rec.autos.simulators

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

mcewen

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by mcewen » Fri, 07 Jan 2005 01:36:08

It's inevitable that sites started/maintained by 1 or 2 individuals
which are useful enough to become hugely popular like rsc, theuspits,
GPL track database, GPLrank etc. will close.  It's not a matter of
"if" they close it's "when".

People get burned out, tired of the abuse, discover a life away from
their computer screen, get married/divorced/remarried, run out of
funding (see previous item), get hit by buses, etc...

It's also almost a given that the really innovative and/or useful
sites, like those mentioned above, are going to be set up by 1 or 2
individuals and not a corporation or committee.  Along with a lot of
***or copy sites of course, but Darwin's laws will take care of
those...

However once they're established a vital service the sim community
and burnout is looming on the horizon it would nice if these guys had
the option of turning their baby over to a committee-like structure
such as FILSCA.  Then we'd have the best of worlds, innovative
websites developed independently and a more stable "share the
workload" organization to take it over when it looks like they could
be lost.

If even half of the exampled above were handed over to FILSCA to be
maintained, secured, and continue to evolve then I'd be willing to
pay them $5-10 a year for access..

Of course the developers would have to be willing to live with the loss
of control that handing it over truly means (I'm sure some would rather
close).

And FILSCA would have to get over the "we didn't build it
ourselves" thing.  I know, I know FILSCA is for leagues, but you
can't have leagues without drivers first..

Phil Le

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by Phil Le » Sat, 08 Jan 2005 00:08:34


> It's inevitable that sites started/maintained by 1 or 2 individuals
> which are useful enough to become hugely popular like rsc, theuspits,
> GPL track database, GPLrank etc. will close.  It's not a matter of
> "if" they close it's "when".

Sorry to dash your hopes but there is no chance of us handing RSC over
to anyone. The admin team are working hard to get the site back up and
running as we speak. In the last day we have overcome a huge hurdle that
has been preventing this and now finally feel we are making progress
towards getting the forum back online.

Cheers

Phil Lee
RSC Administrator

Jaspe

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by Jaspe » Sat, 08 Jan 2005 02:24:09

God no, please dont hand it over to FILSCA couldnt imagine anything worse
quite frankly, they already seem to to think they control simracing so
please dont give them anything more to inflate that opinion.



>> It's inevitable that sites started/maintained by 1 or 2 individuals
>> which are useful enough to become hugely popular like rsc, theuspits,
>> GPL track database, GPLrank etc. will close.  It's not a matter of
>> "if" they close it's "when".

> Sorry to dash your hopes but there is no chance of us handing RSC over to
> anyone. The admin team are working hard to get the site back up and
> running as we speak. In the last day we have overcome a huge hurdle that
> has been preventing this and now finally feel we are making progress
> towards getting the forum back online.

> Cheers

> Phil Lee
> RSC Administrator

mcewen

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by mcewen » Sat, 08 Jan 2005 03:37:09

I'm not a big fan of the current form of FILSCA and it's not so much a
"hope" as a suggestion-of-last-resort for sites that are going/gone.
The one advantage of the committee format though is that they can
change their tune, either by the world ignoring them or by the world
joining them and staging a coup.   Unless of course they're commitee
elections are held in the Ukraine... ;)

Great to hear you'll be back soon Phil but I still think
burnout/closure is inevitable unless your support base is large enough
to be self sustaning, if it is, then you've already become a committee
;)

John Simmon

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by John Simmon » Sat, 08 Jan 2005 19:38:58


says...

Hmmm, I'd never even heard of them until yesterday.  I went to their
website yesterday and didn't see any compelling reason for them to take
over anything.

Byron Forbe

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by Byron Forbe » Sun, 09 Jan 2005 00:50:55



> says...
> > God no, please dont hand it over to FILSCA couldnt imagine anything
worse
> > quite frankly, they already seem to to think they control simracing so
> > please dont give them anything more to inflate that opinion.

> Hmmm, I'd never even heard of them until yesterday.  I went to their
> website yesterday and didn't see any compelling reason for them to take
> over anything.

    I think FILSCA has great potential to centralize sim racing leagues - a
good place to find a league and see who's who and what's what. That will be
more than enough for them however - making it anything like The Pits/RSC
would be huge overload!
mcewen

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by mcewen » Sun, 09 Jan 2005 02:29:17

And a share-the-workload sort of thing.  Assuming from what they
originally intended they'd have some sort of regular elections for
duties.  If you're the guy (un)lucky enough to be maintaining a certain
section of their content you just decline the job the next time it
comes up.

Unfortunatly they don't seem to want to share how they work until after
you've joined.

alex martin

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by alex martin » Mon, 10 Jan 2005 08:56:28

control simracing? That's a little rich - FILSCA's nothing mroe than teh
work of a few guys over the course of a few years to facilitate leagues and
keep drivers' stats for life - and all of it for free. The idea that anyone
wants to control sim racing is a bit much; though i imagine there are those
(no names mentioned) who would, given the opportunity, seek to control our
beloved sim-sport for profit. Filsca cannot make a profit since it's a
not-for-profit club and cannot, legally, show an income. What's more, filsca
is not owned by anyone except the member leagues - which are, in turn,
'owned' by their drivers - as such, filsca cannot 'take over' anything since
filsca is the sim racers and is owned, 100%, by its members. As such, the
idea that it can take over sim racing is, as said, fanciful at best. What
filsca does do, however, is empower its own members to protect simracing
from the vultures that always circle around any 'sport' for profit.




