rec.autos.simulators

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

Chris H

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Chris H » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 06:29:04

Not to argue the point, but figures can all be in the point of view.  ZDNet
reported shortly about disappointing sales after the launch, decrying that
"only about 300,000" copies sold in the first few days.  Other sources,
including MSNBC, noted a second-month sales decrease of about 150,000 copies
in November compared to second-month Win98 or Win98SE sales.  Oh, the poor
babies.  Only 650-750,000 copies sold from October 25 through December 1.

So much is based on "knowledgeable industry sources' expectations" perceive
should happen.  When it doesn't, whatever the item is turns out to be a
flop.  It isn't their projection that's wrong.  I wouldn't mind
three-quarters of a million of something selling.  8-)
--
Chris H.


Ronald Stoeh

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Ronald Stoeh » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 06:39:45


> > > When did Microsoft become an authority in how many changes I can make on
> > > MY system?? WTF is that lame crap!

> > When you agreed to the 'end user license agreement'.  If you don't like
> it,
> > then don't run the software.  It's perfectly simple.

> That's the reason why I haven't bought it. It's nice to confirm that my
> suspensions where correct.

  ^^^^^^^^^^^

Hey, that's the first almost-on-topic-post in this thread? ;^)

Just kidding, this thread is very interesting...

--
l8er
ronny

Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change
to take effect. Reboot now?

Goy Larse

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Goy Larse » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 07:33:14


> Isn't that the preference of the OEM?  Don't the OEMs want to lock the
> consumer into using just their product and their support?  A user can order
> a machine without an OS and purchase an "OEM" version (with qualifying
> hardware) at a lot of places.  Or, like a lot of us have done, build your
> own if you have the knowledge to do so.

Depends, as an OEM manufacturer you *can* choose to supply the OS on a
CD instead of doing the recovery CD thing, but the cost is a fair bit
higher, and with the low profit margin amongst OEM manufacturers, that
is really not an option in most cases

We offer it as an extra cost option if the customer asks for it

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

http://www.theuspits.com
http://www.teammirage.com

"A woman is an occasional pleasure but a cigar is always a smoke"
--Groucho Marx--

Milhous

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Milhous » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 08:13:51

I never have liked XP's integraded CD-writing...it's kinda nifty but I'll
take Nero 5.5 ANY day.

Milhouse




> > As I said, I really probably know less about CD-ROMs/CD-R/CD-RW than
> anyone,
> > but dug out some information for you.  A good starting point is
> > http://www.aumha.org/a/xpcd.htm which discusses file systems and a
pretty
> > good unveiling of the Windows XP built-in CD burner system (in item 2).
> > There are also a couple other interesting links on that page.

> OK, thx for the info. I'm reading that web page now. But I don't think my
> problem is any of the below stuff you posted. I have a Ricoh MP7120A which
> is one of the better cdrw drives and it can burn/read any format,
including
> RAW mode. This is WinXP specific and the file format it is using. They are
> perfectly readable under XP, but not Win98. My guess is that Win98 needs a
> certain file(s) so it can read the cd's burned in XP. Which is more
bollocks
> from XP because I've burned cd's in Win98 and they are readable on any
other
> computer.I can burn with CloneCD (raw mode) in XP and they are readable on
> any computer. The problem only happens when using XP's  built in software.

Milhous

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Milhous » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 08:17:23

You really want something to tinker with?

Go download Linux. ;)

"It's only free if you work for nothing..."

Milhouse




> > Well, then you spoke with your dollars and decided that WPA obviously
> wasn't
> > that bad at the time.

> Not really, initially I swore I wouldn't buy XP, then one day I was bored
> and wanted something to tinker with so I bought a copy of XP. Doesn't mean
I
> can't make my opinion known though and doesn't mean I am going to stay
with
> it either.

jlohma

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by jlohma » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 08:39:53

"> "You need to research your false claims *prior* to spewing forth :)

I don't know why I bothered to look it up, your reply totally convinced me I
was wrong.
But here it is anyway.

http://zdnet.com.com/2100-1106-802522.html

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:20:20

You will....

> Agreed!! I Won't run it!!





