rec.autos.simulators

GPL: Braking question

Andre Warrin

GPL: Braking question

by Andre Warrin » Thu, 28 Oct 1999 04:00:00

On  Ricardo Nunnini's site (http://www.racesimcentral.net/~richardn/)  I
read this about braking in GPL:

------------------------
PHASE 0 threshold, straight line braking. Start by braking hard (to
get the tires up to temp.) then modulate back to squeal;

PHASE 1 initial turn in. The front of the car usually needs to be
loaded to get it to turn in, which is accomplished by braking. Relax
the braking effort (to use some traction budget for turning), and turn
in, aiming to keep the squeal constant.
------------------------

I allways thought the optimal braking point was just before the tires
start to squeel, instead of having the tires squeeling?

Andre

ricardo_nunn..

GPL: Braking question

by ricardo_nunn.. » Thu, 28 Oct 1999 04:00:00

I think you're right about the optimal braking point. But, if there's
no sound coming from the front wheels, how can you tell if you're
braking hard enough? I should have said, "brake until the squeal just
starts and then play around with the brake pedal to keep the squeal on
the threshold".

Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.

Scott Boha

GPL: Braking question

by Scott Boha » Thu, 28 Oct 1999 04:00:00


The tyres don't start to squeel at a set point, the part of the tyre that
starts
to slip gets bigger and bigger across the footprint of the tyre until the
whole footprint is slipping and you have total lock-up.  I think for dry
conditions, you need about 15% of the footprint slipping for optimal
braking.  I don't know how this translates to car simulators,
but GPL is pretty realistic, so I expect they have it modelled well.

You should probably be aiming for a quieter squeel as possible, but as
long as you can still hear it.  If you can't hear any squeeling, you aren't
braking hard enough.

Scott

Andre Warrin

GPL: Braking question

by Andre Warrin » Thu, 28 Oct 1999 04:00:00

Your explanation sounds very convincing, but contradictory to what
other people stated. It's difficult to prove who's right, since it's
so difficult to test in gpl at which point braking is best: little
squeel or just before the squeel...

Andre

Thom j

GPL: Braking question

by Thom j » Thu, 28 Oct 1999 04:00:00

Hello Andre & Scott;
I don't usually reply to many posts but whether your braking,
turning, four wheel drifting or whatever. Each driver has their
own style and {as me} the best way to find the optimal spot
or zone is the same way to Carnegie Hall. Practice, etc, etc.
Now I'm not laying down a vague smug answer/opinion but
if you keep going into a set or just a 'single' turn to brake or
find your best line or whatever you'll find you personal way
of doing it correctly! I'm certainly no expert but everything
is subjective anyway!! Good Luck.. Thom_j.


Liutger Franze

GPL: Braking question

by Liutger Franze » Fri, 29 Oct 1999 04:00:00

I agree that you can archieve it with practice, but information could
help you understand and improve it faster. there are facts or 'rules' in
racing, which apply to every driver regardless of his driving style. and
I personally tried different braking techniques without really finding
out the 'perfect one'. therefore I'd like to hear about the experiences
of other drivers. as far as I observed it, the best braking is with the
tires squeeling just a little bit as ricardo and scott mentioned before.

Lio

Tadej Krev

GPL: Braking question

by Tadej Krev » Sat, 30 Oct 1999 04:00:00

When the tyres are squeeling slightly they're just indicating that you're
coming closer to their traction (grip) limit. My tyres squeel quite often
when I drive hard my Honda Civic and they're not locking up, neither they
lost the grip (still plenty left).

Tadej


> On  Ricardo Nunnini's site (http://website.lineone.net/~richardn/)  I
> read this about braking in GPL:

> ------------------------
> PHASE 0 threshold, straight line braking. Start by braking hard (to
> get the tires up to temp.) then modulate back to squeal;

> PHASE 1 initial turn in. The front of the car usually needs to be
> loaded to get it to turn in, which is accomplished by braking. Relax
> the braking effort (to use some traction budget for turning), and turn
> in, aiming to keep the squeal constant.
> ------------------------

> I allways thought the optimal braking point was just before the tires
> start to squeel, instead of having the tires squeeling?

