rec.autos.simulators

On-Line Question for GPL

Paul Jage

On-Line Question for GPL

by Paul Jage » Tue, 10 Nov 1998 04:00:00

I have just raced for the 1st time on the 'net'. However,
the opponents cars disappear, even when close, and then
reappear again. Do I need to turn down the res or detail
level?
I have a PII 450 with 256 Ram, and a 56k connection, playing
at 1024x768 (2xMonster 3dfx II cards)
Thanks
ymenar

On-Line Question for GPL

by ymenar » Tue, 10 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Paul Jager wrote

This is called warping.  It's mostly because of quality connections and also
the unstable Internet ;)      .

Normally, you should try to always achieve 36fps all the time when racing
online in GPL. I will now send you to Alison's GPL webpage (she was a beta
tester for it). There is full of FAQ and there is a great section called
"Online" where I think you will find all the answers you want ;)

The URL is :  http://www.nh.ultranet.com/~alison/gpl/

- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> Good race at the Brickyard!
- Official Mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
- Excuse me for my English (I'm French speaking)
- Sponsored by http://www.awpss.com/ on the NROS
- "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."--

David G Fishe

On-Line Question for GPL

by David G Fishe » Tue, 10 Nov 1998 04:00:00

ymenard, why don't you tell him the truth? The warping on a machine like his
should be minimal. Other games it would be, with GPL, it's a different
story.

David G Fisher


>Paul Jager wrote
>>I have just raced for the 1st time on the 'net'. However,
>>the opponents cars disappear, even when close, and then
>>reappear again.

>This is called warping.  It's mostly because of quality connections and
also
>the unstable Internet ;)      .

Eric T. Busc

On-Line Question for GPL

by Eric T. Busc » Tue, 10 Nov 1998 04:00:00

The truth is that unless you know the quality of his connection and
those he was racing with there's no way to tell...

- Eric



David G Fishe

On-Line Question for GPL

by David G Fishe » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

The truth is that people are constantly talking about these problems. It's
been going on for weeks now. I'm willing to bet a real Ferrari that if I
gave the original poster a few other sims (or other games with online
ability), he doesn't have the same disconnects and warping with his system
and internet connection.

David G Fisher


>The truth is that unless you know the quality of his connection and
>those he was racing with there's no way to tell...

>- Eric

Andrew MacPhers

On-Line Question for GPL

by Andrew MacPhers » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

You're probably right. But I read somewhere (Alison's FAQ?) than GPL exchanges
something like twice as much info as Nascar2, and Nascar2 didn't use TCP/IP, which is
much more sensitive (I believe) than hub-based IPX type networking. And packet size is --
as I understand it -- the biggest problem for Net ***.

Quake (and more recently Unreal) both struggled hugely at the start, and are still only viable
with a central server based on a fast connection. Despite all their efforts it's still impossible
for a modem user to run a server for more than one or two players to connect to. I fly Su27
online and it faces similar problems to GPL. So does Warbirds, even using simple Head to
Head IP connections, and when I tried the multiplayer Dawn of Aces arena it had more warp
than the whole of Starfleet Command put together. (And Warbirds/DoA are coded from the
bottom up as Net games).

So overall, saying one game performs better on the Net than other isn't a very constructive
statement. It can be perfectly true, but totally meaningless. It's more improtant to compare
people's Net connections than the actual software they're using.

Andrew McP... trying to compare apples with apples

David G Fishe

On-Line Question for GPL

by David G Fishe » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

GPL is not the first racing sim/game to offer TCP/IP racing. It's far from
it. Yet, even though it has the advantage of being the most recent release,
it's performance on the net is disappointing. I'm at the point now with GPL
online that I don't even care what the reasons are for performance problems.
If too much info is being sent, then they should of cut back on the
unnecessary info and just sent the essential. They should of simply copied
whatever other sim developers did that works.

David G Fisher


>>  I'm willing to bet a real Ferrari that if I gave the original poster a
few
>> other sims (or other games with online ability), he doesn't have the
>>  same disconnects and warping with his system and internet connection.

>You're probably right. But I read somewhere (Alison's FAQ?) than GPL
exchanges
>something like twice as much info as Nascar2, and Nascar2 didn't use
TCP/IP, which is
>much more sensitive (I believe) than hub-based IPX type networking. And
packet size is --
>as I understand it -- the biggest problem for Net ***.

Michael Powel

On-Line Question for GPL

by Michael Powel » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

I hope Papyrus look at this and fix it in a patch, I was having an online
race at the 'Ring the other day and there were 2 main problems -

1) Virtually the entire field crashed at the start due to warping - this is
exacerbated by the physics model: if 2 cars warp and end up interpenetrating
the physics model generates a sudden enormous force between them, resulting
in the cars flying off suddenly, sometimes high into the air.

2) The 'Ring is so narrow that you couldn't pass anyone safely as their
"warp radius" was as wide as the track!

This was somebody hosting a race with 10 people over a cable modem. I was
using ISDN with a ping time of 240.

- Michael

John Walla

On-Line Question for GPL

by John Walla » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

On Tue, 10 Nov 1998 00:57:08 -0500, "David G Fisher"


>The truth is that people are constantly talking about these problems. It's
>been going on for weeks now. I'm willing to bet a real Ferrari that if I
>gave the original poster a few other sims (or other games with online
>ability), he doesn't have the same disconnects and warping with his system
>and internet connection.

