rec.autos.simulators

GTR Demo

David G Fishe

GTR Demo

by David G Fishe » Tue, 04 May 2004 13:47:08

Gave this a good run tonight, and it's pretty much exactly as I expected.
It's F1C except with GT cars. Feels and looks  just like F1C, which is
great.

With the default setup I managed a 2:15, but there were some major mistakes,
so I'm sure a 2:12 is possible eventually.

At first, the car was unstable and I wasn't too thrilled with how it felt.
Then I decided I'd do a little experiment and check and see what would
happen if I set up my wheel with the *exact* same settings as I do in F1C.
It instantly felt much, much better (as opposed to default settings), and I
quickly put up the 2:15. That proves to me how much this game is connected
to F1C. It's funny when I read in various forums where guys who have been
critical of F1C are trying to come up with an explanation as to why they
like this demo, and think the physics are so great. They are doing their
best to try and convince people that there's a major difference between the
two. Fact is, they were just plain wrong about F1C. They obviously just
don't like modern F1, can't come to grips with the F1 cars, or they didn't
bother to give F1C enough time due to being strangely devoted fans of other
developers.

My only problem with this sim is that the cars are so slow compared to the
F1 cars in F1C. The thrill (as with the NASCAR and TPTCC cars) just isn't
there for me. I could lap one of these GT cars with an F1 car in a handful
of laps. Schumacher said recently, "I like precise cars," he says. "I don't
like these heavy things. They
are so slow, and I think they are going too slow for me. I try always
to do more than they can do."

That's basically how I feel about any sim car that isn't an F1 jet. I enjoy
racing the other types of cars online, but offline I very quickly get bored.

I'm sure now though that GTR will be the best non-F1 sim when it's released.

David G Fisher

Pete

GTR Demo

by Pete » Tue, 04 May 2004 13:55:03

    David, just out of curiosity. What do you have your wheel settings
set to? I haven't tried F1C so I don't have a comparison to make.

    Pete



Damien Evan

GTR Demo

by Damien Evan » Tue, 04 May 2004 14:44:17

It's very fashionable to bash modern F1.  Didn't you know that?   ;-)
Jason Moy

GTR Demo

by Jason Moy » Tue, 04 May 2004 14:45:24

On Mon, 3 May 2004 00:47:08 -0400, "David G Fisher"


> It's funny when I read in various forums where guys who have been
>critical of F1C are trying to come up with an explanation as to why they
>like this demo, and think the physics are so great. They are doing their
>best to try and convince people that there's a major difference between the
>two. Fact is, they were just plain wrong about F1C. They obviously just
>don't like modern F1, can't come to grips with the F1 cars, or they didn't
>bother to give F1C enough time due to being strangely devoted fans of other
>developers.

I can't speak for anyone else (you'd be surprised how often I've had
to defend F1C to people who still think GPL is the greatest sim ever)
but I like F1C except for 2 things:  the multi code, and the poor
track design.  I still fire up F1C for some laps around Brand's,
Laguna, or Donington, which are all pretty nice (the version I have of
Brand's still has that stupid poly-seam in Druids, but other than that
it's a great track).

On that note, the thing that has me most e***d about the GTR demo is
having a good version of Spa.  I really wish it didn't use the new
file format becuse I'd love to import it into F1C.

Jason

Jan Verschuere

GTR Demo

by Jan Verschuere » Tue, 04 May 2004 19:36:26

I'm pretty much of the same opinion. Except I would say it looks better than
and feels exactly like the GTR2002, which is, indeed, a wonderfull thing.

Even more so seeing as, once released, it's not going to be an F1 game
underneath anymore and we'll be able to have proper GT races (possibly even
online!).

You just had to be quicker than your average Joe, hadn't you? <vbg>

They've licensed the ISI/F1C physics engine, so I don't see why our wheel
settings should be any different.

There isn't, but people often confuse actual physics calculations with the
implementation, i.e. the data fed into the engine in order to simulate a
particular car/series.

Perception is a hard thing to overcome. I think F1C is a good representation
as well.

