rec.autos.simulators

Best wheel & pedals

JML

Best wheel & pedals

by JML » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 02:43:10

Tired of changing these low quality poor feedback wheelsets. I`m going for a
best one available, so anyone, please tell me what to buy and why? Already
had Momo Racing Wheel, Thrustmaster Force Racing Wheel and before those many
other older ones. Suggestions please, is BRD as good as somebody commented?
Jeff Rei

Best wheel & pedals

by Jeff Rei » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 04:55:03

Does BRD offer force feedback now?

pjgt..

Best wheel & pedals

by pjgt.. » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 05:53:14




> Date: Mon, 03 Oct 2005 17:43:10 GMT

> Tired of changing these low quality poor feedback wheelsets. I`m
> going for a best one available, so anyone, please tell me what to buy
> and why? Already had Momo Racing Wheel, Thrustmaster Force Racing
> Wheel and before those many other older ones. Suggestions please, is
> BRD as good as somebody commented?

BRD is the dogs wotsits!

I have had two BRD wheels and pedal set-up's from over six years ago and
they are both working great.

My older BRD wheel and pedals set-up (formerly known as the Interactive
Racing GP500) is now on my "second" pc, this has the old "torsion tube"
type return mechanism for the steering column.

My newer BRD wheel and pedals set-up also has the ball raced spring
return mechanism (much more positive feel).

Apart from buying some new (pedal) springs about once every two years,
and having my old BRD wheel and pedals serviced (once) they have
performed great and will last a lifetime if looked after.

These babies are the best you can get, and BRD are always very helpful.

NB: I also have a BRD Race Frame Pro***pit & seat set-up...!   8-)

For more info and pictures, go to...

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

and also...

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Steve Simpso

Best wheel & pedals

by Steve Simpso » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 10:58:38

I think I read about a BRD FF wheel coming very soon in Autosimsport -  
about 2 grand from memory.

Chad Roger

Best wheel & pedals

by Chad Roger » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 13:09:12

http://ecci6000.com/consumerhome.htm

When only the best will do.

Chad Rogers


Sped

Best wheel & pedals

by Sped » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 21:34:16

http://www.thomas-superwheel.com/

Hi gang, been reading here awhile but this is my first post. I've heard
BRD and ECCI are both good equipment but TSW has to be considered also,
durability and customer service are second to none. I have what was the
top model about 8 years ago and haven't spent a dime on it since day
one. If your really hung up on FF then TEI can't help you but after
owning a TSW for this long,  I wouldn't go back  to FF unless I could
afford some radical $15,000 simulator that can do it properly. I have
an "Old Red" LWFF wheel that I upgraded with  full bearings and it
works well but I'm much more consistant with the Thomas. Considering
TSW's have a "Lifetime" warranty ...it's  a good place to put your $$$;)

pjgt..

Best wheel & pedals

by pjgt.. » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 22:58:35




> Date: Mon, 03 Oct 2005 17:43:10 GMT

> Tired of changing these low quality poor feedback wheelsets. I`m
> going for a best one available, so anyone, please tell me what to buy
> and why? Already had Momo Racing Wheel, Thrustmaster Force Racing
> Wheel and before those many other older ones. Suggestions please, is
> BRD as good as somebody commented?

I agree with two other posters in this thread, that the Thomas Super
Wheels and the ECCI wheels (and pedals) along with BRD are probably the
best three makers in the World at present.

And whilst technically, all three do not have the usual force feedback
method of say Microsoft, Logitech or Momo type wheels, they all employ
their own methods of giving good driver feedback.

Links to the three makers websites are here:

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

I reviewed all three makers in my wbpage about a year ago (see link
below) its a tad out of date as I haven't had time to update it lately,
but its still relevant today.

http://www.racesimcentral.net/

I'm biased towards BRD cos I have two of them, and their***pits are
great quality and value too (and I also have one of those), but I can
see that ECCI and TSW are great quality, and in a similar price bracket
too.

Until someone brings out a good quality, reliable, and accurate force
feedback system, BRD, TSW and ECCI are the best there is at the
moment...

