rec.autos.simulators

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

jason moye

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by jason moye » Fri, 18 Apr 2008 08:53:06


In RL racing, a driver who can't provide input into setup changes is
almost completely useless.  I can't think of anyone who has been a
successful race driver and a bad test driver.

Tony Whitle

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by Tony Whitle » Tue, 22 Apr 2008 21:30:28



> > Not necessarily. Some people are good drivers with fast reactions but
> > not good setup geeks. Just like in RL racing.

> In RL racing, a driver who can't provide input into setup changes is
> almost completely useless. ?I can't think of anyone who has been a
> successful race driver and a bad test driver.

Jim Clark.
jason moye

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by jason moye » Tue, 22 Apr 2008 21:42:47



That's the one person I would have mentioned off the top of my head,
although I wonder how true it is.  It seems hard to believe that any
successful Lotus driver could be a bad test driver, due to how
sensitive Chapman's cars were to setups.  On the other hand, test
driving (at least in F1) didn't really come to the forefront as an
essential skill until Jackie Stewart and Nicki Lauda as far as I can
remember.

terminol..

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by terminol.. » Wed, 23 Apr 2008 02:55:25

On Mon, 21 Apr 2008 05:42:47 -0700 (PDT), jason moyer




>> Jim Clark.

>That's the one person I would have mentioned off the top of my head,
>although I wonder how true it is.  It seems hard to believe that any
>successful Lotus driver could be a bad test driver, due to how
>sensitive Chapman's cars were to setups.  On the other hand, test
>driving (at least in F1) didn't really come to the forefront as an
>essential skill until Jackie Stewart and Nicki Lauda as far as I can
>remember.

Ronnie Peterson was another who had a reputation as a bad test driver,
but he was such a skilled driver that he just adjusted to whatever the
problem was and drove around it.  It's said that he used to infuriate
Colin Chapman by being unable to provide any feedback whatsoever as to
car behaviour and how to improve it.  He also used to infuriate his
teammate, Emerson Fittipaldi, by loading whatever setup EF had on his
car and immediately going faster.
jason moye

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by jason moye » Wed, 23 Apr 2008 07:45:32


Yeah, that's another good one.  I have a few books on Mario Andretti,
and there are bits in there talking about Ronnie and his testing
ineptitude (also about how well they got along, and how devestated
Mario was the day after Monza 78).  Apparently during their one year
together, Mario would do his normal non-stop testing routine and
Ronnie would jump in the car and be like "feels great Mario".

Byron Forbe

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by Byron Forbe » Wed, 23 Apr 2008 17:20:17


> On Mon, 21 Apr 2008 05:42:47 -0700 (PDT), jason moyer



>>> Jim Clark.

>>That's the one person I would have mentioned off the top of my head,
>>although I wonder how true it is.  It seems hard to believe that any
>>successful Lotus driver could be a bad test driver, due to how
>>sensitive Chapman's cars were to setups.  On the other hand, test
>>driving (at least in F1) didn't really come to the forefront as an
>>essential skill until Jackie Stewart and Nicki Lauda as far as I can
>>remember.

> Ronnie Peterson was another who had a reputation as a bad test driver,
> but he was such a skilled driver that he just adjusted to whatever the
> problem was and drove around it.  It's said that he used to infuriate
> Colin Chapman by being unable to provide any feedback whatsoever as to
> car behaviour and how to improve it.  He also used to infuriate his
> teammate, Emerson Fittipaldi, by loading whatever setup EF had on his
> car and immediately going faster.

    But isn't any good driver a good test driver? Even if he hasn't got a
clue about setup/design, being able to drive the car at 10 10ths is
obviously of most importance. Obviously any feedback from someone alleged to
be cluey with setups would be worthless if they're only at 90% of that
car/setup combo's potential. I'd say as an engineer that tyre temperatures
and wear, not to mention lap times, would be a lot more important than
anything that any driver is ever going to tell you. Any driver who can drive
at 10 10ths and report basic oversteer/understeer and any other glaring
problem, is a good test driver.
Dave Seve

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by Dave Seve » Thu, 24 Apr 2008 19:57:35


> In RL racing, a driver who can't provide input into setup changes is
> almost completely useless.  I can't think of anyone who has been a
> successful race driver and a bad test driver.

Tom Cruise.
Quentin Queerbotto

"Hey Pat Dotson, Can I Try Yer Setup?" - ARCA Sim Racing

by Quentin Queerbotto » Thu, 24 Apr 2008 22:26:33



>> In RL racing, a driver who can't provide input into setup changes is
>> almost completely useless.  I can't think of anyone who has been a
>> successful race driver and a bad test driver.

> Tom Cruise.

Jean Alesi

rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.