rec.autos.simulators

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

Hena Hakkane

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Hena Hakkane » Wed, 01 Sep 1999 04:00:00


> Yo David!

> It's just the opposite here in Europe :))) It's almost impossible to see
Nascar
> or Cart race here. Eurosport shows only about 10 races in a year. All you

can

Excuse me? AFAIK Eurosport airs all CART races, most of them live. Nascar?
Don't much care for ...

Hena

--
Best regards,
Hena H?kk?nen

Remove NOSPAM to email me!

The Mocke

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by The Mocke » Wed, 01 Sep 1999 04:00:00

Typos have killed me again.
I don't think further discussion is possible. As an ardent supporter of the
event known as F1 racing you are simply following the party line, defending
your chosen favorite as any fan would. I feel that I have tried to raise
valid concerns as to the skill level of these drivers, which you have
attempted to refute. I remain unconvinced. The fact that former touring car
drivers have raced F1 or vice versa, and they had been able to control the
car in that class, I feel strengthens my argument. Why could they control
one type of car and not another? I know the power to weight ratio is much
higher in an F1 car, but with the much larger *** and wings on those cars
they should be at LEAST as easy to control. In the few times I have tried to
watch F1 racing I have not seen that. What I have seen, the mad dash to
first corner, followed by the "follow the leader" style of racing has not
interested me, or many others I might add. But that is all I want to say
about this topic. The event known as F1 will continue, and we will even have
one here in the States soon. Will a hundred thousand people show up for this
event, most likely. Can even half of them name one quarter of the drivers in
the field, probably not. But it will be a great event I'm sure.
At least until the World League of American football eclipses soccer as the
worlds favorite sport.

The Mocker

.

Wayne Hutchiso

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Wayne Hutchiso » Wed, 01 Sep 1999 04:00:00

Granted the technology and the drivers' salaries are superior in F1, but
sadly the actual racing often isn't. NASCAR of course is generally in the
1960's technology wise (albeit a little more advanced in the areas of
aerodynamics and dampers). Given this, if there are enough properly placed
caution periods at a track with more than one racing groove, NASCAR can put
on a good show/race. CART rides the middle ground in that it has a fairly
high level of technology and rules that generate close racing (full course
yellows).

Maybe the reason that F1 isn't very big in the USA is that there are no
American teams or drivers. What would happen if Penske/Gurney/Matsushita put
an American F1 team together with drivers like Tony Stewart and Jeff Gordon?
Americans might actually watch F1 just to see how "their" team is doing.
Here in Canada, F1 is popular due to the presence of Jacques Villeneuve, but
even if he wasn't there, the memory of his father Gilles Villeneuve would
keep most people tuning in every 2 weeks.

Wayne Hutchison



> NASCAR ruins racing here in the U.S. as far as I'm concerned. It hogs the
TV
> broadcasts and makes it impossible for F1 to make a dent in the U.S.
market.
> F1 is infinitely superior in every way IMO.

> David G Fisher



> > Hi,
> >     Reading all of these posts debating NASCAR/F1, I realized how lucky
I
> > am to live here in Canada!  Up here we get all of the F1/CART races and
a
> > vast majority (if not all) of the NASCAR races!

david kar

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by david kar » Wed, 01 Sep 1999 04:00:00


That's what I thought you were doing.  It was subtle.

That's just SUCH utter bullsh*t.  Have you even begun to consider the
differences between the actual vehicles being driven???  What do CART, IRL
and F1 cars have in common?  Very stiff suspensions, very high downforce . .
.  I'll leave it to some more technically-inclined RAS'er to educate you on
this, but even I saw a serious hole in your knee-jerk reaction.

A hole as big as the sun is hot.

[snip]

mocked.

--DK

ymenar

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by ymenar » Thu, 02 Sep 1999 04:00:00


I remember that ;-)

Btw, there is really School bus racing in the US on those short tracks.
Well up here we have Ski-doo oval racing (Gilles Villeneuve was the best
driver for that ever), so we aren't really better than down there ;)

--
-- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...

"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."

ymenar

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by ymenar » Thu, 02 Sep 1999 04:00:00


He's a Villeneuve, like his Father.  He can't accept to go slower.  For him
it's always at the limit, whatever car he drives.  That's why he was mad to
finish the Spa race.  He would had prefered to push the car to the limit all
race long and not finish than to what he did, lift a little so that they
could finish back in 15th.  He was really mad btw in interviews after the
race :)    .

He's the only F1 driver who doesn't lift in Eau Rouge these days IIRC.  His
father would be proud.

Hehe, he's a Qubecer ;-)

--
-- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...

"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."

buzar

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by buzar » Thu, 02 Sep 1999 04:00:00

I grew up watching races at a small oval. I like almost all forms
of auto racing. Seems like those who are only exposed to road
courses never like anything else!