I agree, for online racing, the sort of car doesn't really matter. The
racing does.

Offline I drive to enjoy my driving and, in that respect, the modern F1s are
just a bit intense for my liking. It would take a considerable effort on my
part to get to a reasonable level with them and, seeing as my spare simming
time is limited as it is, I prefer something that's easier to pick up like
LFS or GT2002/ETCC.

Which is not to say I don't drive an F1 car now and again, badly. ;-))

It's hard to make a call like that, but it will rival NR2003/PWFTA for some.

Jan.
=---

Uwe Sch??rkam

GTR Demo

by Uwe Sch??rkam » Tue, 04 May 2004 19:59:35


>     David, just out of curiosity. What do you have your wheel settings
> set to? I haven't tried F1C so I don't have a comparison to make.

>     Pete

I think dave recommends 50% sensitivity and cranking up the wheel lock
as high as possible until the car becomes too squiggly.

cheers,

uwe

--
mail replies to Uwe at schuerkamp dot de ( yahoo address is spambox)
Uwe Schuerkamp //////////////////////////// http://www.schuerkamp.de/
Herford, Germany \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ (52.0N/8.5E)
GPG Fingerprint:  2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F  67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61

David G Fishe

GTR Demo

by David G Fishe » Tue, 04 May 2004 21:01:43

50% is the default for the x axis sensitivity setting in both F1C and GTR.

I turn it down to 35% and the car instantly feels much better. It then feels
like it has some weight (like a machine made of metal instead of balsa wood
:-) ), and I can run a far smoother lap.

Of course this steering setting might not be the correct one work for other
wheels, but for my Thrustmaster Ferrari FF wheel it's what works. I'd
suggest that people try different settings and see if it helps.

My other wheel settings are 50% sensitivity for both throttle and brake, 0
speed sensivity, and 0 deadzone. In case someone doesn't know, you find
these settings on the controller screen, where there is a button on the
right called "advanced".

David G Fisher



> >     David, just out of curiosity. What do you have your wheel settings
> > set to? I haven't tried F1C so I don't have a comparison to make.

> >     Pete

> I think dave recommends 50% sensitivity and cranking up the wheel lock
> as high as possible until the car becomes too squiggly.

> cheers,

> uwe

> --
> mail replies to Uwe at schuerkamp dot de ( yahoo address is spambox)
> Uwe Schuerkamp //////////////////////////// http://www.schuerkamp.de/
> Herford, Germany \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ (52.0N/8.5E)
> GPG Fingerprint:  2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F  67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61

David G Fishe

GTR Demo

by David G Fishe » Tue, 04 May 2004 21:02:48

In case you don't see my reply to Uwe:

50% is the default for the x axis sensitivity setting in both F1C and GTR.

I turn it down to 35% and the car instantly feels much better. It then feels
like it has some weight (like a machine made of metal instead of balsa wood
:-) ), and I can run a far smoother lap.

Of course this steering setting might not be the correct one work for other
wheels, but for my Thrustmaster Ferrari FF wheel it's what works. I'd
suggest that people try different settings and see if it helps.

My other wheel settings are 50% sensitivity for both throttle and brake, 0
speed sensivity, and 0 deadzone. In case someone doesn't know, you find
these settings on the controller screen, where there is a button on the
right called "advanced".

David G Fisher


>     David, just out of curiosity. What do you have your wheel settings
> set to? I haven't tried F1C so I don't have a comparison to make.

>     Pete



> > Gave this a good run tonight, and it's pretty much exactly as I
expected.
> > It's F1C except with GT cars. Feels and looks  just like F1C, which is
> > great.

> > With the default setup I managed a 2:15, but there were some major
> mistakes,
> > so I'm sure a 2:12 is possible eventually.

