rec.autos.simulators

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

Eldre

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Eldre » Thu, 29 Mar 2001 07:36:35



>Its about physics, plain and simple.  Two cars cannot occupy the same space
>at the same time.  Being able to reset your car gives sim racers false
>courage.  Change all the VROC servers to Pro damage and see what happens<g>.

No one joins them.  They're all scared of the CHALLENGE...<g>

Eldred
--
Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
Homepage - http://www.racesimcentral.net/~epickett
F1 hcp. +28.67...F2 +151.26...

Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Karaya On

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Karaya On » Thu, 29 Mar 2001 07:44:00

Right.

So, if any guy might have a chance to pass me while I'm firmly entrenched in
my low line in the turn, I should back off and let him pass me. Eventually,
I'll be in last place.

Shall I slow down before the turn in case a guy might be coming, so as to
let him pass me, and avoid the wreck that might happen?

And when I want to fight my way back to the front? Only straightaway
passing, no corners?

No wonder I stuck with SCCA Solo 2 all those years. Cones don't worry about
the racing line!

************************************
  Dave Pawlikowski

  www.cushdrive.com
  www.luftwaffe-experten.com
  ICQ - 103134094
"Ah, the Luftwaffe.. The Washington
   Generals of The History Channel."
            Homer Simpson
************************************

Karaya On

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Karaya On » Thu, 29 Mar 2001 07:52:43

More than one corner? No kidding! You think??

So, I should yield to every other racer on the track while in the corner,
though I'm firmly placed in the racing line? And when I'm in last place,
then what happens?

And who knows how to race? YOU???????

************************************
  Dave Pawlikowski

  www.cushdrive.com
  www.luftwaffe-experten.com
  ICQ - 103134094
"Ah, the Luftwaffe.. The Washington
   Generals of The History Channel."
            Homer Simpson
************************************
 > >

Karaya On

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Karaya On » Thu, 29 Mar 2001 08:01:03

So - I back off even though I have the line? I force him to go around me as
we are side by side. And this makes me a bad guy? The other racer having to
actually RACE for the position?

Do some of you actually RACE on-line, or is it just one big band of
gentlemen afraid to make a stand in a turn?

When the corner comes along, is there lots of frantic typing " You first! "
" Or no! You first! " " Oh I couldn't! You please! "

If the nose of my car is at his rear quarter panel in the turn, I have no
problem backing off. There is always time to get the position back. However,
if I have the advantage of the low line and we are side by side or he is
behind I'm keeping it to the floor.

But, it seems this type of attitude is detrimental to racing. At least to a
few here.

************************************
  Dave Pawlikowski

  www.cushdrive.com
  www.luftwaffe-experten.com
  ICQ - 103134094
"Ah, the Luftwaffe.. The Washington
   Generals of The History Channel."
            Homer Simpson
************************************

> IMHO, that's the type of attitude that causes all the T1 crashes in online
> racing.
> It's better to back off and live to fight another day than push a risky
> move.

> --
> Ian P
> <email invalid due to spam>



> > Exactly.

> > Once I'm in the corner its mine. The only way he is getting it back is
> > either by outrunning me on the outside or pushing me off the track.

> > I have no intention of backing off each time he might want to pass me
and
> > get into that turn first. I'm racing.

Ian

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Ian » Thu, 29 Mar 2001 08:48:06

I race alright, it's just that I make sensible moves, not diving into the
inside of another car to try and gain a place. I will follow through a
corner and make a pass on the straight. If that's not possible I will make
sure that I have a good run into  the next corner and that the car I am
overtaking knows that I am there and has plenty of time to react to me being
there.

Although from what you're saying, you're talking more about NASCAR type oval
racing than road circuit racing, thats a totally different ball game because
you can easily run at least two wide at most ovals

--
Ian P
<email invalid due to spam>


Txl

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Txl » Thu, 29 Mar 2001 22:36:08

Rules ? in NASCAR ? they don't even have a faint clue about rules in NASCAR
!!!

