rec.autos.simulators

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

Alan Bernard

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Alan Bernard » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 11:27:10

It's really too early for anyone to say whether F1 2001 is good or not.
These "first impression" reviews are sometimes based on surface things, like
menus and menu sounds and a few crashes here and there.  And oftentimes
enough they are based on reviewers' emotional attachments to other similar
type games, in this case GP3 and GPL.

But what a person likes or dislikes, using these likes and dislikes as a
basis for a "first impressions", is up to the person.  The only thing is
that I don't think others should shy away from getting a game just because
one person, based on personal preferences and biases, says the game is no
good.

I myself, from a few spins with the game, think it's looking like a pretty
nice title.  I do notice some pauses in the video, which may be driver or
system related.  The sounds to me are fine, framerates are good, and overall
the feeling of the game is excellent.

Alanb

> That's really too bad since F1 2000 Cs is not all that great. Here's
hoping
> for 2002!

> Todd



> > Greg
> > I had big hopes for this sim, but give me F1 2000 CS any day.
> > Iain



> > > I am quite surprised at this. I also saw F1 2001 at the SAP tent
> > > at the USGP. It looked essentially the same as F1 2000 CS. The
> > > framerate was fine and there were no issues like this at all.

> > > --




> > > > Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> > > > 1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds
> like
> > a
> > > > scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > > > 2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and
> > overly

> > res,
> > > > EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and
> > feels
> > > > like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > > > 3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite
> trying
> > > > several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The
> back
> > > end
> > > > comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description
> just
> > > > causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the
> car
> > at
> > > > all.

> > > > 4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering
> over
> > > any
> > > > button.

> > > > 5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars
> > finish
> > > > each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to
> race
> > in
> > > > any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > > > 6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > > > 7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there
is
> > no
> > > > excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF
from
> > > F1CS.

> > > > 8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make
it
> > > > unplayable.

> > > > I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong somewhere,
> as
> > I
> > > > have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.  If
> > > things
> > > > don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > > > GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing
to
> > > worry
> > > > about from F1 2001.

> > > > Shall we wait for the patch?

> > > > (BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb
> RAM)

> > > > Iain

TRUSRS

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by TRUSRS » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 14:33:29

CART!
Haqsa

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Haqsa » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 15:53:47

LOL!  Should have known you'd be making an appearance somewhere in this
thread.

Hey, speaking of which, have the guys who did CART2K said anything about
doing a CART mod for F1 2001?


Bart Westr

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Bart Westr » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 16:14:37


(snip)
  The only FF I've seen (or

You must never have tried GP3 1.13 or 2000 then ...

Bart Westra

Iain Mackenzi

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Iain Mackenzi » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 17:00:53

Took the words right out of my mouth Bart. FF in GP3 is by far the best of
any MODERN F1 sim.  Put your foot down too much in 1st or 2nd and get that
fight with the wheel!
Iain




> (snip)
>   The only FF I've seen (or
> > felt) that does anything to help you drive the car is Papy's (in GPL &
> N4),
> > altho the implementation in Mobil 1 Rally Championship was near-great--I
> > loved how *all* feeling went away when you were skating across a patch
of
> > the dreaded Black Ice (no, not the firewall).

> You must never have tried GP3 1.13 or 2000 then ...

> Bart Westra

Iain Mackenzi

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Iain Mackenzi » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 17:03:55

Steve
Where did GPL come into this???  I know this is RAS, but that's taking ot a
bit too far!!!!  You mean F1 2001 obviously. Well, see another post from me
on the difference it made getting rid of the 21.81 drivers.
Iain


> Calm down, John; Thomas there wasn't asking what planet *you* were from--I
> think his comments were directed at Iain.  I don't think Iain has had much
> experience with GPL and his GF2/21.xx Det combo; a lot of people including
> me had trouble there and went back to the earlier drivers.  He seems
miffed
> at the VERY IDEA that the latest drivers aren't giving him the best
> performance.

> The other point seems to be that he'd rather have bad FF than no feedback
at
> all.  One of the F1 2001 designers seemed acutely embarrassed at the FF
> implementation in F1CS and said he'd rather have no FF than bad FF,
> promising a patch to solve the problem later on.  Of course, a lot of
people
> are still waiting for the patch for F1 2000.  The only FF I've seen (or
> felt) that does anything to help you drive the car is Papy's (in GPL &
N4),
> altho the implementation in Mobil 1 Rally Championship was near-great--I
> loved how *all* feeling went away when you were skating across a patch of
> the dreaded Black Ice (no, not the firewall).