Canada???? Try California!! Only thing we don't have is ice
racing!!! We consider that a plus....but you opinion may vary!

buzard


Schlom

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Schlom » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00

Umm ok yea Clark and Hill won at Indy and yes they were both from F1.  But have
you ever considered the fact that Nelson Piquet (an F1 driver) never even came
close to winning Indy.  Emmo and Jaques and Zanardi are others like Hill and
Clark,  theyre good no matter what they drive.  But in the case of guys like
Schumacher and Hakkanin...they prolly havent a clue what to do in a CART car
other than the fact they have a vauge idea how the areodynamics work on it.
SO....saying F1 drivers are better that CART drivers is bullsh*t and you all
know it.  The fact is if u put them both in equal cars (ie. a PRODUCTION MODEL
Ford Taurus, Pontiac Firebird, Renault Laguna, Audi A4....etc) theyre gonna
drive them at about the same rate.  Theyre almost equally matched in that case.
 CART guys are good in CART cars and F1 guys are good in F1 cars.  Add a few
NASCAR guys in there youll have 3 types of drivers equally matched in equal
cars.  None are better than others...just better at the praticular type of
racing they do.

Chris

Schlom

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Schlom » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00

Ok i take that back...i did see him on the podium when i watched the race in
replay.  Guess i got caught on that one <g>

Chris

Matthew Birger Knutse

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Matthew Birger Knutse » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00

<snip>

Good point!
I remember the swap when they put Colin McRae in a Jordan F1 and Martin Brundle in
a rally car, they both were fast in the "wrong" cars, but Mr. Brundle had trouble
keeping the car the right side up...:)

IMO, the rally drivers are the ones who'll adapt to other race cars the best, I
mean, they are probably the craziest people on the earth anyway....!
:-)

Matt

--
---------------------------------
Matthew Birger Knutsen

The Art of Legends;
http://www.gpl.electra.no

Cheek Racing Cars;
http://www.cheekracing.electra.no

Vinc

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Vinc » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00


I think Coulthard was supposed to help Hakkinen in getting the WC. So,
he was expected to let Mika gain the greatest advantage on Irvine, 5
points instead of 1, especially because on Sunday it was supposed that
Schumacher would have come back in Monza. Now the situation is quite
different and Irvine has very small chances to win the championship.
Anyway, it was the same reason for Salo let Irvine pass him.
--
---------------------------------------------------------------------

   Home-page : http://www.geocities.com/CapeCanaveral/Hangar/7917
    Il sito di ISF1mod : http://www.blissett.com/isf1/index.html
---------------------------------------------------------------------

Vinc

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Vinc » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00



Eurosport covers all the CART races, plus highlights from IRL, LM, and
I think also NASCAR
--
---------------------------------------------------------------------

   Home-page : http://www.geocities.com/CapeCanaveral/Hangar/7917
    Il sito di ISF1mod : http://www.blissett.com/isf1/index.html
---------------------------------------------------------------------

Meij

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by Meij » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00

Nope... there are no team orders at McLaren yet. Mika was whining because
he at first felt DC had been a bit unfair at the start, not because DC won.
He's since apologised for the comments and said DC was 100% right to do
what he did.

In any case... MS isn't coming back for at least another month.

M



John Walla

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by John Walla » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00



Only when he has no chance of winning the WC himself - last Sunday
(and now) he still has a chance and has the full support of the team
to race Hakkinen.

Not true - he was supposed to go and try to win the rac.

Cheers!
John

John Walla

If you don't understand stock car racing or road racing move to Canada! :) <G>

by John Walla » Fri, 03 Sep 1999 04:00:00



A proposition isn't valid simply because you make it - to say that F1
drivers lack the skill of car control is such a bizarre assertion that
it requires a lot of backing up, none of which has been apparent so
far.

You're not supposed to be convinced - you are making wild assertions
therefore the onus of proof is on you.

Er, what?

It's not former TC drivers that have raced in F1, its former F1
drivers that have raced in TC. In any case, the drivers were perfectly
capable of controlling either type of car.

 I know the power to weight ratio is much

Why? Any driver who has ever made such a transition from F1 to another
formulae has pointed out the much wider tolerances afforded by
Indycars, Touring Cars, GT cars or whatever. In F1 because of the
level of competition and the way the rules and innovations have forced
the cars to be developed, the cars are constantly on a knife edge if
you want to run quickly. When the car loses control it happens
incredibly quickly, so if a driver in an F1 car is sliding a car
around you can be sure that it takes extreme talent to keep it all
together.

However, what you should also remember is that when you are sliding a
car around you are losing time - the car is slower, you're burning up
your tyres and losing acceleration. It takes more skill to drive at
that speed and NOT slide the car.

I won't be holding my breath!

Cheers!
John


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.