rec.autos.simulators

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

EGK

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by EGK » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 04:10:31

What are the opinions of some of you guys about using steering assists in
Nascar 2003?

 I just joined an informal group running weekly races and had always used
the keyboard since I didn't have a wheel.  Most of the people racing in this
group are pretty inexperienced but most have wheels.  

Well, some new guys joined and used the keyboard too.  I made the mistake of
telling them that on the keyboard, the steering assists were your friend.
Traction control, for instance, is on by default and greyed out when using
the keyboard to steer.  I also said to turn on stability and set steering
assitance to about 60 to smooth out the key imput, otherwise it was like
jerking the wheel of a car back and forth hard all the way around the track.
Anyway, now i'm catching flack from the guys using the steering wheels who
say that's cheating and they're going to go to the patched game so they can
turn off all assists on the server side.  

What gets me is most of these guys using wheels who think they're too good
to need assistance are basically banging the walls and running back down to
the apron all the way around the track.  Am I wrong in thinking it's more
fun to race guys who can at least run a smooth line rather then people who
turn all assists off and can't make it once around without hitting the wall
or spinning out?   I thought the whole idea of putting those in the game was
to make people more competitive.  They claim using all the steering
assistance they can run around the tracks without touching their wheels at
all.  That may be true on some tracks but you then have to steer with the
throttle and they don't mention what happens if you're running side by side
with someone else since the assistance tends to keep you in the preferred
groove which you can't always run in.

Anyway, how do the more experienced guys racing in online leagues deal with
the issue of steering assists?

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

"There would be a lot more civility in this world if people
 didn't take that as an invitation to walk all over you"
                   - (Calvin and Hobbes)

Edgecrushe

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Edgecrushe » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 05:01:38

When the patch is released, they will be banned from my league. I think any reputable league will ban them as well

--

Steve

"They say a glass of wine makes you live longer but there's a drawback with that, the French drink it"

Guvnor.


> Anyway, how do the more experienced guys racing in online leagues deal with
> the issue of steering assists?

> ----------------------------------------------------------------------------

> "There would be a lot more civility in this world if people
>  didn't take that as an invitation to walk all over you"
>                    - (Calvin and Hobbes)

Bruce Kennewel

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Bruce Kennewel » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 05:57:07

Any driver aids which allow him or her to run the car in a way which
provides them with greater pleasure are worthwhile.
After all, it is a game and each person has their own preferences for how
they play it.
Banning something as basic as a filter which smooths out digital data is
utterly ridiculous and smacks of people taking this form of entertainment
way too seriously.

Tell them to get stuffed and start your own league if they take this course
of action.

Bruce.


Sting3

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Sting3 » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 06:15:41

EGK,

    Your touching the subject that is about like twisting your mom's tit.
<G>

     I want to be nice and say I agree, use the aids (I guess, but I never
would) to make yourself stay on track...  IMHO though, with driving aids,
you start  down the path in "Sim Life" with a crutch that you wont ever
force yourself to toss, until a new game comes along that wont help you
drive <twas GPL>.  some games driving help hinders once you reach a
reasonable threshold of performance, in fact back in NR2 and NR3 days this
was still true.  but in NR03, it isn't necessarily a hindrance like it used
to.  The big fight is now, even with wheels many use the "aids" to run cars
that "only the computer could possibly control"  I guess that seems ok to
them, as they thing this is the same playfield as flying f-15's?

        About racing online with NASCAR racing 2003 is ludicrous at best
with a friggin keyboard.  Sorry I feel that way, I think you will find
60-80% feel that way.  Believe me, I don't say it, because your stupid, nor
would you hear me with any remark about your heritage, but all ONLY because
you ***ARE MISSING OUT on the EXPERIENCE*** !!!   Nintendo and Playstation
games are made for keyboard commandos, even if you have a good wheel the
game doesn't actually allow you to control the car in a true sense of
controlling (& this means the car reacting and you reacting to the car...
realistically  (maybe when  you get your license they will drive cars in
real life with keyboards and digital joypads?)  just guessing?

