rec.autos.simulators

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

Maxx

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Maxx » Sun, 06 May 2001 23:55:41


I posted the above here in r.a.s. back in mid February.

Well, as the bl**dy thing packed up on me earlier I thought I'd
update you.

As it says above, you cannot make swift direction changes without
running up against the internals. I have found it a problem on a
few occasions in GPL but with a 12:1 steering ratio I've generally
been able to avoid it.

However, when I have run up against it I have noticed a clicking
sound, like the nylons cogs where slipping. I'd only had this a
few times and generally it didn't seem to effect the steering.

Anyway, my eldest son came around the other day and I showed him
Super 1 Karting Simulation. This is a pretty good Kart sim but
in karting you need to make very swift direction changes. I am
a bit more subtle than my son, who uses a Non-FF wheel. Anyway
he ran up against these cogs a few times so I kicked him off it.

It was now more prevalent and anything more than slowish movement
would cause this sound. In Pre-Qual for today race it was happening
all thew time for the first half lap then all FF disappeared
completely, not even a centering spring. Now all I get is the motor
whirring and no FF.

So, basically it's bust, in less than 3 months use. While it lasted
it was a good wheel, but my suspicions about it's use with games
requiring fast steering movement has been proven. It could be that
mine was a bad example.

Anyone else out there with a Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel have similar
observations?

Maxx

Joao Gonzale

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Joao Gonzale » Mon, 07 May 2001 05:58:39

You're absolutely right. I bought one and a couple of hours of Colin McRae
sent it back to the store to change it for a Microsoft FF.

Regards




> >Oh, there is one thing that is a problem for me. You cannot make
> >very quick major steering changes with this wheel. i.e. VERY quick
> >opposite lock. You run up against the internals, not sure what it
> >is but it really drags. Not a huge issue in GPL (although it has
> >meant the difference between saving it and losing it at least 4-5
> >times, once in a race). I'm wondering if this will cause me a
> >problem in games such as Rallymasters, CMR2 etc.

> I posted the above here in r.a.s. back in mid February.

> Well, as the bl**dy thing packed up on me earlier I thought I'd
> update you.

> As it says above, you cannot make swift direction changes without
> running up against the internals. I have found it a problem on a
> few occasions in GPL but with a 12:1 steering ratio I've generally
> been able to avoid it.

> However, when I have run up against it I have noticed a clicking
> sound, like the nylons cogs where slipping. I'd only had this a
> few times and generally it didn't seem to effect the steering.

> Anyway, my eldest son came around the other day and I showed him
> Super 1 Karting Simulation. This is a pretty good Kart sim but
> in karting you need to make very swift direction changes. I am
> a bit more subtle than my son, who uses a Non-FF wheel. Anyway
> he ran up against these cogs a few times so I kicked him off it.

> It was now more prevalent and anything more than slowish movement
> would cause this sound. In Pre-Qual for today race it was happening
> all thew time for the first half lap then all FF disappeared
> completely, not even a centering spring. Now all I get is the motor
> whirring and no FF.

> So, basically it's bust, in less than 3 months use. While it lasted
> it was a good wheel, but my suspicions about it's use with games
> requiring fast steering movement has been proven. It could be that
> mine was a bad example.

> Anyone else out there with a Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel have similar
> observations?

> Maxx

Iain Mackenzi

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Iain Mackenzi » Mon, 07 May 2001 06:12:13

Had one for a year now, and no problems whatsoever.  The best wheel I've
owned or tried out.  Much better than the MS effort.
Iain



> >Oh, there is one thing that is a problem for me. You cannot make
> >very quick major steering changes with this wheel. i.e. VERY quick
> >opposite lock. You run up against the internals, not sure what it
> >is but it really drags. Not a huge issue in GPL (although it has
> >meant the difference between saving it and losing it at least 4-5
> >times, once in a race). I'm wondering if this will cause me a
> >problem in games such as Rallymasters, CMR2 etc.

> I posted the above here in r.a.s. back in mid February.

> Well, as the bl**dy thing packed up on me earlier I thought I'd
> update you.

> As it says above, you cannot make swift direction changes without
> running up against the internals. I have found it a problem on a
> few occasions in GPL but with a 12:1 steering ratio I've generally
> been able to avoid it.

