rec.autos.simulators

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

Lindsay Adam

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Lindsay Adam » Wed, 04 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Hey John,

I'll agree to a certains extent that the preparation has a lot to do with
it - but you have to have something good to start off with.... that doesn't
mean a good road car, it just means the basis of a good race car. I've been
talking race cars all along here - so we may hav been  talking at cross
purposes througout this post !! :-)

I still think its a great road car though - and much less common  than a
Porker - and with its engine in the right place!!! Hah hah :-D

cheers

-Lindsay




>>In all the races I've watched and been to (admittedly not all the GT races
>>around!!) the Vipers have pasted the Porkers.  I was at Le Mans this year
>>when they came home 11th overall (1st in gt2) - the only non GT1 car
infront
>>of them was a Ferrari SP333, and in a recent  GT race at Donnington in the
>>UK a Viper came third overall, behind a McLaren and Porker - beating many
>>GT1 cars in the process - not sure where you got the last in class
>>thing.....

>The comparison was based on road cars, where the Viper is last in it's
>class against equivalent GT models from other manufacturers. When you
>RACE a car it's a whole different ballgame, and what appears on the
>track will bear no relation to what's on the road.

>What really lets down the road car is the barge-like handling and auto
>'box, and I'm sure you'll agree those will be first kicked out of any
>race car. The racecars come down to who best prepares them, not how
>good the road car is.

>Cheers!
>John

Cossi

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Cossi » Thu, 05 Nov 1998 04:00:00



What did the Toyota Tacoma have in common with a race car? look what Rod
Millen did to it. Same thing with the Swift

Lindsay Adam

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Lindsay Adam » Thu, 05 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Yeah, but those were pure "silhouette" racers, that have very liveral rules
as to what "prduction based" means. Much of the Viper (and many other good
production based racers - including Prokers!! :-)) is very production based
and the regs are no where near as liberal as those for "silhouette" cars..

-Lindsay

Cossi

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Cossi » Thu, 05 Nov 1998 04:00:00



dude look at the taurus in NASCAR, do they look anything like the ones on
the road. no i don't think so...

Stephen Ferguso

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Stephen Ferguso » Thu, 05 Nov 1998 04:00:00

Auto box?  Don't know which Viper they were testing with an automatic, but
even if it is available (I'm not the kind of guy to memorize option sheets)
I doubt many leave the factory with an auto box.  Not that I like the Viper
much, since it is basically a beautiful concept car with a truck engine and
sub-standard chassis.

Stephen

Tim Schu

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Tim Schu » Sat, 07 Nov 1998 04:00:00



> >They can get like 1 hp per cubic inch hehe that's sad..... Try having at least
> >100 hp per liter before you call them a good car company

> AFAIK only two production engines ever managed this - both of them
> made by a certain Bavarian outfit...

> Cheers!
> John

Geez, you guys completely ignored Lotus!  Even the little Elise they put
into production get 190 bhp from a 1.8L NA engine.  I would have to
check to be absolutely sure but I believe the Esprit Turbo put out 142
bhp/L from a 2.0L engine.  That engine held the bhp/L record until
recent years excepting of course the 1.3L, 255bhp Mazda rotary.  Some
have been tuned to well over 600bhp (still 1.3L).

--
Tim Schuh
***el.net

Lindsay Adam

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Lindsay Adam » Sun, 08 Nov 1998 04:00:00

..and your point is?  Nascar cars (and NHRA funny cars for that matter) ,
became far from production cars a very long time ago (when they started
busting the wheel centres out of the standard production wheels due to
cornereing forces they were starting to generate in the fifties, if I
remember correctly)

The piont I was making was that the Tacoma was made to very liberal (not
liveral - my typing never has been good -much better with a spanner than a
keyboard!! :-)) interpretation of what "production based" means - so are
Nascar cars. In GT2, where the Viper dominates, there is very much more of
the original production car left in the race car.

cheers

-Lindsay

Cossi

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Cossi » Sun, 08 Nov 1998 04:00:00



 wrong..the chassis are pretty much different. The thing that remains the
smae is the body. 80% of the chassis is different than the one on the street

Peter Nilss

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Peter Nilss » Mon, 09 Nov 1998 04:00:00




> > >They can get like 1 hp per cubic inch hehe that's sad..... Try having at
>  least
> > >100 hp per liter before you call them a good car company

> > AFAIK only two production engines ever managed this - both of them
> > made by a certain Bavarian outfit...

> > Cheers!
> > John

> And a couple of Honda VTEC/VTI engines, the 1.6 and 1.8`s ?

