rec.autos.simulators

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

Ken MacKa

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Ken MacKa » Fri, 07 Sep 2001 20:10:15

Rumor has it that the Ferrari wheel has been "redesigned"  and is now
gear driven as opposed to the older belt drive system.  Any truth to
this? Has anyone compared the new to old?  How does the new version
feel?

A local shop has this wheel in stock, is there anyway to tell if it has
gears or a belt before I buy it? ...can't think they'd like me taking
the back off of it in the store ;-)

Thanks for any info
Ken
PS I'd get the Force RS if I had the extra cash.

Simon Brow

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Simon Brow » Fri, 07 Sep 2001 21:08:23

The new one was only shown for the first time at ECTS a few days ago I
think, so I'm guessing it hasn't been released yet.  I could be wrong though
:)

Anyway, you can tell the new one because the pedal tops are black and not
light grey.

I'd be very surprised if the FF mechanism was new, since the wheel looks
almost identical to the old one.


Dave Henri

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Dave Henri » Fri, 07 Sep 2001 21:45:52

  He 'may' be crossing up the NEW Logitech MOMO wheel with the Gulli Ferrari
wheel.  Heck in American sportscar racing,  Momo=Ferarri for the longest
time with the Moretti Momo Ferrari 333sp.
dave henrie

> The new one was only shown for the first time at ECTS a few days ago I
> think, so I'm guessing it hasn't been released yet.  I could be wrong
though
> :)

> Anyway, you can tell the new one because the pedal tops are black and not
> light grey.

> I'd be very surprised if the FF mechanism was new, since the wheel looks
> almost identical to the old one.



> > Rumor has it that the Ferrari wheel has been "redesigned"  and is now
> > gear driven as opposed to the older belt drive system.  Any truth to
> > this? Has anyone compared the new to old?  How does the new version
> > feel?

> > A local shop has this wheel in stock, is there anyway to tell if it has
> > gears or a belt before I buy it? ...can't think they'd like me taking
> > the back off of it in the store ;-)

> > Thanks for any info
> > Ken
> > PS I'd get the Force RS if I had the extra cash.

Ken MacKa

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Ken MacKa » Fri, 07 Sep 2001 21:59:49

Hmmm...now I'm confused.

The one at ECTS is the "Ferrari-licensed Force Feedback GT Racing Wheel" and
does show black pedals.  At Thrustmaster site they have the "Force Feedback
Racing Wheel? licensed by Ferrari?" , its labeled as "new" and it has the grey
pedals in the picture, no mention of a "GT" wheel at the site.  And just to make
it interesting Thrustmaster also has a press release from May for the "360
Modena? Force Feedback Racing Wheel". I take it from an earlier thread that the
Modena FF is indeed a separate model being released. Are these other 2 "Ferrari"
wheels separate models or has one of them replaced the original Ferrari model?

BTW the "Force Feedback Racing Wheel? licensed by Ferrari?" at thrustmaster says
USB only, didn't the original have a serial connection as well?

Ken


> The new one was only shown for the first time at ECTS a few days ago I
> think, so I'm guessing it hasn't been released yet.  I could be wrong though
> :)

> Anyway, you can tell the new one because the pedal tops are black and not
> light grey.

> I'd be very surprised if the FF mechanism was new, since the wheel looks
> almost identical to the old one.



> > Rumor has it that the Ferrari wheel has been "redesigned"  and is now
> > gear driven as opposed to the older belt drive system.  Any truth to
> > this? Has anyone compared the new to old?  How does the new version
> > feel?

> > A local shop has this wheel in stock, is there anyway to tell if it has
> > gears or a belt before I buy it? ...can't think they'd like me taking
> > the back off of it in the store ;-)

> > Thanks for any info
> > Ken
> > PS I'd get the Force RS if I had the extra cash.

Jimmy De Plecke

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Jimmy De Plecke » Fri, 07 Sep 2001 23:28:52

You're confusing me..... I'm wondering which version of the wheel I have at
the moment.

My computer shop where I ordered it said I had to wait an extra 2 weeks,
because they just changed models.
He said to me that apparently It was only a cosmetic upgrade, but then again
he never opened the box.

I have this wheel now for a week or 3 and it has grey/silver like pedals,
and an USB only connection.
It appears also to be gear driven however I am not sure about that. I can't
compare the FFB feeling with other wheels as it is my first FFB wheel,
replacing the ol' T2

Then again I think it is strange that Thrustmaster will change its Ferrari
FFB wheel again in such short notice.... If I indeed have that new version
of the wheel (?)
I'll check tonight if I find some sort of version number on the wheel, to
compare it with a the 'older' model.

Jim


Simon Brow

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Simon Brow » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 00:02:39

Dunno, I'm guessing you're refering to his belt vs gear comment.