> > > When did Microsoft become an authority in how many changes I can make
on
> > > MY system?? WTF is that lame crap!

> > When you agreed to the 'end user license agreement'.  If you don't like
> it,
> > then don't run the software.  It's perfectly simple.

> > --
> > Richard.

> > "And he never shows his feelings, But the fool on the hill."

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:34:46

The problem is...you really are not sure of what the customer wants, unless
you take a survey, or at worst look at a genereal study of computer users,
not just those that say they are having a problem.
    One problem with an open environment like this is that people do not
understand that if one person is having a problem, 900 people may not be
having a problem. I've been running a version of XP since mid-June (RC-1)
and haven't had any problems.
    Chris stated that the activiation problem SHOULD not have happened,
backing it up with the best thing Microsoft ever did, the knowledge base
website. Therefore, it was a bug that caused this whole discussion...Just
FYI, this isn't all directed at you, I'd just rather get it out as one
semi-big message then a lot of tiny messages.
-Stuart Becktell



> > Just do what has been suggested:  Don't buy Windows XP.  Don't install
> > Windows XP.  I haven't seen anyone among my friends twist anyone's arms
> and
> > force them into buying XP.

> Yea, yea, I should have stopped supporting the software monkeys at MS and
> just stuck with Dos right? What ever happened to giving the customer what
> they want? The fact is if I want to continue being a gamer and buying
future
> games I will be railroaded into having to use XP and XP compatible
hardware
> so don't tell me I have a choice, because I don't. Look, I like lots of
> things about XP but this activation ***really sucks so telling me not to
> use it if I don't like it is just an arrogant stance coming from a bunch
of
> Micorsoft brown noser's. And don't even get me started on the spyware,
> Passport and forced loading of messenger on XP.

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:39:59

What is packet writing? That just sounds wierd, not stating that you are
wrong (...already know you can't be too cautious in RAS, lol) it just seems
wierd to use a completely different model designed for networks to write
information to a non-network component on a computer.
-Stuart Becktell


> It wasn't clear _how_ he wrote the CD's.  I was just discussing Packet
> Writing in general as it seemed to fit the symptoms.

> Another example of software that does Packet Writing that most don't know
> about.  DriveImage creates CD's in packet written format.

> -Larry





> > > Actually, my guess is that they are being packet-written, and his
Win98
> > > doesn't have the UDF driver installed.

> > > Packet-Written CD's (except in certain circumstances where some
software
> > > burners can 'close' them for use on other machines) are not a normal
> > format
> > > and need help.

> > > -Larry

> > You serious? XP uses packet writing even on a CDR? I don't think it is
> > packet writing because when doing this drag and drop method it writes a
> lead
> > in/lead out just like when you burn cdr with other software. Packet
> writing
> > doesn't do that.

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:41:52

You get what you pay for, I'll never use the included CD writing tool in XP,
just like I won't use the included defragmenter (the full version of
diskeeper is SO MUCH better.)
-Stuart Becktell

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:44:51

Just for a general FYI, I got a full version of XP home with my Dell
notebook.
-Stuart Becktell


> No, Chris.

> Since, I believe January of 2000, Microsoft has pressured OEM's to NOT
> provide full Windows CD's with their computers.

> From what I understand, the OEM's absolutely HATE the idea, but you know
how
> that goes.  Can't risk pissing off the Mothership.  Might start getting
> late/short deliveries and what...

> It's definetely a MS thing, not an OEM thing.

> -Larry



> > Isn't that the preference of the OEM?  Don't the OEMs want to lock the
> > consumer into using just their product and their support?  A user can
> order
> > a machine without an OS and purchase an "OEM" version (with qualifying
> > hardware) at a lot of places.  Or, like a lot of us have done, build
your
> > own if you have the knowledge to do so.
> > --
> > Chris H.



> > > What about all those people who buy OEM machines, and get screwed out
of
> > > their real OS CD's, and only get restoration CD's.

> > > Another fine Microsoft idea :(

> > > -Larry



> > > > I believe that's where we need to boot with the CD and enter using
> Safe
> > > Mode
> > > > without Internet enabled.  I haven't had to do that, but I believe
> it'll
> > > let
> > > > you copy personal data files off to another partition or hard drive.