> Andre

Peter Ive

GPL: Braking question

by Peter Ive » Sat, 30 Oct 1999 04:00:00



First thing of course is to get the brake balance correct.  Too far
forward and the front tyres will be locking up too early causing
sliding.  Too far back and the rear end will start moving about as the
back end locks up.

Well, I've just done a GPL session to figure out what I do during
braking - it's on such a subconscious level that I wasn't quite sure
just thinking about it off the top of my head - this is what I've
discovered.

I find that I slam on the anchors hard during each gear change and then
ease off slightly whilst between gear changes.  So it goes something
like this.  Slam on anchors and start to change down.  Once back in gear
ease off from hard braking and then back on again during next downshift
and so on.  There are odd times that I recall changing down 2 gears at
one time, but these are rare and would only happen when going from 5th
to 3rd.

Using this technique my braking is pretty good and it even allows me to
be competitive under braking into the Parabolica using GPL 1.0.
--
Peter Ives

Andre Warring

GPL: Braking question

by Andre Warring » Sun, 31 Oct 1999 04:00:00

Thanks Peter, I've never tried this technique, I'll try it!

Andre

Don Jenning

GPL: Braking question

by Don Jenning » Sun, 31 Oct 1999 04:00:00

I'm confused, let me know if I'm thinking about this right.  When tires
squeal, what's producing the sound?  It has to be *** sliding across
asphalt, no? As long as no sliding is occurring, 100% of the tire's normal
contact patch is gripping the road.  When you're cornering and the tires
start to "squeal a little", some portion of the contact patch (say 10%) must
be sliding while the remainder of the contact patch (90%) is still
maintaining grip.  Then when the percentage gripping falls below some
critical point, the tire loses grip completely and you slide.

It would seem to be a little different with straight-line braking.  Here the
tire is trying to slide straight ahead instead of sideways.  There's always
another contact patch right next to the current one.  In order to make the
tire squeal, you would have to either lock the wheel, or reduce the size of
the contact patch.  The only way to reduce the size of the contact patch is
to reduce the weight on the tire.  Whenever you're breaking, you're putting
more weight on the front tires and less on the rears.  This could cause the
rears to "squeal a little" without locking the fronts or having the car
slide noticeably.

Does any of this sound right?



Don Jenning

GPL: Braking question

by Don Jenning » Tue, 02 Nov 1999 04:00:00

Richard S Beckett wrote ...

I'm thinking that with a certain amount of weight on the tire, it maintains
traction.  As you lighten the weight, it has less traction, until it gets to
some point where it's slipping.  When you're cornering to the right, you
would have greater weight on the left side of each tire than on the right.
The right edge of each tread could be slipping a bit while the left edge is
maintaining grip.

In other words, the right edge is pregnant and the left edge is just drunk
without protection ;-)

Michael Barlo

GPL: Braking question

by Michael Barlo » Tue, 02 Nov 1999 04:00:00


> Richard S Beckett wrote ...
> > If you assume that the sound is caused by the tyre sliding across the
> > road, then how can you explain that only a part of the tyre is sliding?
> > Surely the tyre is either sliding, or not sliding - you can't be a
> > little bit pregnant! :-)

> I'm thinking that with a certain amount of weight on the tire, it maintains
> traction.  As you lighten the weight, it has less traction, until it gets to
> some point where it's slipping.  When you're cornering to the right, you
> would have greater weight on the left side of each tire than on the right.
> The right edge of each tread could be slipping a bit while the left edge is
> maintaining grip.

> In other words, the right edge is pregnant and the left edge is just drunk
> without protection ;-)

        I think I know what you're saying, and I think you're on the right
track.  Have a look at this site, It may shed some light on the
subject.. http://members.home.net/rck/phor/
--
=========================================
Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing?
=========================================
http://members.xoom.com/BarlowRacing/

Racing online with the help of......

