rec.autos.simulators

simultaneous throttle and brake

Joachim Trens

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Joachim Trens » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 20:12:20

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

An interesting German article, mentioning that Schumacher uses throttle and
brake at the same time. Particularly interesting for this particular topic
are paragraphs 3,4 and 5.

Achim

Scot

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Scot » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 21:32:21


> http://www.f1total.com/news/03083006.shtml

> An interesting German article, mentioning that Schumacher uses throttle and
> brake at the same time. Particularly interesting for this particular topic
> are paragraphs 3,4 and 5.

> Achim

Is there a translation somewhere? I can order food and get the bill in
German but that's about it!!
ae

simultaneous throttle and brake

by ae » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 21:32:54


>Is there a translation somewhere? I can order food and get the bill in
>German but that's about it!!

Use babelfish.altavista.com
--
Andrew
Haqsa

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Haqsa » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 22:01:07


Very, VERY rough translation from Babelfish:

(F1Total.com) - over the last years Michael Schumacher again and again
proved its exception position in the formula 1. The Ferrari pilot belongs to
the best Formel-1-Fahrern of all times and not without reason, as the
specialized magazine could point ' F1 out Racing ' now in a unique analysis.
One could show on the basis telemetry data of the Italian Formel-1-Teams,
how the German deals unbelievably sensitivly and flexibly with gas and brake
pedal. Particularly impressing the comparison is on the basis the data of
the 180-Kehre in Suzuka, a distance, on which Michael Schumacher exceeds
again and again over itself. In principle Rubens Barrichellos style of
driving affects compared with that one from Schumacher the telemetry data
"simply" - "Rubinho" is now real no bad driver. The Brazilian rises before
the curve 15 meters in former times to the brake and gives above all either
gas or brakes. With the world champion looks completely differently. Michael
Schumacher stops clearly longer fully on the gas than Barrichello, but
begins it however before the actual "correct" braking for the hairpin curve
the car with an employment of the brake from only five per cent to to
stabilize. In the curve goes to Barrichello fully from the gas, Schumacher
gives however constantly gas and "plays" with brake and gas, in order to get
the car as fast and stably as possible around the curve. Even in the exit of
the curve Michael Schumacher uses the brake. While Rubens Barrichello tries
to prevent the car by removal of gas from breaking out the German gives
substantially more gases and counterbalances its Ferrari with easy braking.
Alone in this curve is the champion 25 kilometers per hour faster on the way
than Barrichello, which loses 0.3 seconds. Apart from the fact that Rubens
Barrichello brakes either or gives gas and quite frequently both pedals
parallel uses Michael Schumacher in contrast to it, a further difference is
noticeable. Thus Schumacher applies brakes gently a curve mostly later and
stabilizes the car, in which he gives further easily gas, what works at
first sight counter productive, but but ensures that Schumacher can brake
later, without control of his car to lose and cleanly give in can. While
Rubens Barrichello applies brakes gently, speaks a curve nearly "linear"
first strong pressure on the brake pedal constructs and this then
continuously lowers, in order to avoid a blocking of the front wheels,
Schumacher in the braking reduces briefly the brake pressure, in order to
lend to the wheels again more adhesion. Thus Schumacher brings more in into
the hairpin curve of Montreal with 15 kilometers per hour than Barrichello.
And during Schumacher before the apex five meters at all no gas are, are
there with the Brazilian of ten meters. But everything is not gold which
shines. Thus Michael Schumacher with its driving fashion stresses the
material more strongly than Barrichello. The front tires are more strongly
loaded, because Schumacher brakes more strongly and faster in-driven into
the curves. This caused in some past running that the Kerpener could not
drive with the softer tire mixture, Rubens Barrichello however already. Also
the brakes and the engine are more strongly loaded, because Schumacher
brakes at the same time and gives gas. And also gasoline consumption might
be higher with Schumacher by this fact than with the Brazilian. But if it
comes *** hard, as in Montreal, when the brakes over their limit were,
Michael Schumacher can change its style of driving over completely and
preserve the brakes thereby. That constitutes evenly a genuine world
champion.

Eldre

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Eldre » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 22:13:42



>http://www.f1total.com/news/03083006.shtml

>An interesting German article, mentioning that Schumacher uses throttle and
>brake at the same time. Particularly interesting for this particular topic
>are paragraphs 3,4 and 5.

/me wishes I could understand German...

Eldred
--
"A voice from the crowd:  Right, everyone out of my garden.  I've had
enough of this!"

Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank -2.4
N2k3 rank ?

Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Tony Rickar

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Tony Rickar » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 22:23:31


> >An interesting German article, mentioning that Schumacher uses throttle
and
> >brake at the same time. Particularly interesting for this particular
topic
> >are paragraphs 3,4 and 5.

> /me wishes I could understand German...

I think it says that Schuey is driving in an unrealistic manner by using
gas and brake simultaneously throughout the turns... :)

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.512 / Virus Database: 309 - Release Date: 19/08/2003

Mr. Sylvestr

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Mr. Sylvestr » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 22:26:12


> http://www.f1total.com/news/03083006.shtml

> An interesting German article, mentioning that Schumacher uses throttle and
> brake at the same time. Particularly interesting for this particular topic
> are paragraphs 3,4 and 5.

Hey, does this mean that the hotlapper technique of choice in GPL (brake
and throttle at the same time) might be realistic after all ?  While
doing so in GPL significantly reduced my lap times, I refrain from it
because I just feel it would be wrong with real cars (yeah I know, it is
only a game...)

Interestingly, NetKar is another sim in which that driving technique can
make a difference.

Regards
Mr. Sylvestre (puzzled)

Joachim Trens

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Joachim Trens » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 23:11:40

Yes, this is precisely what it says <g>

Achim


..
...

Joachim Trens

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Joachim Trens » Mon, 01 Sep 2003 23:36:58

Well, unless that hotlapper technique people criticize is something
completely different from what is being described for Schumacher, it is
perfectly realistic. It's perhaps harder to do with a 3-pedal setup, but for
example Walter Roehrl also said he was using it.

I've always wondered why some say this technique isn't realistic. I've even
tried it myself in cars and carts (while I was still slender enough to drive
carts fast <g>) and while I wasn't getting anywhere with it in 3-pedal cars,
it worked well in carts. I've AAMOF always thought that _everybody_ is usung
this technique, until I read about it allegedly being 'unrealistic' here.

Achim


...
...

Don Dodg

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Don Dodg » Tue, 02 Sep 2003 00:01:29

It was my impression that this technique had been in use by lots of
drivers for years.

See here (1997):  http://e46m3performance.com/installs/pedal/page3.htm

Also, iianm, NASCAR drivers use the brake against full throttle to draft
at the superspeedways, do they not?

Don D in KC



ae

simultaneous throttle and brake

by ae » Tue, 02 Sep 2003 00:11:14



I certainly heard that MS was doing it at least 4 years ago, and am
pretty sure some other F1 drivers do it too.
--
Andrew

EGK

simultaneous throttle and brake

by EGK » Tue, 02 Sep 2003 01:36:26

I believe that's the exact reason professional racecar drivers use their
right and left foot for gas and brake respectively.  Most people on the
highways use just one foot.  Take it off the gas and apply the brake.  

I think racecar drivers use both feet on the gas and brake more like a
highway driver might feather the gas and the clutch in a manual
transmission.  If you've ever stopped on a grade you know that with the
clutch in, you will start to slide downhill if you take your foot off the
brake.  To avoid that you can feather the gas and clutch together to
maintain your position.  


>It was my impression that this technique had been in use by lots of
>drivers for years.

>See here (1997):  http://e46m3performance.com/installs/pedal/page3.htm

>Also, iianm, NASCAR drivers use the brake against full throttle to draft
>at the superspeedways, do they not?

>Don D in KC



>> I've always wondered why some say this technique isn't realistic. I've
>> even tried it myself in cars and carts (while I was still slender
>> enough to drive carts fast <g>) and while I wasn't getting anywhere
>> with it in 3-pedal cars, it worked well in carts. I've AAMOF always
>> thought that _everybody_ is usung this technique, until I read about
>> it allegedly being 'unrealistic' here.

>> Achim

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

"There would be a lot more civility in this world if people
 didn't take that as an invitation to walk all over you"
                   - (Calvin and Hobbes)

jason moy

simultaneous throttle and brake

by jason moy » Tue, 02 Sep 2003 02:28:31

On Sun, 31 Aug 2003 16:36:58 +0200, "Joachim Trensz"


>Well, unless that hotlapper technique people criticize is something
>completely different from what is being described for Schumacher, it is
>perfectly realistic.

Except that the steering column prevented you from left foot braking
in F1 cars circa 1967...

Jason

ae

simultaneous throttle and brake

by ae » Tue, 02 Sep 2003 02:31:18



Geez, I didn't realise Schuey had been around so long! ;-)
--
Andrew

Cliff Roma

simultaneous throttle and brake

by Cliff Roma » Tue, 02 Sep 2003 02:38:18

Do that too much and you will burn out the clutch


To avoid that you can feather the gas and clutch together to


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.