rec.autos.simulators

GPL: Physics and other questions

Paul Jone

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Paul Jone » Tue, 03 Nov 1998 04:00:00

What is going on (in the real world) to make opposite lock work? It
seems so counter-intuitive - steer left and you go right!
What are the dynamics of these old wingless wonders when you over-rev at
low gears and they suddenly reach a critical point and veer to the left
or right? You appear to reach a critical rev amount for this to happen.
Is it wheel spin or some other phenomenon?
What revs are best to shift up at both in terms of maximum acceleration
and preserving the cars engine. I guess these are the opposite of
eachother.
I'm interested in getting hold of some good Ferrari setups (lazy bastard
that I am) - I'm particulary interested in the Glen, Spa and
Silverstone. Anyone know of a site with these? (Great sounds - like a
mecanical digger eating a washing machine :-) )
Has anyone noticed that when another app (ICQ, email or a scheduled
program) goes off in the background the sounds in the game die but the
car continues to drive okay. You can hit Alt-Tab to get them back but it
can***up a race royally. These beasts are untameable if they're not
growling at you!
Paul
Cossi

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Cossi » Tue, 03 Nov 1998 04:00:00



>On Mon, 02 Nov 1998 03:34:45 +0000,


>>What is going on (in the real world) to make opposite lock work? It
>>seems so counter-intuitive - steer left and you go right!

>You don't go right by steering left. When oversteering, you keep from
>spinning to the right by steering left. Rinse and repeat for opposite
sides.

>>What are the dynamics of these old wingless wonders when you over-rev at
>>low gears and they suddenly reach a critical point and veer to the left
>>or right? You appear to reach a critical rev amount for this to happen.

>Very high performance engines have a rev point where they begin
>to really pour out the horsepower. This happens in higher RPM ranges than
>a normal engine, and it is caused by many factors, not the least of which
are
>camshaft timing, and inlet sizes..

>>Is it wheel spin or some other phenomenon?

>The former.

>>What revs are best to shift up at both in terms of maximum acceleration
>>and preserving the cars engine. I guess these are the opposite of
>>eachother.

>Good rule of thumb:
>Keep your shifts just under the red line on the tach, for maximum
>performance.

In drag racing, peope taught me to shift at a point where you know your next
gear will land around the peak torque range. Let say if the peak torque is
at 5000 RPM, try run in 1st at about 7000 RPM or so, as you shift into 2nd.
Make sure it is right at 5K or so.
KCDC

GPL: Physics and other questions

by KCDC » Tue, 03 Nov 1998 04:00:00


>On Mon, 02 Nov 1998 03:34:45 +0000,


>>What revs are best to shift up at both in terms of maximum acceleration
>>and preserving the cars engine. I guess these are the opposite of
>>eachother.

>Good rule of thumb:
>Keep your shifts just under the red line on the tach, for maximum
>performance.

I haven't actually seen a red line on any GPL tachs. The red needle is just
a tell-tale, that indicates your max rev's in the session. You can reset it
(alt t or something).

Kevin Caldwell
Calgary, Canada

Paul Jone

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Paul Jone » Tue, 03 Nov 1998 04:00:00


> You don't go right by steering left. When oversteering, you keep from
> spinning to the right by steering left. Rinse and repeat for opposite sides.

Yeah, I appreciate this, I wanted to know what the physics were - as the car
begins to spin, say to the left what is going on that makes it come back to the
right when you turn to the left. It feels intuitive that that action should make
it spin faster, but yes I know it works in real life as well as many sims, so
what are the physics?

That is slightly clearer if it is wheel spin because I can understand that there
is a sudden point where the wheels lose grip. It is simply that at a certain
force exerted by the wheels pushing against the tarmac they reach an enery level
where the *** can skate over the surface. It may be assited by the car having
less relative downforce at speed than when moving, which would explain why it is
harder to replicate in modern F1 and Indy cars. I am guessing all this but what
I'm really looking for is the physics of the thing.  I'm a newbie when it comes
to setups and driving for that matter and I wanted to understand what was going
on why the physics - ie the stuff you learn in the classroom.

Yeah, but what are the actual figure in revolutions per second. Is it linear - ie
is this value the same for 1st to 2nd as for 4th to 5th given that you have set
evenly spaced gear ratios. Again I'm looking to understand the physics.

