rec.autos.simulators

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

Goy Larse

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Goy Larse » Fri, 29 Nov 2002 23:59:56




> ...
> > However, for me, roof-riding makes road-racing a bit easier.  It
> > doesn't make me a winner, but it lets me run in the top five
> > (usually).  Other than that, I get no advantage by roof-riding over
> >***pit view.

> Well, that's probably pretty much the advantage the***pit riders think it
> gives you :-)

Yeah, I was going to comment on that myself, if you find it "easier" to
run in roof riding view, then it gives you an advantage :-)

You tried it Achim ?

I have.....:-)

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
"goyl at nettx dot no"

"The Pits"    http://www.racesimcentral.net/

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
--Groucho Marx--

Jason Moy

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Jason Moy » Sat, 30 Nov 2002 00:21:10

On Thu, 28 Nov 2002 11:27:02 -0000, "Joachim Trensz"


>what exactly are you referring to with 'braking and acceling thing'? I've
>seen you make a similar comment before and wonder what exactly you mean.

I think he's referring to the way most sims allow you to use throttle
all the way to the apex while trailbraking to keep the rear end from
stepping out without much of a penalty.  This isn't really an issue in
N2002 since a few laps of that will rip your tires off.

Jason

Joachim Trens

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Joachim Trens » Sat, 30 Nov 2002 01:51:17

I have tried bumper or roof cam once in a race, for a few laps, when my hood
was so crumpled I couldn't drive from inside the***pit anymore. I wasn't
really good from that view, as I wasn't used to it :-)

And I of course switch through all views when I get a new sim.

But in general I've been a***pit driver since day one. I've never even
purchased racing sims that didn't have***pit view. But like I said to John
in another message, differences are part of racing. I try to concentrate on
beating my opponent on the track.

Achim





> > ...
> > > However, for me, roof-riding makes road-racing a bit easier.  It
> > > doesn't make me a winner, but it lets me run in the top five
> > > (usually).  Other than that, I get no advantage by roof-riding over
> > >***pit view.

> > Well, that's probably pretty much the advantage the***pit riders think
it
> > gives you :-)

> Yeah, I was going to comment on that myself, if you find it "easier" to
> run in roof riding view, then it gives you an advantage :-)

> You tried it Achim ?

> I have.....:-)

> Beers and cheers
> (uncle) Goy
> "goyl at nettx dot no"

> "The Pits" http://www.racesimcentral.net/

> "A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
> --Groucho Marx--

Joachim Trens

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Joachim Trens » Sat, 30 Nov 2002 02:12:23

thanks Jason

Achim


> On Thu, 28 Nov 2002 11:27:02 -0000, "Joachim Trensz"

> >what exactly are you referring to with 'braking and acceling thing'? I've
> >seen you make a similar comment before and wonder what exactly you mean.

> I think he's referring to the way most sims allow you to use throttle
> all the way to the apex while trailbraking to keep the rear end from
> stepping out without much of a penalty.  This isn't really an issue in
> N2002 since a few laps of that will rip your tires off.

> Jason

Goy Larse

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Goy Larse » Sat, 30 Nov 2002 01:14:14


> I have tried bumper or roof cam once in a race, for a few laps, when my hood
> was so crumpled I couldn't drive from inside the***pit anymore. I wasn't
> really good from that view, as I wasn't used to it :-)

> And I of course switch through all views when I get a new sim.

> But in general I've been a***pit driver since day one. I've never even
> purchased racing sims that didn't have***pit view. But like I said to John
> in another message, differences are part of racing. I try to concentrate on
> beating my opponent on the track.

Well, I suggest you try the roof cam, or is that hood cam, for a short
practice session on your fav road course, it's a bit of an eye opener,
at least it was for me :-)

And for those wondering, no, I don't use it :-)

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
"goyl at nettx dot no"

"The Pits"    http://www.racesimcentral.net/

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
--Groucho Marx--

Alex 'pez' Porazinsk

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Alex 'pez' Porazinsk » Mon, 02 Dec 2002 00:16:48

id dissagree with jason, its how i drive, and as far as im concerned, its
the only way to drive this sim (and gpl, n4) 'really' quickly (run a poll on
RAS, download the replay of a 36.1 qual lap ive done at homestead, and a
1.13.8lap ive got from the glen in race setup from here (you might have to
copy and paste this URL into your browser to get it to dl, as its on
geocities and doesnt like to work the 'normal' way ;) )
http://www.geocities.com/alexpez/BrakeAccel.zip , and see just how many
people drive it like i do, i bet most of the guys who can match those times
and beat those times drive pretty much exactly the same way. setups are
included in those replays.)

its not, on the other hand, how youd drive these cars in real life, so its a
major flaw when it comes to simulating the driving experience.

pez


> thanks Jason

> Achim



> > On Thu, 28 Nov 2002 11:27:02 -0000, "Joachim Trensz"

> > >what exactly are you referring to with 'braking and acceling thing'?
I've
> > >seen you make a similar comment before and wonder what exactly you
mean.

