rec.autos.simulators

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

David G Fishe

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by David G Fishe » Fri, 08 Nov 2002 11:27:25

From itv-f1.com

Jackie Stewart thinks too much fuss is being made over Ferrari's ***
of Formula 1.
The three-times world champion believes that the Michael Schumacher-Ferrari
combination, which won 11 out of 17 grand prix in 2002, has simply done a
better job than the opposition and has reaped the rewards for its
excellence. This is way it should be according to the BRDC chairman.

In an interview with The Times, Stewart said: "Let's get real. They've just
won for three years. Before that, they hadn't won for 21 years. This is
sport - things don't always go the way you'd like them to. It would be nice
if a different person won every race; it would be nice if different
manufacturers won every year. But sport isn't fair.

"The job of sport is not to share the honours out equally. The job of sport
is to find the strongest, fastest, highest, longest, whatever. In 1971, I
won six out of the first eight races. It was OK then, no one said a word
other than to congratulate me. Today, the public, apparently, demands fair
competition and that means everyone coming up to the line together does it?
And a different driver winning every time?"

----

Stewart also had an ominous warning for the rest of the Formula 1 world. He
expects more of the same from Ferrari and Schumacher next year.

"I believe Schumacher is still on the way up," added Stewart. "If he's got
five world titles to his name already, I could see him getting another three
or four, maybe more. I would not be at all surprised if the nonsense over
the past few months has made him even more determined to stay at the top for
longer."

David G Fisher

Gerry Aitke

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Gerry Aitke » Fri, 08 Nov 2002 16:56:11

He's a wise man indeed. A couple of months ago I was driving through
Scotland on one particularly sunny Sunday afternoon, and who should
flash past me on the A72 in his Range Rover? Yep, non other than Jackie
Stewart! I remember wondering why isn't he at home watching the GP. The
answer is simple; he finds F1 as boring as I do and when out for a nice
drive instead.

Yours sneeringly

GDA

P.S. F1 is starting to disappear up it's own arsehole.

Joachim Trens

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Joachim Trens » Fri, 08 Nov 2002 16:51:36

Steward's right. In the past 10 years a lot of fuss has been made over
things which had been considered perfectly normal during the first 40 years
of F1 history. I'm old enough to remember most of it (sigh) <g>

Achim



Goy Larse

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Goy Larse » Fri, 08 Nov 2002 19:25:16


> Steward's right. In the past 10 years a lot of fuss has been made over
> things which had been considered perfectly normal during the first 40 years
> of F1 history. I'm old enough to remember most of it (sigh) <g>

Uh huh....:-)

I can't believe that FIA is even worrying about the Ferrari ***,
aside from not liking MS himself and not wanting him to win, that bit
doesn't bother me too much as I know that at some point Williams or
McLaren will catch up, the thing that bores me stiff is the lack of on
the track racing for position

Forget the two red cars up front for a moment, they're doing their job
better than anyone else and dominates, fair enough, but further down the
field there's another 20 cars (more or less) divided into groups of cars
with similar performance....and they're not racing each other for
position on the track because in F1 that's neigh on impossible,
"everyone" is just holding their position waiting for the
pitstops....that's the bit that needs attention, I don't care if the
fight for position is about 1st/2nd or 7th/8th as long as it's worth
watching

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

"The Pits"    http://www.racesimcentral.net/

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
--Groucho Marx--

Joachim Trens

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Joachim Trens » Fri, 08 Nov 2002 23:33:39

that's right Goy.

I think the desire to level the playing field as much as possible is also a
major reason why they aren't trying harder to ban driving aids (besides
their saying it's difficult to police). Driving aids make less good drivers
faster, thus keeping the field even closer together. Whether that causes
more battles on the track (because the drivers are closer together) or less
(because any existing differences are balanced out and hence no passing is
possible) is another matter.

