I have to reply to this message, because I seem to be unable to load
previously d-loaded message headers from this NG.
As far as the gentleman who wanted to start the fight... if you want it...
here we go...
First of all it is apparent you have absolutely NO idea what you are talking
about. I can be sure of this since you refer to the MSFF-USB wheel, but it
hasn't even been released yet! (not due until the end of the Q1 or beginning
of Q2 2000) Only the MS NON-FF is available in USB currently.
Next we will go into the "High Accuracy" you speak of (except we will use
the "real" Gameport MSFF wheel). Are you aware that it is among the least
accurate wheels on the market? I mean "technically" of course. It has one of
the lowest positioning resolutions on the market. This is mainly due to the
fact that MS has to cut into the positioning resolution to combat the
ernormous amount of "jitter" these so-called accurate optical light sensors
produce. so what you are left with is a wheel with 270 degrees of turn, but
approximately 96 positioning targets to work with. That means that the wheel
is only able to translate every 3rd degree of turn. This is laughable....
the so-called unaccurate potentiometer wheels are achieving positioning
resolutions to the tune of 128+
In fact the Logitech currently possesses the highest positioning resolution
in FF wheels.
As far as the framedrops and my being crazy..... the frames are not dropping
sporatically because you are constantly being taxed with the MS digital
technology (as opposed to during right hand turns in analog wheels using the
SG). Perhaps some will have enough power in their CPU to make up the lost
time, but it IS taxing your system.
I'm not even going to start with the rachety feeling I got with the MS.
The MS wheel will perform better when it is ported to USB, since this will
solve all of the taxation issues. However... they also need to take a
serious look at their USB algorithm and how they plan to avoid dropping 3
bits of information from the positioning resolution to counteract the jitter
that would occur if they didn't.
A quick question for Mark...... do you have any idea how wheels/joysticks
work? Are you aware of how the Standard Gameport works? Are you familiar
with how the computer translates the positioning of the axis to the game?
Are you familiar with the Microsoft "Optics" you speak so highly of?
Ok..... so I'm trying to make a point..... I already know the answers to the
above questions.
"but optics, don't get ANY MORE ACCURATE Then that" under normal
circumstances this may be the case but the "optics" you speak of is really
just a mini "camera" pointing at an LED type pad. It still needs to be
looked at a lot more before they are "more accurate". Current potentiometer
implementations are still more accurate (although not perfect).
Cheers,
Shumi
P.S. Awaiting your reply... I'm just getting started....
> Hello,
> Once again, I am hurt that our wheel was not mentioned. I am not
> going to spam you, but you should at least take a look at the ACT LABS
> Force RS. www.act-labs.com
> Raymond
> ACT LABS
> >Ok, well, I'll start the fight. Here are your choices:
> > Logitech, Very Accurate in Force Functions, low force until you
replace
> >barings to ball barings. Then good wheel, uses pots, un accurate.
> > Microsft FF-USB, Not as accurate FF functions as in Logitech, but
does
> >it's job great. Currently my own and better then any thrustmaster wheel
you
> >might of owned. Frames drop? This person has gone crazy, no frames drop
> >here, ain't i don't got a powert system. Celeron 300a non o/c, w/ 256mbs
> >sdram w/ win2000 and w98se. High car point accuracy due to no stinkin
Pot
> >use, but optics, don't get ANY MORE ACCURATE Then that.
> > Guillemont, no clue.
> >--
> > Sincerely,
> > Mark F. - SimGo Director
> >Come, And Check The Best Sim Racing Site
> >Out There -SimGo, The Place For SPEED!- At:
> >http://members.xoom.com/DaRacerz/
> >http://simgo.vstores.com
> >> I'm not trying to get into a battle with you. I would just hate to see
> >> someone make a poor buying decision, when are sooo many better wheels
out
> >> there presently, and in most cases... for a better price.
> >> Cheers,
> >> Shumi
> Raymond
> ACT LABS