>> It may be fun if you take out any disbelief that this is actually how a F1
>> car handles. You can't powerslide&trailbrake in real-life, it's an
>> impossible thing that only a few have ever mastered in the history of modern
>> racing. Everybody knows that, and it's imho a reason why a driver like Alex
>> Zanardi failed in F1 compared to the CART series or simply how the F1 cars
>> handled half a century ago.
>Say what? Are you saying that nobody can trailbrake in modern F1 and that only
>a handful of drivers ever accomplished that? I really don't think that's true
>at all.
[ascends soap-box]
I think Frank is unduly opinionated and above all he tends to make
sweeping generalizations that he cannot prove. He tries to include ALL
of RAS in his comments by saying '*we* want', *we* think', *we* are
of the opinion', etc. when he only speaks for himself. At least I can
promise you that he doesn't speak for me.
His silly comments have gone on for some time, but now a great little
(imperfect) sim has been released.. F1-2000. It is the absolute best
modern F1 sim on the planet. [looks around] anybody disagree?
Frank's constant harping on it's perceived flaws are not good for
our hobby. He certainly has a right to not like F1-2000, but maybe
some of his more esoteric 'trailbraking' etc. comments, are best
kept to himself. Of course, he has the right to say what he wants,
but his latest comments are grating to some people, myself included.
His comments -don't- help get us more 'sims'. Esoteric comments such
as his, might make developers think that the *** fans can
never be satisfied.
Summary:
Frank has become the poster boy for why developers may just give up
on the *** fans. It happened in flight sims and it may happen with
racing sims if there is no support for those who make them. If 'we'
don't like a sim because of it's trailbraking flaws, maybe 'we' should
remember that there is a -lot- more to simulation than trailbraking,
and that, perhaps, our *** racing sim hobby is at stake .
[steps down from soap-box]
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *