rec.autos.simulators

F1 2000-My Opinions

Chris Bloo

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Chris Bloo » Thu, 23 Mar 2000 04:00:00

1. The AI - I was trying differant strengths of AI
competitiveness and found that at any strngth above 80% they
would rocket down the straights (faster than me) and depending
on what strength I had set, they were much slower round the
corners than myself.  Seems impossible to drive following
another car like in GPL or GP2.

2. The Sound - ***arcade like.  The start sounds remind me of
Pole Position or something!

3. The Graphics - Not too bad but how come they demand so much
of the machine when GPL runs alot smoother at the same res and
at least as much detail while implementing a far superior
physics engine.

4. The Tracks - This really spoils it.  Parts of tracks seem to
bear no likeness to the real things.  Especially the main
straight at Monza.  Okay Indy is a new F1 circuit but I have
seen races on the speedway and the game doesn't really remind me
of the place.  The track texture/colour seems to be the same for
all tracks?

5. The Physics - Not terrible, but the slides/skids etc seem to
be a pit predictable and the same regardless of the corner.  The
grip on the grass seems to be too great.  SCGT was better in the
context of what it was trying to achieve.

6. Other things - I don't really think the car models are that
accurate and it looks like they are being driven by children.

I think if I was to waste money on this game (notice I don't say
sim) I would end up getting bored within a few days and going
back to GPL.  Within a few months I would have GP3 and within
all probarbility would never look at F1 2000 again.  Think I
will save my money.

Chris

* Sent from RemarQ http://www.racesimcentral.net/ The Internet's Discussion Network *
The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet - Free!

Johnny Cras

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Johnny Cras » Thu, 23 Mar 2000 04:00:00

I agree on all points Chris.


Mike Blackmor

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Mike Blackmor » Thu, 23 Mar 2000 04:00:00

On Wed, 22 Mar 2000 02:45:18 -0800, Chris Bloom

I think the car models are excellent, they are all individual and
convey an excellent impression of the prototypes the detailing is very
good.

I agree with some of your other points but reach a different
conclusion.  I'm enjoying it and I will buy it.

Regards Mike

Andrew

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Andrew » Thu, 23 Mar 2000 04:00:00

I'm not a big fan of the car models.  They don't appear as a cohesive set,
but a collection of parts.  I know this game is going to suck (because it's
not GPL), but take a look at the car models for World Grand Prix by Lankhor
(http://www.lankhor.com).  They've done a much better job of modeling.  Of
course they have more polygons to work with because they are supporting
hardware T&L of the GeForce cards.  The first racing game that I know of
that will take advantage of the GeForce.

rrevve

F1 2000-My Opinions

by rrevve » Thu, 23 Mar 2000 04:00:00


>> I think the car models are excellent, they are all individual and
>> convey an excellent impression of the prototypes the detailing is very
>> good.

>I'm not a big fan of the car models.  They don't appear as a cohesive set,
>but a collection of parts.  I know this game is going to suck (because it's
>not GPL), but take a look at the car models for World Grand Prix by Lankhor
>(http://www.lankhor.com).  They've done a much better job of modeling.  Of
>course they have more polygons to work with because they are supporting
>hardware T&L of the GeForce cards.  The first racing game that I know of
>that will take advantage of the GeForce.

Andrew, no hard feelings, but the car models in F1-2000 completely
blow away those found in OF1R. With the new version of OF1R about
to be released, I can't say for sure, but since I am a ?proud? owner
of OF1R, there is simply NO comparison between it and F1-2000..

--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *

Leaky_Valv

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Leaky_Valv » Thu, 23 Mar 2000 04:00:00

Thanks you for you observations. These, and others, have guided me in my
decision not to buy the game.  There has been to much negative comment regarding
the complete package and that is enough for me to choose not to go for F1-2000.

I shall now await the launch of GP3 and comments surrounding that game.  Ditto
World Sports Cars.

In the meantime, GPL calls :-)


> 1. The AI - I was trying differant strengths of AI
> competitiveness and found that at any strngth above 80% they
> would rocket down the straights (faster than me) and depending
> on what strength I had set, they were much slower round the
> corners than myself.  Seems impossible to drive following
> another car like in GPL or GP2.

