rec.autos.simulators

My GP3 Opinion

Luis Sot

My GP3 Opinion

by Luis Sot » Sun, 30 Jul 2000 04:00:00

You can actually turn it off.  I'm also EXTREMELY annoyed by the car
creeping when idling in gear, but I'm not sure if this is at all inaccurate,
since you *are* providing engine power to the "drive" wheels when you put in
gear.  I think they  overdid it, though. In my opinion, the single greatest
disappointment is that wacky AI.
L.S.


Macc

My GP3 Opinion

by Macc » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

As most of you know, ive been thoroughly for GP3 in the lead up to its
release instead of against it.  I was totally looking forward to it
all friday, got out of work and went striaght to the computer shop in
town hoping that they would have a copy of it.  They did, and i bought
it straight away.
My first opinion is mixed, there is a lot of good and a lot of bad
things about the game.  It is definatly similar to GP2 which isnt
exactly a bad thing.  I quite like the game.
I just did my first proper race then, after only stuffing around with
it earlier.
I chose Australia, did realistic weather, and i was Fisichella in the
Benneton.  I went to the Australia GP in 98 so i remembered the track
well, and all the sponsers etc.
It is VERY well re created, the coloured sand pits, the qantas
sponsers, even down to how the grass was mowed!!!
It was a dry Qualifying session, and it was on rookie, with brakes,
indestructible and autocorrect off.
I went out, and noticed straight away just how quick the car brakes.
Very different to the GP2 braking.  Usually you would need ot brake
near the 150 mark or so in GP2 and it would be a gradual brake down
the gears, in GP3 you can brake at the 100m mark and go into the
corner to slow!!!  This put me off a bit as i was unsure where to
brake, so i went off a few times.  
I ended up witha 1.36.7 and on pole.  I thought, beauty, it wasnt the
best lap, but it was still pretty good.  The cars looked great, as did
the pit crew.  The trees especially on the west side of the track
looked very blocky, but some trees are blocky close up in GPL as well.
Onto the race.  It was wet.  GREAT i thought.  On pole, in the prime
position, and it was a medium type rain, with monsoon later in the
race (around 20% in)
I started well, which was good, got into the lead, but broke too late
into turn 1 in the wet, which was where i broke for in the dry.  I
went on the kerb and got touched by schumacher from the side.  We both
spun, caused some major chaos and struggled to get out of it.  I ended
up 21st by the end of the second turn!!  I only finished 2 laps before
i got hit by Panis and lost a wheel (it was my fault tho)

My opinion on this game.  Im a bit dissapointed...some of the things
are plain confusing, and ***in annoying.

The wheel is annoying, it seems like i have no control over it
sometimes.  It looks like the driver is ifhgting with the wheel, which
is a good thing, but it gives the impression that i dont have control.

In GPL you can turn anyway you want on a turn, straight etc.  You cant
do this in GP3.  If you are on a straight and slow right down and try
to turn the opposite way, the wheel only turns about 10% and you glide
intot he wall.  If you want to turn say left, and a right hand corner,
you cant.  I use the keyboard, and if you press left, you go straight
on.  

THE single most annoying thing, other than not getting steering help
off, is that you cant actaully stop toa  halt.  If i brake down to 0
km, and then i let go of the brake button, it starts to speed upto
about 20 km, which is ***y annoying if youve just spun and want to
try to spin turn it.  
Some things need to be fixed.  I wish i knew how to turn the steering
help off.  All the other buttons are black, and green.  But teh
steering help option is a greyish colour, that you cant change.

ohwell,  i still like this game.  I shall continue having fun
___________________
Macca
"I'd kill myself for you...Id kill you for myself"
Pantera - This Love

G.Aitke

My GP3 Opinion

by G.Aitke » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00


> THE single most annoying thing, other than not getting steering help
> off, is that you cant actaully stop toa  halt.  If i brake down to 0
> km, and then i let go of the brake button, it starts to speed upto
> about 20 km, which is ***y annoying if youve just spun and want to
> try to spin turn it.

Hehe, I fell foul of that, Use the cluch mate ;0). The engine would
stall in reality - don't ask me why it doesn't in GP3. GPL dips the
clutch for you, and I got used to that, it throw me a little then GP3
didn't.

You are using a default control set, you need to setup your own. When
you 've done that all the greyed out stuff will be selectable. I
struggled with that for an hour before the penny dropped. It's a case of
a simple thing that's been over complicated.

