rec.autos.simulators

Please, get rid of F10 view....

steve cov

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by steve cov » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

I think knowing the track is very important.  The only track i know very
well is Monza
and i am finally starting to find that in car view doesnt hinder me.

I think with the next patch, the roll bar view should be incorporated into
the available
 driving view selections so you have simulation view / aracade view / and
the
"intermediate" roll bar view.

As for what is more "true to life", well who is to say...does the in car
view
provide the level of feedback and spatial perception you get from a real
automobile
around you... perhaps the chase view provides the appropriate compensation
for the things
we miss out on.

steve c


Steve Blankenshi

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Steve Blankenshi » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

    I made the mistake recently of thinking the***pit DIDN'T move after
watching some replays.  Oddly, when you drive the***pit moves around while
the front wheels and scenery remain stable in the up-down axis.  But hit F2
and watch from the***pit view and the tub becomes locked while the wheels
and scenery move up and down instead.  There's no head panning either way,
thank goodness.  For flight simmers, it's as if your view is "padlocked" to
the horizon while driving and to the tub when in replay mode.  The
relationship between the***pit, wheels and scenery is basically the same
either way, so you still get the same feedback on car position.  I wonder
why it differs in replay; either way there are still no***pit 3D lighting
effects.
    As for F10 being an advantage, it just gives a better forward view,
putting less importance on memorizing the tracks.  I usually go as quick or
quicker in-car with enough practice, and it's much more enjoyable for me
that way anyway.  I really don't care what view people use, but it seems
Papy could have allowed for a "forced view" .ini line option with online
races, ala GP500.  They already force some client settings, so it seems like
an easy add-on, and it would let people who do care host or join races with
in-car view only.  That would end the argument.

Cheers,

Steve B.


> I think its easier to drive with F10 view cause, you dont have head
panning
> (not sure
> if that is the right word ...)
> i think with that 3D moving***pit, actually you loose a bit of 'feeling'

Phillip McNell

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Phillip McNell » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

I think the thing is having some drivers in a league driving f10 and
others not dirtties up the water. You're not comparing apples with
apples.

To each his own is fair enough when they're on their own. But in a
comp. one would like to feel everyone's at the same advantage /
disadvantage. I can understand completely that some would like to know
they are racing others in an equal way. I can't see any problem with
this concept at all.

All GPL had to do was have an idicator that lets everyone know how the
driver  was /  is driving. It would be simple to have a league rule
that says everyone should be F10 or in the***pit. But unless GPL has
an indicator it may be a token rule. Or better yet - have it as a
server option, like all the other server options, that drivers are
forced to use the driving situation a league requires.

Like lots of others have said here, F10 does give quite an advantge in
some ways. It simple would have been nice if GPL was written to, or
could be made to, let us all compare apples with apples.

Phillip McNelley



Remco Moe

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Remco Moe » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00


>Like lots of others have said here, F10 does give quite an advantge in
>some ways. It simple would have been nice if GPL was written to, or
>could be made to, let us all compare apples with apples.

Yeah....I did a 1:24:8 at Monza and a 6:58:xx at the Ring with chase
view. On the Glen you really have the advantage of the chase view,
I did a 59:99 there! But I feel so ashamed about using the chase view,
that I wouldn't dare to send in these hotlaps.....

<sigh>

Remco

John Simmo

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by John Simmo » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00


says...

That's a crock of shit.  In two seasons of IGPS (29 races total), I won
four events, and only because I happened to be in the right place at the
right time.  EVERY other winner in those seasons was using the in-car
view.  I suspect that out of 50 drivers, only two or three of us used the
chase view, but I would have to poll everybody that raced to make sure.

As far as non-league racing, I almost NEVER win.  So how is my driving
any better or worse than someone using in-car mode?

You people that complain about this are nothing but whiners and
crybabies.  Go back to your Playstations...