> However, when I have run up against it I have noticed a clicking
> sound, like the nylons cogs where slipping. I'd only had this a
> few times and generally it didn't seem to effect the steering.

> Anyway, my eldest son came around the other day and I showed him
> Super 1 Karting Simulation. This is a pretty good Kart sim but
> in karting you need to make very swift direction changes. I am
> a bit more subtle than my son, who uses a Non-FF wheel. Anyway
> he ran up against these cogs a few times so I kicked him off it.

> It was now more prevalent and anything more than slowish movement
> would cause this sound. In Pre-Qual for today race it was happening
> all thew time for the first half lap then all FF disappeared
> completely, not even a centering spring. Now all I get is the motor
> whirring and no FF.

> So, basically it's bust, in less than 3 months use. While it lasted
> it was a good wheel, but my suspicions about it's use with games
> requiring fast steering movement has been proven. It could be that
> mine was a bad example.

> Anyone else out there with a Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel have similar
> observations?

> Maxx

Thom j

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Thom j » Mon, 07 May 2001 11:43:04

Ditto on what Iain has stated!! I just don't understand all the problems
that folks have with the 'TM aka Guillemot Ferrari FFB Race Wheel?'
Odd??......Cheers Thom_j.


| Had one for a year now, and no problems whatsoever.  The best wheel I've
| owned or tried out.  Much better than the MS effort.
| Iain
|

| >
| >

| >
| > >Oh, there is one thing that is a problem for me. You cannot make
| > >very quick major steering changes with this wheel. i.e. VERY quick
| > >opposite lock. You run up against the internals, not sure what it
| > >is but it really drags. Not a huge issue in GPL (although it has
| > >meant the difference between saving it and losing it at least 4-5
| > >times, once in a race). I'm wondering if this will cause me a
| > >problem in games such as Rallymasters, CMR2 etc.
| >
| > I posted the above here in r.a.s. back in mid February.
| >
| > Well, as the bl**dy thing packed up on me earlier I thought I'd
| > update you.
| >
| > As it says above, you cannot make swift direction changes without
| > running up against the internals. I have found it a problem on a
| > few occasions in GPL but with a 12:1 steering ratio I've generally
| > been able to avoid it.
| >
| > However, when I have run up against it I have noticed a clicking
| > sound, like the nylons cogs where slipping. I'd only had this a
| > few times and generally it didn't seem to effect the steering.
| >
| > Anyway, my eldest son came around the other day and I showed him
| > Super 1 Karting Simulation. This is a pretty good Kart sim but
| > in karting you need to make very swift direction changes. I am
| > a bit more subtle than my son, who uses a Non-FF wheel. Anyway
| > he ran up against these cogs a few times so I kicked him off it.
| >
| > It was now more prevalent and anything more than slowish movement
| > would cause this sound. In Pre-Qual for today race it was happening
| > all thew time for the first half lap then all FF disappeared
| > completely, not even a centering spring. Now all I get is the motor
| > whirring and no FF.
| >
| > So, basically it's bust, in less than 3 months use. While it lasted
| > it was a good wheel, but my suspicions about it's use with games
| > requiring fast steering movement has been proven. It could be that
| > mine was a bad example.
| >
| > Anyone else out there with a Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel have similar
| > observations?
| >
| > Maxx
|
|

Phaso

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Phaso » Mon, 07 May 2001 16:28:50

Don't think so - I haven't had any problems either.  Constantly banging the
wheel lock to lock is gonna bust it eventually, sure.  Just like doing it in
your real car will eventually bust it.  The solution: don't! :)

    -Phasor

    -

Maxx

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Maxx » Mon, 07 May 2001 18:33:07



I've since heard from a couple of other Guillemot users who have never
had this "resistance" that I found. It's not banging the wheel from
to lock, it's more to do with speed of movement, even moving it 1/4
lock but very quickly I had this resistance. And lately this has what
has produced this clicking sound.

I have since investigate the problem (shh) and it appears a belt has
broken inside the wheel. Also, however it appears that the belt has
been badly frayed down one side and the the *** from this is
trapped in the sides of the rollers.

