rec.autos.simulators

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

Tim Epstei

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Tim Epstei » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 04:31:32

Hi,

I downloaded a "fast" rallyX replay today - 1:11:22 was the time for one lap
in a turbo. What dissapointed me was the attitude of the car into the
corners on dirt. This was the same as on tarmac, nice clean line with
neutral handling - almost no steering lock at all. In fact I didn't even see
any opposite lock coming out of the dirt corners.

I RallyCrossed many RWD cars for many years, and as anyone who has even
watched them on TV will assert, driving without oversteer on dirt is a very
slow way around the track in reality, but unfortunately appears to be the
fastest on LFS.

There are many reasons to throw a car sideways under brakes (or scando) in
corners. First up is that*** the tail slows you down a hell of a lot
faster than braking in a straight line, as you build up resistance from
pushing the gravel ahead of 4 offset tyres instead of just the front 2. Then
with the car nicely set up for the corner, you can power on much earlier, as
the throttle is helping push the car around the corner.

One disclaimer - due to my bad FPS rate at the moment, I haven't had a
chance to drive in LFS smoothly myself, so am relying on watching the
replays of others. I know that LFS has astoundingly good physics on tarmac,
but would any other real world rally drivers care to comment on their
impressions of the dirt handling?

Thanks,
Tim

Andreas Nystro

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Andreas Nystro » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 05:02:15

Just cause the guy in the replay doesnt use opposite lock, you cant really
turn it down. This is just a early demo / alpha, at v0.04, we cant expect
miracles yet.

I myself have big problems keeping the tail on the RWD in the tarmac, im all
over the place and have to opposite lock most of the times not to go off the
track.


Larr

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Larr » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 05:09:34

I take it the turbo is a RWD?

Man, I can't wait to graduate.  I hate this FWD ***:)

-Larry


> Just cause the guy in the replay doesnt use opposite lock, you cant really
> turn it down. This is just a early demo / alpha, at v0.04, we cant expect
> miracles yet.

> I myself have big problems keeping the tail on the RWD in the tarmac, im
all
> over the place and have to opposite lock most of the times not to go off
the
> track.



> > Hi,

> > I downloaded a "fast" rallyX replay today - 1:11:22 was the time for one
> lap
> > in a turbo. What dissapointed me was the attitude of the car into the
> > corners on dirt. This was the same as on tarmac, nice clean line with
> > neutral handling - almost no steering lock at all. In fact I didn't even
> see
> > any opposite lock coming out of the dirt corners.

> > I RallyCrossed many RWD cars for many years, and as anyone who has even
> > watched them on TV will assert, driving without oversteer on dirt is a
> very
> > slow way around the track in reality, but unfortunately appears to be
the
> > fastest on LFS.

> > There are many reasons to throw a car sideways under brakes (or scando)
in
> > corners. First up is that*** the tail slows you down a hell of a
lot
> > faster than braking in a straight line, as you build up resistance from
> > pushing the gravel ahead of 4 offset tyres instead of just the front 2.
> Then
> > with the car nicely set up for the corner, you can power on much
earlier,
> as
> > the throttle is helping push the car around the corner.

> > One disclaimer - due to my bad FPS rate at the moment, I haven't had a
> > chance to drive in LFS smoothly myself, so am relying on watching the
> > replays of others. I know that LFS has astoundingly good physics on
> tarmac,
> > but would any other real world rally drivers care to comment on their
> > impressions of the dirt handling?

> > Thanks,
> > Tim

Tim Epstei

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Tim Epstei » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 05:15:08

er.. then edit cfg.txt and change selected car line to:

Selected Car XR GT TURBO

Simple as that.

Tim


> I take it the turbo is a RWD?

> Man, I can't wait to graduate.  I hate this FWD ***:)

> -Larry



> > Just cause the guy in the replay doesnt use opposite lock, you cant
really
> > turn it down. This is just a early demo / alpha, at v0.04, we cant
expect
> > miracles yet.

> > I myself have big problems keeping the tail on the RWD in the tarmac, im
> all
> > over the place and have to opposite lock most of the times not to go off
> the
> > track.



> > > Hi,

> > > I downloaded a "fast" rallyX replay today - 1:11:22 was the time for
one
> > lap
> > > in a turbo. What dissapointed me was the attitude of the car into the
> > > corners on dirt. This was the same as on tarmac, nice clean line with
> > > neutral handling - almost no steering lock at all. In fact I didn't
even
> > see
> > > any opposite lock coming out of the dirt corners.

> > > I RallyCrossed many RWD cars for many years, and as anyone who has
even
> > > watched them on TV will assert, driving without oversteer on dirt is a
> > very
> > > slow way around the track in reality, but unfortunately appears to be
> the
> > > fastest on LFS.

> > > There are many reasons to throw a car sideways under brakes (or
scando)
> in
> > > corners. First up is that*** the tail slows you down a hell of a
> lot
> > > faster than braking in a straight line, as you build up resistance
from
> > > pushing the gravel ahead of 4 offset tyres instead of just the front
2.
> > Then
> > > with the car nicely set up for the corner, you can power on much
> earlier,
> > as
> > > the throttle is helping push the car around the corner.

