rec.autos.simulators

Papy goes the same way as Indy

Scott B. Huste

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Scott B. Huste » Wed, 19 May 1999 04:00:00

Winning $$$$ does not make it prestigious when you are competing against
has been and never was drivers.

Scott
PA-Scott
G.T.S. Racing - http://www.racesimcentral.net/

--
Scott B. Husted
ICQ# 4395450

Mark Seer

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Mark Seer » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00

Not forgetting that Moreno got some good results at Benneton when he
replaced Nannini, including a second place.

Mark


> > btw - isn't Cheever the only ex-F1 pilot in IRL? Have I forgotten
someone
> > else?

> -Raul Boesel did some F1 in 1982-83 for March and Ligier.
> -Roberto Guerrero did 2 F1 race in 82/83 also (Ensign F1 team and Theodore
> F1 team).
> -Eliseo Salazar did some F1 in 1981-82-83 (Ensign F1, ATS Ford and Ram
> March).
> -Roberto Moreno raced and tested in F1 in 1987,88,89,90,91,92 and 1995
> (Forti!)

> I think that's all with Eddie Cheever.

> --
> -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
> -- NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
> -- SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
> -- Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
> -- May the Downforce be with you...

> "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
> how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."

John Bod

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by John Bod » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00



>>if you're an F1 fan, the IRL *does* have something to offer . . .

>It certainly had something to offer its Champion: A chance to bail for the bigs
>and drive in NASCAR, where he's doing pretty well! Haven't read too much about
>the rest of the pack being offered rides outside the League, whereas F1 shelled
>out big bucks to get Zanardi and Villeneuve back from CART.

Somebody correct me if I'm wrong (I know you guys will -- you never
disappoint), but I heard that Zanardi took a pay CUT to go from Chip
Ganassi's CART team to F1.  

On the subject of the IRL, Roger Penske recruited Jason Leffler from
the IRL to use him as his test driver this year.  Stewart may be
reaching the "household name" level, but there are definitely others
with talent in the IRL.

John Bod

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by John Bod » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00

On Tue, 18 May 1999 13:42:01 GMT, "Scott B. Husted"


>Winning $$$$ does not make it prestigious when you are competing against
>has been and never was drivers.

Here's words you'll NEVER hear any real race driver utter:

Driver:  "No sir, I'm sorry -- I can't accept that million-dollar
purse.  Your race just isn't prestigious enough, and I couldn't
tarnish my reputation as a driver by taking your money and making
myself a millioniaire.  I'll go struggle in some other series . . ."

If a first-place prize of over a million dollars, and a total purse in
excess of 8 million isn't "prestigious," then I don't know what is.  

Speaking of prestigious, could you tell me, by chance, how much
Montoya's earned for any of his past 3 victories?  I'm not questioning
his talent here, mind you -- he's a DEFINITE talent -- but I'd like to
put a dollar figure on this issue of "prestige," just for the record.

-- JB

John Bod

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by John Bod » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00

Okay folks, this has REALLY gotten ridiculous -- this is one of the
longest threads I've seen in the R.A.S newsgroup yet.  The argument is
asinine, and it really would be more at home in the R.A.S.I. newsgroup
than here, so I'm going to put an end to it now:

The IRL sucks; F1 is just a bunch of weenies; NASCAR ain't real
racin'.  CART rules, period.  The Indy 500 is dead, and Tony George
should be hanged until dead.

There.  Everybody satisfied?  Good.  Now, let's get back to talking
about simulations.  

[Please note that this is the first deurogatory thing I've said here
about ANY race series, and I'm only speaking in jest about F1 and
NASCAR -- and the IRL for that matter.]

-- John Bodin
   Former Publisher, The IRL Insider Magazine
   (now defunct due to the demise of the Indy 500 and the IRL)
   http://www.don'tbothertheirlisajokeandyoudon'tcareanyway.com

John Bod

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by John Bod » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00



>>IMS wants a package deal:  Whoever
>>agrees to broadcast every race of the entire IRL series -- preferrably
>>live -- will win the rights to the Indianapolis 500 in the year 2000
>>and beyond.

>At last! A reason to sign up for the Disney Channel!