But I remember cars and/or drivers being just as *** as Ferrari was
this year, not only in F1 but elsewhere, and it's always been considered as
being perfectly normal. Which is also true for team orders, equally
difficult to police but got prohibited anyway (IMO just a show for us, the
audience, as it'll simply happen in a more subtle way now) - but team orders
have always been part of the game, and I don't remember any fuss being made
over it back then :-)

Achim



> > Steward's right. In the past 10 years a lot of fuss has been made over
> > things which had been considered perfectly normal during the first 40
years
> > of F1 history. I'm old enough to remember most of it (sigh) <g>

> Uh huh....:-)

> I can't believe that FIA is even worrying about the Ferrari ***,
> aside from not liking MS himself and not wanting him to win, that bit
> doesn't bother me too much as I know that at some point Williams or
> McLaren will catch up, the thing that bores me stiff is the lack of on
> the track racing for position

> Forget the two red cars up front for a moment, they're doing their job
> better than anyone else and dominates, fair enough, but further down the
> field there's another 20 cars (more or less) divided into groups of cars
> with similar performance....and they're not racing each other for
> position on the track because in F1 that's neigh on impossible,
> "everyone" is just holding their position waiting for the
> pitstops....that's the bit that needs attention, I don't care if the
> fight for position is about 1st/2nd or 7th/8th as long as it's worth
> watching

Goy Larse

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Goy Larse » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 00:45:23


> I think the desire to level the playing field as much as possible is also a
> major reason why they aren't trying harder to ban driving aids (besides
> their saying it's difficult to police). Driving aids make less good drivers
> faster, thus keeping the field even closer together. Whether that causes
> more battles on the track (because the drivers are closer together) or less
> (because any existing differences are balanced out and hence no passing is
> possible) is another matter.

> But I remember cars and/or drivers being just as *** as Ferrari was
> this year, not only in F1 but elsewhere, and it's always been considered as
> being perfectly normal. Which is also true for team orders, equally
> difficult to police but got prohibited anyway (IMO just a show for us, the
> audience, as it'll simply happen in a more subtle way now) - but team orders
> have always been part of the game, and I don't remember any fuss being made
> over it back then :-)

Exactly, and while I do have issues with Tem Orders when used as
blatantly as Ferrari has this year, I too realise it's neigh on
impossible to police them....and wasn't that the reason they let the
driver aids back in, because it was impossible to police
them.....hellooo ?

What has made this season increasingly boring is Team Orders, in the
past, when there was a *** team, the two drivers in the team has
for the most part been allowed to race each other, at least to a certain
degree, but this year you knew that unless MS did a very poor qualifying
(very unlikely) or messed up the start (it happens), he would win, but
again, how do you police the difference between a Team Order and a
periodic electronic glitch in RB's car ? :-)

What worries me the most is the fact that nobody in the FIA/FOCA can see
that this is ruining the sport as a sport for anyone but the most die
hard fan, yes I've kept on watching it even though I said I'd stop after
the Austrian fiasco (Hi David :-) even though I thought that was totally
uncalled for even for a team that openly uses Team Orders, but there
comes a point where I will rather spend those couple of hours on a
Sunday rebuilding my beloved Opel Manta rather than watching the so
called racing in F1

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

"The Pits"    http://www.racesimcentral.net/

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
--Groucho Marx--

Brad Larocqu

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Brad Larocqu » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 04:16:28

A good example of how do you police team orders came up in the NASCAR
race this past Sunday too. I know it's not F1 but it seems relevant to
me. Kurt Busch and teammate Mark Martin who's fighting for the
championship) were running 1-2. Busch's crew chief radioed him and and
"reminded" him Martin is fighting for a championship, and had the
opportunity to pick up the bonus points for most laps led, which could
go along way towards the title. Busch eased up and let Martin by, even
though he was never explicity told to do so. He "made the dicision" on
his own. Whats to stop the same thing from happening in F1?


>>I think the desire to level the playing field as much as possible is also a
>>major reason why they aren't trying harder to ban driving aids (besides
>>their saying it's difficult to police). Driving aids make less good drivers
>>faster, thus keeping the field even closer together. Whether that causes
>>more battles on the track (because the drivers are closer together) or less
>>(because any existing differences are balanced out and hence no passing is
>>possible) is another matter.

>>But I remember cars and/or drivers being just as *** as Ferrari was
>>this year, not only in F1 but elsewhere, and it's always been considered as
>>being perfectly normal. Which is also true for team orders, equally
>>difficult to police but got prohibited anyway (IMO just a show for us, the
>>audience, as it'll simply happen in a more subtle way now) - but team orders
>>have always been part of the game, and I don't remember any fuss being made
>>over it back then :-)

> Exactly, and while I do have issues with Tem Orders when used as
> blatantly as Ferrari has this year, I too realise it's neigh on
> impossible to police them....and wasn't that the reason they let the
> driver aids back in, because it was impossible to police
> them.....hellooo ?

