rec.autos.simulators

Thomas Super Wheel?

Randy Magrud

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Randy Magrud » Sat, 31 Jul 1999 04:00:00

I'd take a TSW over an ECCI any day, and yes I've tried both.  I
didn't like the feel of the ECCI at all, and the TSW is liquid smooth
and very sturdy.


>I opened my TSW up when I had it, and you are correct.....it is very, very primative electronically.  Almost looks like something that was made in 6th grade shop class.  I've since been using my ECCI, and the quality of the electronics is like night and day compared to the TSW.....looks very profressionally done.



>    Hi,
>    I'm considering buying a wheel from Thomas Super Wheel (TSW).  Can those
>    of you who tried a TSW wheel tell me if they think it's worth the price?
>    Or do you have another wheel to recommend?

>    I bought a TSW three years ago, apparently right in the middle of a power struggle within the company.
>    Unaware of this, I ordered the wheel and sent them a big fat check ($360) up front.  Almost three months later, the wheel arrived.  It didn't work.  The pedals would not calibrate.  I immediately contacted them and got no answer.  I sent emails, snail mails and finally got permission to sent the thing back for repairs (at my own expense ($26.00)) two months after I received it!
>  It took another two months before they sent me a new unit.  In essence, it took seven months to get a workable TSW.  That's the bad news.
>  The good news is that the thing is mechanically indestructable.  It's smooth, solid and feels wonderful.  MECHANICAL repairs are a snap and adding custom springs, steering wheels and such is easy, especially if you're handy with machine tools.

>  Electronically, however, it's primitive.  Aside from the original electronic problems, I've also got a defective mini-plug (the plug from the pedal unit to the wheel) which keeps losing contact (which, in GPL, causes all kinds of disconcerting maladies) and requires some frantic manipulation of plug and wire to regain control.  I've toyed with the idea of sending it back for repairs, but I don't know if I want to wait another three months.The thing that irked me the most was the almost total indifference to me, their customer.  I got no apology, or no offer to pay for the shipping of the defective unit or even an acknowledgement of the problem -- at least for two months.  Granted, I'm just some aging machinist from Massachusetts, but I expected a bit more for $400.

>  --
>  Bob Curtin
>  Worcester Area Strategy & Tactics Exchange
>  http://www.racesimcentral.net/
>  "If God had intended man to join the Army he would have given us green, baggy skin"

Randy Magruder
http://www.racesimcentral.net/
Bob Curti

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Bob Curti » Sat, 31 Jul 1999 04:00:00


>   I opened my TSW up when I had it, and you are correct.....it is
> very, very primative electronically.  Almost looks like something that
> was made in 6th grade shop class.  I've since been using my ECCI, and
> the quality of the electronics is like night and day compared to the
> TSW.....looks very profressionally done.

Well now, let us not go overboard here.  Yes, the electronics are a bit
primitive.  No, it's not something from a 6th grade shop class.  Bear in
mind that except for the funky mini-plug, (something I could probably
get repaired easily if I had any faith in Thomas Enterprises service,
which I don't) the only problems I've had with my TSW is two worn-out
pots, which I replaced myself easily in less than ten minutes..

Again, the TSW is holding up just fine.  It's the way I was treated by
TE (i.e. with suspicion, indifference and a
we'll-get-around-to-it-someday-Why-should-we-hurry-when-we've-already-got-your-money
attitude.).  As you can see, three years later, I'm still pissed and
leery enough of their service department's -- shall we say -- casual
turnaround time, to endure the defective mini-plug rather than send it
back and be without a controller for another three or four months.

--
Bob Curtin
Worcester Area Strategy & Tactics Exchange
http://www.tiac.net/users/ten10ths/
"If God had intended man to join the Army he would have given us green,
baggy skin"

Adam

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Adam » Sat, 31 Jul 1999 04:00:00


>It does look a bit "high-school-shop"

Adam

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Adam » Sat, 31 Jul 1999 04:00:00

    Dave, its better of you to send a personal e-mail to him to resolve the issue.  By calling him a liar in a public forum is beyond professionalism.  In fact, it drives home the point he was trying to make about your business.  Go back to your mom-and-pop operation, and hook up the Fisher Price Workshop.  Maybe if you spent more time building them wheel-thingies, rather then seeing what everyone has to say about you, you might be able to cut some time off of your FOUR MONTH waiting period for a wheel
    That is a very, VERY bad thing to tell one of your customers.....to tell them to "run down to radio shack" to fix a problem, instead of YOU making it right in the first place.


   ....you could run down to Radio Shack and get the problem fixed in about a day, without having to even contact us.

Joel Willstei

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Joel Willstei » Sat, 31 Jul 1999 04:00:00

Bob,

    Well said. As more and more sims come online with Force Feedback equal
to or better than what we now have in gpl,you will be hard pressed not to
have a decent FF wheel to be able to experience it,and the sim to the max.