>> says...
>> > God no, please dont hand it over to FILSCA couldnt imagine anything
> worse
>> > quite frankly, they already seem to to think they control simracing so
>> > please dont give them anything more to inflate that opinion.

>> Hmmm, I'd never even heard of them until yesterday.  I went to their
>> website yesterday and didn't see any compelling reason for them to take
>> over anything.

>    I think FILSCA has great potential to centralize sim racing leagues - a
> good place to find a league and see who's who and what's what. That will
> be
> more than enough for them however - making it anything like The Pits/RSC
> would be huge overload!

JP

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by JP » Mon, 10 Jan 2005 10:10:45


<snip>

What filsca does do, however, is empower its own members to protect
simracing from the vultures that always circle around any 'sport' for
profit.

  That's a bit rich too; a bit to much self-importance being attributed to
sim racing.

Byron Forbe

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by Byron Forbe » Mon, 10 Jan 2005 11:17:10


    It seems there's as much competition off the track as there is on! :)
When they make a show of jealously like that you know you're on the right
track.

    I personally wish you a lot of luck with FILSCA. I don't see why anyone
should be threatened by you - you are both unique and overdue. Drivers can
go there and find a league taylor made for them. League admins can go there
and see how other leagues do things and learn from each other. I really look
forward to seeing you grow and develope into a valuable and exciting
resourse for all - who knows, you might even take over all of sim racing!
LOL.

ZZ

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by ZZ » Mon, 10 Jan 2005 22:06:44

Every time I hear of filsca, I can't help but hear the phrase

"All your racing sims are belong to us"

--
Richard "ZZ" Busch

Member:
Screamers Racing League
oAo
AoA
MARA TransAm
GT Rank  +57.022
GT Rank Monster  1414.955
GPL Rank + 14.768
MoGPL Rank + 308.654
N2003 Rank -18.8060
----------------
Remember racecar is racecar spelled backward
-----------------

----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Uncensored-Secure Usenet News==----
http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 120,000+ Newsgroups
----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =----

Jaspe

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by Jaspe » Tue, 11 Jan 2005 02:24:19

Just how do they empower? And who are the vultures, cant ever remember
seeing anyone demand anything from me before I race online, Iam not against
leauges/teams/drivers joining to together but its all the nonsense of
commitees, sim approval and all that which just seems like kids pretending
to be the Fia to me.
JP

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by JP » Tue, 11 Jan 2005 03:06:53


> Every time I hear of filsca, I can't help but hear the phrase

> "All your racing sims are belong to us"

> --
> Richard "ZZ" Busch

> Member:
> Screamers Racing League
> oAo
> AoA
> MARA TransAm
> GT Rank  +57.022
> GT Rank Monster  1414.955
> GPL Rank + 14.768
> MoGPL Rank + 308.654
> N2003 Rank -18.8060
> ----------------
> Remember racecar is racecar spelled backward
> -----------------

  lol
Tony Rickar

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by Tony Rickar » Tue, 11 Jan 2005 07:59:38


> control simracing? That's a little rich - FILSCA's nothing mroe than teh
> work of a few guys over the course of a few years to facilitate leagues
and
> keep drivers' stats for life - and all of it for free.

I am sure that is the aim.

However, the script writers got a bit carried away IMHO with talks of moving
sim racing up to Quake match status with the associated prize money and the
recognition of our sport. Sim racing is a relative niche market compared to
online FPS.

Also announcing FILSCA as the first world sanctioning body for sim racing
suggests some authority and from where?

The "Federation International des Ligues des Simulateurs de Courses
Automobiles" will alienate more than a few for several reasons:

Firstly it is French which tells the Americans this is European run, and
tells the British that is er French... If it was in English it could be
perceived as a global initiative.

Secondly it sounds an awful like FIA or even FISA. Those more mature amongst
us will remember the FISA vs FOCA political wars which had nothing to do
with racing.

Thirdly if it is a sanctioning body how is this body elected to sanction
anything?

I am not against the concept and I am sure the guys put a lot of thankless
time in keeping this running, but I do think the mission statement is rather
grandiose and stacking sim racing up against competitive FPS playing is way
over optimistic.

Also I remember when Jack Rambo put together his "Nail the Track" series
with a view to developing a World series with the equivalent of motor racing
competition licenses for members back in 1999 with the conclusion that sim
racing was just too niche compared with Quake et al.

I am sure FILSCA means well but the days of professional sim racing drivers
seem way off to me...

Cheers
Tony

Darren Williamso

RSC/USPITS: Time for FILSCA to step up to the plate?

by Darren Williamso » Tue, 11 Jan 2005 19:37:25

Tony, I think you hit it right on the head. Very well stated.

A few years ago I had the opportunity to look at their statutes and
charter shortly after they had their 'unveiling'. With such items as
requiring drivers in member leagues to recognize FILSCA as the "sole
authority over sim racing proper", and not allowing leagues to leave
FILSCA without approval of the management, and numerous other similar
gems, one can only guess what their intentions originally were.

This along with some of the rudeness displayed by some of FILSCA's
management never inspired much confidence in me. 'Poorly begun is hard
to salvage'. It's always seemed to me that they are trying to fix a
problem that doesn't exist. As a 'sanctioning body' they potentially
could end up being the problem.

Do I take it that non-FILSCA leagues are now outlaw leagues :-))))))?
DW


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.