I've tried here but Alison doesn't have Ferrari setups for these tracks.

Thanks anyway,
Paul

Wolfgang Prei

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Wolfgang Prei » Tue, 03 Nov 1998 04:00:00


>What is going on (in the real world) to make opposite lock work? It
>seems so counter-intuitive - steer left and you go right!

I'm not sure what you mean "steer left and you go right". This is
what's happening: you enter a turn and the end of the car breaks lose.
It is oversteering (i.e. you steered left to begin with, but now the
car is steering more left than you want it to.) If you keep steering
in the original direction, the car will spin. It will use the turned
front wheels as a pivot for spinning around, so to speak. Now, if you
apply opposite lock, you're steering the front of the car to the
outside of the turn and prevent the back of the car from overtaking
the front.

It is. The usable power band of those engines was pretty narrow.
Whereas a nicely motorized road car would go like this (from idle to
max rev):
little power - more - more - MORE - less - limiter
a GPL car goes like this:
little power - a bit more - a bit more - a bit more - MUCH, MUCH MORE
- broken engine. :)

As soon as "MUCH, MUCH MORE" power hits the drivetrain, the rear
wheels will break loose and the rear of the car will step to the side.
Spinning wheels, as well as locked wheels, can't transfer lateral
forces.

Basically yes. Taking above example, you want to stay as much as
possible in the "MUCH, MUCH MORE" power part of the spectrum when
accelerating - assuming that you can transfer that power to the road,
that is. Excessively spinning wheels are of no use.

So, if you shift up early, you will drop back into the "a little more"
power section, and it will take some time to get into the full power
part again. But you know the part that comes after it: broken engine.

In reality, it's not as bad, though: given that your gears are set
properly, you will always have plenty of power when shifting one mark
prior to maximum revs as indicated on your tach.

Did you check Alison's GPL page? She has Ferrari setups by Doug Arnao
for download:
http://www.racesimcentral.net/~alison/gpl/index.htm

I have no background apps running when driving GPL. I need every bit
of available CPU power.

--
Wolfgang Preiss   \ E-mail copies of replies to this posting are welcome.


Mike Vanlandingha

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Mike Vanlandingha » Tue, 03 Nov 1998 04:00:00


> What is going on (in the real world) to make opposite lock work? It
> seems so counter-intuitive - steer left and you go right!

The "steer left and you go right" always confuses me. Suffice it to say,
steer to point the front end where you want it to go.  If your back end is
swinging to the right (which means your front end is beginning to point left
of where you were headed before the back end started to move right), you'll
have to steer back to the right a little to correct.  The trick of course is
to become familiar enough with your car and it's behavior to begin to
anticipate what it's going to do and begin your correction before it
actually happens.

Wheel spin.  Most high performance engines produce the bulk of their power
in a narrow rpm range near the engines maximum rev limit.  Lightweight cars
with little downforce tend to "break the rear (in rear wheel drive) tires
loose" as they "come up on the cam" near the rev limit, especially in the
lower gears.  Or even the higher gears if they're cold and/or your in a
slight curve.

On thing you can do to get a baseline is to run a practice with other cars
(including the same model your driving) then after a few laps check the
replay and watch what Clark with the Lotus uses, or Gurney with the
Westlake, etc.

You can avoid that by shutting down everything (ctrl-alt-del from the
desktop) but Explorer and systray, before starting GPL.  I frees up a lot of
memory, too.

David Mast

GPL: Physics and other questions

by David Mast » Tue, 03 Nov 1998 04:00:00


>Again I'm looking to understand the physics.

A wonderful place to start is the "Physics of Racing" series.  It takes some
time, and won't help you with Ferrari setups, but I consider it a must for net
racers (I wish everyone who posts to the various rec.autos groups would read
it!).  The site:
http://members.home.net/rck/phor

Also, I might recommend a couple of books:
How To Make Your Car Handle, by Fred Puhn, ISBN 0-912656-46-8
Secrets of Solo Racing, by Henry A. Watts, ISBN 0-9620573-1-2

SteveBla

GPL: Physics and other questions

by SteveBla » Wed, 04 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Think of it as a lever.  You've just barely applied enough force to cause the
lever to begin to rotate, with the car's front end as the pivot.  Opposite lock
moves the pivot in the same direction as the rear, ending rotation, but moving
the entire lever laterally.  Push a pencil around on a desk and it's easy to
see.  That's why you always end up going wide with opp-lock.  Eventually the
tires will generate enough heat, and thus friction, to stop their slide, and
with luck, you'll still be pointed in a desirable direction with pavement under
your tires.