Race Communications Association
Holodyne Engineering
Mystic Music
(have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)

Gene Boni

GPL: Braking question

by Gene Boni » Tue, 02 Nov 1999 04:00:00

Sorry guys, this makes no sense to me. If part of the tire is slipping
across the surface of the road, and part is gripping the surface of the
road, then the tire is coming apart or is being compressed.

Just my $.02

Gene



> > Richard S Beckett wrote ...
> > > If you assume that the sound is caused by the tyre sliding across the
> > > road, then how can you explain that only a part of the tyre is
sliding?
> > > Surely the tyre is either sliding, or not sliding - you can't be a
> > > little bit pregnant! :-)

> > I'm thinking that with a certain amount of weight on the tire, it
maintains
> > traction.  As you lighten the weight, it has less traction, until it
gets to
> > some point where it's slipping.  When you're cornering to the right, you
> > would have greater weight on the left side of each tire than on the
right.
> > The right edge of each tread could be slipping a bit while the left edge
is
> > maintaining grip.

> > In other words, the right edge is pregnant and the left edge is just
drunk
> > without protection ;-)

> I think I know what you're saying, and I think you're on the right
> track.  Have a look at this site, It may shed some light on the
> subject.. http://members.home.net/rck/phor/
> --
> =========================================
> Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing?
> =========================================
> http://members.xoom.com/BarlowRacing/

> Racing online with the help of......

> Race Communications Association
> Holodyne Engineering
> Mystic Music
> (have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)

Chris Squie

GPL: Braking question

by Chris Squie » Wed, 03 Nov 1999 04:00:00

Both.  I think they call it tire "squirm"

Mike Barlow posted a link to some racing physics pages, great reading.
Check out chapter 10.


> Sorry guys, this makes no sense to me. If part of the tire is slipping
> across the surface of the road, and part is gripping the surface of the
> road, then the tire is coming apart or is being compressed.

> Just my $.02

> Gene




> > > Richard S Beckett wrote ...
> > > > If you assume that the sound is caused by the tyre sliding across
the
> > > > road, then how can you explain that only a part of the tyre is
> sliding?
> > > > Surely the tyre is either sliding, or not sliding - you can't be a
> > > > little bit pregnant! :-)

> > > I'm thinking that with a certain amount of weight on the tire, it
> maintains
> > > traction.  As you lighten the weight, it has less traction, until it
> gets to
> > > some point where it's slipping.  When you're cornering to the right,
you
> > > would have greater weight on the left side of each tire than on the
> right.
> > > The right edge of each tread could be slipping a bit while the left
edge
> is
> > > maintaining grip.

> > > In other words, the right edge is pregnant and the left edge is just
> drunk
> > > without protection ;-)

> > I think I know what you're saying, and I think you're on the right
> > track.  Have a look at this site, It may shed some light on the
> > subject.. http://members.home.net/rck/phor/
> > --
> > =========================================
> > Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing?
> > =========================================
> > http://members.xoom.com/BarlowRacing/

> > Racing online with the help of......

> > Race Communications Association
> > Holodyne Engineering
> > Mystic Music
> > (have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)

Scott Boha

GPL: Braking question

by Scott Boha » Thu, 04 Nov 1999 04:00:00


You are absolutely correct.  Assume you are braking in a straight line.
(This might be for acceleration, I can't remember which way around it
is)  The middle part of the contact patch is compressed and as that part
of the tire moves away from the middle of the contact patch, it starts
to slip.  If you are only braking lightly, it will only start to slip when
it
has more or less left the road, and you won't hear anything.  Under
heavy braking, but not lock-up, the tyre starts to slip earlier and
earlier, causing more sound, until the whole contact-patch is
slipping.

Someone must have an animation of this somewhere, as I'm sure
I'm not the only one who can't visualise it.

Scott


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.