> 2. The Sound - ***arcade like.  The start sounds remind me of
> Pole Position or something!

> 3. The Graphics - Not too bad but how come they demand so much
> of the machine when GPL runs alot smoother at the same res and
> at least as much detail while implementing a far superior
> physics engine.

> 4. The Tracks - This really spoils it.  Parts of tracks seem to
> bear no likeness to the real things.  Especially the main
> straight at Monza.  Okay Indy is a new F1 circuit but I have
> seen races on the speedway and the game doesn't really remind me
> of the place.  The track texture/colour seems to be the same for
> all tracks?

> 5. The Physics - Not terrible, but the slides/skids etc seem to
> be a pit predictable and the same regardless of the corner.  The
> grip on the grass seems to be too great.  SCGT was better in the
> context of what it was trying to achieve.

> 6. Other things - I don't really think the car models are that
> accurate and it looks like they are being driven by children.

> I think if I was to waste money on this game (notice I don't say
> sim) I would end up getting bored within a few days and going
> back to GPL.  Within a few months I would have GP3 and within
> all probarbility would never look at F1 2000 again.  Think I
> will save my money.

> Chris

> * Sent from RemarQ http://www.racesimcentral.net/ The Internet's Discussion Network *
> The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet - Free!

Iain Mackenzi

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Iain Mackenzi » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00

That kind of sums up this group's attitude to every other racing sim out
there!
Iain
Hotd

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Hotd » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00

On Thu, 23 Mar 2000 06:59:51 -0000, "Iain Mackenzie"


>>>I know this game is going to suck because it's not GPL<<
>That kind of sums up this group's attitude to every other racing sim out
>there!
>Iain

Well I wont say it sucks due to GPL (allthough I like GPL) but this
game sucks in the Myth release because the AI in the game is real ***
they dont even race proper lines in there cars, they dont know how to
use there brakes and where to use them, they are really just pure
crap.

Every race I have had so far at least 3-4 drivers have gone out in the
first lap and then another 2 by the 3rd or 4th lap. They have some
sort of promblem with there cars wobbling from side to side as if they
have wonkey wheels or something.

Also the AI at 70% have this slowdown so you can catch em & then speed
up so they get ahead of you built in to the game, I have watched
replays where at monza I was going flat tack down the long straight at
full thr in my Maclaeren, I was in 6th gear and the car had no more to
give, anyway I watched a Jaguar AI car in my mirror zoom up and pass
me and head of to the distance, where I caught him up again by the
corner.

Next race I swapped his car for mine and boy I couldnt catch that
Maclearen at full thr, it was like the AI have extra power when they
need it just so they can pass you and make it a bit more intresting
or something. Anyway anyone who buys this based on the Wearz release
for anything other than M/P is really going to moan out load here
about how ***the AI is in this game, My god even the AI in GP2 geive
you a more better race than in F1 2000.

Other than that the game looks ok, but its no Superbike 2000, now that
game looks like magic and the AI is very smart.

Hotdog

Gregor Vebl

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Gregor Vebl » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00


> Also the AI at 70% have this slowdown so you can catch em & then speed
> up so they get ahead of you built in to the game, I have watched
> replays where at monza I was going flat tack down the long straight at
> full thr in my Maclaeren, I was in 6th gear and the car had no more to
> give, anyway I watched a Jaguar AI car in my mirror zoom up and pass
> me and head of to the distance, where I caught him up again by the
> corner.

> Next race I swapped his car for mine and boy I couldnt catch that
> Maclearen at full thr, it was like the AI have extra power when they
> need it just so they can pass you and make it a bit more intresting
> or something. Anyway anyone who buys this based on the Wearz release
> for anything other than M/P is really going to moan out load here
> about how ***the AI is in this game, My god even the AI in GP2 geive
> you a more better race than in F1 2000.

> Other than that the game looks ok, but its no Superbike 2000, now that
> game looks like magic and the AI is very smart.