> > At first, the car was unstable and I wasn't too thrilled with how it
felt.
> > Then I decided I'd do a little experiment and check and see what would
> > happen if I set up my wheel with the *exact* same settings as I do in
F1C.
> > It instantly felt much, much better (as opposed to default settings),
and
> I
> > quickly put up the 2:15. That proves to me how much this game is
connected
> > to F1C. It's funny when I read in various forums where guys who have
been
> > critical of F1C are trying to come up with an explanation as to why they
> > like this demo, and think the physics are so great. They are doing their
> > best to try and convince people that there's a major difference between
> the
> > two. Fact is, they were just plain wrong about F1C. They obviously just
> > don't like modern F1, can't come to grips with the F1 cars, or they
didn't
> > bother to give F1C enough time due to being strangely devoted fans of
> other
> > developers.

> > My only problem with this sim is that the cars are so slow compared to
the
> > F1 cars in F1C. The thrill (as with the NASCAR and TPTCC cars) just
isn't
> > there for me. I could lap one of these GT cars with an F1 car in a
handful
> > of laps. Schumacher said recently, "I like precise cars," he says. "I
> don't
> > like these heavy things. They
> > are so slow, and I think they are going too slow for me. I try always
> > to do more than they can do."

> > That's basically how I feel about any sim car that isn't an F1 jet. I
> enjoy
> > racing the other types of cars online, but offline I very quickly get
> bored.

> > I'm sure now though that GTR will be the best non-F1 sim when it's
> released.

> > David G Fisher

Damien Evan

GTR Demo

by Damien Evan » Tue, 04 May 2004 21:10:23

For those familiar with Papy games, 50% is full linear - 0% is full
non-linear.  I prefer to run at 50% and reduce the steering lock a little if
it's too twitchy.

Joachim Trens

GTR Demo

by Joachim Trens » Tue, 04 May 2004 21:40:32


> 50% is the default for the x axis sensitivity setting in both F1C and GTR.

I have that set to 15%, and throttle and brake as well I think, or only
slightly higher, like 25%.

However, a lot can be done by tweaking the slow bump/rebound settings
and the diff. Both affect the under/oversteer behaviour considerably.

I'm using a 50/50 diff right now.

Achim

Pete

GTR Demo

by Pete » Tue, 04 May 2004 23:21:59

    Thanks all. Gives me some things to work with.

    Pete



> > 50% is the default for the x axis sensitivity setting in both F1C and
GTR.

> I have that set to 15%, and throttle and brake as well I think, or only
> slightly higher, like 25%.

> However, a lot can be done by tweaking the slow bump/rebound settings
> and the diff. Both affect the under/oversteer behaviour considerably.

> I'm using a 50/50 diff right now.

> Achim

Mitch_

GTR Demo

by Mitch_ » Wed, 05 May 2004 00:57:26

Something feels different about this GTR demo vs F1C to me Dave.  Throttle
response at slow speeds seem much more crisp.  All of the ISI F1 sims and
even Papy sims (other than GPL) seem to have a throttle response lag or dead
spot at low speed.  You punch the throttle but until you gather some revs
you get nothing, certainly not like any 7-800hp engine Ive ever seen.  And
yes traction control is off ;)  I don't know if it's programmed in to
accommodate the less *** simmers but it's always bugged me to no end.
GTR overcomes this where all the other F1C mods don't.  Yes I know this isnt
your ordinary mod :)

Other than that you can sure tell it's F1C lineage.

2:15's, jeeeez.  Cant imagine making up much more time let alone 2+ seconds.
Sure is fun trying though.  I do stay on track throughout the lap, is there
a shortcut you guys take :)

Mitch



Tony Rickar

GTR Demo

by Tony Rickar » Wed, 05 May 2004 01:57:09


> Something feels different about this GTR demo vs F1C to me Dave.  Throttle
> response at slow speeds seem much more crisp.  All of the ISI F1 sims and
> even Papy sims (other than GPL) seem to have a throttle response lag or
dead
> spot at low speed.  You punch the throttle but until you gather some revs
> you get nothing, certainly not like any 7-800hp engine Ive ever seen.

Interesting cos that is exactly what I am complaining of with GTR!.

Particularly when coming off the gas there seems to be a huge throttle lag.
Maybe some controllers/Pc combos work better than others?


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.