> > I think he's referring to the way most sims allow you to use throttle
> > all the way to the apex while trailbraking to keep the rear end from
> > stepping out without much of a penalty.  This isn't really an issue in
> > N2002 since a few laps of that will rip your tires off.

> > Jason

Goy Larse

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Goy Larse » Mon, 02 Dec 2002 00:20:45


> id dissagree with jason, its how i drive, and as far as im concerned, its
> the only way to drive this sim (and gpl, n4) 'really' quickly (run a poll on
> RAS, download the replay of a 36.1 qual lap ive done at homestead, and a
> 1.13.8lap ive got from the glen in race setup from here (you might have to
> copy and paste this URL into your browser to get it to dl, as its on
> geocities and doesnt like to work the 'normal' way ;) )
> http://www.geocities.com/alexpez/BrakeAccel.zip , and see just how many
> people drive it like i do, i bet most of the guys who can match those times
> and beat those times drive pretty much exactly the same way. setups are
> included in those replays.)

> its not, on the other hand, how youd drive these cars in real life, so its a
> major flaw when it comes to simulating the driving experience.

No *need* to drive like that to be quick in NR2002

I've tried it briefly as I was told there's an advantage to it, but I
couldn't get the hang of it and went back to my normal driving style,
talking about road courses here of course, I don't know the first thing
about ovals :-)

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
"goyl at nettx dot no"

"The Pits"    http://www.theuspits.com/

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
--Groucho Marx--

Alex 'pez' Porazinsk

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Alex 'pez' Porazinsk » Mon, 02 Dec 2002 00:50:27

id love to see a replay showing conventional race driving technique (accel,
off accel, brake, turn + ease back on brake, get back on power, either
trailing or balanced, clipping point, power out, straighten wheel) that gets
someone a 1.13.8 lap at the glen at 70 degrees, no wind, clear conditions,
no autoclutch (no aids) with a race setup.

from what ive seen, the really quick guys run setups that are too loose to
allow you to do this, as you need power application pretty much constantly
with them (no way to trail brake with a setup thats as loose as the ones
included in my replay, youll loop it instantly).

from what i can tell, you will get much better tyre wear at the front
running the papyrus technique as you dont lean on the front tyres as much as
you would do with a setup that allows for proper trail braking (one thatd be
alot less 'loose', and allow you to actually balance a car on the brake
pedal, then get on the power to hold it rather than being able to give both
inputs simultaneously and control a much nastier car).

im too infrequent a RAS reader to know if this has been discussed in the
past, but i think i recall Steve Smith posting something about it and a le
mans team trying it out, and braking cars (think thats what he said).

pez



> > id dissagree with jason, its how i drive, and as far as im concerned,
its
> > the only way to drive this sim (and gpl, n4) 'really' quickly (run a
poll on
> > RAS, download the replay of a 36.1 qual lap ive done at homestead, and a
> > 1.13.8lap ive got from the glen in race setup from here (you might have
to
> > copy and paste this URL into your browser to get it to dl, as its on
> > geocities and doesnt like to work the 'normal' way ;) )
> > http://www.geocities.com/alexpez/BrakeAccel.zip , and see just how many
> > people drive it like i do, i bet most of the guys who can match those
times
> > and beat those times drive pretty much exactly the same way. setups are
> > included in those replays.)

> > its not, on the other hand, how youd drive these cars in real life, so
its a
> > major flaw when it comes to simulating the driving experience.

> No *need* to drive like that to be quick in NR2002

> I've tried it briefly as I was told there's an advantage to it, but I
> couldn't get the hang of it and went back to my normal driving style,
> talking about road courses here of course, I don't know the first thing
> about ovals :-)

> Beers and cheers
> (uncle) Goy
> "goyl at nettx dot no"

> "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/

> "A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
> --Groucho Marx--

Alex 'pez' Porazinsk

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Alex 'pez' Porazinsk » Mon, 02 Dec 2002 02:26:35

found steve smiths post (google is pretty cool):

'No, it's the aliens' techniques that wouldn't fly in the RW; specifically,
the simultaneous use of throttle and brakes.  No RW car could take this kind
of punishment for long.  (When Rover was developing the turbine car for Le
Mans, the test drivers discovered that the lap times were much improved by
using the throttle to spool up the turbine--which went to something like
30,000 rpm--whilst still on the binders.  The Rover engineers kept putting
on bigger and bigger rotors, but in the end the problem could only be
'solved' by prohibiting the drivers from employing the practice.)  Likewise,
RW cars could never take the kind of abuse heaped on the engines, tires and
transmissions the way aliens drive.  If you look at footage of RW drivers of
that era, and then at replays of aliens' laps, you'll immediately understand
why the way the latter drive is much closer to Ridge Racer than Jim Clark.'