What -- you never noticed that Donald Duck isn't wearing any pants
until now?  <G>

;-)

-- JB

"No, your honor, I didn't say she was crazy, I said she was . . ."

John Bod

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by John Bod » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00

On Tue, 18 May 1999 23:50:30 -0400, "Scott B. Husted"



>> On Tue, 18 May 1999 13:42:01 GMT, "Scott B. Husted"

>> >Winning $$$$ does not make it prestigious when you are competing against
>> >has been and never was drivers.

>> Here's words you'll NEVER hear any real race driver utter:

>> Driver:  "No sir, I'm sorry -- I can't accept that million-dollar
>> purse.  Your race just isn't prestigious enough, and I couldn't
>> tarnish my reputation as a driver by taking your money and making
>> myself a millioniaire.  I'll go struggle in some other series . . ."

>So what you are saying is that IRL drivers are just collecting money at Indy
>because 99% of them dont have the talent to compete in a "real" series??
>"Ill stay in the IRL so I can compete and make money because I dont have
>enough talent to run in CART and its top notch talent."  ???

No, that's what YOU'RE saying.  Don't put words in my mouth.  I'm the
one who thinks the IRL *is* a "real" prestigious series with top notch
talent, remember?  

I can't tell you how good it makes me feel to know that you follow the
IRL *that* closely -- I couldn't have come up with those figures off
the top of my head.  Doesn't this illustrate to you the inherent
wrongness with your overall view of this whole issue?  The IRL is a
series that you seem to loath, and yet you follow it closely enough
that you are able to retain more useless, esoteric information about
that series than an avowed, *** IRL fan?  Seek help, man, seek
help.  If you like something, watch it, follow it, devour it if you
will, but if you don't like something, then find better things to do
with your time.  Take a walk, spend time with your loved ones, but
don't waste another second of your life following the IRL, worrying
about the state of the Indianapolis 500, or getting all twisted up
with negativity in general.  Geez -- racing is SUPPPOSED to be
entertainment.  

Again, the issue of "top talent" is purely based on individual
opinion.  Alex Zanaradi isn't competing against Dale Earnhardt or Jeff
Gordon, so he isn't (and hasn't) competed against the top talent,
which makes him second-rate . . . gimme a break!  We're almost down to
the "my driver is better than your driver" level here.  I feel an
uncontrollable urge to say, "Oh yeah?  Well neener-neener . . ."

- Show quoted text -

John Bod

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by John Bod » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00



>Okay folks, this has REALLY gotten ridiculous -- this is one of the
>longest threads I've seen in the R.A.S newsgroup yet.  The argument is
>asinine, and it really would be more at home in the R.A.S.I. newsgroup
>than here, so I'm going to put an end to it now:

>The IRL sucks; F1 is just a bunch of weenies; NASCAR ain't real
>racin'.  CART rules, period.  The Indy 500 is dead, and Tony George
>should be hanged until dead.

>There.  Everybody satisfied?  Good.  Now, let's get back to talking
>about simulations.  

>[Please note that this is the first deurogatory thing I've said here
>about ANY race series, and I'm only speaking in jest about F1 and
>NASCAR -- and the IRL for that matter.]

FWIW, I was just kidding about the Tony George part, too -- he's a
VERY nice guy, actually.

- Show quoted text -

Scott B. Huste

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Scott B. Huste » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00


> I can't tell you how good it makes me feel to know that you follow the
> IRL *that* closely -- I couldn't have come up with those figures off
> the top of my head.

No... I simply went to ESPN.com and found it.  They didn't have the dollar
winnings for CART and I didn't feel like looking.  Im not a diehard CART fan
either... but I do enjoy watching them.

Not in the least.

Read above.  I simply pulled it off ESPN.com     I can find the winnings of the
professional chess players but that doesn't mean im a "***" fan.

If it means it would scramble my brain enough to think that the IRL is a
"professional" race series I will pass <G>   The day I believe the IRL in its
current format is a "professional" race series is the day I get a lobotomy!  <G>

SUPPOSED to be is the operative word for the IRL.

I dont and will never follow the IRL.