Anyway, just to clear things up for Ken, there is a new Ferrari wheel from
Thrustmaster/Guillemot on the way (this one is called the FF GT Racing
Wheel), which has redesigned pedals and an improved clamp.  It debuted at
ECTS a few days ago.  The new one has black pedal tops and probably isn't
available yet.  Other than the pedals it looks the same as the old Ferrari
wheel, and hence I would guess it still uses a belt.  The Ferrari wheel has
never particularly suffered from using a belt though, the FF is just as good
(IMO) as the cable driven LWFF.

One point of confusion is that there is already two Guillemot Ferrari
wheels, since shortly after the wheels original release, they modified the
design slightly, making the shifters less wobbly, and removing the spring
effect on the pedal tops.  The first release you can't get anymore, the
second release should be the one on sale now, and I don't know when the one
with the new black-top pedals will be available.  It could be on sale now
for all I know.  Anyway, all you need to know to recognize it is that the
pedals tops are black, whereas the old ones were light grey.


Simon Brow

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Simon Brow » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 00:38:30

And to confuse things even further, the new black topped pedal wheel looks
to be already available in the US called the Nascar Pro FF, and it's
possible it could be a cut-down version of the original Ferrari (that's pure
speculation btw), since it's $30 cheaper.

Does anyone know what's goin on?


Ken MacKa

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Ken MacKa » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 01:14:34

Jimmy, sounds like yours is definitely the latest version. I'm not that
concerned if its gear or belt driven but more importantly how does it feel with
FF off ...ie. is it smooth and precise? I've heard others complain that certain
geared wheels feel notchy when turning the wheel and that they don't point the
car consistently.

I talked to the shop and they couldn't tell me if it gears or belts, but what
they have in stock is USB only.

Thanks
Ken


> You're confusing me..... I'm wondering which version of the wheel I have at
> the moment.

> My computer shop where I ordered it said I had to wait an extra 2 weeks,
> because they just changed models.
> He said to me that apparently It was only a cosmetic upgrade, but then again
> he never opened the box.

> I have this wheel now for a week or 3 and it has grey/silver like pedals,
> and an USB only connection.
> It appears also to be gear driven however I am not sure about that. I can't
> compare the FFB feeling with other wheels as it is my first FFB wheel,
> replacing the ol' T2

> Then again I think it is strange that Thrustmaster will change its Ferrari
> FFB wheel again in such short notice.... If I indeed have that new version
> of the wheel (?)
> I'll check tonight if I find some sort of version number on the wheel, to
> compare it with a the 'older' model.

> Jim



> > Rumor has it that the Ferrari wheel has been "redesigned"  and is now
> > gear driven as opposed to the older belt drive system.  Any truth to
> > this? Has anyone compared the new to old?  How does the new version
> > feel?

> > A local shop has this wheel in stock, is there anyway to tell if it has
> > gears or a belt before I buy it? ...can't think they'd like me taking
> > the back off of it in the store ;-)

> > Thanks for any info
> > Ken
> > PS I'd get the Force RS if I had the extra cash.

Steve Blankenshi

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Steve Blankenshi » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 01:45:14

Looks to me like the new GT/Nascar version is a de-contented version without the extra analog paddles on the wheel and cheaper
pedals, thus the lower price.

SB


> And to confuse things even further, the new black topped pedal wheel looks
> to be already available in the US called the Nascar Pro FF, and it's
> possible it could be a cut-down version of the original Ferrari (that's pure
> speculation btw), since it's $30 cheaper.

> Does anyone know what's goin on?

JDP

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by JDP » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 03:39:17

The more I turn the wheel, the more I get the feeling that it is gear
driven. First I tought the friction I heard
was from the motor, but it is also present in non-ffb games.Going from
normal cornering to oversteer correction is something which is not as fast
as with my previous T2 because of that friction. With FFB enabled no problem
at all (GPL runs just fine). Maybe it needs some extra running-in time.

It is definetely precise to steer. more precise as my T2. But then again it
had completely worn pots.
no jittering at all, nice stable calibration readings.

I should advice you to try to test the wheel tough, if you are not so sure
about it. You just have to feel it, I guess

Jim


> Jimmy, sounds like yours is definitely the latest version. I'm not that
> concerned if its gear or belt driven but more importantly how does it feel
with
> FF off ...ie. is it smooth and precise? I've heard others complain that
certain
> geared wheels feel notchy when turning the wheel and that they don't point
the
> car consistently.

> I talked to the shop and they couldn't tell me if it gears or belts, but
what
> they have in stock is USB only.

> Thanks
> Ken


> > You're confusing me..... I'm wondering which version of the wheel I have
at
> > the moment.

