rec.autos.simulators

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

Gerry Aitke

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Gerry Aitke » Mon, 28 Apr 2003 16:08:05



>> I think your being a little unreasonable, a simple analog joystick
>> would do
>> the job, even second hand would cost about $5-$10

>> keyboards aren't for sims :)

>> Ash
>> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> But you see, I already have a simple analog joystick, Ashley. ;)

> I just map the throttle and brake to the two buttons on it. Give NASCAR
> Heat a try with a joystick(cudos to it's dev's), they've gotten it down
> to a near science.

> It's a terrible habit from NASCAR Racing 2, yet it's how I'm comfortable
> with driving in any sim with this wretched thing. :)

> -Will

Now I understand...user error on your part has screwed your own enjoyment.
Gerry Aitke

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Gerry Aitke » Mon, 28 Apr 2003 16:11:28



>>I just map the throttle and brake to the two buttons on it. Give NASCAR
>>Heat a try with a joystick(cudos to it's dev's), they've gotten it down
>>to a near science.

> Yeah I'm sure the 10 people in the world pushing a button on their joystick
> to accelerate must love Nascar Heat.  Trust me, there's a _reason_ for that.
> For Papy, it is more important to have a safer and more regulated online
> racing presence then to take the chance of completely obliterating that by
> having a toggle for that option.  You know, the average gamer _is_ stupid,
> and he would be enough stupid to turn it off, even if that means being a
> more dangerous driver.

> Anyway, just buy a set of pedals and Y-connector them to the joystick.

> Kudos to Papy for standing on their motorsport values.

Agreed 100%

Will, use analog controllers where they are available, buttons are for
looking left and right, oh and dropping bombs of course.

William Bradsha

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by William Bradsha » Mon, 28 Apr 2003 22:29:26


> Now I understand...user error on your part has screwed your own enjoyment.

Care to explain to me how it's "user error" on my part, please?

Before you do, don't forget that Papy made it possible to use digital
input for throttle and brake. Is it my fault that I'm not having a good
time because of their design? Or is it simply a case of Papy having it
exactly right, and I'm wrong? Forcing aids is right when there is a way
around it?

If it comes down to "Will is not staying within the standards", then
either Papy should remove it, or refine it. In my opinion, that's the
right thing to do. Either support it as best you can and make it work,
or don't bother at all. Thankfully, the "other" two noteworthy sims
(NASCAR Heat and NASCAR Thunder 2003) support my "user error" to a
better extent than Papy has.

I'll go out on a limb here and say that instead of fixing problems in
this area, it is comparable to the infamous "wall glue". Instead of
doing things right, the dev's just become lazy and apply a quick fix and
require it to be a standard. Just as you're telling me to buy a wheel,
the reply to the wall glue is "stay off the wall". Both inhibit gameplay.

And, no, this isn't a wall glue argument. I'm trying to link this
situation with another that everyone (well, most anyways) is well aware of.

-Will

William Bradsha

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by William Bradsha » Mon, 28 Apr 2003 22:32:27


> No problem, Will.  Different people want different things out of the games they
> play.  And while your 'joystick challenge' is interesting, it wouldn't really
> prove anything.  Most people who use a wheel now would have problems
> re-adjusting to a joystick *anyway*...
> And honestly - I've forgotten what you said was forced on when using a
> stick...sorry.<blush>

> Eldred

Thank you for acknowledging and understanding my point, even if we
disagree on whether or not it should be improved, or important.

-Will

Ashley McConnel

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Ashley McConnel » Mon, 28 Apr 2003 22:35:57



> > I think your being a little unreasonable, a simple analog joystick would
do
> > the job, even second hand would cost about $5-$10

> > keyboards aren't for sims :)

> > Ash
> > http://www.siroccoracing.com

> But you see, I already have a simple analog joystick, Ashley. ;)

> I just map the throttle and brake to the two buttons on it. Give NASCAR
> Heat a try with a joystick(cudos to it's dev's), they've gotten it down
> to a near science.