> > > > - Chris H.



> > > > > I think the problem there is that it kicks in too soon, before
> > services
> > > > even
> > > > > launch.  That's why I was unable to re-activate by internet
because
> > the
> > > > NIC
> > > > > card drivers never had a chance to re-install themselves.

> > > > > At a minimum, MS should at least get you to the Desktop, and
permit
> > you
> > > to
> > > > > COPY files to another medium.  At least that way your data isn't
> held
> > > > > hostage.  That really pissed me off more than anything else.

> > > > > Oh, well :)

> > > > > -Larry

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:46:36

Thats fairly common in large corporations. Where I work continualy sells Oki
printers to Xerox. A huge rule at Xerox is that they have ONLY Xerox
printers on site. They also have to buy Xerox printers from us, because it
is to hard for them to get them for free.
-Stuart Becktell


> It's frightening that Microsoft doesn't even know what they, themselves,
are
> doing with the data they collect!

> Man, I can't wait to see the bloopers that crop up with .NET.  It will be
> epic, truly epic.

> -Larry



> > http://www.wired.com/news/technology/0,1282,18423,00.html Is this the
real
> > reason MS want all our info. I'm think it is and the passport system
just
> > proves it to me. Maybe they are collecting info for a rent system in the
> > future.

> > --

> > Steve Levett



> > > Chris,

> > > I'm afraid that doesn't jive with what happened to me.

> > > I didn't even remove the card.  I didn't evem MOVE the card.  I simply
> > > removed it's entry from the device manager so that Windows would
> reinstall
> > > the driver at the next restart.

> > > That suggests that alterations in SOFTWARE can also trigger WPA, and
> that
> > > sucks.

> > > Though I appreciate your input, there is NO excuse for Microsoft's
> digital
> > > leash known as WPA.

> > > What if I had been working on a time-sensitive deliverable?  Would
> > Microsoft
> > > have refunded me the money lost due to this defect in their product?
Of
> > > course, the answer is no...

> > > -Larry



> > > > Eldred:  As long as you're shifting the same items around, you
really
> > > should
> > > > have no problem.  Adding new things, perceived by Windows XP as
> > "changes,"
> > > > to the mix results in a different "hash" being created.  Once the
> > > threshold
> > > > as described at http://www.aumha.org/a/wpa.htm is exceeded, this
would
> > > force
> > > > a free telephone call.

> > > > There's a pretty good 10-item list on that site which describes what
> is
> > > > tracked and the method used.  There are also a few suggestions for
> those
> > > who
> > > > do change hardware quite often.  People have even changed out the
> > > > motherboard, for instance, without triggering a new activation.

> > > > Jens:  I do care, otherwise I wouldn't be putting up with stuff
you're
> > > > stating.  I haven't seen you jump in here with helpful suggestions,
> yet
> > I
> > > > voluntarily try to assist people and all that is coming from you is
an
> > > > unwarranted attack.

> > > > Since you don't know me, your accusations and telling the world what
> > > version
> > > > I own or anything else about what I think or do is not only
> inaccurate,
> > > but
> > > > untruthful.  I own Windows XP Pro, retail final version, available
off
> > the
> > > > shelf at your local computer store.  I also have a copy which I
> received
> > > for
> > > > beta testing the product for nearly a year.  I installed clean on
this
> > > > desktop using XP to format to NTFS, and added my normal programs
> > > afterward.
> > > > --
> > > > Chris H.
> > > > Microsoft MVP - Windows XP
> > > > Associate Expert
> > > > Expert Zone - www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/expertzone

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:48:19

I just wanted you (and everyone else) to know how extremely HELPFUL you have
been throughtout this. I came in a couple days late, but all the links and
all that you put in are just amazing.
-Stuart Becktell

> Would you like to see the receipt, Jens?  It was $194.99 at the local
> Staples, plus 5% tax here, for $204.74 total.  Activated after I installed
> it and fed the ICS wizard information on my DSL connection.