     I both emailed and read emails from Dave jr at TSW. And if you read
between the lines,they are slowly coming to that realization.
Certainly,within a few years,FF will be the norm not the exception. One has
to change with the times,or be buried by those very times.

Joel Willstein

remo

Thomas Super Wheel?

by remo » Sat, 31 Jul 1999 04:00:00

I think things have changed considerably in the last three years. Your
experience sounds like a nightmare. However, I recently sent my TSW to
them for repair of the shifter and a few upgrades ( GT wheel, split
axis, plug-in wiring, extra buttons and paddles) and had a wonderful
experience. Dave Sr. was very helpful on the phone getting things sorted
out. They changed the shifter, gave me a new ball-bearing steering shaft
and gave me a new covers for both parts of the unit, all under warranty.
And all the upgrades have been everything i had hoped. I love the suede
covered GT wheel. The time from shipping it to them and recieving it
back was under 2 weeks without express or overnight delivery. I am very
glad I sent it in for the repairs and upgrades and recommend that route
for anybody thinking about it. But I'd have to say that if I had to wait
3-4 months i'd still be pissed myself.
            Peter
The Black Cat =^..

Thomas Super Wheel?

by The Black Cat =^.. » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00

I would like to say at this point that I've known Trevor since he
first started building wheels in his garage and I have never known
anyone associated with Thomas Enterprises to behave in the manner you
suggest.  I've always been treated politely and with respect and my
needs were promptly attended to.

Regarding the appearance of a TSW, I would suggest you look at the
interior of a Ferrari racing car -- there may be bare metal and the
finish may be rough but it's ideal in its function.  The TSW is easy
to work on, even for someone with ten thumbs like me and lasts
forever.  The only reason to spend more is for the supposed prestige
of the name, not the quality of the product.  

Randy Magrud

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Randy Magrud » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00


>Again, the TSW is holding up just fine.  It's the way I was treated by
>TE (i.e. with suspicion, indifference and a
>we'll-get-around-to-it-someday-Why-should-we-hurry-when-we've-already-got-your-money
>attitude.).  As you can see, three years later, I'm still pissed and
>leery enough of their service department's -- shall we say -- casual
>turnaround time,

I'm sorry, are you saying that your actual first-hand experience with
TE's service is 3 years old?!  Boy you DO hold a grudge, don't you?  
I really hope that those reading this thread get other opinions before
rendering a decision.  A small outfit like TE can definitely have
problems early in its life which it streamlines and corrects over
time.  Have you any evidence that TE's current support for their
products is identical to what yours was THREE YEARS AGO?!

Randy
Randy Magruder
http://members.home.com/rmagruder

Randy Magrud

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Randy Magrud » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00

Sorry, but I don't think there is anything wrong at all with Dave
defending himself publicly when he is attacked publicly.  I generally
agree that grievances like this should be addressed in private and not
in newsgroups, but surely you see that if Dave lets this stand without
challenging it, potential customers might interpret that as an tacit
admission of guilt.  If Dave's got records that dispute this, or this
guy really is lying in order to publicly badmouth TE, and is doing so
PUBLICLY, then Dave has every right to set the record straight.
Remember, this is his livelihood.

Randy


>    Dave, its better of you to send a personal e-mail to him to resolve the issue.  By calling him a liar in a public forum is beyond professionalism.  In fact, it drives home the point he was trying to make about your business.  Go back to your mom-and-pop operation, and hook up the Fisher Price Workshop.  Maybe if you spent more time building them wheel-thingies, rather then seeing what everyone has to say about you, you might be able to cut some time off of your FOUR MONTH waiting period for a wheel
>    That is a very, VERY bad thing to tell one of your customers.....to tell them to "run down to radio shack" to fix a problem, instead of YOU making it right in the first place.


>   ....you could run down to Radio Shack and get the problem fixed in about a day, without having to even contact us.

Randy Magruder
http://members.home.com/rmagruder
Eldre

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Eldre » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00


>Maybe if you spent more time =
>building them wheel-thingies, rather then seeing what everyone has to =
>say about you, you might be able to cut some time off of your FOUR MONTH =
>waiting period for a wheel

FOUR MONTH?!?  Damn, if I order NOW, I might not get it until Xmas???

__

Put your message in a modem, and throw it in the ***-sea...
remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Sean Higgin

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Sean Higgin » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00

Exactly the same reason I will NEVER do any sort of business with TE again.  

--
Sean Higgins

"HigPup"
http://home.sprintmail.com/~higgy/hsts2/  HSTS, Powered by ATI Rage 128
http://home.sprintmail.com/~higgy/  
http://www.colormation.com   Colormation (sponsor of H.O. Motorsports)
http://www.atitech.ca   ATI Technologies

    Again, the TSW is holding up just fine.  It's the way I was treated by TE (i.e. with suspicion, indifference and a we'll-get-around-to-it-someday-Why-should-we-hurry-when-we've-already-got-your-money attitude.).  