The last time I knew Zanardi was not a stock car driver, he was an open wheel
racer.   BIG difference.

Scott
PA-Scott

--
Scott B. Husted
ICQ# 4395450

Andre Min

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Andre Min » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00


> >Okay folks, this has REALLY gotten ridiculous -- this is one of the
> >longest threads I've seen in the R.A.S newsgroup yet.  

John, I see where you're coming from on the IRL/Indy issue.
Unfortunately, it seems that nobody can change anybody's mindset about
an issue on RAS.  That's just the way it is. Save your sanity... you
can't fend off all the incoming missles from the "other viewpoint".
I've got caught up in them in the past... and it's fruitless. However, I
never learn, so...

As for IRL... I'm not real partial to it, but probably because it
doesn't get much exposure, so I don't see it much.  I will say this:

ANYBODY that will jump into a high powered missle and hurl it around at
those speeds deserves a TRUE racing enthusiats respect, league
regardless.  The "Billy Boats" take just as much, or more, risk as the
"Schumacher's" or "Andretti's", etc.  What saddens me is that even
self-proclaimed/so-called "racing enthusiasts" can have the audacity to
belittle the IRL's driver's efforts, and they are engaged in a
potentially life threatning sport as much as any open wheeled driver.  

I have seen drivers with "heart" in each series.  To think that a driver
is less of a person than another because he drives in IRL is ludicrous.
I remember watching Buddy Lazier almost collapse while in the Winner's
Cirle at Indy a few years back.  Why? Because he was driving with a
(recovering) broken back.  Think about that. 220+ MPH with a broken
back... knowing that even a small mishap could leave him crippled for
life. Yet, he took the risk. Why? Because he's a RACER through and
through.  

Odd. I hear all this about that "no name" driver, etc.  Hmmm... seems to
me that every upcoming driver is a "no name". That's why's he's there...
to prove his worth. Few knew squat about past "newbies" in CART.
(Remember some of the hairbrained mistakes a certain newbie made in his
rookie year in CART?  It was a fellow by the name of Alex Zanardi.)  But
some went on to prove their talent... those that couldn't, fall by the
wayside.  That's racing.  Ditto this this "Tony Stewart" kid... who's
he?  Well, it's being proven that he can indeed run with the best in his
chosen ield: Nascar Winston Cup. And, like it or not, he came up through
the IRL to get there.

And therein lies another overlooked fact: Perhaps most of the upcoming
IRL boys don't WANT to drive F1 cars.  Their passion is oval racing.  As
for the so-called "has been" F1 drivers in IRL (or CART)... well...
could it just be that (though their skills aren't what's required for
F1)... they just want to RACE?  Seems to me that's a genuine racer. One
that won't quit because he can't be in the "Big Show" that has all the
glamour... but instead, he finds a car, a series, SOMETHING... and keeps
racing.  Seems to me that's "heart".  But what do I know?

Anyway, it saddens me to see drivers that lay everything on the line,
risking life and limb, REGARDLESS of venue, to be sneered at and
belittled because that venue doesn't happen to be the "Anointed One" of
the small person doing the sneering.  To me, that's a real tradgedy.

Andre Ming

Zonk

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Zonk » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00


>Toyota Atlantic (which is running a race
>this year as a support race for the Canadian GP),

This is not a new thing. They've beening running as a support race there as
long back as i can recall.

Z.

Please remove NOSPAM from my email address when replying.

Bill Bollinge

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Bill Bollinge » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00


> The last time I knew Zanardi was not a stock car driver, he was an open wheel
> racer.   BIG difference.

Assuming it is a BIG difference, it MUST take a LOT of talent to do
both.  Heheheheh, has there been ANY CART guys go from open to stock
cars successfully?  Note:  Since the split up?

Hmmmmm, I wonder which series has had people do that most difficult
trick of being successful in open and stock cars :)  IRL or CART?

Bill / Amish on TEN

Chris Schlette

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Chris Schlette » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00

And your point is what?  With the exception of John Andretti, I would hazard
a guess that most CART drivers wouldn't even want to drive NASCARs.  A lot
of the CART guys have road racing roots, not the other way around.  If they
are going to leave a series for another (by choice and not by not being able
to get rides, aka Cheever, Goodyear, Roberto, etc.) it'd be F1.  IRL and
NASCAR are more alike than CART and NASCAR so you might see a fair amount of
transition between the two, but I don't think you'd see many Busch or WC
drivers going to IRL.