If you try different cars, you'll notice a change in this phenomenon.  The
Lotus and Brabham, for instance, have more torque at low revs, and will break
the wheels loose at lower rpms.  The "cammy" Ferrari, on the other hand, is
more of a high revver, as befits a V12, which depends on greater valve area and
more rpms for power.  You'll notice it "hits" higher and more suddenly.  While
it's wheelspin is more sudden, it's often more controllable because the motor
is already closer to peak revs, and has less "headroom" to send you looping
around.  Really nice the way they captured this aspect of peaky engines.

For max acceleration in a straight line, shift at peak power rpms(see the
engine data in the "player info" screens; each car varies. Some cars won't live
long at this rpm level, though, so you'll have to leave a bit of room).  You
won't always want to do this, though.  Depending on track conditions, it's
often better to short-shift to minimize traction loss, which is pretty much the
Holy Grail in GPL; how to reconcile an excess of power with a surfeit of grip.
As for gear ratios, you'll want to have your upper gears more closely spaced
than the lower ones, with gradually smaller gaps from gear to gear.  You'll
know you've got it when it takes similar time spans to run through each gear.
You should divert from that ideal spacing, though,  to avoid having too many
shifts mid-corner.  You want peak revs in top gear just at your braking point
on the fastest part of the course, and a first gear that gives you good
acceleration without too much wheelspin out of the slowest corner.  Then set
your middle gears to suit.

Cheers,

Steve B.

Paul Jone

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Paul Jone » Wed, 04 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Brilliant reply, Steve, this is loads of help, thanks.
Paul

> >Yeah, I appreciate this, I wanted to know what the physics were - as the car
> >begins to spin, say to the left what is going on that makes it come back to
> >the right when you turn to the left.

> Think of it as a lever.  You've just barely applied enough force to cause the
> lever to begin to rotate, with the car's front end as the pivot.  Opposite lock
> moves the pivot in the same direction as the rear, ending rotation, but moving
> the entire lever laterally.  Push a pencil around on a desk and it's easy to
> see.  That's why you always end up going wide with opp-lock.  Eventually the
> tires will generate enough heat, and thus friction, to stop their slide, and
> with luck, you'll still be pointed in a desirable direction with pavement under
> your tires.

> >That is slightly clearer if it is wheel spin because I can understand that
> >there is a sudden point where the wheels lose grip. It is simply that at a
> certain
> >force exerted by the wheels pushing against the tarmac they reach an enery
> >level where the *** can skate over the surface.

> If you try different cars, you'll notice a change in this phenomenon.  The
> Lotus and Brabham, for instance, have more torque at low revs, and will break
> the wheels loose at lower rpms.  The "cammy" Ferrari, on the other hand, is
> more of a high revver, as befits a V12, which depends on greater valve area and
> more rpms for power.  You'll notice it "hits" higher and more suddenly.  While
> it's wheelspin is more sudden, it's often more controllable because the motor
> is already closer to peak revs, and has less "headroom" to send you looping
> around.  Really nice the way they captured this aspect of peaky engines.

> >Yeah, but what are the actual figure in revolutions per second. Is it linear
> >- ie is this value the same for 1st to 2nd as for 4th to 5th given that you
> have
> >set evenly spaced gear ratios. Again I'm looking to understand the physics.

> For max acceleration in a straight line, shift at peak power rpms(see the
> engine data in the "player info" screens; each car varies. Some cars won't live
> long at this rpm level, though, so you'll have to leave a bit of room).  You
> won't always want to do this, though.  Depending on track conditions, it's
> often better to short-shift to minimize traction loss, which is pretty much the
> Holy Grail in GPL; how to reconcile an excess of power with a surfeit of grip.
> As for gear ratios, you'll want to have your upper gears more closely spaced
> than the lower ones, with gradually smaller gaps from gear to gear.  You'll
> know you've got it when it takes similar time spans to run through each gear.
> You should divert from that ideal spacing, though,  to avoid having too many
> shifts mid-corner.  You want peak revs in top gear just at your braking point
> on the fastest part of the course, and a first gear that gives you good
> acceleration without too much wheelspin out of the slowest corner.  Then set
> your middle gears to suit.

