rec.autos.simulators

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

Chris Bloo

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Chris Bloo » Thu, 10 Feb 2000 04:00:00

I have been dedicating my GPL time (i.e. the time I don't spend working,
sleeping) to the F3 cars the last couple of weeks.  I have found that among
the AI, the Brabham seems to outgun the Lotus and last night I tried a
short intermediate race at Monza with the Brabham and was over a second
faster than my previous best in the Lotus.  I ended up finishing 10 seconds
(despite two spins) behind the other two Brabhams and infront of Hill &
Clark.

Another race I had at Spa in the Lotus, ended with me a few seconds behind
the other Lotus's and the Brabhams 15 odd seconds up the road.

The Brabams also have been winning more F3 races than they do in F1, maybe
it is because of their light weight which would be an advantage with less
power.

Chris

Leo Landma

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Leo Landma » Thu, 10 Feb 2000 04:00:00



> maybe it is because of their light weight which would be an advantage with
> less power.

All cars have the same power in F2 and F3. Brabham has less drag =
higher topspeed, particularly on fast tracks like Monza and Spa.
Time to move on to F2 for you!

--
Bye,
Leo

Mark Seer

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Mark Seer » Thu, 10 Feb 2000 04:00:00

Chris.
The Brabham has a marked straight line speed advantage over all other F3
cars. It is for this reason that there is an unwritten law amongst the
regular F3 online racers that the car should not be used. Indeed, many of
the online leagues have banned it.

MS

Chris Bloo

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Chris Bloo » Thu, 10 Feb 2000 04:00:00


Why?

Bruce Kennewel

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Bruce Kennewel » Fri, 11 Feb 2000 04:00:00

Too fast for F3.  You might fall out when cornering.

--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------




> > Chris.
> > The Brabham has a marked straight line speed advantage over all other F3
> > cars. It is for this reason that there is an unwritten law amongst the
> > regular F3 online racers that the car should not be used. Indeed, many
of
> > the online leagues have banned it.

> Why?

  -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
   http://www.newsfeeds.com       The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including  Dedicated  Binaries Servers ==-----
asgeir nes?e

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by asgeir nes?e » Fri, 11 Feb 2000 04:00:00

I am not sure about this, Leo...

Try testing drag of all the car makes, and see if you can find a difference.

Find a long straight, go at 130mph, depress the clutch and measure the time it
takes before you the car has retarded to 80 mph... Do this with the same setup
for all cars...

I am almost 100% sure that you won't find any distinct difference. At least not
any difference to cause the performance difference between the Brab and the
other cars...

I have been wondering about a difference in torque curves, but I haven't reached
any conclusions...

---Asgeir---




> > maybe it is because of their light weight which would be an advantage with
> > less power.

> All cars have the same power in F2 and F3. Brabham has less drag =
> higher topspeed, particularly on fast tracks like Monza and Spa.
> Time to move on to F2 for you!

> --
> Bye,
> Leo

Michael Barlo

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Michael Barlo » Fri, 11 Feb 2000 04:00:00


> I am not sure about this, Leo...

> Try testing drag of all the car makes, and see if you can find a difference.

> Find a long straight, go at 130mph, depress the clutch and measure the time it
> takes before you the car has retarded to 80 mph... Do this with the same setup
> for all cars...

> I am almost 100% sure that you won't find any distinct difference. At least not
> any difference to cause the performance difference between the Brab and the
> other cars...

> I have been wondering about a difference in torque curves, but I haven't reached
> any conclusions...

> ---Asgeir---




> > > maybe it is because of their light weight which would be an advantage with
> > > less power.

> > All cars have the same power in F2 and F3. Brabham has less drag =
> > higher topspeed, particularly on fast tracks like Monza and Spa.
> > Time to move on to F2 for you!

> > --
> > Bye,
> > Leo

        Asgier knows about my thought from an F3 News group.  At one time we
were trying to find a torque curve for the F3's but were unable to
figure out how (last I remember).  My opinion is the same as his with
the drag.

        Set each car up exactly like the rest. Then do what he suggests and
you'll find that there is no measurable differences.  Do the same with
the F1's and again, you'll find no measurable differences.  Do the same,
but measure the differences from 0-60 mph, and again from 60 to 120 mph
in acceleration!  You'll see a big difference between each marquee.
This makes me believe that either the engines have a different HP or a
different Torque curve.  I've done this test but with two cars and never
wrote down the differences.  I'll do it again and write the differences
in Time and distance.

        Nunini had a Torque graph for each Marquee for the F1 cars.  With our
experience, These torque curves do correspond to the F3 top speeds and
acceleration.  So I can only assume that the F3's in GPL *are* F1's but
with rpm limiters.  The same with the F2's.

