rec.autos.simulators

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

Destro

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Destro » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 13:39:42

Trying to decide a wheel for N4.  I have a FF joystick and for the most
part when I want to play seriously I turn FF off or way down. The FF efx
just get in the way and hinder or alter the stick movement I want to
make.

Is a FF wheel the same way in that FF is cool and fun but when you want
to cut serious lap times or try to win, the FF efx just gets in the way?

Sideshow Bo

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Sideshow Bo » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 13:52:39


> Is a FF wheel the same way in that FF is cool and fun but when you want
> to cut serious lap times or try to win, the FF efx just gets in the way?

I've found it depends on the game's implementation of FF.

In GPL I'd almost say it is indispensable.  In SCGT, FF is near useless.

GPL gives me a lot of car "feel" and I'm much more consistent now.  SCGT has
nearly no car "feel" just the rumble strip-type effects.

Dale.

Warre

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Warre » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 18:51:34

to be honest i have used both and taken the time to get used to both
in GPL ( all i drive) in 2 sec per lap at all tracks faster without FF
it depends on you and what you get used to.
good luck



> > Is a FF wheel the same way in that FF is cool and fun but when you want
> > to cut serious lap times or try to win, the FF efx just gets in the way?

> I've found it depends on the game's implementation of FF.

> In GPL I'd almost say it is indispensable.  In SCGT, FF is near useless.

> GPL gives me a lot of car "feel" and I'm much more consistent now.  SCGT
has
> nearly no car "feel" just the rumble strip-type effects.

> Dale.

Olav K. Malm

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Olav K. Malm » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 18:47:35


> to be honest i have used both and taken the time to get used to both
> in GPL ( all i drive) in 2 sec per lap at all tracks faster without FF
> it depends on you and what you get used to.
> good luck

The nice thing about FF is that while you are not faster, you are much
more consistent in a race. The FF helps a lot when you make mistakes,
and I've saved that car a lot where it would be lost with a non-FF controller.




> > > Is a FF wheel the same way in that FF is cool and fun but when you want
> > > to cut serious lap times or try to win, the FF efx just gets in the way?

> > I've found it depends on the game's implementation of FF.

> > In GPL I'd almost say it is indispensable.  In SCGT, FF is near useless.

> > GPL gives me a lot of car "feel" and I'm much more consistent now.  SCGT
> has
> > nearly no car "feel" just the rumble strip-type effects.

> > Dale.

--
Olav K. Malmin
remove .spam when replying
Gregor Vebl

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Gregor Vebl » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 18:48:51


> to be honest i have used both and taken the time to get used to both
> in GPL ( all i drive) in 2 sec per lap at all tracks faster without FF
> it depends on you and what you get used to.
> good luck

I'd say if you use proper driving technique, FF will help you to do
consistent fast times. If you're 'overdriving' the car, FF won't allow
you that if you have forces set to somewhat realistically high. It
really depends on what kind of speed you're looking at. But for absolute
fastest hotlap time, I'd say a non FF wheel would work best.

I, on the other hand, never knew how to drive GPL any differently than
what I'd do with a real car (I like to caress it :) ), so I noticed a
drop in laptimes and also more consistency.

-Gregor

bob

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by bob » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 21:59:06

             In GPL, FF will help you learn to drive better, because
it lets you know when you're horsing the car around.  OTOH, I'm sure
the ability to unrealistically whip the steering around probably would
be faster sometimes.
steven crook-dawkin

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by steven crook-dawkin » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 22:30:19

They do and they don't: here is my experience:

In Colin McRae (vers 1 this is) :
I find the FF a boon here - it really demonstrates that
you paid the extra for the wheel - not sure if it
helps my driving but it adds to my enjoyment
emmensely. Tend to find I look for large
jumps to get the wheel humming - and this
probably makes for a poor performance.

In GP3:
FF is really annoying, mostly because the FF
is so incredibly subtle I spend half the time
wondering if my wheel has broken. I guess
I could race GP3 better with a non FF wheel
because I wouldn't checking connections under
the desk as I'm driving - or deliberately
knocking other cars to see if the wheel is working.

In GPL:
FF at its best - I'm never distracted by the FF
in this game because it integrates really well
with the visual and audio cues. Not a good enough
racer to explain this - but I can get a feeling for
the level of grip available through the wheel.
FOr instance, I would know when I'm about
to loose it - and this is due to my bad driving,
rather than attempting to test the wheel.

