rec.autos.simulators

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

Dave Henri

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Dave Henri » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 03:18:51


   This week,  Christian Fittipaldi will fill the seat through the rest of
the season.  I would guess they will have CF full time next year in the
#43.

Goy Larse

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Goy Larse » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 06:17:53


> Particularly after today, I'd have to agree.  A good driver is a good
> driver.  I think it would have been a bit more even if JPM had run
> Indy as an oval rather than as a road course.  That would give us some
> idea of how he'd cut it in NASCAR.

> I had thought that having all the data acquisition information
> available to the drivers & engineers would erode the driver quality,
> but apparently that is not the case.  It didn't take long for JPM to
> connect with Philipe Lopez and talk about the car.  Nor did it take
> him long to adopt the terminology either.

Nigel Roebuck (sp, F1 hack) once asked Mario Andretti how he came to be
so good in all sorts of series he entered, Mario apparently answered;
"If you can drive, you can drive"

Guess that about sums it up :-), both of these guys are incredibly
talented and would do good in whatever racing series they chose to
participate in, given a fair chance

Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
"goyl at nettx dot no"

http://www.theuspits.com

"A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
--Groucho Marx--

alex

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by alex » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 08:38:53



Zanardi was way slower than Schumie Jr. in the same cars. Do
you imply that Ralf is much faster driver then Michael?

Alex.

Woodie

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Woodie » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 10:52:20

On Wed, 11 Jun 2003 22:09:44 GMT, Mike Donnelly Jr


>Could he make the jump successfully?  Probably.  But, look at JPM.
>He's a fantastic driver, and yet he has what, 2 wins?  

What do you expect?  Somebody broke his ***ing head.

Don McCorkle

Mike Donnelly J

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Mike Donnelly J » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 10:58:56


>On Wed, 11 Jun 2003 22:09:44 GMT, Mike Donnelly Jr

>>Could he make the jump successfully?  Probably.  But, look at JPM.
>>He's a fantastic driver, and yet he has what, 2 wins?  

>What do you expect?  Somebody broke his ***ing head.

>Don McCorkle

Congratulations!  You've just managed to join Mr Fisher in the
distinguished list of people on my killfile list.  And you managed to
do it in a single post.  Normally it takes several irrelevant posts to
do so.

Mike

Mike Donnelly J

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Mike Donnelly J » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 11:04:18

On Thu, 12 Jun 2003 18:51:46 +0200, Magnus Svensson


>On Wed, 11 Jun 2003 22:09:44 GMT, Mike Donnelly Jr

>>Could he make the jump successfully?  Probably.  But, look at JPM.
>>He's a fantastic driver, and yet he has what, 2 wins?  Granted, he's
>>had a lot of mechanical misfortune when he's had winning
>>opportunities, but still, if there was someone who could take on
>>Shumie, I would have put some money that it would have been him.  I'm
>>still shocked that Zanardi didnt go back and kick Shumie's butt.  That
>>was a guy with some serious car control.  Even with a slightly
>>inferior car, I figured he'd give Shumie a run.  

>Ehhh... Go back from where? He absolutely, positively *BOMBED* in
>Williams in '99. With a capital b.

Question is: was it him or the car?  As I recall, that was also when
they transitioned to grooved tires as well.  So, he had a huge change
to overcome and if I remember, the Williams wasn't as good as it could
have been.  My biggest problem with F1 is if Shumie was in a Tyrell or
other back grid car, he couldn't overcome the weakness of the car with
superior driving skills.  At best he'd get a couple of points for the
team here and there.  Which would bring it up a few slots in the
constructors ranks, allow them to get better personell (& heavier
sponsorship to fund it) and it 3-4 seasons they'd be challenging for
the title.  BUT, only after 2-3 seasons of building and making *better
cars*.  The car is the first question, then the driving skill of the
driver.  

Sportscars and stockcars aren't the same.  They're closer that F1 &
stockcars, but there isn't a european equivilent to NASCAR over there.
Yet.

lol.  I bet they didn't know who he was.  I imagine that if he (or his
agent) had called ahead, it would have gone a bit differently...

When he gets tired of F1 and still has a hankering to drive, I'd say
come on over and give it a serious try.

Mike

Mike Donnelly J

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Mike Donnelly J » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 11:04:20

On Thu, 12 Jun 2003 23:38:53 GMT,




>> I'm
>> still shocked that Zanardi didnt go back and kick Shumie's butt.  That
>> was a guy with some serious car control.  Even with a slightly
>> inferior car, I figured he'd give Shumie a run.  
>Zanardi was way slower than Schumie Jr. in the same cars. Do
>you imply that Ralf is much faster driver then Michael?

>Alex.

Nope.  I just figured after watching him clean the house in CART (back
when those guys were good), he'd go over a start wiping the floor with
Michael.  Didn't happen.  Pure miscalculation on my part.

Mike

David G Fishe

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by David G Fishe » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 12:09:21




> >On Wed, 11 Jun 2003 22:09:44 GMT, Mike Donnelly Jr

> >>Could he make the jump successfully?  Probably.  But, look at JPM.
> >>He's a fantastic driver, and yet he has what, 2 wins?

> >What do you expect?  Somebody broke his ***ing head.