Mike Eppe

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Mike Eppe » Thu, 29 Mar 2001 23:19:18

Why is it that you have to see this as a black or white issue?  Nobody is
suggesting that you yield to every driver that hints at passing you.  The
issue is about judgement... when to press and when not to press.  Pressing a
bad position into Eau Rouge or Masta is just stupid.  On the other hand, you
can have cars side-by-side through Curva Grande, if the drivers are aware
and skillful.

As a matter of fact... Yes.  Methinks thou dost protest too much.

--MikeE

Mike Donnelly J

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Mike Donnelly J » Sat, 31 Mar 2001 10:28:49


> > No, no, not at all!
> > There are NO rules for overtaking in any form of motorsport, there is only
> a
> > gentlemanly conduct that drivers are supposed to follow.

> Wrong! The "International Sporting Code", Appendix L, Chapter IV, Section 2
> is about "Overtaking".  There are clear regulations regarding what a driver
> may/may not do during overtaking.  So, yes the ARE rules for overtaking.

> Everyone would be better served if you included an "AFAIK" in front of you
> statements of pseudo-fact.

> > Rubbish. It's a race, if you can genuinely make an attempt then you are
> > entitled to, weather you make it or not.
> > The lead car does not have a right to take a tight line knowing you'll
> > touch.

> Its about physics, plain and simple.  Two cars cannot occupy the same space
> at the same time.  Being able to reset your car gives sim racers false
> courage.  Change all the VROC servers to Pro damage and see what happens<g>.

> > As far as overtaking "rules" go, they are all in the imagination of
> > Anti-Schumacher fans :-)

> And FIA apparently.

The FIA really doesn't know much about racing, at least not if you look at the
state of F1: drag race followed by a parade.  That's one good thing about short
track ovals: the FIA has 0 oversite of them.

The *smart* racers tend to use those rules that the FIA has just because they
make sense most of the time - the last few laps being the exception.  I've heard
a lot of smart racers (*** and otherwise) use the quote "you can't win the
race on the first lap, but you can certainly lose it".  It's the reality that if
you don't take care in passing, you'll wreck.  If you wreck often enough, you'll
eventually lose your ride.  Just ask Robby Gordon.  About the only way he's
going to race is out of his own pocket.

Mike Donnelly J

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Mike Donnelly J » Sat, 31 Mar 2001 11:05:08


> So - I back off even though I have the line? I force him to go around me as
> we are side by side. And this makes me a bad guy? The other racer having to
> actually RACE for the position?

> Do some of you actually RACE on-line, or is it just one big band of
> gentlemen afraid to make a stand in a turn?

> When the corner comes along, is there lots of frantic typing " You first! "
> " Or no! You first! " " Oh I couldn't! You please! "

This kinda reminds me of a race in an online league I had a few years ago.  A
friend of mine (who incidently is my teamate - still) were racing at Phoenix and
as we went into the final turn early in the race it was him and I and while I
was under him and could have pushed my position, I elected not to - I didn't
want to mess up my teamate's car (particularly since I'm the owner!).  Well, he
kept to the high line because he didn't want to tangle with *his* teammate
either...  So, after a moment's hesitation and the realization that the other
guy was giving up the line - you guessed it! - we both accepted the other's
offer.  I managed not to destroy my teammate's car at the cost of my own.

Some days it doesn't pay to be the nice guy.

Dave Henri

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Dave Henri » Sat, 31 Mar 2001 11:11:57


  Dale Jarret did much the same several years ago in a Busch race.  He had
caught the leader with about 3 laps to go...a kid who had NEVER won before..
Jarret was a Daytona winner, a Winston Cup contender, and yet he stayed
behind the fellow for the last laps with SEVERAL opportunities to spin him
out of the way...(short track..Marty or Bristol??)
dave henrie

GraDe

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by GraDe » Sun, 01 Apr 2001 03:37:55


Doh! So there are... that'll teach me to skip over things.
Anyhow, part of what I was saying still stands... people tend to decide on
their own rules too much to suit their own driver.
If a leading car doesn't leave room for an overtaking car I think he's in
the wrong.
If an overtaking car makes an attempt when the leading car is ahead earning
he has already turned and a collision is imminent then it's his fault.