        If anyone knows of a test that we can do to get the torque curves and
HP ratings, I'd like to know.  This would help everyone immensely.
--
=========================================
Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing?
=========================================
http://members.xoom.com/BarlowRacing/

Racing online with the help of......

Race Communications Association
Holodyne Engineering
Mystic Music
(have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)

Mark Seer

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Mark Seer » Fri, 11 Feb 2000 04:00:00

For the same reason that you wouldn't try racing a Ferrari F40 with a Ford
I guess!

MS



> > Chris.
> > The Brabham has a marked straight line speed advantage over all other F3
> > cars. It is for this reason that there is an unwritten law amongst the
> > regular F3 online racers that the car should not be used. Indeed, many
of
> > the online leagues have banned it.

> Why?

Mark Seer

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Mark Seer » Fri, 11 Feb 2000 04:00:00

Neither one of you have factored the weight fariable with the drag test so
this is not totally valid. you have to remember that the heavier car will
have a lot more energy for given speed than a lighter one .......Just a
thought

MS


> > I am not sure about this, Leo...

> > Try testing drag of all the car makes, and see if you can find a
difference.

> > Find a long straight, go at 130mph, depress the clutch and measure the
time it
> > takes before you the car has retarded to 80 mph... Do this with the same
setup
> > for all cars...

> > I am almost 100% sure that you won't find any distinct difference. At
least not
> > any difference to cause the performance difference between the Brab and
the
> > other cars...

> > I have been wondering about a difference in torque curves, but I haven't
reached
> > any conclusions...

> > ---Asgeir---




> > > > maybe it is because of their light weight which would be an
advantage with
> > > > less power.

> > > All cars have the same power in F2 and F3. Brabham has less drag =
> > > higher topspeed, particularly on fast tracks like Monza and Spa.
> > > Time to move on to F2 for you!

> > > --
> > > Bye,
> > > Leo

> Asgier knows about my thought from an F3 News group.  At one time we
> were trying to find a torque curve for the F3's but were unable to
> figure out how (last I remember).  My opinion is the same as his with
> the drag.

> Set each car up exactly like the rest. Then do what he suggests and
> you'll find that there is no measurable differences.  Do the same with
> the F1's and again, you'll find no measurable differences.  Do the same,
> but measure the differences from 0-60 mph, and again from 60 to 120 mph
> in acceleration!  You'll see a big difference between each marquee.
> This makes me believe that either the engines have a different HP or a
> different Torque curve.  I've done this test but with two cars and never
> wrote down the differences.  I'll do it again and write the differences
> in Time and distance.

> Nunini had a Torque graph for each Marquee for the F1 cars.  With our
> experience, These torque curves do correspond to the F3 top speeds and
> acceleration.  So I can only assume that the F3's in GPL *are* F1's but
> with rpm limiters.  The same with the F2's.

> If anyone knows of a test that we can do to get the torque curves and
> HP ratings, I'd like to know.  This would help everyone immensely.
> --
> =========================================
> Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing?
> =========================================
> http://members.xoom.com/BarlowRacing/

> Racing online with the help of......

> Race Communications Association
> Holodyne Engineering
> Mystic Music
> (have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)

Ron Ayto

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Ron Ayto » Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:00:00

Hi,
The same is true for the Repco's advantage in F2 as it is in F3.
That is why it is considered bad sportmanship for a faster, more
experienced driver to use the Repco in F2 or F3.
As a new driver to GPL, the Repco in F2 & F3 will enable the new driver
to have a chance at being competitive with other more experienced
drivers, but once experience and speed is gained, it is a good idea to
go for one of the other Marques in F2/F3, when racing on-line.

The F2 Repco is nearly as fast as the F1 Cooper.  :)

FWIW, in F2/F3 the Repco is fastest, folllowed by the Eagle, Lotus &
Ferrari, which are all pretty much on a par with each other, the Eagle
has slightly more top end power than the Lotus & Ferrari, but the
Ferrari is the best handler and most stable, followed closely by the
Lotus.
Top end and acceleration performance of the Lotus & Ferrari is
practically identical, so go with the one you feel most comfortable
with.
The Coventry, Murasama then BRM are next in that order as far as
performance stakes in F2/F3.

Cheers,
Ron



> For the same reason that you wouldn't try racing a Ferrari F40 with a
Ford
> I guess!

> MS




> > > Chris.
> > > The Brabham has a marked straight line speed advantage over all
other F3
> > > cars. It is for this reason that there is an unwritten law
amongst the
> > > regular F3 online racers that the car should not be used. Indeed,
many
> of
> > > the online leagues have banned it.

> > Why?

Bruce Kennewel

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Bruce Kennewel » Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:00:00

Do you REALLY realise what you're saying?