one of the technical advisors for n2003 who engineers one of the winston cup
cars has seen the replays ive posted recently, and stated that no driver
he's seen drives like that. id hope that his input to papyrus could lead to
a sim that needs to be driven properly to go quickly, after all, its a real
world driving sim first.

im not saying that you cant use normal real life technique to drive n2002,
but its quicker to use the brake+accel

pez



> id love to see a replay showing conventional race driving technique
(accel,
> off accel, brake, turn + ease back on brake, get back on power, either
> trailing or balanced, clipping point, power out, straighten wheel) that
gets
> someone a 1.13.8 lap at the glen at 70 degrees, no wind, clear conditions,
> no autoclutch (no aids) with a race setup.

> from what ive seen, the really quick guys run setups that are too loose to
> allow you to do this, as you need power application pretty much constantly
> with them (no way to trail brake with a setup thats as loose as the ones
> included in my replay, youll loop it instantly).

> from what i can tell, you will get much better tyre wear at the front
> running the papyrus technique as you dont lean on the front tyres as much
as
> you would do with a setup that allows for proper trail braking (one thatd
be
> alot less 'loose', and allow you to actually balance a car on the brake
> pedal, then get on the power to hold it rather than being able to give
both
> inputs simultaneously and control a much nastier car).

> im too infrequent a RAS reader to know if this has been discussed in the
> past, but i think i recall Steve Smith posting something about it and a le
> mans team trying it out, and braking cars (think thats what he said).

> pez




> > > id dissagree with jason, its how i drive, and as far as im concerned,
> its
> > > the only way to drive this sim (and gpl, n4) 'really' quickly (run a
> poll on
> > > RAS, download the replay of a 36.1 qual lap ive done at homestead, and
a
> > > 1.13.8lap ive got from the glen in race setup from here (you might
have
> to
> > > copy and paste this URL into your browser to get it to dl, as its on
> > > geocities and doesnt like to work the 'normal' way ;) )
> > > http://www.geocities.com/alexpez/BrakeAccel.zip , and see just how
many
> > > people drive it like i do, i bet most of the guys who can match those
> times
> > > and beat those times drive pretty much exactly the same way. setups
are
> > > included in those replays.)

> > > its not, on the other hand, how youd drive these cars in real life, so
> its a
> > > major flaw when it comes to simulating the driving experience.

> > No *need* to drive like that to be quick in NR2002

> > I've tried it briefly as I was told there's an advantage to it, but I
> > couldn't get the hang of it and went back to my normal driving style,
> > talking about road courses here of course, I don't know the first thing
> > about ovals :-)

> > Beers and cheers
> > (uncle) Goy
> > "goyl at nettx dot no"

> > "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/

> > "A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
> > --Groucho Marx--

Nick

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Nick » Mon, 02 Dec 2002 03:22:57


Well, you know they are 'oval', so I guess that's the first thing...

Joachim Trens

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Joachim Trens » Mon, 02 Dec 2002 04:50:06

Hi Alex,

thanks for the info and the replays!

Do you use this same technique in a, say, 50% sim race as well?

Achim



Alex 'pez' Porazinsk

Ending the Roof driving Question--A challenge to RAS

by Alex 'pez' Porazinsk » Mon, 02 Dec 2002 04:06:19

the setups im driving dictate that i need to drive it like this quite long
into each tyre run, then as they wear out and the thing starts to understeer
more, theres less of a need to do it.

pez


> Hi Alex,

> thanks for the info and the replays!

> Do you use this same technique in a, say, 50% sim race as well?

> Achim



> > id love to see a replay showing conventional race driving technique
> (accel,
> > off accel, brake, turn + ease back on brake, get back on power, either
> > trailing or balanced, clipping point, power out, straighten wheel) that
> gets
> > someone a 1.13.8 lap at the glen at 70 degrees, no wind, clear
conditions,
> > no autoclutch (no aids) with a race setup.

> > from what ive seen, the really quick guys run setups that are too loose
to
> > allow you to do this, as you need power application pretty much
constantly
> > with them (no way to trail brake with a setup thats as loose as the ones
> > included in my replay, youll loop it instantly).

> > from what i can tell, you will get much better tyre wear at the front
> > running the papyrus technique as you dont lean on the front tyres as
much
> as
> > you would do with a setup that allows for proper trail braking (one
thatd
> be
> > alot less 'loose', and allow you to actually balance a car on the brake
> > pedal, then get on the power to hold it rather than being able to give
> both
> > inputs simultaneously and control a much nastier car).

> > im too infrequent a RAS reader to know if this has been discussed in the
> > past, but i think i recall Steve Smith posting something about it and a
le
> > mans team trying it out, and braking cars (think thats what he said).


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.