Bottom line is that I think there has always been a fault with the
wheel. As many have said, they have had their wheel much longer
with no problems, and have never felt this resistance which has been
an issue with my wheel form day one.

I'm gonna get it replaced under warranty and we'll see what the
replacement is like.

Maxx

Sjoerd de Roes

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Sjoerd de Roes » Mon, 07 May 2001 20:18:39


I also have the wheel and I love it.
Yes there is a problem when steering very very very fast. But I never had a
problem with it while racing. I never ever steer that fast in a sim. I never
need to.

The wheel is great. The pedals suck but I connected some old thrustmaster
pedals to my gameport and it's great. I can now use the analogue flaps on
the wheel for using the clutch. Awesome. The force feedback effects are very
good and the steering range is great. Not too far like with the act labs but
better than the original logitech.




> > >Oh, there is one thing that is a problem for me. You cannot make
> > >very quick major steering changes with this wheel. i.e. VERY quick
> > >opposite lock. You run up against the internals, not sure what it
> > >is but it really drags. Not a huge issue in GPL (although it has
> > >meant the difference between saving it and losing it at least 4-5
> > >times, once in a race). I'm wondering if this will cause me a
> > >problem in games such as Rallymasters, CMR2 etc.

> > I posted the above here in r.a.s. back in mid February.

> > Well, as the bl**dy thing packed up on me earlier I thought I'd
> > update you.

> > As it says above, you cannot make swift direction changes without
> > running up against the internals. I have found it a problem on a
> > few occasions in GPL but with a 12:1 steering ratio I've generally
> > been able to avoid it.

> > However, when I have run up against it I have noticed a clicking
> > sound, like the nylons cogs where slipping. I'd only had this a
> > few times and generally it didn't seem to effect the steering.

> > Anyway, my eldest son came around the other day and I showed him
> > Super 1 Karting Simulation. This is a pretty good Kart sim but
> > in karting you need to make very swift direction changes. I am
> > a bit more subtle than my son, who uses a Non-FF wheel. Anyway
> > he ran up against these cogs a few times so I kicked him off it.

> > It was now more prevalent and anything more than slowish movement
> > would cause this sound. In Pre-Qual for today race it was happening
> > all thew time for the first half lap then all FF disappeared
> > completely, not even a centering spring. Now all I get is the motor
> > whirring and no FF.

> > So, basically it's bust, in less than 3 months use. While it lasted
> > it was a good wheel, but my suspicions about it's use with games
> > requiring fast steering movement has been proven. It could be that
> > mine was a bad example.

> > Anyone else out there with a Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel have similar
> > observations?

> > Maxx

Thom j

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Thom j » Mon, 07 May 2001 20:48:52

Phasor I just sent one back that was beat to death!!...lol My Bad!
And they still sent a brand new one since it was under warranty!!!
So the only problem I have with the "TM Ferrari Wheel" is Me! I
cant stop running it for 500 to a 1000laps a week.. I do get a tad
over zealous when I race.. "O" well still the TM Ferrari ffb wheel
is just fantastic for me!! Cheers  Thom_j.


| Don't think so - I haven't had any problems either.  Constantly banging
the
| wheel lock to lock is gonna bust it eventually, sure.  Just like doing it
in
| your real car will eventually bust it.  The solution: don't! :)
|
|     -Phasor
|
|     -


| > Ditto on what Iain has stated!! I just don't understand all the problems
| > that folks have with the 'TM aka Guillemot Ferrari FFB Race Wheel?'
| > Odd??......Cheers Thom_j.
|
|
|

Thom j

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Thom j » Mon, 07 May 2001 20:56:44

Maxx,   I just got a brand new one {as posted before} and I got it
fast too!! Just make sure you get ur RMA info and verification ID#.
I sent it out and got a new one back in just over a week!!
Good Luck Thom_j.