Nathan Wo

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Nathan Wo » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00


>    Dave, its better of you to send a personal e-mail to him to resolve =
>the issue.  By calling him a liar in a public forum is beyond =
>professionalism.  In fact, it drives home the point he was trying to =

If he has documentation to prove the wheel was only in their workshop
for 2 days, who are you to say he is lying either? Obviously there is
a problem here, whether its the postal service (or whatever was used
to have it delivered), or something else needs to be determined.
Perhaps the memory and bitterness built up over 3 years has distorted
the true facts? Perhaps it hasnt. Perhaps it was something out of
control of either party, in which case, neither is to blame?

Maybe you should try running a business sometime? Maybe you should try
and make a successful well-received product which gives a lot of
people a lot of fun? Maybe you should show some balls and post using a
real name and address? Gutless wonders like you are what everyone here
doesn't need.

Dave is suggesting this as an alternative to having to send the wheel
away for repair. If the customer wants it done in 10 minutes, it woul
dbe easier to visit Radio Shack. If he wants it done by TSW, then he
sends it back to them, but it takes longer (naturally).

--
Nathan Wong             http://www.nectar.com.au/~alfacors
                      Super Touring - Club Cars - Alfa Romeo

                            http://fullspeed.to/astc
                   Australian Super Touring News and Information

Bob Curti

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Bob Curti » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00


> I'm sorry, are you saying that your actual first-hand experience with
> TE's service is 3 years old?!  Boy you DO hold a grudge, don't you?
> I really hope that those reading this thread get other opinions before
> rendering a decision.  A small outfit like TE can definitely have
> problems early in its life which it streamlines and corrects over
> time.  Have you any evidence that TE's current support for their
> products is identical to what yours was THREE YEARS AGO?!

 Mr. Magruder, this whole thing started with a request from somebody posting a message on
RAS asking for opinions on the TSW, (since he was thinking of buying one).  Unlike most
American consumers (who are sheep who have this irrational desire to be loved by those
with whom they do business and will buy something for no other reason than their friends
like it.) I have absolutely no "brand loyalty."  I ordered a TSW because it had a good
reputation and a lifetime mechanical guarantee.  I was sick of replacing Thrustmaster
wheels every year and wanted a unit which'd stand up to the amount of hours that I
require.  I told the guy what my experience was.  If that offends some Thomas Enterprises
fans out there, too bad.

I have nothing against the TSW.  Mechanically, my wheel has met all of my expectations.
It is smooth as Michael Jordan's pate, solid as the Matterhorn and easier to work on than
than a '57 Chevy.  Electronically, it's not up to the same standards, BUT it still does
the job.  Do I regret buying a TSW?  No.  Quite the contrary.  Did I advise the man not
to buy a TSW?  No, I did not.  In fact, at the beginning of my message I explained that I
had ordered the TSW apparently during some sort of company upheaval.  I couldn't care any
less now than I did three years ago what Thomas Enterprises' problems are.  I did
business with them for mutual benefit.  I expected them to make a profit selling me a
WORKING unit that I'd be happy with.  That TE lost their profit from my sale because of
their screwup is not my problem.

Yes, Mr. Magruder, you're right.  A small company can have problems.  But there is no
excuse for any company, new or old, to treat their customers as combatants or
adversaries, especially when the reason for the problem is because of a defective unit.
Everyone makes mistakes.  It's how you handle those mistakes that separate the
professionals from the amateurs.  If I was running TE and had seen my posting, I would
have done three things immediately.

First, I would have replied to the offended party PRIVATELY and offered to make the
product right, not tell them publicly to take a hike to the nearest RadShack.  I would
have had the customer send it back at company expense and I would have given it
priority.  I would have fixed the problem, done any upgrades available and sent it back
much better than received.

Second, I would have checked company procedures and lines of communications and made
damned sure that nothing like this ever happened again.  Customers are not adversaries
and should never be treated as such -- even when they're wrong.

Thirdly, I'd try to find out why the product was defective in the first place and alter
the design, manufacturing process or materials to correct it.

Under no circumstances would I call a customer a liar just to save face, especially in a
public forum.  If anyone in my company ever did a thing like that, (s)he'd be fired
immediately.

--
Bob Curtin
Worcester Area Strategy & Tactics Exchange
http://www.tiac.net/users/ten10ths/
"If God had intended man to join the Army he would have given us green, baggy skin"

Randy Magrud

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Randy Magrud » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00


> Mr. Magruder, this whole thing started with a request from somebody posting a message on
>RAS asking for opinions on the TSW, (since he was thinking of buying one).  Unlike most
>American consumers (who are sheep who have this irrational desire to be loved by those
>with whom they do business and will buy something for no other reason than their friends
>like it.)

