rec.autos.simulators

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

The Other Larr

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by The Other Larr » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 04:01:51

I think the problem there is that it kicks in too soon, before services even
launch.  That's why I was unable to re-activate by internet because the NIC
card drivers never had a chance to re-install themselves.

At a minimum, MS should at least get you to the Desktop, and permit you to
COPY files to another medium.  At least that way your data isn't held
hostage.  That really pissed me off more than anything else.

Oh, well :)

-Larry


> Drat!  Wish we could pinpoint it, Larry, because it just plain isn't
> supposed to happen.  Not to you, not to me, not to anyone.  I'd sure like
to
> be able to document, step-by-step, an error in WPA and forward to one of
the
> guys I know.
> --
> Chris H.
> Microsoft MVP - Windows XP
> Associate Expert
> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone



> > Chris,

> > I'm afraid that doesn't jive with what happened to me.

> > I didn't even remove the card.  I didn't evem MOVE the card.  I simply
> > removed it's entry from the device manager so that Windows would
reinstall
> > the driver at the next restart.

> > That suggests that alterations in SOFTWARE can also trigger WPA, and
that
> > sucks.

> > Though I appreciate your input, there is NO excuse for Microsoft's
digital
> > leash known as WPA.

> > What if I had been working on a time-sensitive deliverable?  Would
> Microsoft
> > have refunded me the money lost due to this defect in their product?  Of
> > course, the answer is no...

> > -Larry

The Other Larr

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by The Other Larr » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 04:06:55

Ok, that 'splains everything :)

-Larry


> I'm not sure, infact, I've been feeling ill recently.. so I couldn't er...
> read... I had my eyes closed... it was foggy, Look officer, I was on
> holiday, it couldn't have been me.

> Tim



> > Tim,

> > What are you talking about?

> > -Larry



> > > Well... why do you believe you needed to reinstall something which was
> > > working?

> > > Tim



> > > > Well, it was bound to happen.  Windows XP's stupid product
activation
> > was
> > > > _bound_ to***up eventually.

> > > > Well, it did.

> > > > This evening, I was troubleshooting network connectivity problems on
> my
> > XP
> > > > Client Machine.  One of the steps I took was the time-honored
> tradition
> > of
> > > > removing the Ethernet Card entry in the Device Manager, and letting
> > > Windows
> > > > re-detect it and reinstall the drivers during restart.

> > > > Well, instead of Windows XP booting up and redetecting the NIC card
> and
> > > > reinstalling the drivers, I got the dreaded Windows XP Activation
> > notice!

> > > > It said something about not being able to validate my Hardware
> > > > Configuration, and asked me if I wanted to re-activate.

> > > > Sure, why not.

> > > > However, because this stupid Product Activation would not let the
> system
> > > > boot up into Windows, the damned NIC card drivers were not allowed
to
> > > > reinstall and.  This means, of course, that product activation could
> not
> > > do
> > > > it's thing over the Internet.

> > > > Ok, fine.  I've got 10 minutes to waste (like I really had a
choice).

> > > > I called the toll-free number.

> > > > Now, I went through the drawn-out automated re-activation process,
> where
> > > you
> > > > punch in this ridiculously long number, and wait for it to read back
> > your
> > > > activation key.

> > > > Except, it said it could not validate my hardware configuration.

> > > > Now, I had to get passed to a 'human' to get it done.

> > > > Ok, so now I get to plead my case for the continuing privilage of
> using
> > an
> > > > operating system that I paid good money for to someone on the
> telephone.
> > > I
> > > > didn't get the impression that this person really understood the
> > technical
> > > > issue behind this (which I consider a bug in activation), but I did
> get
> > > > re-activated.

> > > > Windows finally booted, installed my NIC card drivers, and I was
back
> on
> > > the
> > > > Internet.

> > > > So, my solution fixed my Network problem, but it was like travelling
> > from
> > > > ***ia to Maryland, by way of San Diego.

> > > > Keep in mind that during this whole process MICROSOFT had all of my
> data
> > > > locked up and held hostage by this stupid activation system.

> > > > If it weren't for the fact that I'd have to go back to Dual-Boot
98/2K
> > (2K
> > > > won't run all of my software), I would throw this XP disk in the
> damned
> > > > trash can.

> > > > We don't need this crap.

> > > > Larry

The Other Larr

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by The Other Larr » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 04:07:32

LOL!

-Larry


> Have you seen how they dress these days?

> I swear when I'm 80 and can't pull a bird anymore I'm gonna move house
> opposite a girls school ;-)




> > > I'm not sure, infact, I've been feeling ill recently.. so I couldn't
> er...
> > > read... I had my eyes closed... it was foggy, Look officer, I was on
> > > holiday, it couldn't have been me.

> > Yeah, yeah, and of course you swear you thought the girl was over 16 ;)

> > Gerry

Chris H

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Chris H » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 05:32:25

I believe that's where we need to boot with the CD and enter using Safe Mode
without Internet enabled.  I haven't had to do that, but I believe it'll let
you copy personal data files off to another partition or hard drive.

- Chris H.