> --Steve

> ----- Original Message -----

> Newsgroups: rec.autos.simulators
> Sent: Friday, October 05, 2001 3:49 PM
> Subject: Re: F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

> > For better video performance, try running in windowed mode -- set the
> > parameter in the config.ini file to "1" (instead of "0").  This is a
> > known problem with newer Detonator drivers.

> > You might also want to visit the High Gear forums -- a LOT of people
> > over there disagree with most of your assessment, it seems, including
> > a lot of F1RC, GP3, and GPL fans.

> > -- JB

> > On Fri, 5 Oct 2001 18:08:04 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie"

> > >Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> > >1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds
like
> a
> > >scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > >2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and
> overly

res,
> > >EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and
feels
> > >like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > >3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite trying
> > >several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The
back
> end
> > >comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description just
> > >causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the car
> at
> > >all.

> > >4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering over
> any
> > >button.

> > >5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars
finish
> > >each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to race
> in
> > >any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > >6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > >7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there is
no
> > >excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF from
> F1CS.

> > >8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make it
> > >unplayable.

> > >I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong somewhere, as
I
> > >have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.  If
> things
> > >don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > >GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing to
> worry
> > >about from F1 2001.

> > >Shall we wait for the patch?

> > >(BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb RAM)

> > >Iain



> > The planet of pathetic driver mismatches, I think -- why else would
> > you use Detonator drivers that are optimized for the GeForce3 with a
> > GeForce2 Ultra?

> > Alternate answer:  The plant of people who have not yet learned the
> > advantages of running F1 2001 in windowed mode if you're using newer
> > Detonator drivers . . .

> > :-p

> > ;-)

> > -- JB

> > On Fri, 05 Oct 2001 19:26:29 GMT, "Thomas Heineman"

> > >What planet are you from?

> > >Thomas


meddelandet

> > >> Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> > >> 1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds
> like a
> > >> scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > >> 2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and
> overly

> res,
> > >> EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and
> feels
> > >> like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > >> 3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite
trying
> > >> several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The
> back
> > >end
> > >> comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description
just
> > >> causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the
car
> at
> > >> all.

> > >> 4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering
over
> > >any
> > >> button.

> > >> 5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars
> finish
> > >> each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to
race
> in
> > >> any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > >> 6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > >> 7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there
is
> no
> > >> excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF
from
> > >F1CS.

> > >> 8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make
it
> > >> unplayable.

> > >> I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong somewhere,
as
> I
> > >> have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.  If
> > >things
> > >> don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > >> GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing
to
> > >worry
> > >> about from F1 2001.

> > >> Shall we wait for the patch?

> > >> (BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb
RAM)

> > >> Iain

Iain Mackenzi

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Iain Mackenzi » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 17:12:20

Morgan
No idea what you are on about!  I don't post in any forums - only on ras.
In fact, PCs are my forte - as you put it - if not, then God knows how I've
been earning my living for the last x years!!!
Iain


> Iain..from reading all your posts here and in forums,and also studying
most
> of the other guys posts in fair detail...i have a definite conclusion.

> PC's are not your forte in life,dont ever think they are.

> ...now what's that saying...?....tools..?....craftsmen..?...forgot..

> Morgan


> > Nonsense!!  the 21.821 drivers have been a big improvement on my GF2
Ultra
> > in everything else. It's a F1 2001 problem.
> > Iain



> > > The planet of pathetic driver mismatches, I think -- why else would
> > > you use Detonator drivers that are optimized for the GeForce3 with a
> > > GeForce2 Ultra?

> > > Alternate answer:  The plant of people who have not yet learned the
> > > advantages of running F1 2001 in windowed mode if you're using newer
> > > Detonator drivers . . .

> > > :-p

> > > ;-)

> > > -- JB

> > > On Fri, 05 Oct 2001 19:26:29 GMT, "Thomas Heineman"

> > > >What planet are you from?

> > > >Thomas


> meddelandet

> > > >> Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> > > >> 1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds
> > like a
> > > >> scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > > >> 2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and
> > overly

any
> > res,
> > > >> EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and
> > feels
> > > >> like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > > >> 3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite
> trying
> > > >> several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The
> > back
> > > >end
> > > >> comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description
> just
> > > >> causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the
> car
> > at
> > > >> all.

> > > >> 4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering
> over
> > > >any
> > > >> button.