        Wheels aren't that expensive, and for that matter, neither are
joysticks.   NR (the whole series) is really for the crowd that can see the
issues of racing & actually controlling the car like you would in real life
"ish".  I grant you that they left the keyboard option in so you could at
least get a taste.  Most of us been around a while, I actually bought the
1st version of NASCAR racing by papy, 2 times.  once as 4 or 5 floppy
install, later better resolution it came on CDrom.  From right on, it was so
obvious that for me to enjoy this I would have to buy at least 1 joystick
( I was cheap at 1st and in college, paid for myself BTW).  One joystick
didn't do it for me, so months later I got another, one to gas & brake, one
to turn.  Then about a year later I bought a wheel/pedal set.

    Something about this game ( and other papy sims) that make you want to
take over the controls.  Sure keyboard kinda worked, but not really ever ...
was the car doing what I wanted it to do.  How can you stand to drive
knowing that your really only controlling oh about <10% of what the car is
doing?  I would be frustrated to all get out...  that in fact I was, I
bought me a wheel, dam it was worth every penny at the time too!
(Thrustmaster T-2, 149.99 via mail-order in Jan, 1996.)

    Can buy wheels now used on ebay for about 30 and change, if you are
careful.

Sure it sounds "elitist" with the wheel thing?  Sorry, I was trying like
hell to be fair...


EGK

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by EGK » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 06:59:19

I'm leaving your post intact because i'm just replying in general.  I
figured this might be a touchy subject but was really looking for opinions.
Hopefully it won't devolve in to any namecalling.  I'm 45 thanks so have had
my real license for a few years.  Nothing but a holographic projection is
going to equal real cars.    I do understand your point of view.  I was
expecting it from players who are really in to racing sims ***.  That's
not the case with me or most of these I was playing with.  At least I didn't
think so.  I was just playing for fun.  I never bought a wheel because I
didn't play often enough to make it worth the bother.

I recently did get a logitech Wingman wheel but was trying to make the ones
who only have a keyboard more competitive.  Frankly, It's more fun for me to
just race offline against the computer then to race online with guys who
think they're too good for assistance yet can hardly make one lap around
without banging the wall and running down on the apron.  They're incapable
of running a smooth line so anyone coming up from behind them has to wait
till they hit the wall or go on to the apron to make a pass.  At least if
you dont want to be put in to the wall yourself.

The kicker in this is these same guys who can't control their cars without
driving aids and say the aids are cheating are playing the game with damage
turned OFF and hurtling all over themselves to download some great new track
setup  :)  They'd never complete a race if they didn't.


>EGK,

>    Your touching the subject that is about like twisting your mom's tit.
><G>

>     I want to be nice and say I agree, use the aids (I guess, but I never
>would) to make yourself stay on track...  IMHO though, with driving aids,
>you start  down the path in "Sim Life" with a crutch that you wont ever
>force yourself to toss, until a new game comes along that wont help you
>drive <twas GPL>.  some games driving help hinders once you reach a
>reasonable threshold of performance, in fact back in NR2 and NR3 days this
>was still true.  but in NR03, it isn't necessarily a hindrance like it used
>to.  The big fight is now, even with wheels many use the "aids" to run cars
>that "only the computer could possibly control"  I guess that seems ok to
>them, as they thing this is the same playfield as flying f-15's?

>        About racing online with NASCAR racing 2003 is ludicrous at best
>with a friggin keyboard.  Sorry I feel that way, I think you will find
>60-80% feel that way.  Believe me, I don't say it, because your stupid, nor
>would you hear me with any remark about your heritage, but all ONLY because
>you ***ARE MISSING OUT on the EXPERIENCE*** !!!   Nintendo and Playstation
>games are made for keyboard commandos, even if you have a good wheel the
>game doesn't actually allow you to control the car in a true sense of
>controlling (& this means the car reacting and you reacting to the car...
>realistically  (maybe when  you get your license they will drive cars in
>real life with keyboards and digital joypads?)  just guessing?

