39


> Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
> CART Precision Racing, anyone?

Does the name MS Flight Simulator mean anything to you, or MS Train
Simulator ?

They have a huge and loyal following, even some former regulars from the
sim racing scene has moved over to the trains, and guess what, they're
highly moddable as well, in fact, they're just about everything we wish
our racing sims could be, not to mention that MS knows how to sell
stuff, meaning it would stand a chance to survive and evolve

Online ***....well, we have XboX live which I hear is pretty good and
I've played more AOE and AOE2 on "The Zone" than I like to remember,
CFSx works pretty well too I've been told

I'm all for giving MS a shot at it, in fact, I can hardly see a downside
to it, after all, all we've seen from Papy the last 4-5 years are Nascar
sims and little to no support for 3rd party add on's, if they want to
make a MS Race Car Simulator where you buy the main program and then buy
all sorts of after market add on's later on....hang on, where have I
heard that idea before

Of course, this is all just MHO

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
--Groucho Marx--

mach

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by mach » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 15:41:49



>> Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
>> CART Precision Racing, anyone?

>Does the name MS Flight Simulator mean anything to you, or MS Train
>Simulator ?

>They have a huge and loyal following, even some former regulars from the
>sim racing scene has moved over to the trains, and guess what, they're
>highly moddable as well, in fact, they're just about everything we wish
>our racing sims could be, not to mention that MS knows how to sell
>stuff, meaning it would stand a chance to survive and evolve

I can hardly imagine an online train race... Somehow it would be really
dumb, with the things forced to always move on the tracks only. I doubt
anyone would want a racing simulation like that. Or a racing simulation
where maybe you see all the details of the other cars, but there is no
scenery around the track, only several thousand feet away...

--
__________   ____---____       Marco Antonio  Checa  Funcke
\_________D /-/---_----'      Santiago de Surco, Lima, Peru
       _H__/_/                      http://machf.tripod.com
      '-_____|(    

remove the "no_me_j." and "sons.of." parts before replying

Joachim Trens

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Joachim Trens » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 19:08:56

Because Microsoft has a history of sucessfully
supporting and promoting online ***? :-)

Achim


Steve Smit

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Steve Smit » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 20:56:06

I've been flying MS FS since 1982.  The new MS CFS is absolutely terrible.
So much for experience/history/reputation.



> > Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
> > CART Precision Racing, anyone?

> Does the name MS Flight Simulator mean anything to you, or MS Train
> Simulator ?

> They have a huge and loyal following, even some former regulars from the
> sim racing scene has moved over to the trains, and guess what, they're
> highly moddable as well, in fact, they're just about everything we wish
> our racing sims could be, not to mention that MS knows how to sell
> stuff, meaning it would stand a chance to survive and evolve

> Online ***....well, we have XboX live which I hear is pretty good and
> I've played more AOE and AOE2 on "The Zone" than I like to remember,
> CFSx works pretty well too I've been told

> I'm all for giving MS a shot at it, in fact, I can hardly see a downside
> to it, after all, all we've seen from Papy the last 4-5 years are Nascar
> sims and little to no support for 3rd party add on's, if they want to
> make a MS Race Car Simulator where you buy the main program and then buy
> all sorts of after market add on's later on....hang on, where have I
> heard that idea before

> Of course, this is all just MHO

> Beers and cheers
> (uncle) Goy

> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> "A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
> --Groucho Marx--

Steve Smit

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Steve Smit » Mon, 27 Jan 2003 21:05:06

I also just finished a piece on the Xbox vs. the PS2 for Motor Trend
magazine: "Car Games for Car Guys."  My conclusion: MS has nothing to offer
car guys (I'm talking abt. real-world car guys, not arcade-sim jockeys).
Read it in the March issue (I think).  I shudder to think how they might
handle another road-racing simulation.  (BTW, I liked Monster Truck Madness
and was unhappy when they walked away from the franchise.  I never thought
much of Midtown Madness, but MM3 for the Xbox sure looks purty.  I liked
their offroad bike sim and wondered why they abandoned that, too.  I've had
MS Train Simulator for a year - it just lays there.   I even thought CPR
showed some promise, but MS doesn't have any more commitment to what it
starts than Anna Nicole Smith...no relation.)



> > Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?
> > CART Precision Racing, anyone?

> Does the name MS Flight Simulator mean anything to you, or MS Train
> Simulator ?

> They have a huge and loyal following, even some former regulars from the
> sim racing scene has moved over to the trains, and guess what, they're
> highly moddable as well, in fact, they're just about everything we wish
> our racing sims could be, not to mention that MS knows how to sell
> stuff, meaning it would stand a chance to survive and evolve

> Online ***....well, we have XboX live which I hear is pretty good and
> I've played more AOE and AOE2 on "The Zone" than I like to remember,
> CFSx works pretty well too I've been told

> I'm all for giving MS a shot at it, in fact, I can hardly see a downside
> to it, after all, all we've seen from Papy the last 4-5 years are Nascar
> sims and little to no support for 3rd party add on's, if they want to
> make a MS Race Car Simulator where you buy the main program and then buy
> all sorts of after market add on's later on....hang on, where have I
> heard that idea before

> Of course, this is all just MHO

> Beers and cheers
> (uncle) Goy

> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> "A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
> --Groucho Marx--

Dave Henri

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Dave Henri » Tue, 28 Jan 2003 00:14:17



>> Erm, Steve - why exactly would that mean "good things" for racing sims?