Good luck

Norm

My GP3 Opinion

by Norm » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

Is it just me or are most of the problems, ***es and complaints about GP3
easily fixed when people actually look at the game set-up and tweak it for
each's individual needs. I mean Steering problems but they have steering
help on?? Sheeeeesh guess I will find out how the game really is when it
hits the US.

Norm



> >The wheel is annoying, it seems like i have no control over it
> >sometimes.  It looks like the driver is ifhgting with the wheel, which
> >is a good thing, but it gives the impression that i dont have control.

> Sounds as if you may have a little spiking in your wheel.
> Try increasing the deadzone slightly.

> >In GPL you can turn anyway you want on a turn, straight etc.  You cant
> >do this in GP3.  If you are on a straight and slow right down and try
> >to turn the opposite way, the wheel only turns about 10% and you glide
> >intot he wall.  If you want to turn say left, and a right hand corner,
> >you cant.  I use the keyboard, and if you press left, you go straight
> >on.

> You have a Microsoft FF wheel, right? There is a known problem.
> Also, you are -definitely- experiencing push (understeer). Try doing
> the keyboard thing in GPL and tell us what it does.

> >THE single most annoying thing, other than not getting steering help
> >off, is that you cant actaully stop toa  halt.  If i brake down to 0
> >km, and then i let go of the brake button, it starts to speed upto
> >about 20 km, which is ***y annoying if youve just spun and want to
> >try to spin turn it.

> Idling motor, Macca. Ticking over, if you prefer. Press and hold
> your shift lever to disengage the clutch. Not a problem. Realistic.

Harjan Bran

My GP3 Opinion

by Harjan Bran » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

Oops, my F1 car was running at idle revs and I put it in first, dead. It
stalled. It's irritating, doesn't happen in real life, they took out the
stalling bit and just modelled what would happen without stalling.

I think the start is irritating as well, it's just to easy to have a good
reaction time. It's impossible to have a bad one.




> >You can actually turn it off.  I'm also EXTREMELY annoyed by the car
> >creeping when idling in gear, but I'm not sure if this is at all
inaccurate,
> >since you *are* providing engine power to the "drive" wheels when you put
in
> >gear.  I think they  overdid it, though.

> Luis:

> 1) Go to your street car and rev the engine to 2500-3000 rpm
> (the idle speed of a modern F1)

> 2) Drop your car into gear.

> 3) Note what happens.

> 4) Report back to us with your findings.

> Thanks.

Macc

My GP3 Opinion

by Macc » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00



Please tell me how you turn it off.  I can go into options, and turn
off Steering help, but on the wheel in the game its grey, when
everything else is fluro green (meaning on) or black (meaning off)  so
i got no idea how to turn it off, as i actually went into the options
and DID turn it off
___________________
Macca
"I'd kill myself for you...Id kill you for myself"
Pantera - This Love

Macc

My GP3 Opinion

by Macc » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

On Sat, 29 Jul 2000 21:52:46 -0500, rrevved



>>The wheel is annoying, it seems like i have no control over it
>>sometimes.  It looks like the driver is ifhgting with the wheel, which
>>is a good thing, but it gives the impression that i dont have control.

>Sounds as if you may have a little spiking in your wheel.
>Try increasing the deadzone slightly.

i dont have a wheel

i  dont have a wheel.  In GPL you can turn the opposite way from the
turn and actually turn that way.  In GP3, you go straight on.

Idling motor.  You mean, on the grid you dont touch the keys at all,
and you creep forward.  If thats so, then why cant you creep forward
before the lights go out.

___________________
Macca
"I'd kill myself for you...Id kill you for myself"
Pantera - This Love

Macc

My GP3 Opinion

by Macc » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00


>Is it just me or are most of the problems, ***es and complaints about GP3
>easily fixed when people actually look at the game set-up and tweak it for
>each's individual needs. I mean Steering problems but they have steering
>help on?? Sheeeeesh guess I will find out how the game really is when it
>hits the US.

I turned Steering help off, but it is a different colour on the wheel
than the other options as if to say you cannot change this option
___________________
Macca
"I'd kill myself for you...Id kill you for myself"
Pantera - This Love
Luis Sot

My GP3 Opinion

by Luis Sot » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

Which is why I said I DIDN'T think it was entirely inaccurate, "since you
*are* providing engine power to the 'drive' wheels when you put in gear" (I
*did* so qualify my statement my post). However...wouldn't you stall in an
F1 if you are idling...just idling...and then drop it in gear without
increasing the revs?

L.S.

Mats Lofkvis

My GP3 Opinion

by Mats Lofkvis » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00


> 1) Go to your street car and rev the engine to 2500-3000 rpm
> (the idle speed of a modern F1)

> 2) Drop your car into gear.