|
| >Don't think so - I haven't had any problems either.  Constantly banging
the
| >wheel lock to lock is gonna bust it eventually, sure.  Just like doing it
in
| >your real car will eventually bust it.  The solution: don't! :)
| >
| >    -Phasor
|
| I've since heard from a couple of other Guillemot users who have never
| had this "resistance" that I found. It's not banging the wheel from
| to lock, it's more to do with speed of movement, even moving it 1/4
| lock but very quickly I had this resistance. And lately this has what
| has produced this clicking sound.
|
| I have since investigate the problem (shh) and it appears a belt has
| broken inside the wheel. Also, however it appears that the belt has
| been badly frayed down one side and the the *** from this is
| trapped in the sides of the rollers.
|
| Bottom line is that I think there has always been a fault with the
| wheel. As many have said, they have had their wheel much longer
| with no problems, and have never felt this resistance which has been
| an issue with my wheel form day one.
|
| I'm gonna get it replaced under warranty and we'll see what the
| replacement is like.
|
| Maxx

Thomas C Norwo

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Thomas C Norwo » Mon, 07 May 2001 22:10:43

I have tried mine briefly in Mobil 1 Rally Championship,
where it is VERY sensitive.  But I haven't tried playing
with the deadzone/sensitivity settings yet.

Also tried it briefly in NFS4; what a difference from a
Gravis Gamepad! :)

I've used it extensively in NFS:PU and F1CS2000 and love it.
I've had it for about 3 months and am hooked.  I haven't noticed
the described problem at all, and I'm trying to be gentle with
the paddle shifters. :)

My next adventures after F1CS2000 are MBTR, GPL, GP3, NFS4, and M1RC;
I've got some "work" to do. :)

   - Tom N.

Peter Ive

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Peter Ive » Tue, 08 May 2001 02:53:54




>om>

>>Don't think so - I haven't had any problems either.  Constantly banging the
>>wheel lock to lock is gonna bust it eventually, sure.  Just like doing it in
>>your real car will eventually bust it.  The solution: don't! :)

>>    -Phasor

>I've since heard from a couple of other Guillemot users who have never
>had this "resistance" that I found. It's not banging the wheel from
>to lock, it's more to do with speed of movement, even moving it 1/4
>lock but very quickly I had this resistance. And lately this has what
>has produced this clicking sound.

Yes Maxx, my Thrustmaster Ferrari wheel does the same.  It happens
during ultra fast attempts at changing the wheel direction over about a
45+ degree of change.  I get a sudden resistance that isn't there during
normal smooth or shorter steering changes.  I've been wondering whether
it is to do with the gain settings in the controllers app.  In my case,
because I haven't got FF enabled, I've reduced all those settings down
to zero and the 'Default Spring' down to 8% so far, but still feel it.
Will try reducing DS down to 0% to see if it goes away.
--
Peter Ives
Remove ALL_STRESS before replying
If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me
GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel +15.11
Thom j

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Thom j » Tue, 08 May 2001 03:58:09

Dag Thomas with all those new titles below you sure will be bizzy! haha
Enjoy! Btw: I just love my TM Ferrari FFB too & it kicks Arse in GPL
but make sure to go GTX-SLOT's site aka Gary to get the core.ini sets
for the Ferrari wheel! Here is the Url..
http://www.slottweak.com/gamesettings.htm
Also go into the rest of his site as he has an enitre "Fix'it" for Ferrari &
many other wheels!! This guys is good & he doesnt pay me for saying
this either!! <g>
Cheers Thom_j.
Btw, This is his opening page: http://www.slottweak.com/



| I have tried mine briefly in Mobil 1 Rally Championship,
| where it is VERY sensitive.  But I haven't tried playing
| with the deadzone/sensitivity settings yet.
|
| Also tried it briefly in NFS4; what a difference from a
| Gravis Gamepad! :)
|
| I've used it extensively in NFS:PU and F1CS2000 and love it.
| I've had it for about 3 months and am hooked.  I haven't noticed
| the described problem at all, and I'm trying to be gentle with
| the paddle shifters. :)
|
| My next adventures after F1CS2000 are MBTR, GPL, GP3, NFS4, and M1RC;
| I've got some "work" to do. :)
|
|    - Tom N.
|

Tim Wheatle

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Tim Wheatle » Tue, 08 May 2001 08:22:50

I, am again here to say I've not had a single problem with mine yet, BUT a lot of people have. I
would heartily advise people to stay clear of the Ferrari FF, simply because so many people have
problems with it.





> > You're absolutely right. I bought one and a couple of hours of Colin McRae
> > sent it back to the store to change it for a Microsoft FF.