> > > >> 5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars
> > finish
> > > >> each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to
> race
> > in
> > > >> any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > > >> 6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > > >> 7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there
> is
> > no
> > > >> excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF
> from
> > > >F1CS.

> > > >> 8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make
> it
> > > >> unplayable.

> > > >> I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong
somewhere,
> as
> > I
> > > >> have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.
If
> > > >things
> > > >> don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > > >> GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing
> to
> > > >worry
> > > >> about from F1 2001.

> > > >> Shall we wait for the patch?

> > > >> (BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb
> RAM)

> > > >> Iain

Stephen Smit

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Stephen Smit » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 20:55:30

Thanks for being stud-muffin enuf to admit it! <BG>

"Iain Mackenzie" <iain.macken...@REMOVE.ntlworld.com> wrote in message

news:NVyv7.17253$jE3.2173029@news6-win.server.ntlworld.com...
> Steve
> Where did GPL come into this???  I know this is RAS, but that's taking ot
a
> bit too far!!!!  You mean F1 2001 obviously. Well, see another post from
me
> on the difference it made getting rid of the 21.81 drivers.
> Iain

> "Stephen Smith" <ssmit...@rochester.rr.com> wrote in message
> news:3ntv7.620157$EF2.86863420@typhoon.nyroc.rr.com...
> > Calm down, John; Thomas there wasn't asking what planet *you* were
from--I
> > think his comments were directed at Iain.  I don't think Iain has had
much
> > experience with GPL and his GF2/21.xx Det combo; a lot of people
including
> > me had trouble there and went back to the earlier drivers.  He seems
> miffed
> > at the VERY IDEA that the latest drivers aren't giving him the best
> > performance.

> > The other point seems to be that he'd rather have bad FF than no
feedback
> at
> > all.  One of the F1 2001 designers seemed acutely embarrassed at the FF
> > implementation in F1CS and said he'd rather have no FF than bad FF,
> > promising a patch to solve the problem later on.  Of course, a lot of
> people
> > are still waiting for the patch for F1 2000.  The only FF I've seen (or
> > felt) that does anything to help you drive the car is Papy's (in GPL &
> N4),
> > altho the implementation in Mobil 1 Rally Championship was near-great--I
> > loved how *all* feeling went away when you were skating across a patch
of
> > the dreaded Black Ice (no, not the firewall).

> > --Steve

> > ----- Original Message -----
> > From: "John Bodin" <jbodin_nos...@iquest.net>
> > Newsgroups: rec.autos.simulators
> > Sent: Friday, October 05, 2001 3:49 PM
> > Subject: Re: F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

> > > For better video performance, try running in windowed mode -- set the
> > > parameter in the config.ini file to "1" (instead of "0").  This is a
> > > known problem with newer Detonator drivers.

> > > You might also want to visit the High Gear forums -- a LOT of people
> > > over there disagree with most of your assessment, it seems, including
> > > a lot of F1RC, GP3, and GPL fans.

> > > -- JB

> > > On Fri, 5 Oct 2001 18:08:04 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie"
> > > <iain.macken...@REMOVE.ntlworld.com> wrote:

> > > >Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> > > >1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds
> like
> > a
> > > >scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > > >2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and
> > overly
> > > >filtered - whether running @ 1280 or 640. Frame rate seems OK at any
> res,
> > > >EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and
> feels
> > > >like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > > >3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite
trying
> > > >several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The
> back
> > end
> > > >comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description
just
> > > >causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the
car
> > at
> > > >all.

> > > >4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering
over
> > any
> > > >button.

> > > >5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars
> finish
> > > >each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to
race
> > in
> > > >any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > > >6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > > >7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there
is
> no
> > > >excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF
from
> > F1CS.

> > > >8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make
it
> > > >unplayable.

> > > >I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong somewhere,
as
> I
> > > >have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.  If
> > things
> > > >don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > > >GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing
to
> > worry
> > > >about from F1 2001.

> > > >Shall we wait for the patch?

> > > >(BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb
RAM)

> > > >Iain

> > "John Bodin" <jbodin_nos...@iquest.net> wrote in message
> > news:3bbe0f8f.19256218@nntp.ext.ray.com...
> > > The planet of pathetic driver mismatches, I think -- why else would
> > > you use Detonator drivers that are optimized for the GeForce3 with a
> > > GeForce2 Ultra?

> > > Alternate answer:  The plant of people who have not yet learned the
> > > advantages of running F1 2001 in windowed mode if you're using newer
> > > Detonator drivers . . .