Chris H

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Chris H » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 05:45:56

I believe, unless something changed, the personal
information/preferences/etc. data doesn't go any farther than the user's own
hard drive.  Quite similar to the download/install file accessed when you go
to Windows Update and ask it to check for something new.  This was the
direction it was headed back in October-November anyway, unless I totally
misunderstood.

The way it was explained to me was like, say, a bank account.  The account
information is kept on the user hard drive, when you contact the bank, the
bank requests permission to access the info on your hard drive and you
either grant or deny it.  Without the user entering their own password to
access the bank system, the bank won't even know who you are and where to
check for the information.

The Remote Assistance in XP is similar.  You have a problem, e-mail or
Messenger a request to someone with XP for help.  They contact you as
instructed in the message, and you authorize access.  If you don't want them
there, or at any time during the assistance the person starts heading in a
direction you don't want, you can immediately kill the authorization and
they're gone.  The user, who sees on their own screen what is happening,
controls the situation, even being able to set a time limit for
authorization in the initial assistance request.

- Chris H.



Steve Levet

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Steve Levet » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 06:21:37

You know, this whole activation thing reminds me of the copy protected music
CDs that came out recently. There was such an uproar about not being able to
play these CDs on different CD players and not being able to mp3 them. Shops
had a very high percentage returned so Philips listen to the consumer and
wuthdrew these CDs. I wonder if MS will do the same with this activation?

--

Steve Levett



> Richard,

> You _really_ think there's a choice in this matter, don't you ?

> There are _some_ choices, but not full choices.

> I have a reason for running XP.  I still have that reason, and I will
> continue to run XP.

> That, however, (the last time I checked), doesn't take away my right to
> point out technical glitches and other complaints.

> -Larry







> > > > If you don't like it, then don't run the software.  It's perfectly
> > > > simple.

> > > What, people aren't allowed to voice their opinion's about bad
> technology
> > > any more, Richard?

> > Of course they are, but it is silly to moan about Microsoft's products
but
> > keep buying them!!!

> > That's almost as daft as people who complain about EA, then buy all
their
> F1
> > titles... ;-)

> > --
> > Richard.

> > "It's been a hard day's night, and I been working like a dog."

Milhous

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Milhous » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 08:17:13

People aren't exactly returning XP, though...

And I don't think Philips made any.  Rather, they said - as they hold lots
of copyrights/patents on the CD standard - that any such CD cannot be
actually called a compact disc.  Kinda pointless, yes.  But it's kinda like
the old SNK NES games.

Milhouse


> You know, this whole activation thing reminds me of the copy protected
music
> CDs that came out recently. There was such an uproar about not being able
to
> play these CDs on different CD players and not being able to mp3 them.
Shops
> had a very high percentage returned so Philips listen to the consumer and
> wuthdrew these CDs. I wonder if MS will do the same with this activation?

> --

> Steve Levett



> > Richard,

> > You _really_ think there's a choice in this matter, don't you ?

> > There are _some_ choices, but not full choices.

> > I have a reason for running XP.  I still have that reason, and I will
> > continue to run XP.

> > That, however, (the last time I checked), doesn't take away my right to
> > point out technical glitches and other complaints.

> > -Larry







> > > > > If you don't like it, then don't run the software.  It's perfectly
> > > > > simple.

> > > > What, people aren't allowed to voice their opinion's about bad
> > technology
> > > > any more, Richard?

> > > Of course they are, but it is silly to moan about Microsoft's products
> but
> > > keep buying them!!!

> > > That's almost as daft as people who complain about EA, then buy all
> their
> > F1
> > > titles... ;-)

> > > --
> > > Richard.

> > > "It's been a hard day's night, and I been working like a dog."

Milhous

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Milhous » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 08:22:49




> > If MS didn't feel like overcharging for anything and everything they
> sell -
> > you could spend more on the software you're putting on your computer
than
> > the computer itself with Microsoft products alone - I highly doubt
piracy
> > would be any problem.

> I don't consider MS pricing overpriced at all. Considering that Norton
Ghost
> 2002 costs $119.00 CAD and XP Home cost me $139.00 CAD I would say that XP
> gives far more bng for the buck.

Ghost costs that much for absolute CRAP!?!?  Wow.  It can't even deal with
NTFS partitions!  I think I got it packaged with a motherboard once.

Milhouse

Milhous

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Milhous » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 08:22:50

Well, then you spoke with your dollars and decided that WPA obviously wasn't
that bad at the time.

Milhouse




> > And I'll take my friends over some 100% anti-MS *** whining in a
> newsgroup
> > any day.

> P.S. How can I possibly be 100% anti-MS when I actually paid MS for using
> WinXP?
> You need a core logic upgrade dude.

Goy Larse

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Goy Larse » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 08:47:48


> People aren't exactly returning XP, though...

> And I don't think Philips made any.  Rather, they said - as they hold lots
> of copyrights/patents on the CD standard - that any such CD cannot be
> actually called a compact disc.  Kinda pointless, yes.  But it's kinda like
> the old SNK NES games.