Y'know, it's funny the way logic goes around here.

Some people have trouble with internet play and the fault lies with
GPL. Never mind the fact that we use the same software and that the
guy's CPU, modem, memory, entire system, are better than mine and the
only thing that differs is his internet connect.

As Eric mentioned, without investigating his connection and who else
was connected to the server you can't understand the problem far less
solve it. Saying "it's GPL" is one way to minimise his chances of
solving the problem by ensuring he stops looking for it.

Cheers!
John

John Walla

On-Line Question for GPL

by John Walla » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

On Mon, 9 Nov 1998 20:22:55 -0500, "David G Fisher"


>ymenard, why don't you tell him the truth? The warping on a machine like his
>should be minimal. Other games it would be, with GPL, it's a different
>story.

David, you'll be after Marc's "font" title next.

The power of the system has little or nothing to do with warping,
rather it's the internet connection he needs to look at. No matter how
powerful a system is, if it doesn't have the data it can't plot it.

Cheers!
John

Matthew Knutse

On-Line Question for GPL

by Matthew Knutse » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

I feel I have to give my 2 cents on this matter 2 :)I have spent far too
much time racing GPL over the net, and with my system (ISDN, PII), I'd
say it's pretty darn good. Sure, I have been to races where quite a
number of people have been disconnected, but those concerned have
through some work managed to improve that. I have had very few races
where I have been dropped, unless there has been major mayhem. It might
sound childish, but I find it totally amazing that I can _race_ somebody
in the USA. While sitting in the absoulute middle of nowhere; at a laid
- down farm -in Norway!!
In my first league race, that lasted for one hour + practice, there was
1 disco. And 14 starters!
And the competition was close..in my real life racing experience, there
"disconnect rate" was much higher!!

Not too bad IMO!

Matt_K

Byron Forbe

On-Line Question for GPL

by Byron Forbe » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Gotta agree with you here. It seems there are a lot of probs on the starting grid too,
probably related to a drop in fps because of the extra cars needed to be drawn both ahead
and in the mirrors. For this reason, and being able to see what's going on around us,
perhpas a little practice with the F10 view might be a good idea at race starts? This view
reportedly yields significantly better fps and should also help us avoid incidents at the
start.


> GPL is not the first racing sim/game to offer TCP/IP racing. It's far from
> it. Yet, even though it has the advantage of being the most recent release,
> it's performance on the net is disappointing. I'm at the point now with GPL
> online that I don't even care what the reasons are for performance problems.
> If too much info is being sent, then they should of cut back on the
> unnecessary info and just sent the essential. They should of simply copied
> whatever other sim developers did that works.

> David G Fisher


> >>  I'm willing to bet a real Ferrari that if I gave the original poster a
> few
> >> other sims (or other games with online ability), he doesn't have the
> >>  same disconnects and warping with his system and internet connection.

> >You're probably right. But I read somewhere (Alison's FAQ?) than GPL
> exchanges
> >something like twice as much info as Nascar2, and Nascar2 didn't use
> TCP/IP, which is
> >much more sensitive (I believe) than hub-based IPX type networking. And
> packet size is --
> >as I understand it -- the biggest problem for Net ***.

--
 Byron Forbes
 Captain of Team Lightning Bolt

 http://www.racesimcentral.net/~HOSHUMUNGUS

    and

 http://www.racesimcentral.net/~godsoe/bolt/home.htm

John Walla

On-Line Question for GPL

by John Walla » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

On Tue, 10 Nov 1998 03:53:07 -0500, "David G Fisher"


>it's performance on the net is disappointing. I'm at the point now with GPL
>online that I don't even care what the reasons are for performance problems.

That may be why you still have them. My 28.8 modem allows me to join
and race perfectly in 17 player races with packets going back and
forward between me in Scotland and the server in the U.S. - doesn't
that suggest something with your system and connection worth looking
into?

What's to fix, it works perfectly.

Cheers!
John

Michael E. Carve

On-Line Question for GPL

by Michael E. Carve » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00


% The truth is that people are constantly talking about these problems. It's
% been going on for weeks now. I'm willing to bet a real Ferrari that if I
% gave the original poster a few other sims (or other games with online
% ability), he doesn't have the same disconnects and warping with his system
% and internet connection.

Warping is caused by either a bad DUN setup or poor performance by the
warper's ISP's internal network or connection to the Internet.  One
other factor is the lantency rate.  The higher the lantency, the more
warping will occur.  Try Ping'ing a host and see how many "time outs" or
lost packets you receive.  The more time outs, the higher the odds for
warping, or even worse Disconnects.  One other factor involved in high
latencies, is the number of hops to the host machine.  Try traceroute
(or tracert in Win95) to find out the number of hops.  

There is a TON of data being pumped back and forth by GPL.  Just check
your modem status after a session on-line and look at the data pushed
back and forth.  I bet in other sims, the number of bytes for the same
amount of on-line time will be greatly less.

--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
     Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./.  [-  < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

Michael Powel

On-Line Question for GPL

by Michael Powel » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Can you give us more info? - what are your special DUN settings and which
ISP do you use?

- Michael


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.