> > > One disclaimer - due to my bad FPS rate at the moment, I haven't had a
> > > chance to drive in LFS smoothly myself, so am relying on watching the
> > > replays of others. I know that LFS has astoundingly good physics on
> > tarmac,
> > > but would any other real world rally drivers care to comment on their
> > > impressions of the dirt handling?

> > > Thanks,
> > > Tim

Larr

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Larr » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 05:18:31

Kewl :)

Thanks!

-Larry


> er.. then edit cfg.txt and change selected car line to:

> Selected Car XR GT TURBO

> Simple as that.

> Tim



> > I take it the turbo is a RWD?

> > Man, I can't wait to graduate.  I hate this FWD ***:)

> > -Larry



> > > Just cause the guy in the replay doesnt use opposite lock, you cant
> really
> > > turn it down. This is just a early demo / alpha, at v0.04, we cant
> expect
> > > miracles yet.

> > > I myself have big problems keeping the tail on the RWD in the tarmac,
im
> > all
> > > over the place and have to opposite lock most of the times not to go
off
> > the
> > > track.



> > > > Hi,

> > > > I downloaded a "fast" rallyX replay today - 1:11:22 was the time for
> one
> > > lap
> > > > in a turbo. What dissapointed me was the attitude of the car into
the
> > > > corners on dirt. This was the same as on tarmac, nice clean line
with
> > > > neutral handling - almost no steering lock at all. In fact I didn't
> even
> > > see
> > > > any opposite lock coming out of the dirt corners.

> > > > I RallyCrossed many RWD cars for many years, and as anyone who has
> even
> > > > watched them on TV will assert, driving without oversteer on dirt is
a
> > > very
> > > > slow way around the track in reality, but unfortunately appears to
be
> > the
> > > > fastest on LFS.

> > > > There are many reasons to throw a car sideways under brakes (or
> scando)
> > in
> > > > corners. First up is that*** the tail slows you down a hell of
a
> > lot
> > > > faster than braking in a straight line, as you build up resistance
> from
> > > > pushing the gravel ahead of 4 offset tyres instead of just the front
> 2.
> > > Then
> > > > with the car nicely set up for the corner, you can power on much
> > earlier,
> > > as
> > > > the throttle is helping push the car around the corner.

> > > > One disclaimer - due to my bad FPS rate at the moment, I haven't had
a
> > > > chance to drive in LFS smoothly myself, so am relying on watching
the
> > > > replays of others. I know that LFS has astoundingly good physics on
> > > tarmac,
> > > > but would any other real world rally drivers care to comment on
their
> > > > impressions of the dirt handling?

> > > > Thanks,
> > > > Tim

Biz

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Biz » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 05:44:36

What fun would that be unless you earn your way to it.  It only takes a few hours at best to get
enough credits to reach the Turbo.
--
Biz

"Don't touch that please, your primitive intellect wouldn't understand
alloys and compositions and,......things with molecular structures,....and
the....." - Ash


> er.. then edit cfg.txt and change selected car line to:

> Selected Car XR GT TURBO

> Simple as that.

> Tim



> > I take it the turbo is a RWD?

> > Man, I can't wait to graduate.  I hate this FWD ***:)

> > -Larry



> > > Just cause the guy in the replay doesnt use opposite lock, you cant
> really
> > > turn it down. This is just a early demo / alpha, at v0.04, we cant
> expect
> > > miracles yet.

> > > I myself have big problems keeping the tail on the RWD in the tarmac, im
> > all
> > > over the place and have to opposite lock most of the times not to go off
> > the
> > > track.



> > > > Hi,

> > > > I downloaded a "fast" rallyX replay today - 1:11:22 was the time for
> one
> > > lap
> > > > in a turbo. What dissapointed me was the attitude of the car into the
> > > > corners on dirt. This was the same as on tarmac, nice clean line with
> > > > neutral handling - almost no steering lock at all. In fact I didn't
> even
> > > see
> > > > any opposite lock coming out of the dirt corners.

> > > > I RallyCrossed many RWD cars for many years, and as anyone who has
> even
> > > > watched them on TV will assert, driving without oversteer on dirt is a
> > > very
> > > > slow way around the track in reality, but unfortunately appears to be
> > the
> > > > fastest on LFS.

> > > > There are many reasons to throw a car sideways under brakes (or
> scando)
> > in
> > > > corners. First up is that*** the tail slows you down a hell of a
> > lot
> > > > faster than braking in a straight line, as you build up resistance
> from
> > > > pushing the gravel ahead of 4 offset tyres instead of just the front
> 2.
> > > Then
> > > > with the car nicely set up for the corner, you can power on much
> > earlier,
> > > as
> > > > the throttle is helping push the car around the corner.