Flashback to 1967.  Colin Chapman, John Cooper, Dan Gurney, Enzo himself,
Sochiro Honda and Tony Rudd surround Jack Brabham and Dennis Hulme in the
Brabham pit at the Kyalami circuit.  Ron Tauranac and Phil Irving just
happen to be in attendance for the first GP of the season, looking forward
to seeing the car in action.

Chapman clears his throat and says "Errmmm, Jack old chap. Got a minute?
Good!  Well, it's just that you can't enter the Championship this year
because the Brabham is too fast.  It was too fast last year and we let that
go but twice in a row is a bit much! The other fellows and I have decided
that it's just not on that your two cars should have an advantage.  Okay?

Jack clears his throat, looks at Ron Tauranac and winks, clears his throat
and says "Colin.....piss off!!"

--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------


> Hi,
> The same is true for the Repco's advantage in F2 as it is in F3.
> That is why it is considered bad sportmanship for a faster, more
> experienced driver to use the Repco in F2 or F3.
> As a new driver to GPL, the Repco in F2 & F3 will enable the new driver
> to have a chance at being competitive with other more experienced
> drivers, but once experience and speed is gained, it is a good idea to
> go for one of the other Marques in F2/F3, when racing on-line.

> The F2 Repco is nearly as fast as the F1 Cooper.  :)

> FWIW, in F2/F3 the Repco is fastest, folllowed by the Eagle, Lotus &
> Ferrari, which are all pretty much on a par with each other, the Eagle
> has slightly more top end power than the Lotus & Ferrari, but the
> Ferrari is the best handler and most stable, followed closely by the
> Lotus.
> Top end and acceleration performance of the Lotus & Ferrari is
> practically identical, so go with the one you feel most comfortable
> with.
> The Coventry, Murasama then BRM are next in that order as far as
> performance stakes in F2/F3.

> Cheers,
> Ron



> > For the same reason that you wouldn't try racing a Ferrari F40 with a
> Ford
> > I guess!

> > MS




> > > > Chris.
> > > > The Brabham has a marked straight line speed advantage over all
> other F3
> > > > cars. It is for this reason that there is an unwritten law
> amongst the
> > > > regular F3 online racers that the car should not be used. Indeed,
> many
> > of
> > > > the online leagues have banned it.

> > > Why?

  -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
   http://www.newsfeeds.com       The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including  Dedicated  Binaries Servers ==-----
Bruce Kennewel

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Bruce Kennewel » Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:00:00

He cleared his throat twice because he was drinking a Fosters at the time
and it produces a lot of phlegm.

--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------

  -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
   http://www.newsfeeds.com       The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including  Dedicated  Binaries Servers ==-----

David Kar

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by David Kar » Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:00:00

Having a few "down" there, Bruce?
:9


==-----

Michael Barlo

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by Michael Barlo » Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:00:00


> Do you REALLY realise what you're saying?

> Flashback to 1967.  Colin Chapman, John Cooper, Dan Gurney, Enzo himself,
> Sochiro Honda and Tony Rudd surround Jack Brabham and Dennis Hulme in the
> Brabham pit at the Kyalami circuit.  Ron Tauranac and Phil Irving just
> happen to be in attendance for the first GP of the season, looking forward
> to seeing the car in action.

> Chapman clears his throat and says "Errmmm, Jack old chap. Got a minute?
> Good!  Well, it's just that you can't enter the Championship this year
> because the Brabham is too fast.  It was too fast last year and we let that
> go but twice in a row is a bit much! The other fellows and I have decided
> that it's just not on that your two cars should have an advantage.  Okay?

> Jack clears his throat, looks at Ron Tauranac and winks, clears his throat
> and says "Colin.....piss off!!"

> --
> Regards,
> Bruce Kennewell,
> Canberra, Australia.
> ---------------------------

        You can also say the same thing about a show room stock SCCA race where
someone brings in a formula one racing car and declares it to be a show
room stock car.  It is a very close comparison.
asgeir nes?e

GPL-F3 - Brabham is fastest

by asgeir nes?e » Sat, 12 Feb 2000 04:00:00

In that case, the BRM should trundle on  forever, because it is so insanely
heavy...

I would think that the difference in stored energy has less to say than the drag
variable... The drag force is acceleratingly increasing with speed (at a factor
V*V*V), the stored energy is increasing constantly.

If we found a BRM to roll shorter than the Brab, the drag must be way, way
higher, since the bigger weight of the BRM points in one direction, and the drag
in the opposite...

Clumsily put, but you get the idea.

---Asgeir---


> Neither one of you have factored the weight fariable with the drag test so
> this is not totally valid. you have to remember that the heavier car will
> have a lot more energy for given speed than a lighter one .......Just a
> thought

> MS


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.