rec.autos.simulators

Wheel better than a joystick?

Robert Pollar

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Robert Pollar » Mon, 08 Jul 2002 23:40:40

Hi Folks,
        I've just started using the wheel for F1 2002, but unfortunately
with me, I'm actually lapping 1:28's instead of my usual 1:24's on
Silverstone (all help off, non-grip standard EA setup) when using a
joystick.
        The only advantage I could find with the wheel, is that stopping
spins and recovering from them is easier than with a  joystick. Is this
a case of not being used to it? Or are joysticks (Although not
realistic) the way to go for high lap times?
        So I guess my question is, should I persevere with the wheel? Or
drop it altogether?
--
Robert Pollard
Dave Henri

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Dave Henri » Mon, 08 Jul 2002 23:58:54


  When I first got a wheel, I lost time too.  It was very humbling.  Keep in
mind the in-game settings are usually different for a wheel vs a joystick.
You may want to poke around the controller setup screens.  Haqsau & Fat n
Slo have come up with some good settings for F1 2001,  I don't know how
they translate to 2002 yet tho.  Try putting all the sensitivity sliders to
50%.  Reduce your speed sensitivity to zero and then in EACH individual
setup, reduce the steering lock from th 19 to 24 degree range to 10 to 12
degrees.  (Monaco might need a little more for the hairpins)
  Good luck.
oh and some of the fastest guys in world use joysticks in gpl, but some
others use wheels...it's just a matter of what works for you.
dave henrie

jason moy

Wheel better than a joystick?

by jason moy » Tue, 09 Jul 2002 02:22:27

On Sun, 7 Jul 2002 15:40:40 +0100, Robert Pollard


>        So I guess my question is, should I persevere with the wheel? Or
>drop it altogether?

I'd rather be slow with a wheel than fast with a joystick. =)

That said, I played GPL for nearly a year with the keyboard.  I lost
several seconds at each track when I first got a wheel.  Just keep
practicing and you'll be fine.

Jason

Eden

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Eden » Tue, 09 Jul 2002 04:11:01

I'll start using a Joystick in a racing game when they'll be the Standard
controlling device for 90 % of the car manufacturers and/or Racing Teams.

Being fast is fun but having the impression of controlling a "real" car, is
even better.

Which is why I prefer a "sim" over an "arcade" game.

Denis

L.A. Mi

Wheel better than a joystick?

by L.A. Mi » Tue, 09 Jul 2002 04:54:16

IMHO, it depends on your reason for simming:

* Is cutting the absolute, fastest lap possible, your top and only
priority? If so, then run what yields that result. (After giving the
wheel a fair amount of time, and doing some "tweaks" as suggested.)

* Is immersing yourself into a racing simulation and overcoming
challenges similiar to what an actual race car driver faces your top
priority? Then a wheel is the only answer.

I switched to a wheel in '96 and NO WAY would I EVER think of going
back. (I fall into the latter category above.) Yes, there was a new
learning curve, but it added so much to the "immersal factor" when
simming that I was hooked on a wheel immediately. In fact, if I could
not have a wheel/pedals... then I couldn't care less about any auto
racing simulation. For me, I choose to use a wheel even if I'm seconds
per lap slower. Why? For the "immersal factor".

So in recap, what's your priority in simming? To play a racing game
and have fun trying to be the fastest? Or, to attempt to simulate as
closely as practical the wonderful world of auto racing?

Neither approach is "wrong", neither is "better"... just different.

Your call.

Andre Ming

Obak

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Obak » Tue, 09 Jul 2002 09:42:22


>I'll start using a Joystick in a racing game when they'll be the Standard
>controlling device for 90 % of the car manufacturers and/or Racing Teams.

you know thats a great idea.  they've started using computer like joysticks in
airliners (airbus) instead of those old huge 'wheels' they should look into
using a joystick style controller for cars

hmm, maybe i should approach a F1 team about this :)  hope theres nothing in
the FIA rulings that says drive-by-wire is illegal?

B Bonne

Wheel better than a joystick?

by B Bonne » Tue, 09 Jul 2002 10:30:54



As long as you put the joystick back after leaving the car... :)

There have been experiments done at some car manufacturers. For example,
SAAB had an fully working, joystick-driven concept car in the eighties. I
don't think it got very far beyond the factory walls though.

mach

Wheel better than a joystick?

by mach » Tue, 09 Jul 2002 15:31:16




>> you know thats a great idea.  they've started using computer like
>> joysticks in airliners (airbus) instead of those old huge 'wheels'
>> they should look into using a joystick style controller for cars

>> hmm, maybe i should approach a F1 team about this :)  hope theres
>> nothing in the FIA rulings that says drive-by-wire is illegal?

>As long as you put the joystick back after leaving the car... :)

>There have been experiments done at some car manufacturers. For example,
>SAAB had an fully working, joystick-driven concept car in the eighties. I
>don't think it got very far beyond the factory walls though.

Remember what early cars used before they started to use a steering wheel?
What about Cadillac's [I believe it was them but I may be wrong] "wrist-twist"
steering device?

--
__________   ____---____       Marco Antonio  Checa  Funcke
\_________D /-/---_----'      Santiago de Surco, Lima, Peru
       _H__/_/                      http://machf.tripod.com
      '-_____|(    

remove the "no_me_j." and "sons.of." parts before replying

jason moy

Wheel better than a joystick?

by jason moy » Tue, 09 Jul 2002 17:33:03


>hmm, maybe i should approach a F1 team about this :)  hope theres nothing in
>the FIA rulings that says drive-by-wire is illegal?

Dunno if it's legal, but Villeneuve has been trying to convince BAR to
try a joystick for years.

Jason

Peter Ive

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Peter Ive » Wed, 10 Jul 2002 01:16:49



<snippage>

Yeah, I was much faster with a joystick than I am now with a wheel, but
then it's not just about being fast, is it? :)

Gave up using joystick over a year ago.  Best thing I ever did.  Well...
almost.  <BG>
--
Peter Ives
Remove ALL_STRESS before replying via email
If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me
GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel -21.77

Robert Pollar

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Robert Pollar » Wed, 10 Jul 2002 04:28:49

Thanks for all the posts. I think I'll stick with the wheel as it does
add more to the immersive qualities of the sim. I guess with practice my
lap times will eventually drop again!
--
Robert Pollard
Chri

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Chri » Wed, 10 Jul 2002 10:39:34

Villeneuve has been trying to convince BAR to compete for years.  When do
they listen to him?  (except last Sunday)

I'm pretty sure that drive by wire is illegal in F1, but it doesn't have to
be electronic, early planes weren't.

Chris



> >hmm, maybe i should approach a F1 team about this :)  hope theres nothing
in
> >the FIA rulings that says drive-by-wire is illegal?

> Dunno if it's legal, but Villeneuve has been trying to convince BAR to
> try a joystick for years.

> Jason

Steve Rawlinso

Wheel better than a joystick?

by Steve Rawlinso » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 01:13:36

It wouldnt work because of the lateral Gs. Works in planes cos the
accelleration is vertical, the plane of movement in which the joystick
doesnt move.

steve


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.