rec.autos.simulators

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

Michael Powel

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Michael Powel » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00

Aiming to get my lap times down in GPL, I went down to the store and bought
one of Thrustmaster's F1 wheels (I think its called Nascar Pro in the US).

I couldn't get on with it! I went back to my trusty old CH tiny joystick.
This one looks like a radio control stick, and you operate it with your
finger and thumb - left/right and throttle/brake.

I found the main disadvantage with the wheel is I simply couldn't apply the
opposite lock as fast as with the stick. Also the pedals didn't have the
feel that I thought they would have, especially for braking.

Does anyone else think the same, or is everybody a wheel fan?

- Michael

David Mast

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by David Mast » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00


I think it depends on what you are used to and how much you are willing to
"retrain" yourself.  I'm so used to my CH sticks and Pro Pedals that wheels
just seem wrong.  After quite a few laps, I managed to get about as quick in
some sims with the TM GP1, but I went back to my trusty ol stick.  I never
liked the GP1's poor centering.

SteveBla

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by SteveBla » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00

Try a GP1 wheel without modifying the as-shipped lock.  At 180 degrees
lock-to-lock, it's much quicker than a wheel with a 270 degree rotation.  I
modified mine for more, but that's just preference.  I do run the linearity
slider almost full left, though.  What do you use with the joystick, and did
you change that for the wheel?
You're right about the Nascar Pro pedals.  I use CH pedals, which you can use
with your joystick as well.  MUCH better than the TM ones.  Apparently, some of
the development people at Papyrus use a stick/pedal setup also.

Steve B.

Jason Mond

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Jason Mond » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00

Hi Michael,

I like my racing to be as realistic as possible.  The wheel/pedal combo
can't be beat (for realism).  I like the wheels -- won't go back to
joysticks for a racing sim, no matter how much quicker it is.


> Aiming to get my lap times down in GPL, I went down to the store and bought
> one of Thrustmaster's F1 wheels (I think its called Nascar Pro in the US).

> I couldn't get on with it!

How much time did you take to learn it?  When I bought my first wheel itwas for
N2.  I had to alter my steering lock and such .. and did get better
times -- especially on the long turns.  You just have better control.

All the stuff I learn about correcting slides and stuff can be applied
to my daily driving (with a wheel).  Do you find your self shifting from
Neutral to 5th to correct a slide (in winter of course -- I don't drive
like a manic -- thats saved the for sims ;)

True, but not worth scrapping the wheel.

Hmm..  Force-Feed Back brakes might help.  Still its justanother controlling
device to get used to.  Once you have the
hang of it, there is nothing like it.

Jason.
--------
Jason Monds
(a.k.a. Clapper on GPL!)
(Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)

Ronald Stoe

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Ronald Stoe » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00


> Aiming to get my lap times down in GPL, I went down to the store and bought
> one of Thrustmaster's F1 wheels (I think its called Nascar Pro in the US).

> I couldn't get on with it! I went back to my trusty old CH tiny joystick.
> This one looks like a radio control stick, and you operate it with your
> finger and thumb - left/right and throttle/brake.

> I found the main disadvantage with the wheel is I simply couldn't apply the
> opposite lock as fast as with the stick. Also the pedals didn't have the
> feel that I thought they would have, especially for braking.

> Does anyone else think the same, or is everybody a wheel fan?

I wouldn't use a joystick for racing sims, even if I could cut lap times
in half! I really prefer to simulate driving a car and using a joystick
would ruin the experience for me...

l8er
ronny

--
How to get rid of censorship in German game releases
<http://www.gamesmania.com/german/maniac/freedom/freedom.htm>

          |\      _,,,---,,_        I want to die like my Grandfather,
   ZZZzz /,`.-'`'    -.  ;-;;,_              in his sleep.
        |,4-  ) )-,_. ,\ (  `'-'     Not like the people in his car,
       '---''(_/--'  `-'\_)            screaming their heads off!

Rick Baumhaue

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Rick Baumhaue » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00

I still miss my old CH joystick - just like the one mentioned - but Win95
refuses to recognize it any more.  The stick may have gone bad.  If not for
that, I probably wouldn't have bought my Formula T1 - I can't drive with my
CH Flightstick Pro, it's far too large for fine control.

Of course, the reason I like the small joystick was that the first decent
racing sim I played was GP1 (World Circuit, actually) on the Amiga, with a
small DIGITAL joystick.  How they achieved the illusion of feel with a
digital stick is beyond me, but I had blast with that game.

