rec.autos.simulators

Opinions on Creative Labs Banshee Video Card

KayBe

Opinions on Creative Labs Banshee Video Card

by KayBe » Fri, 30 Apr 1999 04:00:00

I'm looking to purchase a Creative Labs Banshee 16MB AGP port Voodoo 2 video
card.
I play racing sim games (Viper Racing, Formula 1, Nascar 99).  Is this a

Thanks,
Kent
(please email responses)
Meij

Opinions on Creative Labs Banshee Video Card

by Meij » Sat, 01 May 1999 04:00:00

To be honest I'd steer clear of a Banshee. If you must buy a 3Dfx card to
replace your main gfx card, get a Voodoo 3. The Banshee isn't much good
really when you look at the alternatives.

M



-proxy.airnews.net>:

>I'm looking to purchase a Creative Labs Banshee 16MB AGP port Voodoo 2
>video card.
>I play racing sim games (Viper Racing, Formula 1, Nascar 99).  Is this a

>Thanks,
>Kent
>(please email responses)

David Mast

Opinions on Creative Labs Banshee Video Card

by David Mast » Sat, 01 May 1999 04:00:00


>To be honest I'd steer clear of a Banshee. If you must buy a 3Dfx card to
>replace your main gfx card, get a Voodoo 3. The Banshee isn't much good
>really when you look at the alternatives.

I agree that the V3 is the Voodoo to get (providing the reports I've seen of
problems are the exception and not the rule).  However, I think you unfairly
dismiss the Banshee (surprise, yes I have one!).  You can get one for $70 or
so now, so it's a deal.  And, if the game does not utilize multi-texturing
(does anyone know of a *sim* that does?), it is marginally better than a TNT,
ATI Fury, or V2, and has the Glide support that only the Voodoos have.  No, it
isn't up to the class of a V3, V2 SLI, or TNT2.  I'd fork out the extra $50
or so and get a V3 2000 at least.  But if you really want to keep it cheap,
the Banshee will serve you well.

As to the CL, I don't in particular know.  But I thought most of these cards
are essentially the same.  Differing in panel options, heatsink vs fan, and
SDRAM vs SGRAM.  Most of these make little/no difference.

pyt..

Opinions on Creative Labs Banshee Video Card

by pyt.. » Mon, 03 May 1999 04:00:00



>I agree that the V3 is the Voodoo to get (providing the reports I've seen of
>problems are the exception and not the rule).  However, I think you unfairly
>dismiss the Banshee (surprise, yes I have one!).  You can get one for $70 or
>so now, so it's a deal.  And, if the game does not utilize multi-texturing
>(does anyone know of a *sim* that does?), it is marginally better than a TNT,
>ATI Fury, or V2, and has the Glide support that only the Voodoos have.  No, it
>isn't up to the class of a V3, V2 SLI, or TNT2.  I'd fork out the extra $50
>or so and get a V3 2000 at least.  But if you really want to keep it cheap,
>the Banshee will serve you well.

I ba\ck up everything David says. Sure, if you can get one, V3 is now
the way to go. However, when I got my cl banshee, v3 didn't exist, and
for low spec machines like mine, i reckon banshee is ideal. I'm well
chuffed with mine.

--

SJKH,

Ipswich, UK
"I have several test post replies listed on e-bay.  Contact me if you are
interested." - Randy Smith.

BH New

Opinions on Creative Labs Banshee Video Card

by BH New » Tue, 04 May 1999 04:00:00

I agree as well.

Every system I was building for friends came with a Banshee, till the V3's.
It rivaled easily with the TNT I have.

BH




> >I agree that the V3 is the Voodoo to get (providing the reports I've seen
of
> >problems are the exception and not the rule).  However, I think you
unfairly
> >dismiss the Banshee (surprise, yes I have one!).  You can get one for $70
or
> >so now, so it's a deal.  And, if the game does not utilize
multi-texturing
> >(does anyone know of a *sim* that does?), it is marginally better than a
TNT,
> >ATI Fury, or V2, and has the Glide support that only the Voodoos have.
No, it
> >isn't up to the class of a V3, V2 SLI, or TNT2.  I'd fork out the extra
$50
> >or so and get a V3 2000 at least.  But if you really want to keep it
cheap,
> >the Banshee will serve you well.

> I ba\ck up everything David says. Sure, if you can get one, V3 is now
> the way to go. However, when I got my cl banshee, v3 didn't exist, and
> for low spec machines like mine, i reckon banshee is ideal. I'm well
> chuffed with mine.

> --

> SJKH,

> Ipswich, UK
> "I have several test post replies listed on e-bay.  Contact me if you are
> interested." - Randy Smith.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.