99765.news.dfncis.de:

   Well that was one of my biggest gripes with Motorcross Madness 1&2.  
Here you had this huge online enviroment, the msn *** zone(or whatever
they call it..been so long I have forgotten the exact name.)  and they
limit the races to 4 or 6 racers.  MAN!  Could you imagine what a rush a
good supercross sim would be at the start?  approximentally 30 riders all
charging for the same spot?  Mayhem, drama...RACING.  But with 6 guys...you
all just spread out and run hotlaps.
dave henrie

Steve Smit

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Steve Smit » Tue, 28 Jan 2003 00:18:54

No, but at least they worked.


> On Sat, 25 Jan 2003 21:14:29 GMT, "Steve Smith"

> >The Ultimate Microsoft Anecdote is what they've done to sales of the new
BMW
> >7-Series.  My jaw dropped when I heard BMW boasting that the GUI in the
next
> >7-Series would be "powered by" Windows.  Now the votes are in: everybody
> >hates it - the critics, the owners - everybody.  Not only is it
impossible
> >to decipher, it has a learning curve steeper than the North Face.  And
once
> >you think you've got it handled, it exhibits all the horrors we FDUs have
> >hated it for since the previous century.  One woman complained the
> >(alledgedly) voice-controlled radio would come on for no reason, at top
> >volume.  The only way it could be turned off was to pull over, turn off
the
> >ignition, wait 10 seconds, then restart the car.  I don't want these
people
> >making my operating system, I don't want them mucking about with my car,
and
> >I sure as hell don't want them messing with my simulations!

> What a bunch of***weeds. I suppose you all think Papy doing all
> those Nascar sims for years was real innovative?

Goy Larse

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Goy Larse » Tue, 28 Jan 2003 03:08:29


> I also just finished a piece on the Xbox vs. the PS2 for Motor Trend
> magazine: "Car Games for Car Guys."  My conclusion: MS has nothing to offer
> car guys (I'm talking abt. real-world car guys, not arcade-sim jockeys).
> Read it in the March issue (I think).  I shudder to think how they might
> handle another road-racing simulation.  (BTW, I liked Monster Truck Madness
> and was unhappy when they walked away from the franchise.  I never thought
> much of Midtown Madness, but MM3 for the Xbox sure looks purty.  I liked
> their offroad bike sim and wondered why they abandoned that, too.  I've had
> MS Train Simulator for a year - it just lays there.   I even thought CPR
> showed some promise, but MS doesn't have any more commitment to what it
> starts than Anna Nicole Smith...no relation.)

I'm sorry but I have to disagree, I'd say that MS commits to anything
that makes them money, or draws in customers so that other parts of
their company makes money

If anyone can make a profit out f a race car simulator of some sorts,
it's Bill G and his band of merry men, in fact, I'd say if a company
like MS doesn't commit to racing sims soon, the genre will forever be
doomed to be made by a small number of enthusiast for a small number of
enthusiasts and we can all sit here and cry "Cart, GPL2 or AussieV8's"
to our heart's content

I'll take the MS FS model any day, it's a decent FS and you can do just
about anything with it as far as adding new scenery (tracks) and planes
(cars), so even though the latest CFS may not be nothing to write home
about, they have had at least 2 before that was fairly well received,
how many GPL's have we had so far ?

MS knows about making money, if they're seriously looking into the sim
racing market, then that's good news as it means they think it's
possible to make money from it either directly or indirectly, hell, if
they only do it so they can sell more FF racing wheels I don't care, as
long as it's decent, not to mention that if MS is willing to take the
plunge, other large companies will pay attention and if MS makes money,
they might be interested too

And personally I'd rather see Papy end up under the MS umbrella and
given one or two chances at coming up with a good sim that also makes
money, than see them end up as yet another company producing multi
platform racing games such as NFS or whatever, MS has teams/partners
capable of doing this already, MM and MTM and various XboX titles

If they really are interested in picking up a company like Papy, it can
only be because they're either part of a package or because they're
genuinely interested in making a decent sim, IMHO, outside the
Nascar/GPL scene, hardly anyone knows who Papy is so it can't be for
their name and reputation as that can't be worth a whole lot in a
greater perspective, so it must be the talent and knowledge they're
after (still assuming they're actually after Papy), something that would
be totally wasted in the "just another racing game for your console"
type thing

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

http://www.theuspits.com

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
--Groucho Marx--


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.