> Cheers,

> Steve B.

Grant Reev

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Grant Reev » Thu, 05 Nov 1998 04:00:00



> Yeah, I appreciate this, I wanted to know what the physics were - as the car
> begins to spin, say to the left what is going on that makes it come back to the
> right when you turn to the left. It feels intuitive that that action should make
> it spin faster, but yes I know it works in real life as well as many sims, so
> what are the physics?

the way I understand opposite lock steering is that we come blasting
out of a turn thinking we are the coolest driver around, nailing
the throttle too early. Thus the rear wheels start wheelspinning
fractionally, thus losing cornering traction. Then the rear of the
car starts wanting to go in a straight line - which because we are
turning with the front of the car means that the rear feels like it's
trying to swap ends with the front by heading off towards the fence.
So, at this point you think "oh shit", and start turning the wheel
into the slide, in teh opposite direction of the turn to regain control.
This helps because by turning the front wheels to point in the direction
the rear wheels are sliding in, it enables the front of the car to
go in the same direction as the rear, ie: outwards, and thus the car
is now no longer spinning around - instead it is merely in a balanced
slide, which is a good thing because it's still vaguely pointed in the
right direction (forwards). Because the front wheels are pointed in
the direction of the slide, they roll nice and freely, but the rear
wheels are pointed in the direction the car is facing, and they are
only going sideways due to slip, so now the front of the car is going
sideways faster than the rear enabling the rear to get back under
control giving you time to get off the power or wait for the rear
wheels to regain traction.
I think you mentioned somewhere where you wondered why turning
the wrong way still enables the car to go around the corner, i think
that's a case of the driver being a maniac and deliberately using
his throttle to keep the rear wheels sliding and using a lot of
opposite to prevent the spin, but they are actually balancing the
car so that the rear is still very slowly overtaking the front and
the car is thus slowly going around the turn. While very spectacular
it does cost speed though, due to the sideways wheel slippage at the
rear reducing the level of forward grip available.
While i can control the car in this power oversteer way, i find it's
more stable and faster to simply (or not so simply) apply the
power in a progressive function so that the rear doesn't break traction

the reason these '67 f1 cars get so darn sideways is because the
tyres they use are fairly soft and pliant, they can flex sideways
quite a way without breaking traction.
Modern tyres have many times less sideways movement so they don't
allow cars to get very sideways at all because traction is broken,
that "edge" where you are balancing the car sideways is much much
smaller. or that's what i think so far:) hoepfully i'm not too wrong.

i like to just shift the gear when the rpm reaches a certain level
just under max rpm for that engine, for instance in the lotus i
like to shift just under the 9000 rpm mark. it gives me excellent
reliability (in 3 weeks of solid GPL play i have only blown the
engine non-deliberately once, and damaged it once, both in practice
sessions). I also gear top gear so it reaches that same rpm mark
at the fastest point on the track - that way i won't over-rev and
break the engine on long straights, and i have extra rpm for
slipstreaming.
Also, i think i can feel the acceleration rate beginning to drop
if i rev too high, which is another reason i don't like to crank
the engine up too high.
I may not rev the engine to it's max power levels, but i still put
in lap times that are quicker than 95% of gpl drivers:)

not sure if any of this helped, or just confused you ;)
Grant.

Michael Youn

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Michael Youn » Thu, 05 Nov 1998 04:00:00

I would guess you're spinning mightily when you're over-revving. The
engine torque is removed while you're shifting, and the rev's drop down
to the "correct" value. You'll probably see a similar drop when you
lift, or simply burb the throttle. Come to think of it, I've seen
precisely this; the tach at the high end of lower gears almost look like
it's spinning against a fluid coupled transmission. Rev's drop sharply
when you burb it, and go back up quickly when you get back on it. Might
also be the clutch slipping. (?)

Michael.