Ian Parke

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Ian Parke » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

I use the***pit view only (except to check exit speed if I've come out of
a corner well :) ) but have no objections at all to others using the F10
view, whatever they feel comfortable with.
I can be relatively competitive and stay on track for a whole race every now
and again :) using the***pit view, I also have a friend who is high in the
records for hotlaps who also drives in***pit view.
Therefore IMO there is very little difference to the times achievable in
either view, just what is preferable to the individual driver.

--
Ian Parker

UKGPL League
http://www.racesimcentral.net/~ukgpl/index.html




> >I race GPL. It is the absolute best SIMULATION ever made.

> >So why the F10 view.  sure - it can be good when you
> >are learning tracks or what ever.  but we don't really
> >need it.

> >I think we need to get rid of it for the next patch
> >(when ever it's release date is).

> >Why?  Because if you want to go fast, you need to use
> >it. If you want realism, you won't go fast.

> >This sucks.  if we take it out, then EVERYONE is
> >definately on a level ground.

> >I would like to think I can compete against everyone
> >with the most realistic simulation available using
> >realistic settings.  If I wanted to go fast, I would
> >use F10 but it just feels wrong, so consequently I
> >can't.

> >I'm not saying it is cheating, but I think most ppl
> >would say we don't really need it, and without it,
> >we would be better off.

> Wow, you didn't site one real reason why they should remove it other than
> because *you* don't feel competitive against someone that uses it.  For
> many of us, it makes the *game* driveable and if it weren't for the
> existance of "arcade" mode, many more would probably have abandoned the
> *game* as unplayable.

> As for being competitive, that's a relative term.  If you're only
> interested in turning the world's fastest time in the *game*.  If that's
> your idea of fun, so be it, but IMHO, one-lap wonders ain't shit.  I siad
> it when SVGA was around, and I stick by that claim - one lap doesn't win
> a race.  If you can keep the car on the gray part and manage not to hit
> anything or anyone, you're doing good.  If you're fast too, even better.

> I use "chase" mode when driving in GPL, and it certainly doesn't make me
> the fastest (ask anyone in IGPS about that), but it does allow me to keep
> up.  It's a crutch, sure, but I don't really give a flyin' f*ck what
> anyone else thinks about it because it doesn't keep them from using the
> in-car view if they so choose.

> --
> =========================================================
> Redneck Techno-Biker (Zerex12)
>   http://www.racesimcentral.net/
> Barbarian Diecast Collector (370+ cars and counting)
>   http://www.racesimcentral.net/
> Internet Grand Prix Series Season 2
>   http://www.racesimcentral.net/
> North American Stockcar Racing Online Competition
>   http://www.racesimcentral.net/
> Super X Philes
>   http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> If you want to send me email, go to the first URL shown
> above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame.
> =========================================================

Steve Ferguso

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Steve Ferguso » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

: AMEN! Everytime I hear someone say they don't feel the sense of speed
: in GPL, I know they must be running in arcade view. Even in real life
: there isn't a sense of speed driving RC cars, why would a sim be any
: different?

I'm new to GPL, and I have to admit the speed *scares* me at times.  There
is definitely a sense of speed.  A quick look left or right on the
straightaways will double the e***ment.

Stephen
(and I also find the***pit view *easier* to drive from, but I'm not fast
anyway)

BendsMast

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by BendsMast » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00



Well I need it for the start of the race to cover for the blind spots
in gpl. At the start I never really have any time to look sideways,
even if I did, I still wouldn't be able to see the incoming car as it
would be sort of half-way behind me.
I have done a lot of laps with the f10 view to find out if I was any
faster but it turns out I tend to "throw" the car too much into high
speed turns, therefore, I am actually slower with the F10 view as I
feel you get less visual feedback from the car.
Some races I do half of the first lap with the F10 view, specially
on-line. I wouldn't see a need to get rid of it in a upcoming patch
since you can simply choose not to use. I think that in fact they
should introduce more views in gpl rather than remove one of two
current possible views.
I would rather have too many views, than too few.