> BTW, I'm not pushing sales of any product.  In fact, I've only said to NOT
> purchase anything if someone is happy with their system.  I've never said
to
> go buy anything - that's all your own idea.  Do we run out and buy all the
> new cars the automobile manufacturers advertise every year?  Not when
we're
> happy with what we've got, which in my case happens to be two '95
vehicles,
> one which we bought used.

> I've got two machines here which will never see XP installed, because
> they're running other operating systems just fine and upgrading isn't
> necessary for their purpose.  Just like other people, money counts.

> Now if GPL 2 came out at the local store, I would have to convince my Wife
> that I just couldn't live without it.  8-)

> - Chris H.





> > > Jens:  I do care, otherwise I wouldn't be putting up with stuff you're
> > > stating.  I haven't seen you jump in here with helpful suggestions,
yet
> I
> > > voluntarily try to assist people and all that is coming from you is an
> > > unwarranted attack.

> > I believe I have done much more to help people her in r.a.s than you
have.
> > Unwarranted attack? You are lying through your teeth using outrageous
spin
> to
> > sell the product. So the attack is warranted.

> > > Since you don't know me, your accusations and telling the world what
> version
> > > I own or anything else about what I think or do is not only
inaccurate,
> but
> > > untruthful.  I own Windows XP Pro, retail final version, available off
> the
> > > shelf at your local computer store.  I also have a copy which I
received
> for
> > > beta testing the product for nearly a year.  I installed clean on this
> > > desktop using XP to format to NTFS, and added my normal programs
> afterward.
> > > --

> > Funny, you never said that you bought it. Thus you received it from MS.
> And as
> > you are a self-appointed expert et al, they presumably gave it to you
> without
> > activation required. I noticed you didn't mention activating your XP.
> You're
> > spinning so fast, you could be a DVD player.

> > I think it is time I invoked Eldred's rule.

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:51:53

and those damn notebooks...so easy to find components to make your own...


> writes:


> >> So if you buy a new computer which is loaded with the new whiz-bang OS,
is
> >that
> >> an implicit approval of said OS installed therein?

> >Sure.  M$ got their money for another copy of XP didn't they?  Cmon
> >Eldred, I know you possess the abilities to build one on your own.  Make
> >it YOUR way! <g>

> I *did* build my own, and I've very happy with it.  I was talking about a
> system for my dad...<g>  He wants all the bells and whistles of a couple
of
> packages he saw on TV...<sigh>  I can't match those prices with a homemade
> system.

> Eldred
> --
> Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
> Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
> GPLRank - under construction...

> Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats
you
> with experience...
> Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Stuart Becktel

OT - My first problem with Windows XP Product Activation

by Stuart Becktel » Thu, 31 Jan 2002 11:53:57

Question, why do you have two servers at your house? File and print?
-Stuart Becktell


> Well, I don't know about Bye-Bye Microsoft.  That's a bit too tough
> especially since I make a decent living supporting PC's and MS products,
but
> that doesn't mean some stuff can't be 'offloaded' from Windows.

> I have one of the new LCD iMac's on order.  The one with the DVD burner
and
> other goodies.  I intend on offloading as much personal stuff as I can to
> this machine and the really superb MacOS X.

> I have 4 PC's (including two servers) running at home that will continue
to
> do so for work purposes and sim racing.

> All of my 'Digital Media' stuff and home computing will move to the iMac.

> This is actually kind of funny, but guess what was the first software
> package I bought?  Yep.  Microsoft Office v.X.  LOL!  Ya can't truly win,
> can you :)

> -Larry





> > > This is what I wonder about. I have done reinstalls of 98 and 2000 on
> two
> > > computers, one of them a dual boot system. Now what happens to the
> product
> > > activation if I buy xp, and 3 years from now MS decides they no longer
> > offer
> > > support for it. Will they release something to bypass activation on it
> so
> > > users familiar with it can reinstall it, or will you have to buy the
> > newest
> > > version of windows because you cant get the older copy "activated"?

> > Chris said to me in another post that if this comes to be then they will
> > offer a download that will disable the activation process. He also said
he
> > has heard rumours that MS plan to make their OS rentware but isnt'
privvy
> to
> > that info himself, and so have I. Bye-bye Microsoft.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.