rec.autos.simulators

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

Andrew Sawczy

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Andrew Sawczy » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 12:41:31

I ordered a new Logitech MOMO from www.buy.com ($158 shipped). It
arrived today and I eagerly installed it and fired up GPL. The first
thing I noticed was the frame rate, it plummeted. Then I did a few laps
and found the force feedback effects to be absolutely awful. This is
compared to my original LWFF (that I took apart to insert into my other
wheel, and well, that project never took off).

Now my question for everyone, is this... I'm not sure if it's the wheel
that is ***or my PC. You see, I've been putting off a PC upgrade until
WSC is released. Obviously my PC is a little old now. It's a Celeron
466, V3, 256mb. The typical old system. Since I've seen a dramatic drop
in frame rates, I'm wondering if the PC performance is also affecting
the performance of the wheel. Is it time to bite the bullet and upgrade?

I still don't want to upgrade until I know something about WSC, so I
could set the wheel aside for a few months (if WSC isn't out in demo
form by the end of the year, then***'em.). But I don't want to set
this thing aside if the wheel just isn't as great as it has been touted.

For those of you who have owned the original LWFF and the MOMO, along
with a modern PC, what do you think of the MOMO?

Pickax

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Pickax » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 13:30:26

 > Now my question for everyone, is this... I'm not sure if it's the wheel

It's your PC, spend $50 and upgrade.

It's awesome on a decent computer.

Pick

Steve Smit

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Steve Smit » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 19:56:11

Andrew,

It seems extremely unlikely that the MOMO caused yer fps to nosedive.  As a
USB device (like yer LWFF), it shouldn't be sucking any more CPU cycles
outta yer system than yer old setup.  OTOH, it is a different s/w
environment.  Make sure you've got the latest s/w d/l's from Logitech and
the Wingman Team...and any other controller applets you think might help
(DXTweak, TM Pro, etc.).

We should hear something abt. WSC within a few days.  If it is ever
released, it likely won't demand the latest h/w, because it has been in
dev't so long that most of the chalk marks on the floor (the h/w params)
were prolly laid down anticipating a 1.3-Gig Athlon and a GeForce 3.  IOW,
it ain't gonna be no Unreal Tournament 2003.

And yes, the MOMO is a great wheel (it's the pedals that suck 55-in. of Hg),
altho Alison Hine was over the other day and complained the FF f/x didn't
feel a *thing* like her beloved red-rim, ball-bearing Logi.

--Steve


Isotrip

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Isotrip » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 21:00:21

If you are running Win95 or Win98 1st Edition, and your Momo is USB, you are
probably experiencing the effects of the 1st generation USB Drivers. Win98SE
on up have much better USB Drivers and are less resource intensive. Just a
thought.

- Isotrip?


Steve Smit

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Steve Smit » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 21:21:14

<< IOW,  it ain't gonna be no Unreal Tournament 2003.>>

I meant it ain't gonna be no DOOM 3.


> Andrew,

> It seems extremely unlikely that the MOMO caused yer fps to nosedive.  As
a
> USB device (like yer LWFF), it shouldn't be sucking any more CPU cycles
> outta yer system than yer old setup.  OTOH, it is a different s/w
> environment.  Make sure you've got the latest s/w d/l's from Logitech and
> the Wingman Team...and any other controller applets you think might help
> (DXTweak, TM Pro, etc.).

> We should hear something abt. WSC within a few days.  If it is ever
> released, it likely won't demand the latest h/w, because it has been in
> dev't so long that most of the chalk marks on the floor (the h/w params)
> were prolly laid down anticipating a 1.3-Gig Athlon and a GeForce 3.  IOW,
> it ain't gonna be no Unreal Tournament 2003.

> And yes, the MOMO is a great wheel (it's the pedals that suck 55-in. of
Hg),
> altho Alison Hine was over the other day and complained the FF f/x didn't
> feel a *thing* like her beloved red-rim, ball-bearing Logi.

> --Steve



> > I ordered a new Logitech MOMO from www.buy.com ($158 shipped). It
> > arrived today and I eagerly installed it and fired up GPL. The first
> > thing I noticed was the frame rate, it plummeted. Then I did a few laps
> > and found the force feedback effects to be absolutely awful. This is
> > compared to my original LWFF (that I took apart to insert into my other
> > wheel, and well, that project never took off).