> > > :-p

> > > ;-)

> > > -- JB

> > > On Fri, 05 Oct 2001 19:26:29 GMT, "Thomas Heineman"
> > > <thomas.heinemanREMOVES...@home.se> wrote:

> > > >What planet are you from?

> > > >Thomas

> > > >"Iain Mackenzie" <iain.macken...@REMOVE.ntlworld.com> skrev i
> meddelandet
> > > >news:TNlv7.11849$jE3.1544199@news6-win.server.ntlworld.com...
> > > >> Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> > > >> 1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds
> > like a
> > > >> scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > > >> 2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and
> > overly
> > > >> filtered - whether running @ 1280 or 640. Frame rate seems OK at
any
> > res,
> > > >> EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and
> > feels
> > > >> like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > > >> 3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite
> trying
> > > >> several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The
> > back
> > > >end
> > > >> comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description
> just
> > > >> causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the
> car
> > at
> > > >> all.

> > > >> 4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering
> over
> > > >any
> > > >> button.

> > > >> 5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars
> > finish
> > > >> each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to
> race
> > in
> > > >> any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > > >> 6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > > >> 7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there
> is
> > no
> > > >> excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF
> from
> > > >F1CS.

> > > >> 8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make
> it
> > > >> unplayable.

> > > >> I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong
somewhere,
> as
> > I
> > > >> have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.
If
> > > >things
> > > >> don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > > >> GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing
> to
> > > >worry
> > > >> about from F1 2001.

> > > >> Shall we wait for the patch?

> > > >> (BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb
> RAM)

> > > >> Iain

John Bod

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by John Bod » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 21:47:47

No CART mods planned, but how about a retail CART sim based on the F1
2001 physics engine?

:-D

-- JB



>LOL!  Should have known you'd be making an appearance somewhere in this
>thread.

>Hey, speaking of which, have the guys who did CART2K said anything about
>doing a CART mod for F1 2001?



>> CART!

Thom j

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Thom j » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 21:54:49

This is truely sad after some of the hype before hand! phew


| Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!
|
| 1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds like a
| scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!
|
| 2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and overly

| EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and feels
| like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.
|
| 3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite trying
| several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The back
end
| comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description just
| causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the car at
| all.
|
| 4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering over
any
| button.
|
| 5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars finish
| each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to race in
| any way competitively for previous reasons.
|
| 6) Mirrors don't work at all!
|
| 7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there is no
| excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF from
F1CS.
|
| 8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make it
| unplayable.
|
| I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong somewhere, as I
| have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.  If
things
| don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.
|
| GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing to
worry
| about from F1 2001.
|
| Shall we wait for the patch?
|
| (BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb RAM)
|
| Iain
|
|
|
|

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.282 / Virus Database: 150 - Release Date: 9/25/2001

Thom j

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Thom j » Sun, 07 Oct 2001 22:09:02

TRUS comes thru again!! hahaha


| CART!

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.282 / Virus Database: 150 - Release Date: 9/25/2001

Ed Solhei

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Ed Solhei » Mon, 08 Oct 2001 00:15:27

Why 'o why do you guys fall for the same  EA joke?!?
 Time after time ...  - or title after title - that is!

--
ed_



> Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> 1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds like a
> scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> 2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and overly

> EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and feels
> like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> 3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite trying
> several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The back
end
> comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description just
> causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the car at
> all.

> 4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering over
any
> button.

> 5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars finish
> each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to race in
> any way competitively for previous reasons.

> 6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> 7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there is no
> excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF from
F1CS.

> 8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make it
> unplayable.

> I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong somewhere, as I
> have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.  If
things
> don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing to
worry
> about from F1 2001.

> Shall we wait for the patch?

> (BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb RAM)

> Iain

Chairbor

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Chairbor » Mon, 08 Oct 2001 00:29:41

On Fri, 5 Oct 2001 18:08:04 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie"


>Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

Ian, we are both GP3 fans, so we have a similar starting point.

The engine sound is better than F1RC, and we all know default sounds
are bad anyway.  These will be easy to fix.  I kinda liked the skid
sound.

>2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and overly

>EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and feels
>like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

I thought the graphics were ok, albeit cartoony.  There is a tick box
for FSAA, and setting that did bring on the glitch.  I turned that
off, and turned FSAA on for the card, and it seemed ok.  This is 1024,
high car and track, everything else medium.  The Ferrari steering
wheel in the***pit was very nice.  The driver arms are pretty weird.

