rec.autos.simulators

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

Dave Boyl

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Dave Boyl » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 05:35:38


Yeah, I imagine you are right about their main focus being on Xbox with this
(possible) acquisition. Even so, I see it as a good sign that Microsoft is
still producing PC games even with their very aggressive console strategy.
If it happens, I'll take more of a neutral wait and see type attitude rather
than the somewhat concerned feelings I have right now with Vivendi as
parent.

That said, I have no idea of the corporate structure/interaction between
Vivendi/Sierra/Papyrus or what it would possibly be with Microsoft. But I
would have many less doubts with a cash cow like Microsoft at the head
rather than a near bankrupt, debt laden cow like Vivendi.

db

Goy Larse

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Goy Larse » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 07:07:12


> Yeah, I imagine you are right about their main focus being on Xbox with this
> (possible) acquisition. Even so, I see it as a good sign that Microsoft is
> still producing PC games even with their very aggressive console strategy.
> If it happens, I'll take more of a neutral wait and see type attitude rather
> than the somewhat concerned feelings I have right now with Vivendi as
> parent.

> That said, I have no idea of the corporate structure/interaction between
> Vivendi/Sierra/Papyrus or what it would possibly be with Microsoft. But I
> would have many less doubts with a cash cow like Microsoft at the head
> rather than a near bankrupt, debt laden cow like Vivendi.

Exactly, with MS you have at least have a fighting chance as long as you
make a profit, with Vivendi you're going down with the ship

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

http://www.theuspits.com

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
--Groucho Marx--

David G Fishe

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by David G Fishe » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 07:24:49

"I forget how many drivers could join the Monster Truck races, but looking
at
the quality of the drivers in them I was glad the number was somewhat
limited :-)"

Your comment absolutely put down the "quality" of the drivers of another
sim.

David G Fisher


> Please don't misunderstand my comments as an assessment made relative to
> drivers of another sim. They were meant exclusively as a friendly joke
about
> things I saw at the Zone.

> As for your little bet, I don't know who'd be faster, and honestly, it
> doesn't matter to me.

> Achim



> > There were different levels of drivers. The good and best MTM2 drivers
> were
> > fantastic. No different than there are different levels of drivers in
GPL.
> > GPL races tend to be crash fests at the best of times, by drivers with
> years
> > of experience on the smae tracks, somthing that somehow conveniently
gets
> > forgotten by many.

> > To be honest Joachim, I'd bet my right arm that if you took a random
> sample
> > of GPL drivers and had them compete against a random sample of 4x4 Evo2
> > drivers (follow up to MTM2) in a new, third sim with a controlled amount
> of
> > practice time, the 4x4 Evo2 drivers would put the GPL drivers to shame.
> You
> > could just take the top 20% of both and the results would be the same.
> > Having competed against both, that's my opinion.

David G Fishe

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by David G Fishe » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 07:39:38



> > To be honest Joachim, I'd bet my right arm that if you took a random
sample
> > of GPL drivers and had them compete against a random sample of 4x4 Evo2
> > drivers (follow up to MTM2) in a new, third sim with a controlled amount
of
> > practice time, the 4x4 Evo2 drivers would put the GPL drivers to shame.
You
> > could just take the top 20% of both and the results would be the same.
> > Having competed against both, that's my opinion.

> But by your own admission you got bored of GPL after six short weeks,
> then installed because you weren't interested! Are you basing your
> appraisal of the quality of GPL drivers on six weeks?!

> I have a point, Dave, so there's not a chance in hell that you'll answer
> me!

Actually, you don't.

First of all, The best way to judge a driver(s) is to see how well they do
with a new sim that they have no or little time with. Not after they've had
tons of practice with it.

Secondly, I've raced with familiar names online with POD, CPR, MTM2, GPL,
N2002, LFS, and probably a few others that I forget right now.

Finally, I've seen replays of GPL races, and read race reports where it's
crash after crash after crash from people who've been racing the same cars
on the same tracks for years. Hardly any different from what you see from
the general crowd in most online racing games.

POD drivers would kick your ass Gerry.

David G Fisher

Tony Rickar

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Tony Rickar » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 07:55:13

"David G Fisher" wrote

As Joachim reiterates - based on *his* experience as your comments are based on
*your* experience

I could show you many GPL league race replays which are most definately not
crash fests nor wild sliding unrealistic affairs but it would all get rather
boring - time to move on.

Cheers
Tony

David G Fishe

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by David G Fishe » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 09:11:09


Here we go.

