Today I went to the IWCCCars site and was rather disappointed to see they
had posted an editorial regarding the updates situation there (and more or
less carrying over into other areas as well).
I do not condone people sending insulting, inflammatory email to web site
operators who perhaps do not meet the standards that the flamer sets out for
them, by any means. But I do feel that if you operate a web site which
provides a service, and if that service is faltering, you do need to have a
thick enough skin to accept a little criticism constructively and stop
falling back on the excuse which I have seen repeatedly and has truly begun
to get under my skin.
That excuse is... "Hey, this is a free site, so you have no right to
complain".
I am not trying to step on anyones toes or upset someone to the extent that
they are going to close down their web site, although I suppose that is a
possibility when I point out something like this... but this needs to be
said. I feel that if someone has made a commitment to do something, the
issue of what it costs is not the point. For example, if you are involved
in little league baseball, as I have been, and you have made a commitment to
coach, do you have the right to say "Hey, I do this for free, so the parents
have no right to complain if I***up"? Can you absolve yourself of all
responsibility for your actions if (and because) you do something on a
volunteer basis?
I am not saying that anyone here owes anyone else anything... if you want to
paint cars or make utilities, thats great, but thats up to you, your
motivation to do so is your own... whether it is because you want such a
feature in YOUR game and having made it work you wish to share it with other
people, or a situation like Dave Noonans, where he saw there was a desire to
get a certain utility and put in the time and commitment to make one and
then market it for some small form of income, or you do it for the
recognition and adoration of everyone who comes to your web site...
Motivation is really not the point here, its a question of taking on
responsibility to do something and then not living up to your own
commitment.
If you have a legitimate reason for not being able to do something, thats
perfectly understandable... if your computer blows up and you lose all your
web site stuff, or you leave on a vacation, or anything like that, hey, we
understand; at least I hope most of us do, the ones with the maturity and
common sense should. But this tiring refrain of "this is free" seems to have
become a mantra for many of the web sites around pertaining to Sim racing,
and frankly its begun to get on my nerves. A little while back I posted a
message saying the level of dedication had gone down at a certain web site,
and I received an email saying that "dedication" had nothing to do with it,
it was for this reason or that reason that the person had something else to
do. Well, if you have something else to do that gives you priority over
working on something for NASCAR 2, that means your level of dedication is
lower for NASCAR 2 than for the other thing. Thats not an insult, its
simply a statement of the obvious, isn't it?
All I hope for is if you are going to do something, you do your best to do
it right. If you are doing your best and it does not go according to plan,
its understandable. But to say something like, hey, I have a real life to,
and this is free anyways, I volunteered, so don't complain... its just
evading the commitment you made. I haven't seen many messages on web sites
saying, "Hey, we are having a little trouble providing what we hoped to,
sorry about that... if you wish to help out email us and we'll see what we
can do." In the days before the Internet became widespread, I ran a BBS,
and as a SysOp I worked hard to make things the best they could be. And
yeah, sometimes I had to put up with people who had no idea how much work
and dedication was involved in making such a system work and that complained
incessantly because THEY did not get what THEY wanted. But if the situation
was one where I screwed up, I always would do my best to correct the problem
and apologize... I would NOT turn around and say, hey, you don't pay for
this, what right have you to complain?
I happen to truly appreciate the IWCCCars project... as well as many other
sites, such as The Pits, Chris Fredericks Racing HQ, Sim ***world, and
others... NASCAR 1 was one of the primary reasons I signed up for Internet
access. I read about the availability of info, utilities, patches, etc., out
here and wanted to be a part of it. I've also tried to make my own small
contributions when I figure out some small piece of data in a track.txt or
make some race logos for ones that are missing. The thing to consider is
that this is a community, a society of sim racers, where hopefully anyone
with the skill will continue to contribute to make the sims better, and
where you will expect to find a small number of people among us who will
simply take and take and complain for no legitimate reason, but you will
also find many people who truly appreciate what the more skilled among us
has done to improve the community. You should expect that the majority that
do appreciate things also will say very little, which is a sad but true fact
of human nature.
Well, I'm getting off the point here... that being that a site being FREE
does not constitute an reason why things aren't getting done. I am not
saying that anyone owes anyone an explanation either, but one is always
appreciated. I would hope that most of us know that you don't HAVE to do
what you do at all, its not your job that we have a right to insist that you
do because we pay your salaries by buying your products or paying taxes...
generally thats pretty clear. Lets just stop falling back on this "I don't
get paid anything for this, so I don't HAVE to do it at all" reasoning... I
would hope you were doing it in the first place because you WANTED to... and
if you want to stop, you are free to do so. Naturally some people are going
to protest if you do, however!
I do want to express a heartfelt thanks to ALL the people who have
contributed to increasing my Sim enjoyment over the years, and I am not
going to single out one or two in particular... I want ANYONE who has ever
contributed anything to know that I, and many others, have always
appreciated the contributions. Anyone who has made a utility or car pcx
file or NASCAR 1 car set or NASCAR 2 car file or track... thank you. You
all know who you are, and you should feel good inside to have contributed.
I'm happy to help out in any way I can, if I have the ability... I always
wish to return the many favours owed to these dedicated people. But if I do
something and I***up, I will NOT make the excuse.. "Hey, I did it for
free, what do you expect?"
ST