>        Wheels aren't that expensive, and for that matter, neither are
>joysticks.   NR (the whole series) is really for the crowd that can see the
>issues of racing & actually controlling the car like you would in real life
>"ish".  I grant you that they left the keyboard option in so you could at
>least get a taste.  Most of us been around a while, I actually bought the
>1st version of NASCAR racing by papy, 2 times.  once as 4 or 5 floppy
>install, later better resolution it came on CDrom.  From right on, it was so
>obvious that for me to enjoy this I would have to buy at least 1 joystick
>( I was cheap at 1st and in college, paid for myself BTW).  One joystick
>didn't do it for me, so months later I got another, one to gas & brake, one
>to turn.  Then about a year later I bought a wheel/pedal set.

>    Something about this game ( and other papy sims) that make you want to
>take over the controls.  Sure keyboard kinda worked, but not really ever ...
>was the car doing what I wanted it to do.  How can you stand to drive
>knowing that your really only controlling oh about <10% of what the car is
>doing?  I would be frustrated to all get out...  that in fact I was, I
>bought me a wheel, dam it was worth every penny at the time too!
>(Thrustmaster T-2, 149.99 via mail-order in Jan, 1996.)

>    Can buy wheels now used on ebay for about 30 and change, if you are
>careful.

>Sure it sounds "elitist" with the wheel thing?  Sorry, I was trying like
>hell to be fair...



>> What are the opinions of some of you guys about using steering assists in
>> Nascar 2003?

>>  I just joined an informal group running weekly races and had always used
>> the keyboard since I didn't have a wheel.  Most of the people racing in
>this
>> group are pretty inexperienced but most have wheels.

>> Well, some new guys joined and used the keyboard too.  I made the mistake
>of
>> telling them that on the keyboard, the steering assists were your friend.
>> Traction control, for instance, is on by default and greyed out when using
>> the keyboard to steer.  I also said to turn on stability and set steering
>> assitance to about 60 to smooth out the key imput, otherwise it was like
>> jerking the wheel of a car back and forth hard all the way around the
>track.
>> Anyway, now i'm catching flack from the guys using the steering wheels who
>> say that's cheating and they're going to go to the patched game so they
>can
>> turn off all assists on the server side.

>> What gets me is most of these guys using wheels who think they're too good
>> to need assistance are basically banging the walls and running back down
>to
>> the apron all the way around the track.  Am I wrong in thinking it's more
>> fun to race guys who can at least run a smooth line rather then people who
>> turn all assists off and can't make it once around without hitting the
>wall
>> or spinning out?   I thought the whole idea of putting those in the game
>was
>> to make people more competitive.  They claim using all the steering
>> assistance they can run around the tracks without touching their wheels at
>> all.  That may be true on some tracks but you then have to steer with the
>> throttle and they don't mention what happens if you're running side by
>side
>> with someone else since the assistance tends to keep you in the preferred
>> groove which you can't always run in.

>> Anyway, how do the more experienced guys racing in online leagues deal
>with
>> the issue of steering assists?

>> --------------------------------------------------------------------------

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

"There would be a lot more civility in this world if people
 didn't take that as an invitation to walk all over you"
                   - (Calvin and Hobbes)

Pete

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Pete » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 13:16:56

    Mike Helton after reading your post has decided to ban all power
steering
assists from Nascar sponsered racing. Manual steering is now mandated.
    It will come into effect as soon as the Sierra patch is official.

    Pete


any reputable league will ban them as well
with that, the French drink it"

Eldre

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Eldre » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 14:10:16


>Something about this game ( and other papy sims) that make you want to
>take over the controls.  Sure keyboard kinda worked, but not really ever ...
>was the car doing what I wanted it to do.  How can you stand to drive
>knowing that your really only controlling oh about <10% of what the car is
>doing?

I still get that feeling even using a WHEEL...<g>

Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett

Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Bruce Kennewel

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Bruce Kennewel » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 16:31:53

Jeez! That's gunna be one hell of a patch, then. :)

Bruce.


