I think that the ideal solution is to own both a non-FF wheel and a FF
wheel, if possible. My experience with the Saitek FF wheel is that
while it works okay in non-FF games (ICR2 and such), I still like a
good non-FF wheel for use with a good non-FF sim. I also imagine that
FF will create a HUGE frame rate hit for on-line racing, so it might
be desirable to have a good non-FF wheel for use in these situations.
Additionally, I found that while FF effects did help me turn in better
times in Viper Racing initially, I was ultimately able to better these
times with my non-FF TSW2 wheel. I think others have probably
encountered this same situation, too -- I'm sure I'm not alone in
this, at any rate. Given that, when the chips are on the line and the
competition is for real, the real competitors might not want to be
burdened with the distractioin of the FF effects, so a non-FF wheel
would be ideal at those times. Granted, GPL's FF implementation may
prove to be more of an enhancement than a distraction, but in the end,
despite how good the FF is in Viper Racing, I found it to slightly
more of a distraction than an enhancement to me. This is obviously a
personal preference thing, but I also imagine that while there will be
people who like FF much more than I do, there will also be those who
like it much less, too.
It's like this with everything: Some of my friends love NFS3, for
example, but I personally don't care all that much for it. Nobody's
wrong in either case -- it's just a matter of personal opinion. FF is
the same way -- you either love it, you hate it, or you don't care
much one way or the other.
The ultimate solution with regards to the non-FF versus FF issue is
obviously to have one of each -- a FF wheel, and a non-FF wheel. This
becomes a VERY expensive proposition for the ECCI owners in the group.
This is also somewhat cost-prohibitive for the TSW owners, but it's
not quite as much of a financial stretch. For example, I still
couldn't afford an ECCI for what I have invested in my TSW2 and my
Saitek R4 Force wheel, so in the mid-range price category, it is
possible to have the best of both worlds.
For people using lower-cost non-FF wheels from Thrustmaster, ACT Labs,
or other companies, it is possible to find an affordable FF rig to use
as a secondary controller. The ACT Labs and Logitech wheels can be
had for quite a bit less than $150 (not much more than I paid for my
Thrustmaster NASCAR Pro way back when), and refurbished Saitek R4
Force wheels can be had for $79 from Saitek, while my local Best Buy
has the Interact V4 Force wheel on sale for $49 (I have heard mixed
reviews on this, but most indicate that while this wheel may not be a
top-of-the-line FF wheel, it's still nowhere near as bad as the
original Interact V4). FF is definitely becoming more affordable.
So what we have now is plenty of options and plenty of choices across
the entire spectrum. People are going to have their preferences, and
people are going to try to defend their choices. Preferences are
based on opinions, and opinions are like belly-buttons: Everybody has
one.
This issue will surely be debated into the ground, I'm sure (we're
already several feet deep), but I hope we all take time out to realize
how fortunate we are at this point. We've got a lot of great sims on
the market, a cornucopia of outstanding controllers to choose from,
and the prices keep dropping across the board. So what are we
complaining about? Doesn't anybody remember when all we had was the
original GP and ICR1 sims, and the Thrustmaster T1 wheel had to be
mail-ordered.
We've come a long way, baby.
Ain't it grand?
;-)
-- JB
>With all due respect John! this Force Feedback will literally blow you away,
>if you drift back to a non FF wheel, i would be greatly suprised.
>Randy Cassidy and the team have set new standards, that had me trying every
>corner on every circuit till 4am this morning........
>I kept giggling out loud, which was a bit disconcerting for my wife, as I
>was wearing headphones and she was trying to sleep in the next room
>Please please, don't get involved in any arguments about "Who's wheel is
>better" or "Force feedback is just a feature" debates,
>Go immediatly and take that wheel back from your friend, even though you may
>have to fight him if he has a patched version of GPL <g> but wrestle it
>from his sweaty palms and then rush home, plug it in, and...........well let
>me know.....
>Regards Davey_Willo
>> Ah, at last something that ECCI and TSW owners can agree on! <G>
>> I have access to a Saitek R4 Force wheel, but I find myself seldom
>> using it -- my TSW/TSW2 wheels are far more precise, and I can turn in
>> consistently better lap times (and better race times, too). The FF
>> effects are neat, and in Viper Racing, they do add an immersive
>> quality, but there are too many other sensations missing for FF to be
>> anything more than a neat gimmick, as far as I'm concerned. Adding in
>> the Aura Interactor helps fill in some of the blanks left by a FF
>> wheel, but even with that added in, I'm still not ready to trade in my
>> TSW. All in all, I really enjoy sims more with my TSW wheels than I
>> do with a FF wheel.
>> I don't have access to the Saitek wheel today (it's out on loan to a
>> friend -- lucky guy!), so the jury is out on GPL and FF for me, but I
>> imagine I'll think it's neat up to a point, and slowly drift back to
>> using the TSW2 full-time (my TSW2 has a nicer wheel than my TSW <G>).
>> -- JB
>> On Fri, 9 Jul 1999 14:06:51 -0500, "Scottie Smith"
>> >There isn't a FF wheel made today that I would trade my ECCI for. In fact
>> >the only way that I'll ever be separated from my ECCI is to upgrade to a
>> >newer ECCI:) I bet the TSW owners feel the same way.
>> >You'll always be happy with your Yugo until you try a Ferrari. When you
>do
>> >you'll realize what you've been missing:)
>> >Scottie
>> >>> I think the ff is fantastic!
>> >>> Andre
>> >>Except on those $1000 ECCI wheels. Or even $300 TSW/TSW2 wheels. ;)