rec.autos.simulators

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

Debu

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Debu » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 08:35:46


Then why are you asking if you have to press a button to draft?!

l..

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by l.. » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 08:50:33

Thanks Shock for your reply. By chance do you have the PC Version of
Thunder? If you do does it have this Alliance and Grudge stuff or is
this just something exclusive to the console versions?

-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----==  Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----

Shoc

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Shoc » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 09:10:57




> > I actually bought Thunder 2004 because of all the hype and I was deeply
> > disappointed.

> Then why are you asking if you have to press a button to draft?!

I never asked that question.  If you look lower you will see where I told
the initial poster that I did not know the answer.

Shock

Shoc

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Shoc » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 09:15:27




> > I think for most people it is a shock that somebody even slightly
defends
> > Thunder as being a sim, so don't take people too seriously when they
joke
> > around about it.  I personally think EA has the potential (and $$$) to
> make
> > a great sim (F1C is great), but I don't think they will do it because
more
> > $$$ are related to arcade style games rather than sims.  What I would
like
> > to see happen is EA hiring Papyrus to make a sim or to even release
future
> > versions of Nascar Racing Season.  At the same time EA could continue to
> > release Thunder for all the little kiddies to play.  My nephews love it,
> but
> > they are 10 and 7.  Opinions are opinions and more power to ya if you
like
> > Thunder!  Play it until the end of time, but unless it improves it is my
> > humble opinion that most dedicated sim racers probably won't join ya.

> > Have a nice day!

> > Shock

> You're a no nothing dumbass. The PS2 and PC versions of Nascar Thunder
2004
> are not even developed by the same people. Look up Tiburion and then ISI.
> No! There is no button to press in order to draft in the PC version. The
PC
> version of Thunder *2004* is almost as much a sim of Nascar racing as the
> Papyrus version.

Ok, I can't believe I am going to respond, but I will anyway.  I won't call
you names because that is incredibly lame, but I will tell you my thinking.
I didn't not realize they were developed by different companies, however,
aren't they released under the EA Sports name?  Therefore, wouldn't EA
Sports have the say on what goes into the final build?  (Correct me if I am
wrong).  I wasn't sure if there was a drafting button or not and I never
stated one way or the other.  Also, the fact that you think Thunder 2004 is
almost as much a sim of Nascar racing as the Papyrus version is your opinion
and I respect that.  Please lay off the name, that is lame and childish.

Thanks,

Shock

Shoc

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Shoc » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 09:16:48

I have it, but I am not fond of it, so it isn't installed.  If you would
like me to I can re-install it in the next few days and answer your
questions for ya.

Shock


> Thanks Shock for your reply. By chance do you have the PC Version of
> Thunder? If you do does it have this Alliance and Grudge stuff or is
> this just something exclusive to the console versions?

> -----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
> http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
> -----==  Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----

Mitch_

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Mitch_ » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 09:34:14

One thing you may have forgotten though JP.  When N4 came out the top of the
line box was a 1 gig P3 so your comparison isnt quite fair in all respects
:-)

Mitch





> > >   If you could run N4, as you imply, you can run 03 just fine.

> > Really?  My frame rates dropped in half from N4 to N2003, until I
upgraded
> > my PC.  N2003 asks a lot more of a system than N4 does.

> > My exerience.  Your mileage may vary, as, I'm sure, does Lacy's

> > cheers
> > John

>   <shrug>  No change at all here, maybe even slightly better with 03.  On
a
> lowly P4 1.4

JP

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by JP » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 09:48:14

  Hmm...don't know about that....I built my P4 before N4 came out........or
was it slightly after ?  I plead the fifth <g>


> One thing you may have forgotten though JP.  When N4 came out the top of
the
> line box was a 1 gig P3 so your comparison isnt quite fair in all respects
> :-)

> Mitch






> > > >   If you could run N4, as you imply, you can run 03 just fine.

> > > Really?  My frame rates dropped in half from N4 to N2003, until I
> upgraded
> > > my PC.  N2003 asks a lot more of a system than N4 does.

> > > My exerience.  Your mileage may vary, as, I'm sure, does Lacy's

> > > cheers
> > > John

> >   <shrug>  No change at all here, maybe even slightly better with 03.
On
> a
> > lowly P4 1.4

elrik

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by elrik » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 10:20:08


> Thanks Shock for your reply. By chance do you have the PC Version of
> Thunder? If you do does it have this Alliance and Grudge stuff or is
> this just something exclusive to the console versions?

Exclusive to console version.