Correct, and they actually took it one step further, saying they would
develop CD-burners that would overcome this copy protection, and if they
changed the protection, they would develop a new burner, and so forth,
Philips did NOT like this at all

It seems to have been dropped now though, *** gave it another think,
but then again, the only 2 CD's released so far that I know of was
Natalie Imbruglia (who ?) and Westlife (yippe, since I don't own a
regular stereo, I'll never play their CD by accident should anyone leave
one around here for some strange and obscure reason, thx ***,
actually I'd like to see more CD's with this copy protection when I
think about it, ........:-)

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

http://www.racesimcentral.net/
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

"A woman is an occasional pleasure but a cigar is always a smoke"
--Groucho Marx--

Mark Jeangerar

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Mark Jeangerar » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 09:28:57

Whoa... Hold it right there! We're restricted to how many hardware changes
we make? I know you work for MS, Chris, but you've obviously never owned
Windows. You see, when you have a Windows OS, some days the best thing you
can do is remove everything and let it start over. ....and, that's half the
fun of Windows - digging all your goodies out of your closet or other
computers that you have laying around and seeing what run with what. :-)

I do have a serious question though, what about a computer with no internet
connection like my ProTools machine in the studio?

--

"Racing! - Science for the action minded."

mark

> The NIC does carry extra weight in the calculation, Larry, plus you made
> three other changes, too.  Remember, if you're going to make a lot of
> changes, note the date you've activated because after 120 days the system
is
> reset to "zero" amount of the calculated hardware changes.  This is sort
of
> saying if you were 100 days into your first activation, changing of the
> controller, hard drive and adding another drive (don't believe that's
> counted, but anyway) would count only until the 121st day.

> Then those changes are reset to zero and adding the NIC would not have
> triggered anything because it would only have been count one or two (at
> most) of the four to six allowed changes.  At this moment, I don't see
> anything but activation seeing a "different" system, therefore requiring
the
> telephone call.  I can see where activation may have been triggered by the
> numerous changes within a single, 120-day period, but if you'd like I'll
> continue to track it down so we know for sure.

> It is stuff like this which is keeping me from installing my USB MS
> SideWinder FF wheel and hitting the GPL tracks.  8-)  GPL, with the update
> patch, runs quite well for me on a clean NTFS install of  Windows XP Pro,
an
> AMD Thunderbird 1 GB with 512 PC133 RAM and a GeForce2 MX400 w/64 Megs.
8-)
> --
> Chris H.
> Microsoft MVP - Windows XP
> Associate Expert
> Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone



> > Chris,

> > There was no error on the card in the device manager.  It was simply my
> > desire to 'freshen' the installation and the drivers for the Intel
> > In-Business 10/100 NIC Card, which did, in the end, fix my Network
> problems.

> > The only hardware changes that have been made to this computer are the
> > installation of a Maxtor ATA/133 Controller and 80GB Maxtor D740X hard
> > drive, and the replacement of an old Pioneer DVD-113 with a new Pioneer
> > DVD-116 DVD drive.

> > I assure you I was suprised as well :)

> > I don't know the exact time, but it was about 9pm this evening.

> > The guy on the phone was nice and all.  No complaints there.  However I
> > didn't get the impression that he understood what I was reporting, and
> that
> > I felt it was a bug in the Activation system.

> > It still all boils down to the fact that we don't need this nonsense.

> > Thanks for your input!

> > -Larry

Mark Jeangerar

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Mark Jeangerar » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 09:33:56

Ah.... Jan Verschueren. Had the pleasure to share a bit of asphalt with the
man myself. It is always a pleasure.

--

"Racing! - Science for the action minded."

mark







> > > > /Jens, having a Jan day.

> > Would that be Jan Brady?

> Who?

> Nah, somebody of talent and style. And good at the Ring. ;-)

Chris H

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Chris H » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 09:46:40

Ghost 7.0 works fine with XP on NTFS, and so does DriveImage 5.0.
--
Chris H.






> > > If MS didn't feel like overcharging for anything and everything they
> > sell -
> > > you could spend more on the software you're putting on your computer
> than
> > > the computer itself with Microsoft products alone - I highly doubt
> piracy
> > > would be any problem.

> > I don't consider MS pricing overpriced at all. Considering that Norton
> Ghost
> > 2002 costs $119.00 CAD and XP Home cost me $139.00 CAD I would say that
XP
> > gives far more bng for the buck.

> Ghost costs that much for absolute CRAP!?!?  Wow.  It can't even deal with
> NTFS partitions!  I think I got it packaged with a motherboard once.

> Milhouse

> > > And I'll take my friends over some 100% anti-MS *** whining in a
> > newsgroup
> > > any day.

> > At least I don't steal from Microsoft! You think your friends are some
> > modern day Robin Hood's or what?

jlohma

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by jlohma » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 09:46:15

That's the reason why I haven't bought it. It's nice to confirm that my
suspensions where correct.

jlohma

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by jlohma » Wed, 30 Jan 2002 09:48:40

I'll agree with you on that one, but it was nice to read some of the
problems, so those of us who haven't bought it can continue to hold our
ground.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.