Cheers me deers

Jim Alliso

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Jim Alliso » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

I always drive with the in-car view but I find that F10 is sometimes very
useful in the corners if you're unsure
whether there is someone in your blind spot. The "look left-right" feature
won't cover all of your blind spot.
As I'm now much more comfortable with online racing and keeping track of car
positions in the heat of battle,
I hardly use it at all now. Unless I'm sure I just assume that someone is
there rather than use F10 all the time.

I wouldn't mind not using F10 at all as long as everyone else was in the
same boat (or car).


Chris Schlette

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Chris Schlette » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

And its not even close to being a perfect simulation either....so your point
is what?


> Well said..i totally agree with you...........did you know that most of
the
> fast lap world records are done in F10....disgracefull...its a simulation.


> > I race GPL..    It is the absolute best SIMULATION ever made.....

> > So why the F10 view..  sure..  it can be good when you are learning
tracks
> > or what ever..   but we don't really need it..

> > I think we need to get rid of it for the next patch (when ever it's
> release
> > date is)...

> > Why??   Because if you want to go fast..  you need to use it..
   If
> > you want realism..  you won't go fast....

> > This sucks..   if we take it out..  then EVERYONE is definately on a
level
> > ground..

> > I would like to think I can compete against everyone with the most
> realistic
> > simulation available using realistic settings..  If I wanted to go
fast..
> I
> > would use F10.. but it just feels wrong.. so consequently I can't....
:-(

> > I'm not saying it is cheating..  but I think most ppl would say we don't
> > really need it..  and without it..  we would be better off ...

> > James Pickard,
> > Melbourne,
> > AUSTRALIA
> > Grand Prix Legends Australian Champion Season 1
> > (jsut so you know where I"m coming from...    :-)

Chris Schlette

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by Chris Schlette » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

John,

For once I completely agree with you. :)

John Simmo

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by John Simmo » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00


Chris, you're starting to scare me dude. :-)

'John' Joao Sil

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by 'John' Joao Sil » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00

Who are we talking about here? are you talking about fast GPL Hot Lappers in
VROC pickup races or the truly FAST GPL drivers who drive in leagues and can
run lap after lap of clean fast laps without mistakes?

I find it hard to believe that the F-10 view would be used by the really
fast GPL drivers, mostly because I don't think it would give any true
advantage to the really fast drivers, maybe it helps some people to get
a handle on GPL, but the really fast drivers would be hindered by not
having the in-car feel.

Curious if any really really fast GPL drivers would actually resort to
F-10 view.

Personally, GPL is not only about being fast, but about "experiencing"
a simulation of what driving a '67 F1 race car would be like, I would never
even consider driving from F-10 view, no matter how many tenths it would gain
me, because it would ruin my suspension of disbelief, if I wanted to
drive from unrealistic viewpoints I would be driving console arcade racers
not GPL.

Seeyas on the track.

--John (Joao) Silva



>But.. I have never been able to match the times of the best drivers..   no
>matter what I did..  using there setups..  everything.. I couldn't even get
>within a second..   then I found out what the difference was..

>They are awesome drivers..   but they also use F10..   once you get to a
>certain stage you can't go any faster..   I'm there now..   and even so.. I
>am still about 1 second slower than the top guys at Monza (I do 27.8's PB..
>WR are high 26s?? )    I couldn't work it out...

George M. Smile

Please, get rid of F10 view....

by George M. Smile » Tue, 14 Sep 1999 04:00:00


> So why the F10 view..  sure..  it can be good when you
> are learning tracks or what ever..   but we don't really
> need it..

> I think we need to get rid of it for the next patch (when
> ever it's release date is)...

Whatever happened to the 'Force***pit View As Boss'
option?  For the life of me I seem to recall seeing this some
where in the game or an .ini file but I can't seem to locate it
now (except as a string in the EXE).

Randy?  Anyone?

 - George


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.