> >Don McCorkle

> Congratulations!  You've just managed to join Mr Fisher in the
> distinguished list of people on my killfile list.  And you managed to
> do it in a single post.  Normally it takes several irrelevant posts to
> do so.

> Mike

Fame at last.

David G Fisher

- Show quoted text -

Magnus Svensso

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Magnus Svensso » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 12:44:05

On Fri, 13 Jun 2003 02:04:18 GMT, Mike Donnelly Jr


>>Ehhh... Go back from where? He absolutely, positively *BOMBED* in
>>Williams in '99. With a capital b.

>Question is: was it him or the car?  As I recall, that was also when
>they transitioned to grooved tires as well.  So, he had a huge change
>to overcome and if I remember, the Williams wasn't as good as it could
>have been.  My biggest problem with F1 is if Shumie was in a Tyrell or
>other back grid car, he couldn't overcome the weakness of the car with
>superior driving skills.  At best he'd get a couple of points for the
>team here and there.  Which would bring it up a few slots in the
>constructors ranks, allow them to get better personell (& heavier
>sponsorship to fund it) and it 3-4 seasons they'd be challenging for
>the title.  BUT, only after 2-3 seasons of building and making *better
>cars*.  The car is the first question, then the driving skill of the
>driver.  

It was him, and he's among the first to admit it. Because there was
another Shumacher sitting in an exactly as bad a car; Ralfie.

It was true that Williams wasn't at the top of their game in '98 and
'99(to say the least), they were a bit caught out by the rule changes
in '98, grooved tyres et.al. But if you compare the two teammates
Ralfie completely trounced poor Alessandro. Check out the European GP
that year for instance:

Ralf:   Q 4    Race 4

Alex:   Q 18(!)  Race DNF

Ralf outqualified Zanardi by almost _two_ whole seconds. Furthermore,
Ralfie took three podiums, five fourth and three fifth places that
year. Alex didn't take one single point but racked up 10 DNFs!

According to Zanardi himself he couldn't get to terms with the
carbon-carbon brakes and the many setup options on an F1 compared to a
champcar. Williams even tried carbon-steel brakes that year to see if
that would make any difference...

Well, as far as I'm concerned it is close enough. In sportscar racing
the #1 issue is tyre conservation. I suppose it is in NASCAR aswell,
maybe even moreso. Apart from plate tracks of course.

J.D. Elli

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by J.D. Elli » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 14:15:33



> On Thu, 12 Jun 2003 18:51:46 +0200, Magnus Svensson

> >There was an anecdote from last year that said that Michael on
> >vacation in Texas went to the motorspeedway there to try out the Petty
> >experience(or something similar?) but grew tired of waiting in line...
> >Imagine the PR-value lost there and then.

> lol.  I bet they didn't know who he was.  I imagine that if he (or his
> agent) had called ahead, it would have gone a bit differently...

I believe part of said story was the Michael purposely showed-up unannouced
to avoid any special treatment.  Since the wait was long that particular
day, he elected to head back to wherever he was vacationing without making a
scene or a big deal out of it.

-jde

J.D. Elli

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by J.D. Elli » Sat, 14 Jun 2003 14:16:53


For those that missed the re-airs last night, I believe I saw it will be
shown again during prime time next Friday.

-jde

Nick

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Nick » Sun, 15 Jun 2003 00:02:35



There kinda is, it's called ASCAR. It's about as popular as NASCAR is
outside the US, (ie) nobody cares.

Carl Ribbegaard

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Carl Ribbegaard » Sun, 15 Jun 2003 10:17:03

LOL :)
Mike Donnelly J

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by Mike Donnelly J » Sun, 15 Jun 2003 11:38:05





>> Sportscars and stockcars aren't the same.  They're closer that F1 &
>> stockcars, but there isn't a european equivilent to NASCAR over there.
>> Yet.

>There kinda is, it's called ASCAR. It's about as popular as NASCAR is
>outside the US, (ie) nobody cares.

Okay, looks like I sit corrected.  It's unfortunate that it's not
picked up over there, but, this isn't a perfect world.

Mike

saul

OT - Gordon/Montoya at Indy

by saul » Sun, 15 Jun 2003 16:29:35

i agree!! if you have those instincts that make you a good driver in one
series i think that with practice those same instincts could be developed in
another series.



> > Particularly after today, I'd have to agree.  A good driver is a good
> > driver.  I think it would have been a bit more even if JPM had run
> > Indy as an oval rather than as a road course.  That would give us some
> > idea of how he'd cut it in NASCAR.

> > I had thought that having all the data acquisition information
> > available to the drivers & engineers would erode the driver quality,
> > but apparently that is not the case.  It didn't take long for JPM to
> > connect with Philipe Lopez and talk about the car.  Nor did it take
> > him long to adopt the terminology either.

> Nigel Roebuck (sp, F1 hack) once asked Mario Andretti how he came to be
> so good in all sorts of series he entered, Mario apparently answered;
> "If you can drive, you can drive"

> Guess that about sums it up :-), both of these guys are incredibly
> talented and would do good in whatever racing series they chose to
> participate in, given a fair chance

> Beers and cheers
> (uncle) Goy
> "goyl at nettx dot no"

> http://www.theuspits.com

> "A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
> --Groucho Marx--


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.