> > Now my question for everyone, is this... I'm not sure if it's the wheel
> > that is ***or my PC. You see, I've been putting off a PC upgrade until
> > WSC is released. Obviously my PC is a little old now. It's a Celeron
> > 466, V3, 256mb. The typical old system. Since I've seen a dramatic drop
> > in frame rates, I'm wondering if the PC performance is also affecting
> > the performance of the wheel. Is it time to bite the bullet and upgrade?

> > I still don't want to upgrade until I know something about WSC, so I
> > could set the wheel aside for a few months (if WSC isn't out in demo
> > form by the end of the year, then***'em.). But I don't want to set
> > this thing aside if the wheel just isn't as great as it has been touted.

> > For those of you who have owned the original LWFF and the MOMO, along
> > with a modern PC, what do you think of the MOMO?

Internet Use

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Internet Use » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 22:01:30


> Andrew,

> It seems extremely unlikely that the MOMO caused yer fps to nosedive.  As a
> USB device (like yer LWFF), it shouldn't be sucking any more CPU cycles
> outta yer system than yer old setup.  OTOH, it is a different s/w
> environment.  Make sure you've got the latest s/w d/l's from Logitech and
> the Wingman Team...and any other controller applets you think might help
> (DXTweak, TM Pro, etc.).

My LWFF was one of the original gameport versions and it was running on
Win 98.  I'm running XP now, and I think that little bit of extra
overhead is contributing to the problems.  I am running the latest and
greatest of everything, including the beta drivers from the Wingman Team.

Speaking of Alison.  I went back to my original LWFF settings for GPL,
the ones I found on Alisons' site.  These seem to work much better and
are closer to what I remember from the original wheel.  The settings I
found on this forum that were created specifically for the MOMO were not
good at all.  Too over powering.  I can still feel the gears, but the
wheel reacts better to what's happening on the track with Alisons' settings.

Thanks for the reply.  I guess I'll know after this weekend (post
Goodwood) when I'll be upgrading my PC.  I'll have to kick the "maybe
there's something better on the horizon" thought process and buy
something now.

MadDAW

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by MadDAW » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 23:14:55

Why don't you let her borrow it for a few days and see if she can come up
with the core.ini settings for it. :)  I thought her settings for the cable
driven LWFF were great, but I have not been able to get the MOMO to feel the
same. My guess is the main reason is the differance between the cable drive
and gear drive setups.

MadDAWG

Jan Verschuere

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Jan Verschuere » Thu, 11 Jul 2002 23:25:05

Turn up the latency to the 30ms range.

Jan.
=---

Steve Smit

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Steve Smit » Fri, 12 Jul 2002 03:02:51

Actually, Alison confidently dialed in the settings from her beloved LWFF,
and made a sour face as soon as she tried it, so I gather the MOMO doesn't
feel anything like the LWFF with the same settings in DX and core.ini.  I
thought the diff I was feeling was mechanical (between the innards of the
LWFF and the MOMO), not electrical (the degree of torque, latency,
blah-blah), but I must admit I'm numb to what Alison was talking abt.  There
are too many variables, jumping back & forth from the game to Control Panel,
so I guess I'll just live with what I've got (until I get a chance to tune
the basics with the more-up-to-date F1 2002).



> > Andrew,

> > It seems extremely unlikely that the MOMO caused yer fps to nosedive.
As a
> > USB device (like yer LWFF), it shouldn't be sucking any more CPU cycles
> > outta yer system than yer old setup.  OTOH, it is a different s/w
> > environment.  Make sure you've got the latest s/w d/l's from Logitech
and
> > the Wingman Team...and any other controller applets you think might help
> > (DXTweak, TM Pro, etc.).

> My LWFF was one of the original gameport versions and it was running on
> Win 98.  I'm running XP now, and I think that little bit of extra
> overhead is contributing to the problems.  I am running the latest and
> greatest of everything, including the beta drivers from the Wingman Team.

> > And yes, the MOMO is a great wheel (it's the pedals that suck 55-in. of
Hg),
> > altho Alison Hine was over the other day and complained the FF f/x
didn't
> > feel a *thing* like her beloved red-rim, ball-bearing Logi.

> Speaking of Alison.  I went back to my original LWFF settings for GPL,
> the ones I found on Alisons' site.  These seem to work much better and
> are closer to what I remember from the original wheel.  The settings I
> found on this forum that were created specifically for the MOMO were not
> good at all.  Too over powering.  I can still feel the gears, but the
> wheel reacts better to what's happening on the track with Alisons'
settings.