8-)

*Peter* -  http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Larr

Best wheel & pedals

by Larr » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 23:02:58

The email I received from BRD states their FF wheel will be available in
November.

It will most likely be extremely expensive though.

You are right.  I've been lost since my MSFFW died.  I've got a black momo
now and I just cannot get the hang of this thing.  I look like a total
amatuer out there on the track.

-Larry


Larr

Best wheel & pedals

by Larr » Wed, 05 Oct 2005 23:10:11

For those used to Force Feedback, how is the 'de-sensittation to this ?

> http://ecci6000.com/consumerhome.htm

> When only the best will do.

> Chad Rogers



>>> Does BRD offer force feedback now?

>> I think I read about a BRD FF wheel coming very soon in Autosimsport -
>> about 2 grand from memory.

JML

Best wheel & pedals

by JML » Thu, 06 Oct 2005 00:23:08

If I understood correctly you mean how does it feel to have a non-ff wheel
like Ecci etc? I would also like know this. I know that some manufacturers
use benji-cord and other "flexible" materials to have the authentic "linear"
feeling (but naturally wont bump into fingers though..), but as I do not
have experience, really like to hear more...

Btw, are you guys willing to pay like 500+ dollars for a good quality
wheel/pedal set. I personally believe that this is quite a lot of money and
only a very small margin of simracers are so enthusiastic that they put so
much money to it. I will certainly do that, but this is something I really
like and love, apart from the real racing a have chance to do occasionally.


> For those used to Force Feedback, how is the 'de-sensittation to this ?


>> http://ecci6000.com/consumerhome.htm

>> When only the best will do.

>> Chad Rogers



>>>> Does BRD offer force feedback now?

>>> I think I read about a BRD FF wheel coming very soon in Autosimsport -
>>> about 2 grand from memory.

JML

Best wheel & pedals

by JML » Thu, 06 Oct 2005 00:28:21

I saw in your website the ActLabs wheel as well. I had that as well but one
of the pedal strings broke and believe it or not, I didnt succeed to even
open the pedal box, it was so robustly built that in the end the whole
system broke down. That was one nice wheel, expecially at that time when the
game titled just Rally with WRC Seat etc cars, I drove a lot with the 6 gear
system attached to it. Wheel itself was very thick and comfortable.






>> Date: Mon, 03 Oct 2005 17:43:10 GMT

>> Tired of changing these low quality poor feedback wheelsets. I`m
>> going for a best one available, so anyone, please tell me what to buy
>> and why? Already had Momo Racing Wheel, Thrustmaster Force Racing
>> Wheel and before those many other older ones. Suggestions please, is
>> BRD as good as somebody commented?

> I agree with two other posters in this thread, that the Thomas Super
> Wheels and the ECCI wheels (and pedals) along with BRD are probably the
> best three makers in the World at present.

> And whilst technically, all three do not have the usual force feedback
> method of say Microsoft, Logitech or Momo type wheels, they all employ
> their own methods of giving good driver feedback.

> Links to the three makers websites are here:

> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> I reviewed all three makers in my wbpage about a year ago (see link
> below) its a tad out of date as I haven't had time to update it lately,
> but its still relevant today.

> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> I'm biased towards BRD cos I have two of them, and their***pits are
> great quality and value too (and I also have one of those), but I can
> see that ECCI and TSW are great quality, and in a similar price bracket
> too.

> Until someone brings out a good quality, reliable, and accurate force
> feedback system, BRD, TSW and ECCI are the best there is at the
> moment...

> 8-)

> *Peter* -  http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Don Scurloc

Best wheel & pedals

by Don Scurloc » Thu, 06 Oct 2005 03:42:50


$500 dollars a lot of money? I bought my ECCI wheel/pedal system in March
of 1996. It's almost 10 years old! Since then it's cost me maybe 15 bucks
for springs and button replacment and it's as solid and tight as the day it
arrived.
 Contrast that with the big white box on my desk which may as well have a
flush handle on the side of it, expensive hardware goes through that thing
like shit through a goose. High end wheel systems are worth every penny,
you appreciate their quality everytime you touch them and their performance
doesn't deteriorate like almost everything else in the computer chain. And
in terms of retaining value, I could probably sell my ECCI system today for
a good portion of what I paid for it. How much do you think I could get for
a ten year old video card, or motherboard, or cpu, or harddrive.........

