Whether you are wrong or right, and in general I think you are right, it's
still no excuse for the sloppy recent batch of F1 titles.
Even if GP3, F1RC, F12K and F1CS2K were as good as is possible in terms of
their physics (which I doubt anyway), that doesn't excuse poor (slow) 3d
engines, graphical glitches, dreadful AI, poor replay systems, stupid
limited frame-rates, inaccurate track layouts, poor carshapes, inaccurate
data, awful sound and failure to use the latest hardware (both audio and
video).
I won't say which of those games suffers from which of those flaws, but
obviously not all those flaws are in all those games.
GPL clearly has more than just sim-friendly cars, it also has real quality
in every area.