Bill Bollinge

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by Bill Bollinge » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00


>> Hmmmmm, I wonder which series has had people do that most difficult
>> trick of being successful in open and stock cars :)  IRL or CART?

>And your point is what

Well, the point was that it IS difficult and takes a very talented driver to
make successful transition between the 2 series.  I just wonder which series
has produced the most successful drivers at making that transition?  It was
said earlier it is NOT a easy transition.  Assuming it isn't an easy
transition it MUST take talented drivers to make that transition.  If that
is true, then it would seem logical that the series that has produced more
successful racers in the other series MUST have more talented drivers?
So.... Which has produced more?  IRL or CART?

Bill / Amish on TEN

David Kar

Papy goes the same way as Indy

by David Kar » Thu, 20 May 1999 04:00:00

Andre,

Well put; that needed saying.

DK



> > >Okay folks, this has REALLY gotten ridiculous -- this is one of the
> > >longest threads I've seen in the R.A.S newsgroup yet.

> John, I see where you're coming from on the IRL/Indy issue.
> Unfortunately, it seems that nobody can change anybody's mindset about
> an issue on RAS.  That's just the way it is. Save your sanity... you
> can't fend off all the incoming missles from the "other viewpoint".
> I've got caught up in them in the past... and it's fruitless. However, I
> never learn, so...

> As for IRL... I'm not real partial to it, but probably because it
> doesn't get much exposure, so I don't see it much.  I will say this:

> ANYBODY that will jump into a high powered missle and hurl it around at
> those speeds deserves a TRUE racing enthusiats respect, league
> regardless.  The "Billy Boats" take just as much, or more, risk as the
> "Schumacher's" or "Andretti's", etc.  What saddens me is that even
> self-proclaimed/so-called "racing enthusiasts" can have the audacity to
> belittle the IRL's driver's efforts, and they are engaged in a
> potentially life threatning sport as much as any open wheeled driver.

> I have seen drivers with "heart" in each series.  To think that a driver
> is less of a person than another because he drives in IRL is ludicrous.
> I remember watching Buddy Lazier almost collapse while in the Winner's
> Cirle at Indy a few years back.  Why? Because he was driving with a
> (recovering) broken back.  Think about that. 220+ MPH with a broken
> back... knowing that even a small mishap could leave him crippled for
> life. Yet, he took the risk. Why? Because he's a RACER through and
> through.

> Odd. I hear all this about that "no name" driver, etc.  Hmmm... seems to
> me that every upcoming driver is a "no name". That's why's he's there...
> to prove his worth. Few knew squat about past "newbies" in CART.
> (Remember some of the hairbrained mistakes a certain newbie made in his
> rookie year in CART?  It was a fellow by the name of Alex Zanardi.)  But
> some went on to prove their talent... those that couldn't, fall by the
> wayside.  That's racing.  Ditto this this "Tony Stewart" kid... who's
> he?  Well, it's being proven that he can indeed run with the best in his
> chosen ield: Nascar Winston Cup. And, like it or not, he came up through
> the IRL to get there.

> And therein lies another overlooked fact: Perhaps most of the upcoming
> IRL boys don't WANT to drive F1 cars.  Their passion is oval racing.  As
> for the so-called "has been" F1 drivers in IRL (or CART)... well...
> could it just be that (though their skills aren't what's required for
> F1)... they just want to RACE?  Seems to me that's a genuine racer. One
> that won't quit because he can't be in the "Big Show" that has all the
> glamour... but instead, he finds a car, a series, SOMETHING... and keeps
> racing.  Seems to me that's "heart".  But what do I know?

> Anyway, it saddens me to see drivers that lay everything on the line,
> risking life and limb, REGARDLESS of venue, to be sneered at and
> belittled because that venue doesn't happen to be the "Anointed One" of
> the small person doing the sneering.  To me, that's a real tradgedy.

> Andre Ming


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.