Don

Sped

Best wheel & pedals

by Sped » Thu, 06 Oct 2005 04:28:07


> If I understood correctly you mean how does it feel to have a non-ff wheel
> like Ecci etc? I would also like know this. I know that some manufacturers
> use benji-cord and other "flexible" materials to have the authentic "linear"
> feeling

TSW uses two opposing steel springs to achieve a centering affect that
while it may not be 100% realistic it does feel quite natural to drive
and is very smooth, especially if compared to something that is gear
driven like the logitec momo where you can feel the gears meshing
together. The "feel" of a TSW is excellent, both in the wheel and the
pedals. Everything is rock solid, control is extremely smooth and
accurate. IMO FF is nothing more than a cheap novelty and does nothing
for a persons skill level, where-as a good wheel certainly does improve
your driving.

Cheaper wheels tend to last 2/3 yrs usually until they need
replacement, my TSW is 8 yrs old and shows no sign of excessive wear or
sloppiness in either the wheel or pedal unit. Only once I've had to
replace a wheel centering spring and that was shipped free of charge in
less than a week. A "Lifetime" warranty is worth alot;)

JML

Best wheel & pedals

by JML » Thu, 06 Oct 2005 05:22:45

Yes, I believe every word you say about quality wheels. Therefore I`m going
for one and it seems to me that it will be Ecci or TSW. The best model
however is very expensive, so you think I should go for the cheaper ones.
Anything they miss, as websites do tells a lot, differences between Ecci
models for example aren`t so big.




>> If I understood correctly you mean how does it feel to have a non-ff
>> wheel
>> like Ecci etc? I would also like know this. I know that some
>> manufacturers
>> use benji-cord and other "flexible" materials to have the authentic
>> "linear"
>> feeling

> TSW uses two opposing steel springs to achieve a centering affect that
> while it may not be 100% realistic it does feel quite natural to drive
> and is very smooth, especially if compared to something that is gear
> driven like the logitec momo where you can feel the gears meshing
> together. The "feel" of a TSW is excellent, both in the wheel and the
> pedals. Everything is rock solid, control is extremely smooth and
> accurate. IMO FF is nothing more than a cheap novelty and does nothing
> for a persons skill level, where-as a good wheel certainly does improve
> your driving.

> Cheaper wheels tend to last 2/3 yrs usually until they need
> replacement, my TSW is 8 yrs old and shows no sign of excessive wear or
> sloppiness in either the wheel or pedal unit. Only once I've had to
> replace a wheel centering spring and that was shipped free of charge in
> less than a week. A "Lifetime" warranty is worth alot;)

PlowBo

Best wheel & pedals

by PlowBo » Thu, 06 Oct 2005 06:44:07

Some could argue that if you were not the ultimate PC technician, ESPECIALLY
since you had the "Logitech" branded wheel, you have no fruitfull experience
with force feedback.

Im not doggin you honest, Lets just look at the facts.  The troubles I seen
(and tried to work through as a tech & friend), read, & encountered with the
older logitech drivers and other issues.  That is the fact that would be
making me state the above.   In my Humble Estimation, one in 10 Logitech
owners, could setup the wheel correctly (more importantly keep it from
goofing itself up within minutes ruining the experience, by not one fault of
their own BTW...

SO I will ask, now days is it one in 5?  so in 500 wheels, 100 of you had a
fair and working chance to judge it, as I see it, the odds are against you
having been the lucky 20% to setup the wheel & FF.

Because I say this, I am only going by logic, of which you enlighten me
with, pushed into a thought about my experiences with both logitech,
Thrustcrapper, and finally Sidewinder wheels.  when you have FF that is
setup and works like it does in my humble opinion, you wont go back to
springs...

that is my $.02 (USD)...

Spede enlightened us with:


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.