rec.autos.simulators

GPL + Force Feedback

Russell Spearin

GPL + Force Feedback

by Russell Spearin » Thu, 30 Jan 2003 09:13:10

Hi all,

Can anyone help me. I have a logitech MOMO Force wheel and am having a
problem with GPL.
I am happy with the force feedback when going round corners, but going down
the straights it is very hard to keep the car in a straight line. It tends
to veave from side to side and I am struggling to counteract it. I have
tried setting a dead zone for the steering which has not made that much
difference (I have tried setting the dead zone up to 8%).

Does anyone have any ideas how to correct this.

Many thanks

Russell

Leo Landma

GPL + Force Feedback

by Leo Landma » Thu, 30 Jan 2003 09:37:59



No wonder you're weaving on the straights. Try 0% instead. Make sure you
have the latest drivers from Logitech Wingmanteam.

Bye,
Leo

Russell Spearin

GPL + Force Feedback

by Russell Spearin » Thu, 30 Jan 2003 09:48:04

Hi Leo,

I started out with the dead zone at 0% and the weaving was terrible. It was
then that I tried increasing it.

Thanks for the reply though

Russell




> > (I have tried setting the dead zone up to 8%).

> No wonder you're weaving on the straights. Try 0% instead. Make sure you
> have the latest drivers from Logitech Wingmanteam.

> Bye,
> Leo

Malc

GPL + Force Feedback

by Malc » Thu, 30 Jan 2003 18:10:42

Reduce the latency (in the core.ini) to zero to cure your weaving & slowly
increase it until the ff matches what the car is doing. It takes time,
because you have to keep coming back to the desktop, but once it's done it's
done.

Malc.


> Hi Leo,

> I started out with the dead zone at 0% and the weaving was terrible. It
was
> then that I tried increasing it.

> Thanks for the reply though

> Russell





> > > (I have tried setting the dead zone up to 8%).

> > No wonder you're weaving on the straights. Try 0% instead. Make sure you
> > have the latest drivers from Logitech Wingmanteam.

> > Bye,
> > Leo

Marc Collin

GPL + Force Feedback

by Marc Collin » Thu, 30 Jan 2003 23:33:38

I already told him that a week or more ago, so I doubt it's that.

Marc


> Reduce the latency (in the core.ini) to zero to cure your weaving & slowly
> increase it until the ff matches what the car is doing. It takes time,
> because you have to keep coming back to the desktop, but once it's done
it's
> done.

> Malc.



> > Hi Leo,

> > I started out with the dead zone at 0% and the weaving was terrible. It
> was
> > then that I tried increasing it.

> > Thanks for the reply though

> > Russell




bericht

> > > > (I have tried setting the dead zone up to 8%).

> > > No wonder you're weaving on the straights. Try 0% instead. Make sure
you
> > > have the latest drivers from Logitech Wingmanteam.

> > > Bye,
> > > Leo

Russell Spearin

GPL + Force Feedback

by Russell Spearin » Fri, 31 Jan 2003 02:19:07

Hi all,

I have already done that, but I will drop it to zero and start again. I
don't think a appreciated the relationship between the latency setting and
weaving on the straights. I followed the advice of setting the latency by
driving over a curb and getting the suspension movement to coincide with the
"thump" from the wheel.

Many Many thanks for you're help (and patience)

Russell


> I already told him that a week or more ago, so I doubt it's that.

> Marc



> > Reduce the latency (in the core.ini) to zero to cure your weaving &
slowly
> > increase it until the ff matches what the car is doing. It takes time,
> > because you have to keep coming back to the desktop, but once it's done
> it's
> > done.

> > Malc.



> > > Hi Leo,

> > > I started out with the dead zone at 0% and the weaving was terrible.
It
> > was
> > > then that I tried increasing it.

> > > Thanks for the reply though

> > > Russell




> bericht

> > > > > (I have tried setting the dead zone up to 8%).

> > > > No wonder you're weaving on the straights. Try 0% instead. Make sure
> you
> > > > have the latest drivers from Logitech Wingmanteam.

> > > > Bye,
> > > > Leo

Malc

GPL + Force Feedback

by Malc » Fri, 31 Jan 2003 02:48:19


The reason why you're weaving down the straight is that gpl is predicting
the force to apply to your wheel, but it's out of synch with your reactions.
You see the car go to the left & steer to the right slightly. gpl reacts
slowly (high latency) and sends the controller a 'car going left' force
while you turn right, and this forces the wheel even further to the right.
You correct & the same thing happens in reverse, getting worse & worse until
you either back off the throttle or keep the wheel straight. It sounds like
you've gone too far with the latency, you probably just need to lower it a
little.