> 3) Note what happens.

> 4) Report back to us with your findings.

> Thanks.

Your street car probably has a red line at around 6000; the
F1 maxes out at 18000 or so. So 3000 in the F1 is more like
1000 in the street car if you just compare the rpm's, which
means the relative idle rpm's are more or less the same.

Without auto-throttle to stop the engine from stalling, the
low rotational inertia of the F1 engine surely would kill it
immediately at a idle rpm / no throttle start, but how much
would it pull at idle rpm with proper amount of throttle?

The F1 has a completely insane power to weight ratio compared
to the street car, but on the other hand the level of tuning
of the F1 engine also reduces the relative level of torque
at low rpm's a lot.

So the problem now is to judge if the factor 20 higher power
to weight ratio of the F1 is enough to make it pull harder
than a street car at idle rpm's, despite the extreme level
of tuning.

I don't know :-)

      _
Mats Lofkvist

Macc

My GP3 Opinion

by Macc » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

On Sun, 30 Jul 2000 06:26:02 -0500, rrevved


>>i  dont have a wheel.  In GPL you can turn the opposite way from the
>>turn and actually turn that way.  In GP3, you go straight on.

>One word ---> 'Understeer'.

>(Look it up)

you dont get what i mean.  What i mean is...in GPL you can go straight
on in the corners and it goes straight.  On GP3 it turns in a bit
instead of going dead straight.  
Say im about to turn on turn 1 at hockenheim (a right hander)
For some un godly reason i want to turn left there.  If i press the
left key just before the turn you go straight on instead of turning
left.  If this was GPL you would turn left.
Do you understand now what i mean??

___________________
Macca
"I'd kill myself for you...Id kill you for myself"
Pantera - This Love

ExMrBlond

My GP3 Opinion

by ExMrBlond » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

I know what you mean Macca.  There are two lots of steering assist in GP3.
One is in the normal driving aids, the other is in the Controller Setup.
There is a bar that that says "Steering Assist" (or something like that),
and it defaults to 100%.  If you turn this down to 0%, then it will get rid
of your problem.. You can only change this if you create a new setup option.
Click on the right of screen to where it says "Unused" and set up your
controller from scratch.  This DOESN'T work when setting up a new keyboard
setup !! (I don't know why though)

Hope this helps...

Macc

My GP3 Opinion

by Macc » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

On Sun, 30 Jul 2000 07:21:01 -0500, rrevved


>>you dont get what i mean.  What i mean is...in GPL you can go straight
>>on in the corners and it goes straight.  On GP3 it turns in a bit
>>instead of going dead straight.  
>>Say im about to turn on turn 1 at hockenheim (a right hander)
>>For some un godly reason i want to turn left there.  If i press the
>>left key just before the turn you go straight on instead of turning
>>left.  If this was GPL you would turn left.
>>Do you understand now what i mean??

>Yes. Turn OFF the driving aids. It is trying to steer you
>automatically into the corner.

>That will fix it.

god sake I HAVE.  THATS WHY IM ANNOYED BECAUSE I DID TURN THEM ALL OFF
AND IT DIDNT WORK
___________________
Macca
"I'd kill myself for you...Id kill you for myself"
Pantera - This Love
Macc

My GP3 Opinion

by Macc » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00

On Sun, 30 Jul 2000 22:40:41 +1000, "ExMrBlonde"


>I know what you mean Macca.  There are two lots of steering assist in GP3.
>One is in the normal driving aids, the other is in the Controller Setup.
>There is a bar that that says "Steering Assist" (or something like that),
>and it defaults to 100%.  If you turn this down to 0%, then it will get rid
>of your problem.. You can only change this if you create a new setup option.
>Click on the right of screen to where it says "Unused" and set up your
>controller from scratch.  This DOESN'T work when setting up a new keyboard
>setup !! (I don't know why though)

>Hope this helps...

thankyou :)
___________________
Macca
"I'd kill myself for you...Id kill you for myself"
Pantera - This Love
Jeff Vince

My GP3 Opinion

by Jeff Vince » Mon, 31 Jul 2000 04:00:00



Macca,

   Since the resident GP3 guru seems to have trouble communicating
with you, I'll try (even though I don't have GP3).

   First, rrevved, he's using the keyboard (try reading his original
post).

   Second, GP2 (and since GP3 is JLGP2) had steering help in two
places, one in aids and one in controller setup.

   Third, if you are using the keyboard, I think it may be impossible
to turn one of those aids off.  Sorry.

"But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was
nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into
a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.