Baaaahhh Baaaaahhh <g>.   Americans are sheep in many ways, but brand
loyalty isn't one of them, unless a brand has inspired such confidence
that it inspires repeat business.

Nor do I.

Sounds like me.

I accept that.  I'm not excusing anything that happened to you now or
three years ago.  What AM saying is that if TE has cleaned up their
act since, or that your experience was not indicative of what others
experience, they have a right to set that straight.  My experience
with them has been very good, for example.  Of course, if they tell me
how I can fix some problem myself or send it back in, it's my choice.
How many people send their broken-springed Thrustmasters back to TSW
versus just getting new springs and replacing them by themselves?
It's a choice each company gives you:  You fix it, or we'll fix it.
Most people don't want to be without a wheel so they fix it
themselves.

Let me ask you this.  Did they refuse to fix it?  Or were they
offering you a way to deal with the problem that would be quicker and
cheaper than shipping the unit to them?

But customers who trash a company publicly CAN be corrected by someone
in the company if they are wrong.  Bigger companies hire PR people to
make "statements", a company like TE is too small for that so they
have to defend themselves and they are obviously not professional PR
people.  I would not defend them trashing a customer here, but I do
support their right to defend themselves, particularly if someone is
trying to infer that everyone is unhappy with their service, when in
reality it might be only a small % (and if you are being truthful
you'd admit that there isn't a single company out there that doesn't
have some % of dissatisfied or angry customers).

If it were just "saving face" I'd agree with you, but since people
here tend to be the biggest potential customers of their product, and
this IS their livelihood, if a customer tells a lie, and the company
has evidence to demonstrate that its a lie, I am GLAD they spoke up
and pointed it out.  This IS the Internet, after all, and people say
LOTS of things they can't back up.  Let's say, for example, that I
grew up with Dave Thomas and he stole and married my girlfriend.  Now
as an *** I might have an axe to grind, so I go on the Internet and
begin trashing his new company, calling his product garbage and his
customer support terrible.  Customers are reading this and turning to
alternative products, meaning my slam tactics are working.  Is that
right?  The above is just an example (I don't know anyone in that
company personally).  The point is, if someone tries to drive off your
customers by telling a lie, there's NOTHING wrong with disputing it.
If the customer does so publicly, then the company has the right to
defend itself publicly.  TE is not a huge company where an internet
malcontent doesn't matter.  It DOES matter because their market is a
niche market and every unrefuted bad report on them has the ability to
impact their livelihood.  

I will also add that if it were a matter of opinion, the company
should keep it's mouth shut.  If I own a TSW and tell everyone I'm
unhappy with the way it was built and don't like the feel of it, the
TSW reps have no business telling me I'm "wrong".  It's a matter of
opinion.  But if TSW has records demonstrating that someone is trying
to slander them publicly, I believe they have the right to demonstrate
that, so as not to allow potential customers (again, in this NICHE
market) to be frightened off by something untrue.

Finally, I don't know the truth on this and don't claim to.  The
customer could be right and TSW could be lying for all I know.  I'm
only arguing that IF TE is telling the truth they have the right to
investigate it and supply the evidence.  If that means telling
everyone that  customer is fibbing, then fine.

Randy

Randy Magruder
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Eldre

Thomas Super Wheel?

by Eldre » Sun, 01 Aug 1999 04:00:00


>Yes, Mr. Magruder, you're right.  A small company can have problems.  But
>there is no
>excuse for any company, new or old, to treat their customers as combatants or
>adversaries, especially when the reason for the problem is because of a
>defective unit.
>Everyone makes mistakes.  It's how you handle those mistakes that separate
>the
>professionals from the amateurs.  If I was running TE and had seen my
>posting, I would
>have done three things immediately.

>First, I would have replied to the offended party PRIVATELY and offered to
>make the
>product right, not tell them publicly to take a hike to the nearest RadShack.
>I would
>have had the customer send it back at company expense and I would have given
>it
>priority.  I would have fixed the problem, done any upgrades available and
>sent it back
>much better than received.

The problem is that on the internet/newsgroup, one bad comment from an irate
customer can be read by THOUSANDS.  What's the potential for customer loss
here?  Too much.  Therefore, you(meaning the companies) really DO need to
respond publicly, and make sure the customer is COMPLETELY satisfied.  It would
have been better if the satisfaction was finished BEFORE the customer got
pissed enough to post in a public newsgroup, but that's another story.  
You also hear stories about someone who wasn't happy with their purchase, but
the company bent over backwards to rectify the situation.  If the company has
good service AFTER the sale, I'd still consider doing business with them...as
long as the service wasn't needed OFTEN.

Eldred

__

Put your message in a modem, and throw it in the ***-sea...
remove SPAM-OFF to reply.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.