> It's a terrible habit from NASCAR Racing 2, yet it's how I'm comfortable
> with driving in any sim with this wretched thing. :)

> -Will

I understand you have got into the habit, but i promise you that you will
love these games so much more if you bite the bullet and go fully analogue.
I'd suggest really going for it and getting a wheel, they have really came
down in price recently.

All the best,
Ash
http://www.siroccoracing.com

William Bradsha

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by William Bradsha » Mon, 28 Apr 2003 22:43:31


> I understand you have got into the habit, but i promise you that you will
> love these games so much more if you bite the bullet and go fully analogue.
> I'd suggest really going for it and getting a wheel, they have really came
> down in price recently.

> All the best,
> Ash
> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

You're right, I did love the Papy games with my wheel. But after the
paddle I used for throttle broke, coupled with the horrible and tiny
pedals I got with it, my only real option was to revert back to a
joystick (and thank god for my love of flight sims, otherwise I'd be in
worse shape :).

Really, it's the only reason I'm ***ing is because I can see some of
the problems of "non-standard" contollers with this particular series of
game.

OT, if all goes well locally in available jobs (recently, there hasn't
been /anything/ open) I should have a el-cheapo wheel from the first
paycheck. Or I'll hold off a few weeks and get a TSW. I'm still up in
the air about it.

-Will

Eldre

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Eldre » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 01:33:23



>I don't know how you ever got into that habit.  Even in the days of yore when
>I used a joystick for
>my racing games,  forward and back were always accel/brake, so it is always
>assigned to an analog
>control.  Who assigns throttle/brake to buttons on an analog joystick besides
>you?  You are the only
>person I have heard of(I'm sure there are others that do so no need to spout
>off now) that assigns
>throttle/brake to buttons on their joystick instead of of forward and back.
>That would be like
>assigning dive and climb to joystick buttons in a flight sim....

Not spouting off<g>, but I can give you a reason why.  For me, it was
impossible to maintain good braking/throttle control using the forward/backward
axis.  When I'd go into the turns, I'd be unable to control my braking
correctly.  I know that some can do it fine - I couldn't.

Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank:-1.950
MonsterRank: +305.145
N2002 Rank:+17.59

Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

William Bradsha

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by William Bradsha » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 01:40:52


> Not spouting off<g>, but I can give you a reason why.  For me, it was
> impossible to maintain good braking/throttle control using the forward/backward
> axis.  When I'd go into the turns, I'd be unable to control my braking
> correctly.  I know that some can do it fine - I couldn't.

> Eldred

Same here. That's precisely the reason I don't set my controller up like
that. Trying to slow down or accelerate while keeping the X-axis in same
spot is pretty damn tough, IMO.

Using buttons, I have much more control and attention to my car and how
it's reacting instead of trying to multi-task the brake/throttle.

You're not alone. :)

-Will

Gerry Aitke

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Gerry Aitke » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 03:38:46



>> Now I understand...user error on your part has screwed your own
>> enjoyment.

> Care to explain to me how it's "user error" on my part, please?

How hard did you try? I'd bet, not very. Give it six weeks and i'd bet
you'd have no trouble using joystick axis for brake and throttle.

But what is easier, to try or to whine?

Gerry Aitke

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Gerry Aitke » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 03:40:27





>>>I think your being a little unreasonable, a simple analog joystick would

> do

>>>the job, even second hand would cost about $5-$10

>>>keyboards aren't for sims :)

>>>Ash
>>>http://www.siroccoracing.com

>>But you see, I already have a simple analog joystick, Ashley. ;)

>>I just map the throttle and brake to the two buttons on it. Give NASCAR
>>Heat a try with a joystick(cudos to it's dev's), they've gotten it down
>>to a near science.

>>It's a terrible habit from NASCAR Racing 2, yet it's how I'm comfortable
>>with driving in any sim with this wretched thing. :)

>>-Will

> I understand you have got into the habit, but i promise you that you will
> love these games so much more if you bite the bullet and go fully analogue.
> I'd suggest really going for it and getting a wheel, they have really came
> down in price recently.

Ash, this guys is just going to whine.