If you can't get it to stop doing it (I couldn't in NR2002) you can increase
the damping and force levels in the core.ini and decrease the overall force
in your controller applet. The feeling will still be there, but it will be
heavily damped, so it never gets the chance to get worse.

Does it do the same thing with the latency at zero?

Malc.

Steve Garrot

GPL + Force Feedback

by Steve Garrot » Fri, 31 Jan 2003 05:39:34

You may wish to add more toe in to the front wheels in your setups (or
is it less) and see if this removes the Force Feedback Induced
Ocelation.

SLG

On Wed, 29 Jan 2003 00:13:10 +0000 (UTC), "Russell Spearing"


>Hi all,

>Can anyone help me. I have a logitech MOMO Force wheel and am having a
>problem with GPL.
>I am happy with the force feedback when going round corners, but going down
>the straights it is very hard to keep the car in a straight line. It tends
>to veave from side to side and I am struggling to counteract it. I have
>tried setting a dead zone for the steering which has not made that much
>difference (I have tried setting the dead zone up to 8%).

>Does anyone have any ideas how to correct this.

>Many thanks

>Russell

Russell Spearin

GPL + Force Feedback

by Russell Spearin » Fri, 31 Jan 2003 07:44:37

Hi Malc,

I have gone through the process again but this time gradually increased the
latence value in smaller steps (0.0025). Last time I was going in increments
of 0.01 and I think the best value fell between two settings and so I never
found the sweet spot. I have now found that 0.0225 is about the best
setting. Going either side of this value and the weaving starts getting
worse again. With the latency set at 0.0225 the weaving is much much better
and the car is now more controllable. I shall now just play with the
damping, force level and controller applet to see if it can be improved any
more.

Hopefully I can go back to online racing on WinVroc. Its one thing weaving
down the straights and taking out a few AI cars but I don't think I would
have been very popular doing the same thing online.

Really appreciate your help

Russell




> > Hi all,

> > I have already done that, but I will drop it to zero and start again. I
> > don't think a appreciated the relationship between the latency setting
and
> > weaving on the straights. I followed the advice of setting the latency
by
> > driving over a curb and getting the suspension movement to coincide with
> the
> > "thump" from the wheel.

> The reason why you're weaving down the straight is that gpl is predicting
> the force to apply to your wheel, but it's out of synch with your
reactions.
> You see the car go to the left & steer to the right slightly. gpl reacts
> slowly (high latency) and sends the controller a 'car going left' force
> while you turn right, and this forces the wheel even further to the right.
> You correct & the same thing happens in reverse, getting worse & worse
until
> you either back off the throttle or keep the wheel straight. It sounds
like
> you've gone too far with the latency, you probably just need to lower it a
> little.

> If you can't get it to stop doing it (I couldn't in NR2002) you can
increase
> the damping and force levels in the core.ini and decrease the overall
force
> in your controller applet. The feeling will still be there, but it will be
> heavily damped, so it never gets the chance to get worse.

> Does it do the same thing with the latency at zero?

> Malc.

Malc

GPL + Force Feedback

by Malc » Fri, 31 Jan 2003 08:27:36


Glad you managed to make some progress. It took me about a week (2 years
ago) to get mine really sorted, and I haven't had to change it since.

As you've found, the latency is very much down you your personal combination
of controller and PC/OS, but the other two settings (and your controller's
own settings) are much more subjective.

The two main paths people seem to follow are very light forces & low
damping, or very high force strength with heavy damping.

Partly because my controller gets the occasional spike, I prefer to have
very light forces & damping (otherwise the spikes would throw me off the
track).
My damping is set to 10.0 in the core.ini, and steering torque is 500,
although anything over about 300 is probably enough for light effects with a
wheel. If you tend to hold the wheel lightly & let it guide you through the
corners, try this approach.

For a stiffer feel to your wheel, you could set the damping to around 60-65,
with steering torque at around 100-150. If you tend to get white knuckles &
lean your whole body into corners, this might work better for you so you've
got something to fight with. Read the readme11.txt in your gpl folder for
more info.

Personally I leave my wingman settings at 100% but that's because I don't
really use ff in anything but gpl.
If you race another sim or game that doesn't have built in ff adjustment (eg
Viper Racing), set up your controller software to work with that, then
adjust your gpl settings afterwards to compensate.
Don't forget to make sure you have disabled the centering spring, and use
split-axis pedals if you have the option.

Malc.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.