rec.autos.simulators

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

Jeff Ha

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Jeff Ha » Sat, 04 Jul 1998 04:00:00

All,

What is it about gore, *** and death and ignorant marketing PR
types? The sd for GP Legends in the latest issue of Computer ***
World proclaims:
"In 1968 they changed the rules of GrandPrix racing to cut down on
driver Fatalities.

Welcome to 1967."

Are we buying or interested in GPLegends so we can die? I don't think
so. I think we all might have vicarious interests in appreciating the
danger of driving a GP car in that era but is GP Legends really about
driver fatalities?  I can't believe that Mike Lescault(sp?) is too
pleased with that ad campaign.

Jeff Haas

papa..

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by papa.. » Sat, 04 Jul 1998 04:00:00

Agreed.....it seems that Sierra is so large that taste is something
only the people making the sim have....not marketing

PAPA DOC

Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand
Pink Flamingo Pilot...

http://www.racesimcentral.net/~plegrand/PINKFLAMINGO.htm

Trip

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Trip » Sat, 04 Jul 1998 04:00:00

On the other hand, while the ad may be in poor taste, I don't think it's
aimed at racing sim fans... we're all going to buy GPL the day it's
released whether they advertise it or not.

I think the ad is aimed at the much larger general *** crowd... the
folks who buy Quake and Duke Nukem type games... if it succeeds in
attracting a good percentage of them, then it's done its job.

Trips


> Agreed.....it seems that Sierra is so large that taste is something
> only the people making the sim have....not marketing

> PAPA DOC

> >All,

> >What is it about gore, *** and death and ignorant marketing PR
> >types? The sd for GP Legends in the latest issue of Computer ***
> >World proclaims:
> >"In 1968 they changed the rules of GrandPrix racing to cut down on
> >driver Fatalities.

> >Welcome to 1967."

> >Are we buying or interested in GPLegends so we can die? I don't think
> >so. I think we all might have vicarious interests in appreciating the
> >danger of driving a GP car in that era but is GP Legends really about
> >driver fatalities?  I can't believe that Mike Lescault(sp?) is too
> >pleased with that ad campaign.

> >Jeff Haas

> Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand
> Pink Flamingo Pilot...

> http://www.racesimcentral.net/~plegrand/PINKFLAMINGO.htm

Bruce Kennewel

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Bruce Kennewel » Sun, 05 Jul 1998 04:00:00

Irrespective of your concern over "death" being advertised, I'd like to
know how on Earth the marketing people came up with such a weird line!!

The rules regarding wings were *written and included* in 1968 (*LATE*
1968) to overcome the dramas occurring with the collapsing of the tall,
strut-mounted aerofoils.  The actual formula rules, the *core* of the
formula, if you like,  between the cars raced at the start of the 3.0
litre era (1966) and thos raced in 1968, were almost identical.

So what the blazes are they talking about?!  Driver fatalities in 1967
were *NOT* due to teams introducing wings in 1968 and were *NOT* due to
the Rules being updated later that year in order to ban strut-mounted
wings!!

As I said...."weird"!!


> All,

> What is it about gore, *** and death and ignorant marketing PR
> types? The sd for GP Legends in the latest issue of Computer ***
> World proclaims:
> "In 1968 they changed the rules of GrandPrix racing to cut down on
> driver Fatalities.

> Welcome to 1967."

> Are we buying or interested in GPLegends so we can die? I don't think
> so. I think we all might have vicarious interests in appreciating the
> danger of driving a GP car in that era but is GP Legends really about
> driver fatalities?  I can't believe that Mike Lescault(sp?) is too
> pleased with that ad campaign.

> Jeff Haas

--
Regards,
Bruce.
----------
The GP Legends Historic Motor Racing Club  is located at:-
http://www.racesimcentral.net/
Karl Raup

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Karl Raup » Sun, 05 Jul 1998 04:00:00

        You're exactly right Trips.  And MOST IMPORTANTLY, justified the
expense and manpower to create this and other simmies from
Sierra/Papy/et al.  Most of us here consider ourselves the ***
gamers/simmers but as far as market share, we all combined prolly don't
amount to a hill of beans when it comes to sales volume.  It's the
masses who dabble in arcade mode and only race at 'Dega such that keep
Sierra and others in business.

        TTYL
        Karl

Karl Raup

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Karl Raup » Sun, 05 Jul 1998 04:00:00

        Poor taste be damned, I like it ;)

        TTYL
        Karl

Paul Hamilt

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Paul Hamilt » Sun, 05 Jul 1998 04:00:00


> I think we all might have vicarious interests in appreciating the
>danger of driving a GP car in that era but is GP Legends really about
>driver fatalities?

I agree with you.  I'm one of the minority of folks in their target
market who remembers when he heard that Jimmy Clark had been killed.
It's not a pleasant memory for me, and that ad would be sort of like
having something along the lines of...

"Grand Prix II -- back to those golden days of 1994 when Roland
Ratzenberger and Ayrton Senna splattered themselves at 200 mph at
Imola before the days of wimpy chicanes and high***pit sides...

I hope that for the vast, vast majority of us, death is an unwelcome
intruder in the sport we love.  I watch for the skill of the drivers
and the roar of the cars, and I want my racing sims to reflect those
same attitudes.  I make a point of avoiding Quake and games of that
sort.  I've been thinking very seriously of cancelling my subscription
to CGW because the ads have become so repulsive, but I never thought
that Sierra/Papyrus would stoop so low...


