You too are missing a few points. EA has an enormous influence on
what features a developer like ISI can include in a program. EA
controls the money and therefore the direction the programmers must
follow. IF EA says take out the Sim stuff and put more ARCADE thingies
in, then ISA will pretty much have to do what EA wants, if they want to
see any more checks.
Having said that, we can relax some tho, and here's why.
A) EA did NOT choose the Nascar Rev devolopers, who-ever they were.
This indicates they are at least shooting for some sort of sim vs an
arcade product.
B) F12k is fairly far along is development cycle. Most feature choices
have been made long ago and few new features or deletions occur this far
along the process. Since several seemingly reliable users here have
seen at least some of ISI's work, I think we can rest assured that the
program choices are definately leaning heavily into the sim side of
racing.
Remember in the end, if EA say make crap, ISI is pretty much obligated
to attempt to produce said crap. There have been a few instances where
producers and developers have gone separate ways because of design
choices, but this doesn't seem to be a problem with ISI. This will be
the 2nd program they have produced for EA so they 'should' know at least
how EA operates and what the big boys are looking for. Conversely, EA
knows that ISI produces a pretty good product so they will probably not
try to influence their coding toooo much.(hopefully!)
dave henrie
ps. many marketeers have proclaimed in the last year that their new
product was a gpl beater. To date...I don't think we have seen one
program that does indeed surpass gpl as a sim. So until F12k or GP3 or
any other sim has been released, reviewed and disected, we all should
hesitate from proclaiming the next king. When that day comes and the
king is finally toppled from the throne, then we can shout til we are
hoarse.
> >>I've spoken to a reliable source that says ISI/EA Sports' F1 2000 will
> >>smoke GPL. This is coming from a person who considered GPL to be
> >>the pinnacle of sims. Can't wait for 3/25/00...
> >That will be the day... when EA sports makes a half decent racing sim.
> >FWIW EA doesn't make sims.. they make games.
> Some people are so dense. Dude, EA is just the publisher of this
> upcoming F1 sim, they had nothing to do with making it. ISI is just
> using EA's name to get the game into people's hands. Now if EA had
> made it, like they did Nascar Revolution, then I'd know even without
> seeing it that it would be a joke of a racing game. ISI employed a
> couple people from Crammond's Grand Prix 2 team to help out.