That's just my own idea of things and it applies to every touch. Peoples
views of the rules change from incident to incident to suit the driver they
follow to much IMO.

GraDe

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by GraDe » Sun, 01 Apr 2001 03:39:40



> > It's only all common sense and chivalry. That's why I sort of defended
> > Rubens in Melbourne. The TV shots showed he tried to back out (broke
very
> > very hard to stop the car) when he realised he was too far back.
Frentzen
> > had the idea in his head that if he's ahead, he "owns" the corner, so he
> > turned in much too sharply with a car to your inside, Rubens nose was
there
> > and bam, out goes Heinz. In fairness to Rubens he looked like he tried
to
> > back out but couldn't completely stop his car at that speed! Frentzen
took a
> > very tight racing line as if there wasn't a car in sight hoping that if
they
> > did touch he'd just blame Rubens as "he owned the corner".

> IMO you are talking utter rubbish, just my opinion of course.

> Gerry

Ok, if that's your pinion, after reading your own in-depth explanation  I
how have seen overtaking in a new light :-)
GraDe

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by GraDe » Sun, 01 Apr 2001 03:44:16


Well that's where the confusion is made.
I don't get this "owning a corner". You have to keep fighting, most of the
time in F1 drivers just sort of give up or allow someone past after such a
point as they'll get it anyway but that's off the topic.

If a guy has an inch on your back wheel you don't let him past, no not at
all. BUT! But if you turn in on him, you'll go out of the race and blame
him. Its not That fair, you're moving into his space yet you blame him.
You have to fight fight fight but if a guy even has an inch on you  have to
allow him his space, you do NOT have to let him past, IMO.
They are two very different things IMHO.

GraDe

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by GraDe » Sun, 01 Apr 2001 03:47:02




> > Co-incidentally this is the reason I like guys like Montoya and
> Schumacher,
> > if their on your inside and think they can make it, they'll race you and
> go
> > for it! It's racing afterall!
> > And it's the same reason i don't like the style of someone like DC. "I
was
> > 2mm ahead, I owned the corner, I had to right to turn in on
him"...etc...
> > Rubbish!

> Oh come on, when did he last do that?

> In the last couple of seasons I reckon Coulthard has made some of the best
> (only?) overtaking moves on the track.

> Two years ago he did manage to spin out his team-mate with a rather dumb
> move, but since then he's been excellent in the overtaking department (if
> not everywhere else...).

> It all started when he was accused of being "too nice", so he's now making
> sure he overtakes whenever he can!

heh hehe, I did exaggerate.
But what I mean is that in the few of DC's overtaking manoeuvres he's
touched people (i.e. Schumacehr) who resisted the overtaking manoeuvre.
The French (Fish) Finger suggested he didn't approve of MS fighting back in
a corner that was "his".

I fairness though, I'm picking on DC, that's not fair in this situation.

Gerry Aitke

How far alongside for a corner to be yours?

by Gerry Aitke » Wed, 04 Apr 2001 01:56:29


> Ok, if that's your pinion, after reading your own in-depth explanation  I
> how have seen overtaking in a new light :-)

RB had a brain-fart, how much more in-depth explanation is needed? I'm
amazed you think Frentzen had time to check to see if someone was on
collision course, what with him being a bit busy turning the corner at
the time. BTW, he had to turn the corner at some point. RB came from SO
far back with no hope of achieving his goal, that only a real novice
observer would lay any blame AT ALL at HHF's door.

Gerry

PS. Please keep away from VROC.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.