> What has made this season increasingly boring is Team Orders, in the
> past, when there was a *** team, the two drivers in the team has
> for the most part been allowed to race each other, at least to a certain
> degree, but this year you knew that unless MS did a very poor qualifying
> (very unlikely) or messed up the start (it happens), he would win, but
> again, how do you police the difference between a Team Order and a
> periodic electronic glitch in RB's car ? :-)

> What worries me the most is the fact that nobody in the FIA/FOCA can see
> that this is ruining the sport as a sport for anyone but the most die
> hard fan, yes I've kept on watching it even though I said I'd stop after
> the Austrian fiasco (Hi David :-) even though I thought that was totally
> uncalled for even for a team that openly uses Team Orders, but there
> comes a point where I will rather spend those couple of hours on a
> Sunday rebuilding my beloved Opel Manta rather than watching the so
> called racing in F1

> Beers and cheers
> (uncle) Goy

> "The Pits"       http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> "A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
> --Groucho Marx--

Goy Larse

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Goy Larse » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 04:40:13


> A good example of how do you police team orders came up in the NASCAR
> race this past Sunday too. I know it's not F1 but it seems relevant to
> me. Kurt Busch and teammate Mark Martin who's fighting for the
> championship) were running 1-2. Busch's crew chief radioed him and and
> "reminded" him Martin is fighting for a championship, and had the
> opportunity to pick up the bonus points for most laps led, which could
> go along way towards the title. Busch eased up and let Martin by, even
> though he was never explicity told to do so. He "made the dicision" on
> his own. Whats to stop the same thing from happening in F1?

You're mistaken, that will never happen NASCAR in a million years, shame
on you for even suggesting such a thing....

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy

"The Pits"    http://www.theuspits.com/

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
--Groucho Marx--

Tony Rickar

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Tony Rickar » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 05:13:59


> From itv-f1.com

> Jackie Stewart thinks too much fuss is being made over Ferrari's ***
> of Formula 1.

I agree, David. I don't recall much fuss (certainly from us Brits!) when Mansell
& Williams dominated in '92. Plus Mansell attempted to manfacture wins for
Patrese in a rather blatant way (like coming to a near stop on one lap).
Williams and Mclaren have taken turns to dominate for years.

The romance in F1 was Ferrari being the underdog, and yearning for the glory
years gone by when Ferrari could compete forthe championship. Now we have this
we yearn for the romantic years of the fragile but beautiful Italian car up
against the odds.

Maybe the concept of Italian engineering beating German is just too much for the
older members here to comprehend :-) I still find it ironic that my 10 year old
Alfa had to jump start my wife's 1 year old VW and my father-in-law's brand new
Jag !!

Cheers

Tony

Damien Smit

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Damien Smit » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 08:38:03

Right on, old timer!

Gerry Aitke

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Gerry Aitke » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 08:42:00


> > He's a wise man indeed. A couple of months ago I was driving through
> > Scotland on one particularly sunny Sunday afternoon, and who should
> > flash past me on the A72 in his Range Rover? Yep, non other than Jackie
> > Stewart! I remember wondering why isn't he at home watching the GP. The
> > answer is simple; he finds F1 as boring as I do and when out for a nice
> > drive instead.

> Right on, old timer!

I'm 37!
Steve Blankenshi

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Steve Blankenshi » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 09:36:08



> > > He's a wise man indeed. A couple of months ago I was driving through
> > > Scotland on one particularly sunny Sunday afternoon, and who should
> > > flash past me on the A72 in his Range Rover? Yep, non other than
Jackie
> > > Stewart! I remember wondering why isn't he at home watching the GP.
The
> > > answer is simple; he finds F1 as boring as I do and when out for a
nice
> > > drive instead.

> > Right on, old timer!

> I'm 37!

Like he said... ;-)
Jason Moy

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by Jason Moy » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 12:04:39

On Thu, 07 Nov 2002 23:42:00 +0000, Gerry Aitken


>I'm 37!

I'm 25, and I still find 95-02 F1 boring.

It's kinda sad, take away one broken steering shaft and it would
possibly still be a good sport.

Jason

TDRacin

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by TDRacin » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 12:28:34

Yep


John Pancoas

OT-Jackie Stewart Is a Wise Man

by John Pancoas » Sat, 09 Nov 2002 13:04:35


> On Thu, 07 Nov 2002 23:42:00 +0000, Gerry Aitken

> >I'm 37!

> I'm 25, and I still find 95-02 F1 boring.

> It's kinda sad, take away one broken steering shaft and it would
> possibly still be a good sport.

> Jason

  Nah, he'd be retired by now anyway.

John


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.