> > > > One disclaimer - due to my bad FPS rate at the moment, I haven't had a
> > > > chance to drive in LFS smoothly myself, so am relying on watching the
> > > > replays of others. I know that LFS has astoundingly good physics on
> > > tarmac,
> > > > but would any other real world rally drivers care to comment on their
> > > > impressions of the dirt handling?

> > > > Thanks,
> > > > Tim

Gerry Aitke

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Gerry Aitke » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 05:51:09


> What fun would that be unless you earn your way to it.  It only takes a few hours at best to get
> enough credits to reach the Turbo

I'll go down the pub for a couple of hours in stead.
Larr

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Larr » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 05:52:49

Well, for one, I don't think everyone else is waiting :)

I got my DOORS blown off in the straights yesterday.

I felt like I was in a Yugo!

-Larry


few hours at best to get

> enough credits to reach the Turbo.
> --
> Biz

> "Don't touch that please, your primitive intellect wouldn't understand
> alloys and compositions and,......things with molecular structures,....and
> the....." - Ash



> > er.. then edit cfg.txt and change selected car line to:

> > Selected Car XR GT TURBO

> > Simple as that.

> > Tim



> > > I take it the turbo is a RWD?

> > > Man, I can't wait to graduate.  I hate this FWD ***:)

> > > -Larry



> > > > Just cause the guy in the replay doesnt use opposite lock, you cant
> > really
> > > > turn it down. This is just a early demo / alpha, at v0.04, we cant
> > expect
> > > > miracles yet.

> > > > I myself have big problems keeping the tail on the RWD in the
tarmac, im
> > > all
> > > > over the place and have to opposite lock most of the times not to go
off
> > > the
> > > > track.



> > > > > Hi,

> > > > > I downloaded a "fast" rallyX replay today - 1:11:22 was the time
for
> > one
> > > > lap
> > > > > in a turbo. What dissapointed me was the attitude of the car into
the
> > > > > corners on dirt. This was the same as on tarmac, nice clean line
with
> > > > > neutral handling - almost no steering lock at all. In fact I
didn't
> > even
> > > > see
> > > > > any opposite lock coming out of the dirt corners.

> > > > > I RallyCrossed many RWD cars for many years, and as anyone who has
> > even
> > > > > watched them on TV will assert, driving without oversteer on dirt
is a
> > > > very
> > > > > slow way around the track in reality, but unfortunately appears to
be
> > > the
> > > > > fastest on LFS.

> > > > > There are many reasons to throw a car sideways under brakes (or
> > scando)
> > > in
> > > > > corners. First up is that*** the tail slows you down a hell
of a
> > > lot
> > > > > faster than braking in a straight line, as you build up resistance
> > from
> > > > > pushing the gravel ahead of 4 offset tyres instead of just the
front
> > 2.
> > > > Then
> > > > > with the car nicely set up for the corner, you can power on much
> > > earlier,
> > > > as
> > > > > the throttle is helping push the car around the corner.

> > > > > One disclaimer - due to my bad FPS rate at the moment, I haven't
had a
> > > > > chance to drive in LFS smoothly myself, so am relying on watching
the
> > > > > replays of others. I know that LFS has astoundingly good physics
on
> > > > tarmac,
> > > > > but would any other real world rally drivers care to comment on
their
> > > > > impressions of the dirt handling?

> > > > > Thanks,
> > > > > Tim

Dave

LFS -dissapointing physics on RallyX

by Dave » Sun, 25 Aug 2002 06:16:00

Tim,

Wait until split axis is working to make a judgement.I can do consistent
1:08s with the turbo,but without being able to trail brake and blip the
throttle,it's impossible to drive like real life.I think the physics have a
solid foundation,but the shared axis doesn't show the full potential.

Dave K
dmk


> Hi,

> I downloaded a "fast" rallyX replay today - 1:11:22 was the time for one lap
> in a turbo. What dissapointed me was the attitude of the car into the
> corners on dirt. This was the same as on tarmac, nice clean line with
> neutral handling - almost no steering lock at all. In fact I didn't even see
> any opposite lock coming out of the dirt corners.

> I RallyCrossed many RWD cars for many years, and as anyone who has even
> watched them on TV will assert, driving without oversteer on dirt is a very
> slow way around the track in reality, but unfortunately appears to be the
> fastest on LFS.

> There are many reasons to throw a car sideways under brakes (or scando) in
> corners. First up is that*** the tail slows you down a hell of a lot
> faster than braking in a straight line, as you build up resistance from
> pushing the gravel ahead of 4 offset tyres instead of just the front 2. Then
> with the car nicely set up for the corner, you can power on much earlier, as
> the throttle is helping push the car around the corner.

> One disclaimer - due to my bad FPS rate at the moment, I haven't had a
> chance to drive in LFS smoothly myself, so am relying on watching the
> replays of others. I know that LFS has astoundingly good physics on tarmac,
> but would any other real world rally drivers care to comment on their
> impressions of the dirt handling?

> Thanks,
> Tim


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.