Yeah, you get that floaty feeling that was bad but not as noticeable
in F12K.  I am still working on settings that will allow me to put the
car where I want it.  Not even close yet.

That is curious, same here.  There is a place to turn them on, but it
doesn't make any difference.  Tied into framerate somehow?  I noticed
that some video changes would result in red graphics, telling you (I
guess) that this was too high for your card as benchmarked (which it
does at the setup).

None.  Not even the imaginary FF of F12K.  I cannot comprehend this.

I have not had that problem...yet.

I'm waiting for a while to see how the mods change things.  But,
without FF, it will never be played.

Amen

No.  Wait for the real developers:  the guys doing the mods.

733/GTS/128 here.  Latest det drivers are no problem here, except for
the FSAA snafu.

Haqsa

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Haqsa » Mon, 08 Oct 2001 00:31:05

I had heard that rumor, too.  Any official announcement yet?


> No CART mods planned, but how about a retail CART sim based on the F1
> 2001 physics engine?

> :-D

> -- JB



> >LOL!  Should have known you'd be making an appearance somewhere in
this
> >thread.

> >Hey, speaking of which, have the guys who did CART2K said anything
about
> >doing a CART mod for F1 2001?



> >> CART!

Stephen Smit

F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

by Stephen Smit » Mon, 08 Oct 2001 01:25:50

Iain, all,

For a deeper explanation of the performance differences betw. the various
Detonators, I recommend:

http://f1gamers.com/cgi-bin/f1/link.pl?http://www.guru3d.com/detonato...
/

--Steve

"Stephen Smith" <ssmit...@rochester.rr.com> wrote in message

news:SiCv7.620817$EF2.87256051@typhoon.nyroc.rr.com...
> Thanks for being stud-muffin enuf to admit it! <BG>

> "Iain Mackenzie" <iain.macken...@REMOVE.ntlworld.com> wrote in message
> news:NVyv7.17253$jE3.2173029@news6-win.server.ntlworld.com...
> > Steve
> > Where did GPL come into this???  I know this is RAS, but that's taking
ot
> a
> > bit too far!!!!  You mean F1 2001 obviously. Well, see another post from
> me
> > on the difference it made getting rid of the 21.81 drivers.
> > Iain

> > "Stephen Smith" <ssmit...@rochester.rr.com> wrote in message
> > news:3ntv7.620157$EF2.86863420@typhoon.nyroc.rr.com...
> > > Calm down, John; Thomas there wasn't asking what planet *you* were
> from--I
> > > think his comments were directed at Iain.  I don't think Iain has had
> much
> > > experience with GPL and his GF2/21.xx Det combo; a lot of people
> including
> > > me had trouble there and went back to the earlier drivers.  He seems
> > miffed
> > > at the VERY IDEA that the latest drivers aren't giving him the best
> > > performance.

> > > The other point seems to be that he'd rather have bad FF than no
> feedback
> > at
> > > all.  One of the F1 2001 designers seemed acutely embarrassed at the
FF
> > > implementation in F1CS and said he'd rather have no FF than bad FF,
> > > promising a patch to solve the problem later on.  Of course, a lot of
> > people
> > > are still waiting for the patch for F1 2000.  The only FF I've seen
(or
> > > felt) that does anything to help you drive the car is Papy's (in GPL &
> > N4),
> > > altho the implementation in Mobil 1 Rally Championship was
near-great--I
> > > loved how *all* feeling went away when you were skating across a patch
> of
> > > the dreaded Black Ice (no, not the firewall).

> > > --Steve

> > > ----- Original Message -----
> > > From: "John Bodin" <jbodin_nos...@iquest.net>
> > > Newsgroups: rec.autos.simulators
> > > Sent: Friday, October 05, 2001 3:49 PM
> > > Subject: Re: F1 2001 - first impressions!?!

> > > > For better video performance, try running in windowed mode -- set
the
> > > > parameter in the config.ini file to "1" (instead of "0").  This is a
> > > > known problem with newer Detonator drivers.

> > > > You might also want to visit the High Gear forums -- a LOT of people
> > > > over there disagree with most of your assessment, it seems,
including
> > > > a lot of F1RC, GP3, and GPL fans.

> > > > -- JB

> > > > On Fri, 5 Oct 2001 18:08:04 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie"
> > > > <iain.macken...@REMOVE.ntlworld.com> wrote:

> > > > >Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very poor!