Joachim put down the MTM drivers with his comments. That's a fact.

As for the GPL replays, if what you say they contain is even true, I'd be
completely and totally unimpressed. After years of driving the same cars on
the same tracks, I would hope the most dedicated GPL drivers who are racing
against those they are most familiar with would be able to keep them under
some kind of control by now.

David G Fisher

Gerry Aitke

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Gerry Aitke » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 09:19:01


> As for the GPL replays, if what you say they contain is even true, I'd be
> completely and totally unimpressed. After years of driving the same cars on
> the same tracks,

There are hundreds of tracks, and an engine swapper, you imbecile!
David G Fishe

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by David G Fishe » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 09:33:06



> > As for the GPL replays, if what you say they contain is even true, I'd
be
> > completely and totally unimpressed. After years of driving the same cars
on
> > the same tracks,

> There are hundreds of tracks, and an engine swapper, you imbecile!

Ooohh. An engine swapper. That makes a huuuge difference.

Just logged into VROC, and almost every single track of the 26 listed for
racing was a track that shipped with the game years ago. Familiar names were
there too.

David G Fisher

Ruud Dingeman

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Ruud Dingeman » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 13:59:27


>>MS is not in it for excellence in *** (or in anything, for that
>>matter). MS is, and will always be, in it for the ca$h and the
>>privileges it provides.

> Exactly, and they don't need a company like Papy to make shitty arcade
> games,

Goy, they really wouldn't *care* about Papyrus, as a part of Vivendi.
They probably wouldn't even know what it is. They could care less if it
makes good or bad sims, as long as it makes them money.

Some companies, like Apple or Papy, like to strive for good or even
excellent products while making ca$h at the same time. MS does not have
that frame of mind. It is, in other words, not product-oriented.

Regards, Ruud

Tony Rickar

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Tony Rickar » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 16:54:23


> Here we go.

No, that was *my* point!

Joachim made a joke based on his own experiences on the Zone. You countered that
it was very different & Joachim explained it was a joke based on waht he had
seen and accepted that the general standard may have been very different. Did it
end there? No.

How trusting...

Well I said it would be a boring exercise - so we agree on that :). Although
they would include replays from 98 and the beginning of 99, so hardly the years
of practice you elude to.

I am probably getting sucked into a DGF vs Gerry slanging match - so I think I
will stop there.

Cheers
Tony

Gerry Aitke

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Gerry Aitke » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 17:02:05





> > > As for the GPL replays, if what you say they contain is even true, I'd
> be
> > > completely and totally unimpressed. After years of driving the same cars
> on
> > > the same tracks,

> > There are hundreds of tracks, and an engine swapper, you imbecile!

> Ooohh. An engine swapper. That makes a huuuge difference.

Yes it does actually: mix and match a combination of 18 chassis, and 18
engines. All you silly little F1 games only ever have one car, one
engine, and six*** of the most boring tracks in the history of motor
racing!

Most of the leagues I keep track on use 3rd party tracks!! Admit it,
david, the world of sim racing loves GPL, and you are just a lonely
little opinion in the great scheme of things. Where are all the F1CR and
4x4 evo online leagues, btw?

The truth is you only hate GPL because you cannot drive the cars!
Realistic physics makes no sense to you. Must be because of all those
second-rate racing games you've played with over the years!

Anyway, enough on this topic, because you are boring me, and I have
bigger fish to fry.

Patronizingly yours

GDA

Joachim Trens

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Joachim Trens » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 17:11:15

Hi Dave,

not at all, as it was a comment about people driving the same sim as myself.

And I wasn't discrediting anyone based on the fact that they were driving a
specific sim, I was plainly referring to personal experiences made at the
Zone.

Achim



...

Mar

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Mar » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 21:37:01


Riiiight...

Mark

Jason Moy

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Jason Moy » Wed, 29 Jan 2003 23:08:19

On Mon, 27 Jan 2003 17:39:38 -0500, "David G Fisher"


>POD drivers would kick your ass Gerry.

So why don't you guys just settle this on VROC like men, eh?

Jason

Gerry Aitke

Microsoft might be buying Sierra/Papy

by Gerry Aitke » Thu, 30 Jan 2003 01:45:56


> Hi Dave,

> not at all, as it was a comment about people driving the same sim as myself.

> And I wasn't discrediting anyone based on the fact that they were driving a
> specific sim, I was plainly referring to personal experiences made at the
> Zone.

Hehe, Achim, picking on a minority group, shame on you!! ;)

Gerry


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.