rec.autos.simulators

Review of GP2 in UK Edge magazine

Glenn Davi

Review of GP2 in UK Edge magazine

by Glenn Davi » Wed, 20 Mar 1996 04:00:00

There is a review of GP in this months issue of Edge (Issue 31, April
1996). Whilst the review did not have much in the way of details about
the *features* of the game (other than to say that there are many), it
did have some interesting things to say regarding speed:

"F1GP2 has the fastest polygon engine that currently exists on the PC.
In both VGA and SVGA it easily outpaces all its rivals, running at
around 25 frames per second on a slow Pentium in VGA and near that on
a P100 with a decent graphics card on a P100"

"For those with a lower end PC it is possible to alter the scenery
using the extremely effective in-race detail settings. This enables
even a 486/66 to run the game quite adequately".

Comments like these make me wonder if:

a) There are two versions of GP2 out there - one optimised and one not
- and magazines are reviewing different versions.

or

b) Magazines are simply making these reviews up !

I rather hope it is a) !! For what it's worth, Edge gave the game a
score of 9 out of 10. I find their reviews usually reliable - if
sometimes a little harsh (particularly if the reviewer is not a fan of
the genre of the game he is reviewing). They gave ICR2 5 out of 10 - a
mark with which I do not agree - the same reviewer went on to give the
graphically excellent but limited in lasting playability Ridge Racer
Revolution (Playstation) 7 !!!


Mark Newma

Review of GP2 in UK Edge magazine

by Mark Newma » Sat, 23 Mar 1996 04:00:00

It seems odd that magazines (PC Gamer for instance) reviewed this game
so far back.

How *on Earth* can they have reviewed a reliable version of the game two
issues ago - the review must have been written *3* months ago.

And look at the Edge screenshots: one of them (from in the car) doesn't
have any numbers on the dashboard!

Very fishy.
--
MarkN

Jeff Vince

Review of GP2 in UK Edge magazine

by Jeff Vince » Mon, 25 Mar 1996 04:00:00


>>b) Magazines are simply making these reviews up !
>It seems odd that magazines (PC Gamer for instance) reviewed this game
>so far back.
>How *on Earth* can they have reviewed a reliable version of the game two
>issues ago - the review must have been written *3* months ago.
>And look at the Edge screenshots: one of them (from in the car) doesn't
>have any numbers on the dashboard!
>Very fishy.

   Kind of like the "review" of GPManager in the April issue of "Racer".
*Everyone* here knows its chock full of bugs.  It looks like they just
reprinted a press release verbatim.  True, its not their job to review
software, but if you're going to promote it (which they are doing putting
it on their pages), you should at least find out if its a functional,
competent piece of software.  :(


Pick one or more: Model Rockets (competition-NERCB) / PCs (even Atari!) /
ICR-PRO / NASCAR-NRL / Who needs a life when you have multiple non-lives?

Bruno Schleic

Review of GP2 in UK Edge magazine

by Bruno Schleic » Thu, 28 Mar 1996 04:00:00



>>b) Magazines are simply making these reviews up !
>>It seems odd that magazines (PC Gamer for instance) reviewed this game
>>so far back.
>>How *on Earth* can they have reviewed a reliable version of the game
>>twoissues ago - the review must have been written *3* months ago.
>>And look at the Edge screenshots: one of them (from in the car) doesn't
>>have any numbers on the dashboard!
>>Very fishy.

>    Kind of like the "review" of GPManager in the April issue of "Racer".
> *Everyone* here knows its chock full of bugs.  It looks like they just
> reprinted a press release verbatim.  True, its not their job to review
> software, but if you're going to promote it (which they are doing putting
> it on their pages), you should at least find out if its a functional,
> competent piece of software.  :(

Just like the PC Gamer Review of GPManager - not one single mention of
the bugs, and instead of doing a proper review, they had a silly dialog
on how many buttons there were to click...
And the F1GP2 review (available now they said - either they are naive or
something else) - how can you review an unfinished product and comment on
its speed etc...
 Last time I buy PC Gamer...


Terje Wold Johans

Review of GP2 in UK Edge magazine

by Terje Wold Johans » Sat, 30 Mar 1996 04:00:00



...
> Just like the PC Gamer Review of GPManager - not one single mention of
> the bugs, and instead of doing a proper review, they had a silly dialog
> on how many buttons there were to click...
> And the F1GP2 review (available now they said - either they are naive or
> something else) - how can you review an unfinished product and comment on
> its speed etc...
>  Last time I buy PC Gamer...

I know a *lot* of people who feel the same about PC Gamer and
other game mags.
I never buy them because they are usually 100% full of shit.

The worst review I have ever read(I read the very interesting stuff
at the newsstands...) was the PC Zone's review of GP2.
That was crappiest piece of journalism I have ever read bare none.

Even my little sister, who is eight, believed that the reviewer was
imbecility personified.

--
--- Terje Wold Johansen

--- http://www.ifi.uio.no/~terjjo/
--- "I am your inferior superior." O.W.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.