EGK

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by EGK » Sun, 24 Aug 2003 23:54:40



>>Something about this game ( and other papy sims) that make you want to
>>take over the controls.  Sure keyboard kinda worked, but not really ever ...
>>was the car doing what I wanted it to do.  How can you stand to drive
>>knowing that your really only controlling oh about <10% of what the car is
>>doing?

>I still get that feeling even using a WHEEL...<g>

You said that in jest but I find it a true statement.  I guess I don't
understand the argument that because you have a wheel you're getting the
"true" experience as if it equates to driving a real race car.  

I gave a stock answer to those guys who demand driving aids be turned off by
saying if that's the case then they should all turn off automatic
transmission also and certainly they shouldnt be driving with damage turned
off if they want the realistic experience.  And by the way, be sure and keep
a hammer next to your chair so you can pick it up and whap yourself in the
head everytime you hit the wall cuz you're too good for driving aids.  At
least you'll experience a bit of what a real racer does if he can't drive
the car.

I guess what it boils down to for me is whether this is supposed to be a fun
game or whether people are taking it as life or death.

Say one or the other in the first place but don't change it halfway through.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

"There would be a lot more civility in this world if people
 didn't take that as an invitation to walk all over you"
                   - (Calvin and Hobbes)

Larr

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Larr » Mon, 25 Aug 2003 02:01:50

I think it helps when fixed setups are imposed (i.e. fast setup), and a
persons wheel and/or driving style simply isn't as compatible as one would
wish).

I don't think it provides any competitive edge.

There is one downside.  It tends to pull your car to the preferred racing
line, and you have to be careful not to allow it to pull you into someone.
This was noticeable at Watkins Glen.  I could tell who had steering assist
turned on going into the bus-stop because if you went inside of someone to
pass here, the outside car would lean in on you and then veer away as the
driver corrected.

-Larry


McWho

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by McWho » Mon, 25 Aug 2003 04:10:19




> >>Something about this game ( and other papy sims) that make you want to
> >>take over the controls.  Sure keyboard kinda worked, but not really ever
...
> >>was the car doing what I wanted it to do.  How can you stand to drive
> >>knowing that your really only controlling oh about <10% of what the car
is
> >>doing?

> >I still get that feeling even using a WHEEL...<g>

> You said that in jest but I find it a true statement.  I guess I don't
> understand the argument that because you have a wheel you're getting the
> "true" experience as if it equates to driving a real race car.

> I gave a stock answer to those guys who demand driving aids be turned off
by
> saying if that's the case then they should all turn off automatic
> transmission also and certainly they shouldnt be driving with damage
turned
> off if they want the realistic experience.  And by the way, be sure and
keep
> a hammer next to your chair so you can pick it up and whap yourself in the
> head everytime you hit the wall cuz you're too good for driving aids.  At
> least you'll experience a bit of what a real racer does if he can't drive
> the car.

> I guess what it boils down to for me is whether this is supposed to be a
fun
> game or whether people are taking it as life or death.

> Say one or the other in the first place but don't change it halfway
through.

Don't forget to put the space heater by your feet, put on thermal underwear,
long pants, long sleeve shirt, helmet and driving gloves.   Turn your
speakers WAAAY  up, turn on***pit view, turn off auto clutch, and only
drink water during a pit stop.  No munchies, Beer, or smoking.
Now you are starting to get close to a somewhat realistic experience.
I think you use what makes the driving fun for you.  Whatever these other
guys may consider cheating, if you wreck them because you don't have
traction control on, I bet you they will scream their heads off and demand
to know what you were even doing on the track if you cant drive.   To tell
the truth, no one will know what aids you are using if you don't say.
Sometimes that is best  :-)

Sean

Tim

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by Tim » Mon, 25 Aug 2003 04:28:36

You'll know it when I have them turned on
:)))

--
Tim White
www.intracmotorsports.com


McWho

Opnions of Steering assists in Nascar 2003

by McWho » Mon, 25 Aug 2003 08:05:08

EA Sports?  Did I miss something?

Sean




rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.