> > My computer shop where I ordered it said I had to wait an extra 2 weeks,
> > because they just changed models.
> > He said to me that apparently It was only a cosmetic upgrade, but then
again
> > he never opened the box.

> > I have this wheel now for a week or 3 and it has grey/silver like
pedals,
> > and an USB only connection.
> > It appears also to be gear driven however I am not sure about that. I
can't
> > compare the FFB feeling with other wheels as it is my first FFB wheel,
> > replacing the ol' T2

> > Then again I think it is strange that Thrustmaster will change its
Ferrari
> > FFB wheel again in such short notice.... If I indeed have that new
version
> > of the wheel (?)
> > I'll check tonight if I find some sort of version number on the wheel,
to
> > compare it with a the 'older' model.

> > Jim



> > > Rumor has it that the Ferrari wheel has been "redesigned"  and is now
> > > gear driven as opposed to the older belt drive system.  Any truth to
> > > this? Has anyone compared the new to old?  How does the new version
> > > feel?

> > > A local shop has this wheel in stock, is there anyway to tell if it
has
> > > gears or a belt before I buy it? ...can't think they'd like me taking
> > > the back off of it in the store ;-)

> > > Thanks for any info
> > > Ken
> > > PS I'd get the Force RS if I had the extra cash.

Ken MacKa

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Ken MacKa » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 04:08:20

Thanks for the review, sounds good, especially the GPL part. I should have one
next week. :-) They don't have one on display, I'll check the return policy
before I pay for it.

I called customer service number and got the Guillemot technical support
(Canada). I asked if the Ferrari FF for the PC had been revised to be gear
driven.  They said as far as they new the Ferrari wheel was still belt
driven...if they had changed it no one had told them!  They did say that there
had been some small revisions since the paddle updates last summer but it was
still basically the same wheel.

Ken
PS what started all this was the "wheel advice" and the "Difference between old
and new TM Ferrari wheels?"  threads in the tweaks and review forum:
http://www.slottweak.com/cgi-bin/UBB/forumdisplay.cgi?action=topics&f...APO|s+Den+&number=1&DaysPrune=&LastLogin=


> The more I turn the wheel, the more I get the feeling that it is gear
> driven. First I tought the friction I heard
> was from the motor, but it is also present in non-ffb games.Going from
> normal cornering to oversteer correction is something which is not as fast
> as with my previous T2 because of that friction. With FFB enabled no problem
> at all (GPL runs just fine). Maybe it needs some extra running-in time.

> It is definetely precise to steer. more precise as my T2. But then again it
> had completely worn pots.
> no jittering at all, nice stable calibration readings.

> I should advice you to try to test the wheel tough, if you are not so sure
> about it. You just have to feel it, I guess

> Jim



> > Jimmy, sounds like yours is definitely the latest version. I'm not that
> > concerned if its gear or belt driven but more importantly how does it feel
> with
> > FF off ...ie. is it smooth and precise? I've heard others complain that
> certain
> > geared wheels feel notchy when turning the wheel and that they don't point
> the
> > car consistently.

> > I talked to the shop and they couldn't tell me if it gears or belts, but
> what
> > they have in stock is USB only.

> > Thanks
> > Ken


> > > You're confusing me..... I'm wondering which version of the wheel I have
> at
> > > the moment.

> > > My computer shop where I ordered it said I had to wait an extra 2 weeks,
> > > because they just changed models.
> > > He said to me that apparently It was only a cosmetic upgrade, but then
> again
> > > he never opened the box.

> > > I have this wheel now for a week or 3 and it has grey/silver like
> pedals,
> > > and an USB only connection.
> > > It appears also to be gear driven however I am not sure about that. I
> can't
> > > compare the FFB feeling with other wheels as it is my first FFB wheel,
> > > replacing the ol' T2

> > > Then again I think it is strange that Thrustmaster will change its
> Ferrari
> > > FFB wheel again in such short notice.... If I indeed have that new
> version
> > > of the wheel (?)
> > > I'll check tonight if I find some sort of version number on the wheel,
> to
> > > compare it with a the 'older' model.

> > > Jim



> > > > Rumor has it that the Ferrari wheel has been "redesigned"  and is now
> > > > gear driven as opposed to the older belt drive system.  Any truth to
> > > > this? Has anyone compared the new to old?  How does the new version
> > > > feel?

> > > > A local shop has this wheel in stock, is there anyway to tell if it
> has
> > > > gears or a belt before I buy it? ...can't think they'd like me taking
> > > > the back off of it in the store ;-)

> > > > Thanks for any info
> > > > Ken
> > > > PS I'd get the Force RS if I had the extra cash.

Thom j

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Thom j » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 04:24:07

I have 2 here & they have both USB and serial connection but I got my
last wheel about 3months ago or so..