> Thanks for the reply.  I guess I'll know after this weekend (post
> Goodwood) when I'll be upgrading my PC.  I'll have to kick the "maybe
> there's something better on the horizon" thought process and buy
> something now.

Steve Smit

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Steve Smit » Fri, 12 Jul 2002 03:04:09

That's what I thought, but from Alison's reaction, I gather it goes deeper
than that.

(P.S. I'd be happy to loan her my MOMO...but she's 400 miles away, so we
don't get to visit as often as we'd like.)


Steve Smit

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Steve Smit » Fri, 12 Jul 2002 04:42:49

Jan,

What are your other settings (& basic system info), please?

--Steve


Jan Verschuere

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Jan Verschuere » Fri, 12 Jul 2002 06:14:23

That's sort of the point, Steve, once I followed the advise to crank up the
latency I found I could adapt the other settings to taste.

It would appear miss Hine is getting a little conservative nowadays. To me
the MOMO is more responsive and "crisper" than even a ball bearing equipped
LWFF. That said, I found it does need a bit of a "break-in" period. It
definately smooths out with use.

I think the comforting feel from the LWFF stems from the "give" which is
present in the steel cables and therefore switching to the more direct gear
drive is a bit of a shock. Once over the initial shock though, one finds
one's even more connected to the sim than before. IMO this effect is more
pronounced in N2k2 than GPL.

Anyhow, for reference:

Athlon XP2000+, 512Mb DDR Ram, GF3 Ti200, Win98se, DirectX8.1, WingMan 4.11
drivers.

I use the standard setup of the overall strenght setting at 100%, other
sliders at 0% in *** Options.

GPL core.ini

[ Hack ]
steer_ratio = 1    ; Enable low speed ratio override

[ Joy ]
allow_force_feedback = 1             ; Use FF if device has it
force_feedback_damping = 70          ; force feedback damping coefficient
force_feedback_latency = 0.030000    ; force feedback latency (secs)
max_steering_torque = 298.000000     ; steering torque in N*in giving max
device force

100% steering linearity in the game and I usually use a 16:1 steering ratio.

N2k2

Strenght : 65%
Damping  : 37%
Latency  : 30ms
Steering Linearity : 100%

Jan.
=---

Internet Use

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Internet Use » Fri, 12 Jul 2002 07:45:57


> [ Hack ]
> steer_ratio = 1    ; Enable low speed ratio override

> [ Joy ]
> allow_force_feedback = 1             ; Use FF if device has it
> force_feedback_damping = 70          ; force feedback damping coefficient
> force_feedback_latency = 0.030000    ; force feedback latency (secs)
> max_steering_torque = 298.000000     ; steering torque in N*in giving max
> device force

> 100% steering linearity in the game and I usually use a 16:1 steering ratio.

Those don't feel too bad.  The latency seems a bit off.  I still prefer
Alisons' 0.020000, but I'm cruising around at a blazing 15fps so my
opinion really means nothing in that regard.

I've forgotten how much fun it is to drive with a FF wheel.  I'm using
my top-hinged, steel pedals from SRC and GPL is a blast to drive!

Andre Warrin

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Andre Warrin » Fri, 12 Jul 2002 18:35:13

On Wed, 10 Jul 2002 10:56:11 GMT, "Steve Smith"


>Andrew,

>It seems extremely unlikely that the MOMO caused yer fps to nosedive.  As a

Well.. a year or so ago I bought a GF2 GTS card, and when I installed
it I had 36fps in GPL at the start, at the back of the grid. But a
while after that I noticed some major drops in fps while racing.
I thought it was caused by some updates, perhaps some of those 16bit
cars I recently had installed. For testing I installed an older backup
of GPL, but still had the fps drops.

Since then I tried a lot, different drivers, windows memory settings,
but the problem still remains. Yesterday I read a post on Legends
Central from a guy who had the same problem, and wondered if it could
be caused by his Momo. I never though about the momo software being
the possible cause in the fps drops, but I did buy the momo a while
after my GF2 card, so it -could- be the case..

I will uninstall the momo drivers and software when I get home and
test if the drop in fps is gone in GPL.. will post the results here.

Andre

Steve Smit

Did my MOMO turn my PC to Junk?

by Steve Smit » Fri, 12 Jul 2002 19:58:55

Thx, Jan - I'll try yer settings!



rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.