>2. "The best driving game": Need For Speed III. Irk! Other nominees
>were Ubisof't F1RS and Grand Prix Legends, and NFS3 beat them both?
>Oh well, maybe NFS3 has more mass appeal...
Well, it's just someone's opinion, and we all know how little we share
each others opinions! But I don't think they had enough categories.
They spent half the introduction talking about all these excellent
games released into each genre, plus games which crossed genres, but
they didn't really accommodate them. For example, while Half Life is
probably the best action game, I was disappointed to see Thief come
away with only nominations and no award - but where does Thief fit?
It's hardly an action game next to Half Life, yet it's not a
simulation or adventure. More of an action-adventure, perhaps? It was
certainly far more innovative and original than Half-Life yet in some
ways Half-Life provides more visceral fun, in other ways Thief's
atmosphere is unbeatable and more immersive.
Grand Prix Legends is another - to compare it with NFS3 doesn't make
sense. It's a game you have to play a lot of in order to get anything
of out it, whereas NFS3 is the opposite. Serious game vs. arcade game,
but both are fun overall. Mass appeals wins, but the better game...?