> Actually, some of the "limited" edition Mitsubishi`s will do that too,
> only available in Japan though :-(

> Beers and cheers
> (uncle) Goy

The relatively new Volvo T4 engine gives out 200hp/1800cc. That counts?

/petern

Lindsay Adam

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Lindsay Adam » Mon, 09 Nov 1998 04:00:00

street

I think you'll find that under the fia gt2 rules there is a lot of
modification allowed but not change - and the chassis has to remain intact
and original to that which is homologated

Appendix J Articles 251 & 258....

"Chassis:

The overall structure of the car around which are assembled the mechanical
components and the bodywork including any structural part of the said
structure."

"1.5 Original:

As fitted to the road registered FIA homologated car."

"3.6.1 - Strengthening of the chassis and bodywork is allowed provided that
the material used follows the _original_ shape and is in direct contact with
it." - i.e the ORIGINAL MUST REMAIN

"10.3 Suspension type and mounting (Class 2):

10.3.1 - All suspension components, with the exception of parts specifically
mentioned, must be _original_ equipment supplied by the manufacturer or
homologated. These parts may be strengthened provided the original part can
still be identified."

"10.7 Steering (Class 2):

10.7.1 - All steering components, with the exception of the steering ratio,
must be _original_ equipment supplied by the manufacturer. These parts may
be strengthened provided the original part can still be identified."

transmissons are free as long as they are of the same type as original (2
wheel,rear wheel drive etc) and engine mods are free, but orignal engine
must be retained in the same orientation and possition as original.

so..... whilst 80% of the car may be modified, substantially more than 20%
of the _original_ must remain, and be identifiable as such.

Returning to my original argument - I never claimed that the bog standard
road car was a good race car, what I did say was that it formed the _basis_
of a good race car. What is a good road car is far to subjective a
discussion to enter into! :-D

later

-Lindsay

Lindsay Adam

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Lindsay Adam » Mon, 09 Nov 1998 04:00:00

street

I think you'll find that under the fia gt2 rules there is a lot of
modification allowed but not change - and the chassis has to remain intact
and original to that which is homologated

Appendix J Articles 251 & 258....

"Chassis:

The overall structure of the car around which are assembled the mechanical
components and the bodywork including any structural part of the said
structure."

"1.5 Original:

As fitted to the road registered FIA homologated car."

"3.6.1 - Strengthening of the chassis and bodywork is allowed provided that
the material used follows the _original_ shape and is in direct contact with
it." - i.e the ORIGINAL MUST REMAIN

"10.3 Suspension type and mounting (Class 2):

10.3.1 - All suspension components, with the exception of parts specifically
mentioned, must be _original_ equipment supplied by the manufacturer or
homologated. These parts may be strengthened provided the original part can
still be identified."

"10.7 Steering (Class 2):

10.7.1 - All steering components, with the exception of the steering ratio,
must be _original_ equipment supplied by the manufacturer. These parts may
be strengthened provided the original part can still be identified."

transmissons are free as long as they are of the same type as original (2
wheel,rear wheel drive etc) and engine mods are free, but orignal engine
must be retained in the same orientation and possition as original.

so..... whilst 80% of the car may be modified, substantially more than 20%
of the _original_ must remain, and be identifiable as such.

Returning to my original argument - I never claimed that the bog standard
road car was a good race car, what I did say was that it formed the _basis_
of a good race car. What is a good road car is far to subjective a
discussion to enter into! :-D

later

-Lindsay

gulag13>don't spam pleas

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by gulag13>don't spam pleas » Tue, 10 Nov 1998 04:00:00



>>spent be a big deal.  Take a trip down to your local drag strip and
>>check out what fast is.  Or, just watch Le Mans next year and watch
>>Porsche win for the 17th time even in the face of Toyota and Nissan's
>>best efforts.

>Toyota won Le Mans and Honda have dominated both F1 and CART.

..............not to mention, the "made in the USA" entries kept the
LeMans fire teams pretty busy. Oh yea, then there is the GM powerd
Marcos.................
Daisy Du

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Daisy Du » Wed, 11 Nov 1998 04:00:00


>ABS don't help braking distance in dry condition

.....or wet for that matter.
Larr

Why GT blows chunks.... (was Re: F**k GPL, there is only one good racing game !)

by Larr » Thu, 24 Dec 1998 04:00:00

I'm a truck man, so I guess I'd dig it :)

-Larry


> Auto box?  Don't know which Viper they were testing with an automatic, but
> even if it is available (I'm not the kind of guy to memorize option sheets)
> I doubt many leave the factory with an auto box.  Not that I like the Viper
> much, since it is basically a beautiful concept car with a truck engine and
> sub-standard chassis.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.