             ===|==============================================
                 Remove the NOSPAM from my address to mail me
             ==================================================
                  "You just keep going faster and faster and
                   finally...you burst into fire forever."
                                       -- Laura Palmer                                                  

Paul Jone

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Paul Jone » Sun, 05 Jul 1998 04:00:00

I too remember Jim Clark's death though I was only a kid. And I also
remember it as a sad event. But it's also true that the instrinsic dangers
of motor sport are an element of it's attraction. High speed is exciting
precisely because it's dangerous - if it weren't it wouldn't get your
heart racing. Dangerous sports are so popular now because they are
dangerous. The very many brave souls who have died or been seriously
injured at all levels of motor sport are heroes because they risk their
lives. The same is true of mountaineers, polar explorers, hang gliders,
free-style parachutists etc. I can understand why Sierra/Papyrus would use
that line to sell it. And it's different to shoot 'em ups because the risk
is perpetrated against one self and not against someone else.
PJ



> > I think we all might have vicarious interests in appreciating the
> >danger of driving a GP car in that era but is GP Legends really about
> >driver fatalities?

> I agree with you.  I'm one of the minority of folks in their target
> market who remembers when he heard that Jimmy Clark had been killed.
> It's not a pleasant memory for me, and that ad would be sort of like
> having something along the lines of...

> "Grand Prix II -- back to those golden days of 1994 when Roland
> Ratzenberger and Ayrton Senna splattered themselves at 200 mph at
> Imola before the days of wimpy chicanes and high***pit sides...

> I hope that for the vast, vast majority of us, death is an unwelcome
> intruder in the sport we love.  I watch for the skill of the drivers
> and the roar of the cars, and I want my racing sims to reflect those
> same attitudes.  I make a point of avoiding Quake and games of that
> sort.  I've been thinking very seriously of cancelling my subscription
> to CGW because the ads have become so repulsive, but I never thought
> that Sierra/Papyrus would stoop so low...


>              ===|==============================================
>                  Remove the NOSPAM from my address to mail me
>              ==================================================
>                   "You just keep going faster and faster and
>                    finally...you burst into fire forever."
>                                        -- Laura Palmer

Bruce Kennewel

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Bruce Kennewel » Mon, 06 Jul 1998 04:00:00

"Hill of beans"?
We'd be lucky to amount to a *PLATE* of beans!!


> we all combined prolly don't
> amount to a hill of beans when it comes to sales volume.  It's the
> masses who dabble in arcade mode and only race at 'Dega such that keep
> Sierra and others in business.

--
Regards,
Bruce.
----------
The GP Legends Historic Motor Racing Club  is located at:-
http://www.netspeed.com.au/brucek/legends/
Bruce Kennewel

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Bruce Kennewel » Mon, 06 Jul 1998 04:00:00

What you have written may contain a certain amount of fact but there are
also some errors.....the 3.0 litre formula came into being for season
1966; by 1967 the chassis were nothing like those of the 1.5 litre era.

However, it doesn't explain the reason why Sierras marketing gurus have
written advertising copy that makes no sense, either historically or
chronologically!!

(I posted a response to this yesterday with some incorrect info:- I said
that the rules were changed in 1968 to ban high, strut-mounted wings.
This is wrong...there were no rule changes until 1969, at the Monaco GP,
where the strut-mounted wings were made illegal.)

So that makes the advertising blurb even more incorrect!


> GPL's is a simulation based on the year they stepped up to
> larger(3.0)engines.Same unstable chassis's,same dangerous tracks but now with
> tons more power!!These cars were then put in the hands of extremely skilled........

--
Regards,
Bruce.
----------
The GP Legends Historic Motor Racing Club  is located at:-
http://www.netspeed.com.au/brucek/legends/
Trip

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Trip » Mon, 06 Jul 1998 04:00:00


> These days with all the safety Nazi's running around protecting
> knuckleheads from disaster we risk having the gene pool ruined. These
> types of "games" would take care of that....<VBG>

The gene pool is already ruined. Forty years of "Walk/Dont Walk" signs
at every intersection and "Close cover before striking" on every
matchbook have pretty well covered it.

Trips

papa..

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by papa.. » Mon, 06 Jul 1998 04:00:00

Im not denigrating any of them. Im attempting to learn a bit about
what they did....to better understand what all the books I read about
them were talking about...

If you are so enamored with Sierra that you cant see that the ad is in
poor taste I feel sorry for you. Its only a game....using the deaths
of REAL people to advertise a game is wrong....not legally...but
morally and besides that its just damn bad taste. What is it wrong to
have good taste...must everything be judged against Quake morals and
found to be ok...?

PAPA DOC

Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand
Pink Flamingo Pilot...

http://home.earthlink.net/~plegrand/PINKFLAMINGO.htm

Bruce Kennewel

Sierra GPLegends Ad in Poor Taste

by Bruce Kennewel » Tue, 07 Jul 1998 04:00:00

LOL!
I think we've all been there, Neil :o)


> I broke my arm cornering *** a tricycle in '63.  It was quite
> a thrill, but the ruling body at the time (my mom) called it a
> "racing incident"....no rules changes, and I moved up to the
> bicycle class in '65.

--
Regards,
Bruce.
----------
The GP Legends Historic Motor Racing Club  is located at:-
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.