If I went to a nonFF wheel with GPL, I would be
much worse, if this where possible.

In Rally Championship 2000:
this is a cross between the "fun" element in CMR
and the useful element in GPL. This game is the
one I use after I've played GP3 to reassure myself
that the wheel does, in fact work. This is because
RC 2000, would happy wrench the wheel from
your hands - great stuff.


> Trying to decide a wheel for N4.  I have a FF joystick and for the most
> part when I want to play seriously I turn FF off or way down. The FF efx
> just get in the way and hinder or alter the stick movement I want to
> make.

> Is a FF wheel the same way in that FF is cool and fun but when you want
> to cut serious lap times or try to win, the FF efx just gets in the way?

Jan Verschuere

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Jan Verschuere » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 22:58:02

Need to lose the He-Man settings there Steven... GP3 will talk to you more
(also: patch takes care of the lag) and you'll be even more consistent in
GPL (because it takes less effort to stop the car overreacting to an upset).
Wheel should only be wrung from your hands if something major happens (like
catching a wheel on something in GPL).

Jan.
=---

Jan Verschuere

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Jan Verschuere » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 23:06:44

For N4 I'd say definately... there is such a lot you can "feel" about the
car, which subsequently you don't have to look for with your eyes and ears,
allowing you to be much more situational aware in traffic and ultimately, in
longer races, it's also much less tirering. Make sure you read the FF-FAQ at
Alison's site: http://alison.simracing.com/gpl/

If you just want to hotlap then by all means, use a non-FF wheel (car can't
fight back). Might want to lose the centering bungee/spring in there too.
Two of the fastest people I know don't use any form of centering whatsoever.
Using F10 view can also be benificial.<vwg>

Jan.
=---

steven crook-dawkin

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by steven crook-dawkin » Fri, 19 Jan 2001 23:19:23

Sorry - can you be more specific for GP3? The trouble
is I cannot gain any benefit from FF in GP3.

My post about "wrenched from your hands" was a bit
of a joke. But I do maintain that I need to be able
to detect the FF to allow it to improve my driving.

I did mention that the settings (at a subtle level)
help in GPL, it is the lack of any feedback in
GP3 that's the trouble. I don't see how "loosing
He-man settings" will address this. Are you perhaps
saying that when set to 100% the FF in GP3
somehow decreases?


Jan Verschuere

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Jan Verschuere » Sat, 20 Jan 2001 00:06:41

No, I'm just saying it downs out subtle clues.

Have to admit the car is still not as "alive" and predictable as in GPL, but
it helps.

Jan.
=---

Graeme Nas

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Graeme Nas » Sat, 20 Jan 2001 21:06:48

It depends on the wheel IMHO. I have used three wheels with GPL, a TMF1,
an MSFF, and now a TM Modena Pro 360. Out of the three I was slowest
with the MSFF because it's a big 'orrible thing.

The TM wheels have no FF but for me they are much more precise and
easier to drive with.

--
Cheers!
Graeme Nash

Stephen Smit

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Stephen Smit » Mon, 22 Jan 2001 09:47:11

Graeme,

In my experience, a FF wheel will *ultimately* make you faster in GPL
because the sim models caster return.  IOW, when yer doin' it wrong, FF
tells you!  Like Pavlov's pooch, you soon learn to do WHATEVER IT TAKES to
avoid the *** "U f*cked up" msg. thru the wheel rim, sooooo...after a
while...you start driving so smooooth you don't get the tactile klaxon,
and--mirabile dictu--yer lap times come down.  However...this takes some
getting used to.  I'd say abt. a month...and that's with a *good* wheel (the
original Logi WMFF, the TM/Guillemont Ferrari, etc.).

--Steve Smith


Graeme Nas

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Graeme Nas » Mon, 22 Jan 2001 11:46:50

I'd rather not know what I'm doing wrong. Ignorance is GPLRank bliss :-)

LOL, I recently took my UK A-Level psychology exam and pretty much the
only thing I got decent marks on was Pavlovian theory :-) (And Social
Identity Theory!) :-)

--
Cheers!
Graeme Nash

Stephen Smit

Do FF wheels make your lap times lower?

by Stephen Smit » Mon, 22 Jan 2001 22:11:46

Graeme,

<<I'd rather not know what I'm doing wrong. Ignorance is GPLRank bliss.>>

Then might I suggest you drive with the keyboard....

--Steve


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.