> Hotdog

I don't have the sim yet but is it possible that you had a more
downforce setup so on straight the AI could outrun you?

-Gregor

Andre Warrin

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Andre Warrin » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00

No, that's just the way the (stupid) AI works. This is even more
noticable when you crank the AI up to 120%.

F1 2000 is great for hotlapping and multiplayer, the AI is something
they really have to work on. Hard.

Andre

On Thu, 23 Mar 2000 11:57:09 +0100, Gregor Veble


>I don't have the sim yet but is it possible that you had a more
>downforce setup so on straight the AI could outrun you?

>-Gregor

Jo Hels

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Jo Hels » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00

On Thu, 23 Mar 2000 11:57:09 +0100, Gregor Veble



>> Also the AI at 70% have this slowdown so you can catch em & then speed
>> up so they get ahead of you built in to the game, I have watched
>> replays where at monza I was going flat tack down the long straight at
>> full thr in my Maclaeren, I was in 6th gear and the car had no more to
>> give, anyway I watched a Jaguar AI car in my mirror zoom up and pass
>> me and head of to the distance, where I caught him up again by the
>> corner.

.....

I don't have it either, but several people have reported that
"increasing the level of the AI" results in higher speeds on the
straights, while cornering speeds remain as usual. So this presumably
results in VERY unrealistic behaviour of the AI when you race against
them.

So much for the "suspension of disbelief"...

JoH

Kankki

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Kankki » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00

My opinion there is the biggest problem is FPS,
AI is second problem because race is unplayable.

-Jani Kankaanp??-



> On Thu, 23 Mar 2000 11:57:09 +0100, Gregor Veble


> >> Also the AI at 70% have this slowdown so you can catch em & then speed
> >> up so they get ahead of you built in to the game, I have watched
> >> replays where at monza I was going flat tack down the long straight at
> >> full thr in my Maclaeren, I was in 6th gear and the car had no more to
> >> give, anyway I watched a Jaguar AI car in my mirror zoom up and pass
> >> me and head of to the distance, where I caught him up again by the
> >> corner.

> .....

> >I don't have the sim yet but is it possible that you had a more
> >downforce setup so on straight the AI could outrun you?

> >-Gregor

> I don't have it either, but several people have reported that
> "increasing the level of the AI" results in higher speeds on the
> straights, while cornering speeds remain as usual. So this presumably
> results in VERY unrealistic behaviour of the AI when you race against
> them.

> So much for the "suspension of disbelief"...

> JoH

Andrew

F1 2000-My Opinions

by Andrew » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00

I have that game too (OF1R) and wasn't all that impressed.  There is also
the sequel (OF1R '99) out today (I think), but World Grand Prix appears to
be a new game due out this fall.

xenocid

F1 2000-My Opinions

by xenocid » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00


> On Thu, 23 Mar 2000 06:59:51 -0000, "Iain Mackenzie"

> >>>I know this game is going to suck because it's not GPL<<
> >That kind of sums up this group's attitude to every other racing sim out
> >there!
> >Iain

> Well I wont say it sucks due to GPL (allthough I like GPL) but this
> game sucks in the Myth release because the AI in the game is real ***
> they dont even race proper lines in there cars, they dont know how to
> use there brakes and where to use them, they are really just pure
> crap.

> Every race I have had so far at least 3-4 drivers have gone out in the
> first lap and then another 2 by the 3rd or 4th lap. They have some
> sort of promblem with there cars wobbling from side to side as if they
> have wonkey wheels or something.

> Also the AI at 70% have this slowdown so you can catch em & then speed
> up so they get ahead of you built in to the game, I have watched
> replays where at monza I was going flat tack down the long straight at
> full thr in my Maclaeren, I was in 6th gear and the car had no more to
> give, anyway I watched a Jaguar AI car in my mirror zoom up and pass
> me and head of to the distance, where I caught him up again by the
> corner.

<snip>
Maybe the jaguar caught you as you failed to use your 7th gear?

- Show quoted text -

ivica.buljevi

F1 2000-My Opinions

by ivica.buljevi » Fri, 24 Mar 2000 04:00:00

?

rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.