> > Regards

> I also have the wheel and I love it.
> Yes there is a problem when steering very very very fast. But I never had a
> problem with it while racing. I never ever steer that fast in a sim. I never
> need to.

> The wheel is great. The pedals suck but I connected some old thrustmaster
> pedals to my gameport and it's great. I can now use the analogue flaps on
> the wheel for using the clutch. Awesome. The force feedback effects are very
> good and the steering range is great. Not too far like with the act labs but
> better than the original logitech.




> > > >Oh, there is one thing that is a problem for me. You cannot make
> > > >very quick major steering changes with this wheel. i.e. VERY quick
> > > >opposite lock. You run up against the internals, not sure what it
> > > >is but it really drags. Not a huge issue in GPL (although it has
> > > >meant the difference between saving it and losing it at least 4-5
> > > >times, once in a race). I'm wondering if this will cause me a
> > > >problem in games such as Rallymasters, CMR2 etc.

> > > I posted the above here in r.a.s. back in mid February.

> > > Well, as the bl**dy thing packed up on me earlier I thought I'd
> > > update you.

> > > As it says above, you cannot make swift direction changes without
> > > running up against the internals. I have found it a problem on a
> > > few occasions in GPL but with a 12:1 steering ratio I've generally
> > > been able to avoid it.

> > > However, when I have run up against it I have noticed a clicking
> > > sound, like the nylons cogs where slipping. I'd only had this a
> > > few times and generally it didn't seem to effect the steering.

> > > Anyway, my eldest son came around the other day and I showed him
> > > Super 1 Karting Simulation. This is a pretty good Kart sim but
> > > in karting you need to make very swift direction changes. I am
> > > a bit more subtle than my son, who uses a Non-FF wheel. Anyway
> > > he ran up against these cogs a few times so I kicked him off it.

> > > It was now more prevalent and anything more than slowish movement
> > > would cause this sound. In Pre-Qual for today race it was happening
> > > all thew time for the first half lap then all FF disappeared
> > > completely, not even a centering spring. Now all I get is the motor
> > > whirring and no FF.

> > > So, basically it's bust, in less than 3 months use. While it lasted
> > > it was a good wheel, but my suspicions about it's use with games
> > > requiring fast steering movement has been proven. It could be that
> > > mine was a bad example.

> > > Anyone else out there with a Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel have similar
> > > observations?

> > > Maxx

Some Call Me Ti

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Some Call Me Ti » Tue, 08 May 2001 09:45:21


lot of people have. I
because so many people have

Mine's been great and I've had it for over a year. It's very robust, feels
very solid and has the best FF effects I've tried. It's still as good as the
day I bought it. Some owners had problems with early models paddles braking
but later ones like mine are improved.

The slowness is the damping, simply turn it down to 0.

--
Some Call Me Tim

Larr

Guillemot Ferrari FF wheel - Warning

by Larr » Wed, 09 May 2001 01:31:36

Maybe it's emulating being low on Power Steering Fluid ?

Wow, what a wheel!

:)

Larry





> >om>

> >>Don't think so - I haven't had any problems either.  Constantly banging
the
> >>wheel lock to lock is gonna bust it eventually, sure.  Just like doing
it in
> >>your real car will eventually bust it.  The solution: don't! :)

> >>    -Phasor

> >I've since heard from a couple of other Guillemot users who have never
> >had this "resistance" that I found. It's not banging the wheel from
> >to lock, it's more to do with speed of movement, even moving it 1/4
> >lock but very quickly I had this resistance. And lately this has what
> >has produced this clicking sound.

> Yes Maxx, my Thrustmaster Ferrari wheel does the same.  It happens
> during ultra fast attempts at changing the wheel direction over about a
> 45+ degree of change.  I get a sudden resistance that isn't there during
> normal smooth or shorter steering changes.  I've been wondering whether
> it is to do with the gain settings in the controllers app.  In my case,
> because I haven't got FF enabled, I've reduced all those settings down
> to zero and the 'Default Spring' down to 8% so far, but still feel it.
> Will try reducing DS down to 0% to see if it goes away.
> --
> Peter Ives
> Remove ALL_STRESS before replying
> If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me
> GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel +15.11


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.