Rick

David G Fishe

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by David G Fishe » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00


Supposedly some people at Papyrus use joysticks for GPL. It's been
questioned if this affected the way they set up the steering settings in
GPL. Who knows for sure? I don't.  :-)

David G Fisher
DmndDave

Michael Youn

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Michael Youn » Sat, 17 Oct 1998 04:00:00

Gotta say it works for me. I'm loathe to go back to a wheel now,
although I'd been thinking about an ACTLabs FF for some time.

Michael.


> >I couldn't get on with it! I went back to my trusty old CH tiny joystick.

> Supposedly some people at Papyrus use joysticks for GPL. It's been
> questioned if this affected the way they set up the steering settings in
> GPL. Who knows for sure? I don't.  :-)

> David G Fisher
> DmndDave

Michael Powel

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Michael Powel » Sun, 18 Oct 1998 04:00:00

control.

I know what you mean - the advantage of the little one is that your thumb
and finger have much finer control than your whole hand.

- Michael

Michael Powel

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Michael Powel » Sun, 18 Oct 1998 04:00:00

I use the middle position for the stick, and I modified it to about 1/4
along from the left for the wheel

setup also.

Now that's something I haven't tried!

- Michael

Tapani Kaijanmak

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Tapani Kaijanmak » Sun, 18 Oct 1998 04:00:00

Hi,
I always find joystick best. Dont have pedals but I use keyboard for gas &
brakes
bye
Tapani

Mike Laske

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Mike Laske » Sun, 18 Oct 1998 04:00:00


>The key is to *not* need to throw the steering from side to side!

Why's that then? <g>

Mike.

David G Fishe

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by David G Fishe » Sun, 18 Oct 1998 04:00:00

That Spa lap you sent me was definitely the best I've seen yet. Awesome.
But, like I think I mentioned in my letter to you (maybe not), I'm still not
sure about most of the other GPL tracks (shorter, tighter turns) and the
ability to be smooth and also very fast. I'm going to set up a joystick and
do some experimenting. It would be strange if people were actually faster
with joysticks. After all this time, there's no way I could ever feel
comfortable using a stick instead of my wheel.

David G Fisher
DmndDave



>It's indeed possible, but as you've seen GPL can be driven very >smoothly -
>and fast - with a wheel. The key is to *not* need to throw the steering
>from side to side!

>Cheers,
>Richard

>--
>We all bump into each other every day of our lives, and we render our
opinions
>whether we know anything or not, and if anybody catches us out we lie...

Lutrel

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by Lutrel » Sun, 18 Oct 1998 04:00:00



>There might be a slight tradeoff of immersiveness but I feel much more in
>control of the car.  With the joystick, I can slide into a turn much better
>because I can catch the tail if it kicks out much easier.  And I can dive
into
>a turn with more confidence.

Did you try calibrating the wheel with less steering input? That is only
turn it half or less of its travel side to side when calibrating it.
The steering will be a lot quicker.

Lutrell,
Dsr#74 :-)
http://www2.scca.com/amateur/club_racing/runoffs/photogal/dsr-74.jpg

JG_

Shock: Joystick better than Wheel for GPL!

by JG_ » Mon, 19 Oct 1998 04:00:00





>>Supposedly some people at Papyrus use joysticks for GPL. It's been
>>questioned if this affected the way they set up the steering settings in
>>GPL. Who knows for sure? I don't.  :-)

>It's indeed possible, but as you've seen GPL can be driven very smoothly -
>and fast - with a wheel. The key is to *not* need to throw the steering
>from side to side!

I agree Richard, the key it seems is to be able to drive smoothly
which is pretty hard with the CH Mach series, but with the advantage
of being able to snap on some opposite lock when you really need it.

I am in the same position it seems as Michael in the original message.
I used my CH Mach3 for the demo, getting a 1:06:90 and 1:31:4x. Since
getting the full thing I felt I could go a little faster at both these
places with the default setups... I'm not exactly sure what happened
some days ago but the controls went all wierd on me.. Braking was just
about impossible. Only took me a few hours this morning running
different calibs to figure out it had all been reset, and the settings
I had got used to..

Therefore it *really* helps to have the thing calibrated properly..
;-)

Now I have a very strange problem that I don't trust the car. :)

Thanks,



-:http://www.simproject.com/ccg/


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.