Hmmm...now I'm confused.
<snipped>
BTW the "Force Feedback Racing WheelT licensed by Ferrari?" at thrustmaster
says
USB only, didn't the original have a serial connection as well?

Ken

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.276 / Virus Database: 145 - Release Date: 9/3/2001

Thom j

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Thom j » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 06:51:22

Go on the Guillemot aka Thrustmaster site & see the 2 different Ferrari
models now! I'd also re-check where you bought it after you stop into
the site.. Good luck..


| You're confusing me..... I'm wondering which version of the wheel I have
at
| the moment.
|
| My computer shop where I ordered it said I had to wait an extra 2 weeks,
| because they just changed models.
| He said to me that apparently It was only a cosmetic upgrade, but then
again
| he never opened the box.
|
| I have this wheel now for a week or 3 and it has grey/silver like pedals,
| and an USB only connection.
| It appears also to be gear driven however I am not sure about that. I
can't
| compare the FFB feeling with other wheels as it is my first FFB wheel,
| replacing the ol' T2
|
| Then again I think it is strange that Thrustmaster will change its Ferrari
| FFB wheel again in such short notice.... If I indeed have that new version
| of the wheel (?)
| I'll check tonight if I find some sort of version number on the wheel, to
| compare it with a the 'older' model.
|
| Jim
|
|
|


| > Rumor has it that the Ferrari wheel has been "redesigned"  and is now
| > gear driven as opposed to the older belt drive system.  Any truth to
| > this? Has anyone compared the new to old?  How does the new version
| > feel?
| >
| > A local shop has this wheel in stock, is there anyway to tell if it has
| > gears or a belt before I buy it? ...can't think they'd like me taking
| > the back off of it in the store ;-)
| >
| > Thanks for any info
| > Ken
| > PS I'd get the Force RS if I had the extra cash.
| >
| >
| >
| >
|
|

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.276 / Virus Database: 145 - Release Date: 9/3/2001

Thom j

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Thom j » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 06:55:05

On the TM aka Guillemot site Simon it doesnt say one thing about
the GT having analog paddles on the wheel!! Crapolla!!

| Dunno, I'm guessing you're refering to his belt vs gear comment.
|
| Anyway, just to clear things up for Ken, there is a new Ferrari wheel from
| Thrustmaster/Guillemot on the way (this one is called the FF GT Racing
| Wheel), which has redesigned pedals and an improved clamp.  It debuted at
| ECTS a few days ago.  The new one has black pedal tops and probably isn't
| available yet.  Other than the pedals it looks the same as the old Ferrari
| wheel, and hence I would guess it still uses a belt.  The Ferrari wheel
has
| never particularly suffered from using a belt though, the FF is just as
good
| (IMO) as the cable driven LWFF.
|
| One point of confusion is that there is already two Guillemot Ferrari
| wheels, since shortly after the wheels original release, they modified the
| design slightly, making the shifters less wobbly, and removing the spring
| effect on the pedal tops.  The first release you can't get anymore, the
| second release should be the one on sale now, and I don't know when the
one
| with the new black-top pedals will be available.  It could be on sale now
| for all I know.  Anyway, all you need to know to recognize it is that the
| pedals tops are black, whereas the old ones were light grey.
|
| >   He 'may' be crossing up the NEW Logitech MOMO wheel with the Gulli
| Ferrari
| > wheel.  Heck in American sportscar racing,  Momo=Ferarri for the longest
| > time with the Moretti Momo Ferrari 333sp.
| > dave henrie
|
|
|

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.276 / Virus Database: 145 - Release Date: 9/3/2001

Thom j

Guillemot/TM Ferrari FFB: new vs old?

by Thom j » Sat, 08 Sep 2001 07:41:13

Jim I have been using the Ferrari race wheel since it came out. To me,
it always had a 'tiny bit' of a mechanical feel when you turn the wheel
but nothing decernable. So it can be the older or it can be the newer?
Yea I know this didnt help one bit, did it? "O" well I tried..lol

| The more I turn the wheel, the more I get the feeling that it is gear
| driven. First I tought the friction I heard
| was from the motor, but it is also present in non-ffb games.Going from
| normal cornering to oversteer correction is something which is not as fast
| as with my previous T2 because of that friction. With FFB enabled no
problem
| at all (GPL runs just fine). Maybe it needs some extra running-in time.
|
| It is definetely precise to steer. more precise as my T2. But then again
it
| had completely worn pots.
| no jittering at all, nice stable calibration readings.
|
| I should advice you to try to test the wheel tough, if you are not so sure
| about it. You just have to feel it, I guess
|
| Jim

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.276 / Virus Database: 145 - Release Date: 9/3/2001


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.