> Thank you for all your great answers. On one particular point - when the
> rear end breaks loose if you over-rev in low gears why does it correct
> itself when you up-shift? Surely you are not reducing the wheels' velocity
> relative to the road and I seem to be able to go on accelerating directly
> after up-shifting. So that it seems logical that if the relative speed of
> the tyre to the road is exceeding the stiction (am I using the right word
> here?) why doesn't the problem get worse rather than better when you
> up-shift but stay on the throttle? Is it because while the revs build up
> again you are actually decelerating?
> Paul


> > What is going on (in the real world) to make opposite lock work? It
> > seems so counter-intuitive - steer left and you go right!
> > What are the dynamics of these old wingless wonders when you over-rev at
> > low gears and they suddenly reach a critical point and veer to the left
> > or right? You appear to reach a critical rev amount for this to happen.
> > Is it wheel spin or some other phenomenon?
> > What revs are best to shift up at both in terms of maximum acceleration
> > and preserving the cars engine. I guess these are the opposite of
> > eachother.
> > I'm interested in getting hold of some good Ferrari setups (lazy bastard
> > that I am) - I'm particulary interested in the Glen, Spa and
> > Silverstone. Anyone know of a site with these? (Great sounds - like a
> > mecanical digger eating a washing machine :-) )
> > Has anyone noticed that when another app (ICQ, email or a scheduled
> > program) goes off in the background the sounds in the game die but the
> > car continues to drive okay. You can hit Alt-Tab to get them back but it
> > can***up a race royally. These beasts are untameable if they're not
> > growling at you!
> > Paul

Paul Jone

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Paul Jone » Fri, 06 Nov 1998 04:00:00


> While i can control the car in this power oversteer way, i find it's
> more stable and faster to simply (or not so simply) apply the
> power in a progressive function so that the rear doesn't break traction

I just use it to keep from winding up on the grass !

It helped - thanksPaul

Paul Jone

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Paul Jone » Fri, 06 Nov 1998 04:00:00


>  (I wish everyone who posts to the various rec.autos groups would read
> it!).  The site:
> http://members.home.net/rck/phor

This is a great site - there's one hell of a lot of really good stuff here and it's
written very well.
Thanks for this,
Paul
Paul Jone

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Paul Jone » Fri, 06 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Thank you for all your great answers. On one particular point - when the
rear end breaks loose if you over-rev in low gears why does it correct
itself when you up-shift? Surely you are not reducing the wheels' velocity
relative to the road and I seem to be able to go on accelerating directly
after up-shifting. So that it seems logical that if the relative speed of
the tyre to the road is exceeding the stiction (am I using the right word
here?) why doesn't the problem get worse rather than better when you
up-shift but stay on the throttle? Is it because while the revs build up
again you are actually decelerating?
Paul

> What is going on (in the real world) to make opposite lock work? It
> seems so counter-intuitive - steer left and you go right!
> What are the dynamics of these old wingless wonders when you over-rev at
> low gears and they suddenly reach a critical point and veer to the left
> or right? You appear to reach a critical rev amount for this to happen.
> Is it wheel spin or some other phenomenon?
> What revs are best to shift up at both in terms of maximum acceleration
> and preserving the cars engine. I guess these are the opposite of
> eachother.
> I'm interested in getting hold of some good Ferrari setups (lazy bastard
> that I am) - I'm particulary interested in the Glen, Spa and
> Silverstone. Anyone know of a site with these? (Great sounds - like a
> mecanical digger eating a washing machine :-) )
> Has anyone noticed that when another app (ICQ, email or a scheduled
> program) goes off in the background the sounds in the game die but the
> car continues to drive okay. You can hit Alt-Tab to get them back but it
> can***up a race royally. These beasts are untameable if they're not
> growling at you!
> Paul

Jason Mond

GPL: Physics and other questions

by Jason Mond » Fri, 06 Nov 1998 04:00:00


> <snip>
> Also, i think i can feel the acceleration rate beginning to drop
> if i rev too high, which is another reason i don't like to crank
> the engine up too high.
> I may not rev the engine to it's max power levels, but i still put
> in lap times that are quicker than 95% of gpl drivers:)

> Grant.

I found some extra speed in the Ferrari by winding the engine
up to passed 10,000RPM (top of the tech, anyway).

All the computer players did it, so I decided to try it.

I was struggling with everyone (Lotus, ...) beating me on the
straights, not anymore :)  This also uses up more gas than
usual, so you need to add an extra gallon or so, or else
I'm running on fumes the last lap.

--
--------
Jason Monds
(Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.