Elrikk

Byron John Forbe

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Byron John Forbe » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 23:20:05


> No, it doesn't affect the draft itself. You can still do this without
> pressing R2. Draft sharing is for the Grudges and Alliance sytem that
> EA has in Thunder 2004. I have raced without it before and done quite
> well. The only thing I had a question about is whether you can "share
> a draft" with the car behind you as the manual seems to indicate but
> does not specifically say how to accomplish within the Grudges and
> Alliance Sytem.

    WTF? That's even too arcady for an arcade game - it's fantasy! No
machine guns on the roof? What about the "T" key - tacks?

    LOL.

Byron John Forbe

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Byron John Forbe » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 23:24:16


> When I started this thread it was just a simple question about Thunder
> 04 for PS2. I never intended to start a "which sim is better" debate.
> I have raced Papy since the first one came out untill the last
> versions came out. The game outgrew my system after N4. I have since
> that time been using the PS2 Versions from EA and  Infogrames.

> I have found things I like about all of them and thing I don't like.
> It is really up the the individual which one he likes at any
> particular moment in time.

> Anyway, my original question still has not been answered. Any
> intelligent person would have answered the question (even if it was to
> say that they don't know) and been done with it. Instead we have some
> people who would rather argue about something that has nothing to do
> with the original point of the topic.

    To be further pedantic, a game of this nature has no place in a forum
called rec.autos.***simulators***

    Sorry, couldn't resist.

Byron John Forbe

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Byron John Forbe » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 23:26:28





    This is an abuse of the word "exclusive". How about - "only the PS2
version has this bug"?

Bill Bollinge

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Bill Bollinge » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 23:58:29

The game is very cool on the XBOX.  Unless you have tried it, don't knock
it.

Bill Bollinger
www.gsxn.com






Bill Bollinge

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Bill Bollinge » Mon, 23 Feb 2004 23:59:27

Thunder for PS2 and XBOX in many ways in more of a simulator of the Nascar
Experience than any current PC game.

Bill Bollinger
www.gsxn.com






JP

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by JP » Tue, 24 Feb 2004 00:36:00

  Yep.  But the Blinders Brigade would never know <g>


> Thunder for PS2 and XBOX in many ways in more of a simulator of the Nascar
> Experience than any current PC game.

> Bill Bollinger
> www.gsxn.com





> > > When I started this thread it was just a simple question about Thunder
> > > 04 for PS2. I never intended to start a "which sim is better" debate.
> > > I have raced Papy since the first one came out untill the last
> > > versions came out. The game outgrew my system after N4. I have since
> > > that time been using the PS2 Versions from EA and  Infogrames.

> > > I have found things I like about all of them and thing I don't like.
> > > It is really up the the individual which one he likes at any
> > > particular moment in time.

> > > Anyway, my original question still has not been answered. Any
> > > intelligent person would have answered the question (even if it was to
> > > say that they don't know) and been done with it. Instead we have some
> > > people who would rather argue about something that has nothing to do
> > > with the original point of the topic.

> >     To be further pedantic, a game of this nature has no place in a
forum
> > called rec.autos.***simulators***

> >     Sorry, couldn't resist.

Peter Ive

Nascar Thunder 2004 (Ps2) Drafting Question

by Peter Ive » Tue, 24 Feb 2004 03:53:26


writes



>> I think for most people it is a shock that somebody even slightly defends
>> Thunder as being a sim, so don't take people too seriously when they joke
>> around about it.  I personally think EA has the potential (and $$$) to
>make
>> a great sim (F1C is great), but I don't think they will do it because more
>> $$$ are related to arcade style games rather than sims.  What I would like
>> to see happen is EA hiring Papyrus to make a sim or to even release
>future
>> versions of Nascar Racing Season.  At the same time EA could continue
>to
>> release Thunder for all the little kiddies to play.  My nephews love it,
>but
>> they are 10 and 7.  Opinions are opinions and more power to ya if you like
>> Thunder!  Play it until the end of time, but unless it improves it is my
>> humble opinion that most dedicated sim racers probably won't join ya.

>> Have a nice day!

>> Shock

>You're a no nothing dumbass. The PS2 and PC versions of Nascar Thunder
>2004
>are not even developed by the same people. Look up Tiburion and then ISI.
>No! There is no button to press in order to draft in the PC version. The PC
>version of Thunder *2004* is almost as much a sim of Nascar racing as the
>Papyrus version.

Cheers for putting the record straight there.  All I was asking.  :)
As for which is the better, I have not played Thunder 2004 so have no
opinion at this time.
--
Peter Ives (AKA Pete Ivington)
Remove ALL_STRESS before replying via email
If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me :)
GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel -25.01

rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.