> > > > >1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding sounds
> > like
> > > a
> > > > >scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > > > >2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal and
> > > overly
> > > > >filtered - whether running @ 1280 or 640. Frame rate seems OK at
any
> > res,
> > > > >EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks and
> > feels
> > > > >like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > > > >3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite
> trying
> > > > >several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car! The
> > back
> > > end
> > > > >comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any description
> just
> > > > >causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with the
> car
> > > at
> > > > >all.

> > > > >4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when hovering
> over
> > > any
> > > > >button.

> > > > >5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5 cars
> > finish
> > > > >each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable to
> race
> > > in
> > > > >any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > > > >6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > > > >7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA, there
> is
> > no
> > > > >excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF
> from
> > > F1CS.

> > > > >8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and make
> it
> > > > >unplayable.

> > > > >I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong
somewhere,
> as
> > I
> > > > >have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.
If
> > > things
> > > > >don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > > > >GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have nothing
> to
> > > worry
> > > > >about from F1 2001.

> > > > >Shall we wait for the patch?

> > > > >(BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP, 512Mb
> RAM)

> > > > >Iain

> > > "John Bodin" <jbodin_nos...@iquest.net> wrote in message
> > > news:3bbe0f8f.19256218@nntp.ext.ray.com...
> > > > The planet of pathetic driver mismatches, I think -- why else would
> > > > you use Detonator drivers that are optimized for the GeForce3 with a
> > > > GeForce2 Ultra?

> > > > Alternate answer:  The plant of people who have not yet learned the
> > > > advantages of running F1 2001 in windowed mode if you're using newer
> > > > Detonator drivers . . .

> > > > :-p

> > > > ;-)

> > > > -- JB

> > > > On Fri, 05 Oct 2001 19:26:29 GMT, "Thomas Heineman"
> > > > <thomas.heinemanREMOVES...@home.se> wrote:

> > > > >What planet are you from?

> > > > >Thomas

> > > > >"Iain Mackenzie" <iain.macken...@REMOVE.ntlworld.com> skrev i
> > meddelandet
> > > > >news:TNlv7.11849$jE3.1544199@news6-win.server.ntlworld.com...
> > > > >> Well, I've just got F1 2001 and my first impressions are very
poor!

> > > > >> 1)  Sound is terrible. Tyre sounds are like static, skidding
sounds
> > > like a
> > > > >> scraping sound, engines sound like demented bees!

> > > > >> 2)  Graphics are very poor.  Looks like a cartoon - very unreal
and
> > > overly
> > > > >> filtered - whether running @ 1280 or 640. Frame rate seems OK at
> any
> > > res,
> > > > >> EXCEPT for the fact that every 5 seconds or so everything looks
and
> > > feels
> > > > >> like travelling through treacle for 1-2 seconds.

> > > > >> 3)  Control seems to be almost nil.  My Ferrari FF wheel despite
> > trying
> > > > >> several settings just doesn't seem to be able to drive the car!
The
> > > back
> > > > >end
> > > > >> comes round if you breath too hard, and braking of any
description
> > just
> > > > >> causes instability.  There is no feeling of being in touch with
the
> > car
> > > at
> > > > >> all.

> > > > >> 4) Menus have a very irritating sound which comes up when
hovering
> > over
> > > > >any
> > > > >> button.

> > > > >> 5) Having tried about 10 quick races at Imola, only about 4-5
cars
> > > finish
> > > > >> each time.  Can't give any assessment of AI because I am unable
to
> > race
> > > in
> > > > >> any way competitively for previous reasons.

> > > > >> 6) Mirrors don't work at all!

> > > > >> 7) There is no FF!  Despite the deadlines no doubt set by EA,
there
> > is
> > > no
> > > > >> excuse for this.  They could have used the (less than perfect) FF
> > from
> > > > >F1CS.

> > > > >> 8) Twice now, the graphics corrupt at the start of a race, and
make
> > it
> > > > >> unplayable.

> > > > >> I really hope that there is something fundamentally wrong
> somewhere,
> > as
> > > I
> > > > >> have only scratched the surface.  God knows what else I'll find.
> If
> > > > >things
> > > > >> don't improve in a couple of days, then it's going back.

> > > > >> GP3 2000, F1RC (despite some AI probs) and even F12KCS have
nothing
> > to
> > > > >worry
> > > > >> about from F1 2001.

> > > > >> Shall we wait for the patch?

> > > > >> (BTW I'm running on 1.4 Athlon, GF2 Ultra, 21.80 Dets on XP,
512Mb
> > RAM)

> > > > >> Iain


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.