rec.autos.simulators

Bathurst 24-Hours

Bruce Kennewel

Bathurst 24-Hours

by Bruce Kennewel » Fri, 28 Nov 2003 12:36:57

Well, Byron old mate, I've never really thought of the "V8 Supercars" as
"real Bathurst" anyway.
In MY book, real tin-top racing died there when the event was reduced to two
makes and one class.
The "Australian Touring Car Championship" with just Ford and Holden V8's?
You've gotta be kidding?!
This is a manufactured project, specifically designed for TV and nothing
else.

So, in MY book, the 24-hour is neither better nor worse than the ATCC - in
fact, with its class break-up, it is certainly closer in format (yes, I know
that the types of cars are different) to what the ATCC used to be like than
the rubbish which passes as "touring car" racing today.

Peter Brock is neither hero nor villain for me but is simply one of those
drivers I associate with the days when I used to attend every ***y event
at Oran Park, Warwick Farm, Catalina Park, Amaroo Park and Bathurst!

But then that was when motor-sports were for two classes of people:
competitors and track-side spectators.

Bruce.



Byron John Forbe

Bathurst 24-Hours

by Byron John Forbe » Sat, 29 Nov 2003 01:43:08

    No argument from me, but....
   Although the Holden/Ford only ATCC has become stale, it is still the
ATCC. And what this really means is that the best of the aussie drivers,
with a few international drivers mixed in, are there. Not so for the 24 hour
race. The 24 hour race is too international, too liberal with the rules and
most of all it's a one off. This particular win is nothing like Brocky"s
"legitimate 9" and to say it is only cheapens those 9 in my opinion. And the
man himself. No comparison. Let him grow old gracefully. It's like a 70s
band trying to make a comeback! :)


> Well, Byron old mate, I've never really thought of the "V8 Supercars" as
> "real Bathurst" anyway.
> In MY book, real tin-top racing died there when the event was reduced to
two
> makes and one class.
> The "Australian Touring Car Championship" with just Ford and Holden V8's?
> You've gotta be kidding?!
> This is a manufactured project, specifically designed for TV and nothing
> else.

> So, in MY book, the 24-hour is neither better nor worse than the ATCC - in
> fact, with its class break-up, it is certainly closer in format (yes, I
know
> that the types of cars are different) to what the ATCC used to be like
than
> the rubbish which passes as "touring car" racing today.

> Peter Brock is neither hero nor villain for me but is simply one of those
> drivers I associate with the days when I used to attend every ***y event
> at Oran Park, Warwick Farm, Catalina Park, Amaroo Park and Bathurst!

> But then that was when motor-sports were for two classes of people:
> competitors and track-side spectators.

> Bruce.



> >   So this is the "real" Bathurst in your book now Bruce? So what's the
V8
> > Supercar one then?

> >   Mate, it's gotta be part of the ATCC to qualify - in my book. Gee peop
le
> > get obsessed with their heroes and nice round numbers like "10"! :)

Bruce Kennewel

Bathurst 24-Hours

by Bruce Kennewel » Sat, 29 Nov 2003 03:57:55

"Cheapens the other nine"?!!
Gimme a break!
Taking part in punting ANY car around Panorama for 24 hours is in no way
"cheapening" any previous six-hour effort, irrespective of when it took
place and in what type of car.

Bruce.



is only cheapens those 9 in my opinion.

Jeff Shar

Bathurst 24-Hours

by Jeff Shar » Sat, 29 Nov 2003 11:33:29

On Thu, 27 Nov 2003 16:43:08 GMT, "Byron John Forbes"


>    No argument from me, but....
>   Although the Holden/Ford only ATCC has become stale, it is still the
>ATCC. And what this really means is that the best of the aussie drivers,
>with a few international drivers mixed in, are there. Not so for the 24 hour
>race. The 24 hour race is too international, too liberal with the rules and
>most of all it's a one off. This particular win is nothing like Brocky"s
>"legitimate 9" and to say it is only cheapens those 9 in my opinion. And the
>man himself. No comparison. Let him grow old gracefully. It's like a 70s
>band trying to make a comeback! :)

"too international, too liberal with the rules and
most of all it's a one off." Sounds like the year that Bathurst was a
round of the failed World Touring Car Championship.
Byron John Forbe

Bathurst 24-Hours

by Byron John Forbe » Sat, 29 Nov 2003 22:04:37

   All this 24 hour race is is a showcase for GM. They own it! Not a level
playing field for the top runners at all. Joke.
      Don't tell me Bruce, that when they ran the 4 bangers there that you
thought that was a legit "Bathurst" race as well?

   Anyway, so your saying that this 24 hour race is the new "Real Bathurst"
race and that the V8 Supercar one is just another race at Bathurst?

   Gimme a break! :)


> "Cheapens the other nine"?!!
> Gimme a break!
> Taking part in punting ANY car around Panorama for 24 hours is in no way
> "cheapening" any previous six-hour effort, irrespective of when it took
> place and in what type of car.

> Bruce.



> > This particular win is nothing like Brocky"s "legitimate 9" and to say
it
> is only cheapens those 9 in my opinion.

Bruce Kennewel

Bathurst 24-Hours

by Bruce Kennewel » Sun, 30 Nov 2003 07:19:52

Give it a rest, Byron.
You know what you like; I know what I like.
Leave it at that.

BK



>    All this 24 hour race is is a showcase for GM. They own it! Not a level
> playing field for the top runners at all. Joke.
>       Don't tell me Bruce, that when they ran the 4 bangers there that you
> thought that was a legit "Bathurst" race as well?

>    Anyway, so your saying that this 24 hour race is the new "Real
Bathurst"
> race and that the V8 Supercar one is just another race at Bathurst?

>    Gimme a break! :)



> > "Cheapens the other nine"?!!
> > Gimme a break!
> > Taking part in punting ANY car around Panorama for 24 hours is in no way
> > "cheapening" any previous six-hour effort, irrespective of when it took
> > place and in what type of car.

> > Bruce.



> > > This particular win is nothing like Brocky"s "legitimate 9" and to say
> it
> > is only cheapens those 9 in my opinion.

Byron John Forbe

Bathurst 24-Hours

by Byron John Forbe » Sun, 30 Nov 2003 22:04:28

   Ok then. I'm counting this as my 10th usenet victory then.

  LOL.


> Give it a rest, Byron.
> You know what you like; I know what I like.
> Leave it at that.

> BK



> >    All this 24 hour race is is a showcase for GM. They own it! Not a
level
> > playing field for the top runners at all. Joke.
> >       Don't tell me Bruce, that when they ran the 4 bangers there that
you
> > thought that was a legit "Bathurst" race as well?

> >    Anyway, so your saying that this 24 hour race is the new "Real
> Bathurst"
> > race and that the V8 Supercar one is just another race at Bathurst?

> >    Gimme a break! :)



> > > "Cheapens the other nine"?!!
> > > Gimme a break!
> > > Taking part in punting ANY car around Panorama for 24 hours is in no
way
> > > "cheapening" any previous six-hour effort, irrespective of when it
took
> > > place and in what type of car.

> > > Bruce.



> > > > This particular win is nothing like Brocky"s "legitimate 9" and to
say
> > it
> > > is only cheapens those 9 in my opinion.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.