Gerry

Gerry Aitke

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Gerry Aitke » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 03:42:40



>> I understand you have got into the habit, but i promise you that you will
>> love these games so much more if you bite the bullet and go fully
>> analogue.
>> I'd suggest really going for it and getting a wheel, they have really
>> came
>> down in price recently.

>> All the best,
>> Ash
>> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> You're right, I did love the Papy games with my wheel. But after the
> paddle I used for throttle broke, coupled with the horrible and tiny
> pedals I got with it, my only real option was to revert back to a
> joystick (and thank god for my love of flight sims, otherwise I'd be in
> worse shape :).

> Really, it's the only reason I'm ***ing is because I can see some of
> the problems of "non-standard" contollers with this particular series of
> game.

> OT, if all goes well locally in available jobs (recently, there hasn't
> been /anything/ open) I should have a el-cheapo wheel from the first
> paycheck. Or I'll hold off a few weeks and get a TSW. I'm still up in
> the air about it.

A TSW? And I thought you were broke!

Gerry

William Bradsha

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by William Bradsha » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 03:59:05


>> OT, if all goes well locally in available jobs (recently, there hasn't
>> been /anything/ open) I should have a el-cheapo wheel from the first
>> paycheck. Or I'll hold off a few weeks and get a TSW. I'm still up in
>> the air about it.

> A TSW? And I thought you were broke!

> Gerry

Hey, Mr. Attitude, which part of the message didn't you understand? Do I
really need to break it down sentence by sentence for you to comprehend
it all? Here, let me help you.

"OT, if all goes well locally in available jobs (recently, there hasn't
been /anything/ open)"

Just about anyone would understand that this would mean that while I,
Will, am not working at the moment I will soon be going back out to
look. Maybe I, Will, will get lucky if there are any jobs available locally.

"I should have a el-cheapo wheel from the first paycheck."

This means that upon getting my first paycheck, if I can find anything
for work, I will spend it on a cheap wheel.

"Or I'll hold off a few weeks and get a TSW. I'm still up in the air
about it."

This means that my other option instead of buying a cheap wheel, I'll
wait and save up money to buy a TSW.

Therefore, Gerry Aitken, yes I am broke. Any questions?

-Will

William Bradsha

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by William Bradsha » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 04:02:47


> Ash, this guys is just going to whine.

> Gerry

In your mind it may be whining. To me, whining is trying to get a point
across without offering any constructive ideas. Your posts have shown to
me that you're not interested in discussion, just you treating your
opinions as fact. I'll be sure not to waste my time, nor yours, by
replying to you any further.

-Will

Gerry Aitke

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Gerry Aitke » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 04:22:47



>>> OT, if all goes well locally in available jobs (recently, there
>>> hasn't been /anything/ open) I should have a el-cheapo wheel from the
>>> first paycheck. Or I'll hold off a few weeks and get a TSW. I'm still
>>> up in the air about it.

>> A TSW? And I thought you were broke!

>> Gerry

> Hey, Mr. Attitude, which part of the message didn't you understand? Do I
> really need to break it down sentence by sentence for you to comprehend
> it all? Here, let me help you.

> "OT, if all goes well locally in available jobs (recently, there hasn't
> been /anything/ open)"

> Just about anyone would understand that this would mean that while I,
> Will, am not working at the moment I will soon be going back out to
> look. Maybe I, Will, will get lucky if there are any jobs available
> locally.

> "I should have a el-cheapo wheel from the first paycheck."

> This means that upon getting my first paycheck, if I can find anything
> for work, I will spend it on a cheap wheel.

> "Or I'll hold off a few weeks and get a TSW. I'm still up in the air
> about it."

> This means that my other option instead of buying a cheap wheel, I'll
> wait and save up money to buy a TSW.

> Therefore, Gerry Aitken, yes I am broke. Any questions?

> -Will

Yeah, when will you stop whining?
Aide

I Got To Thinking About My Dislike For...

by Aide » Tue, 29 Apr 2003 04:20:29

Unbiased observation.....

Will..... you don't post very well......leaving yourself open to this
'Gerry' attack

AD.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.