rec.autos.simulators

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

Eldre

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Eldre » Tue, 04 Feb 2003 01:00:37



>It seems that some really pissed off computer users who do their taxes on
>their computers are voting with their wallets, and telling Intuit exactly
>where they can stick their troublesome, intrusive "Product Activation" copy
>protection.

Did they change something with ALL their software, or just tax stuff?  I run
Quicken 2001 Deluxe.  Although I don't have any reason to change at the
moment(software runs great), I'd be concerned if I needed to upgrade...

Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.racesimcentral.net/~epickett
GPLRank:-0.381
N2002 Rank:+17.59

Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Klin

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Klin » Tue, 04 Feb 2003 22:17:26


Another option is TaxWiz (http://www.taxwiz.ca/). It's non-Intuit, can be used to
file electronically, usually available from Office Depot, Future Shop, etc for the
same price as QuickTax. Not quite as clean an interface, but I used it last year with
no problems.

...Klinn

Scott B. Husted

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Scott B. Husted » Wed, 05 Feb 2003 00:38:31

Just another little tidbit...   Starting with Quicken 2004, it will no
longer support .QIF file formats for downloading your online banking
transactions.   They are forcing financial institutions to purchase very
expensive licensing for their download products to integrate with their
online banking system.

I'm a Manager at a $92 million asset credit union and it's extremely cost
prohibitive for us to pay for their licensing which means any of our members
who will upgrade to 2004 when it is released will no longer be able to
import the QIF format we offer.   If you have thousands of online banking
users paying fees, then you may be able to justify the cost - but for a
financial institution our size, it's just not possible.  They already took
the QFX format away from us last year with an outrageous licensing fee so we
are down to OFC (MS Money),  OFX, QIF for Quicken 99 and later,  QIF for
Quicken 98 and earlier, and CSV (Comma separated variables).

It's all about the licensing $$$$.     =)

--
Scott B. Husted
PA-Scott
ICQ# 4395450
http://www.Husted.cc


> They have instituted an online product activation system that makes the
one
> in Windows XP look tame by comparision.

> It's causing no end of problems for people, especially since those that
have
> already bought it had no warning.

> One person I read about bought it, had to replace the computer two weeks
> later due to a failure in the old one, and now it won't run because it's
> calling him a thief saying he already uses it on another computer!  As far
> as I know he has gotten no satisfaction from Intuit, and he ended up
buying
> another copy.

> Not to mention people are asking what will happen when years down the
road,
> when they have most likely changed computers, they have to re-install this
> years version to submit an updated tax return or something and the damned
> thing won't run because it thinks they are cheating.

> It's an awful mess, and Intuit is trying politicaly to wiggle themselves
out
> of it with lip-service, but no one is buying.

> And get this.  When you remove TurboTax, the Macrovision Activation based
> Copy-Protection is NOT removed.

> BTW... In case you didn't know, from what I hear Quicken 2003 contains the
> same Activation-based copy protection but I have not been able to verify
> this.

> I will not be upgrading beyond Quicken 2002 for this very reason.

> Larry



> > I will be sending Intuit a fairly scathing letter about
> > > their practices and next year I'll be using some other product.
> > > dave henrie

> > What are they doing now thats makin everyone mad?

Scott B. Husted

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Scott B. Husted » Wed, 05 Feb 2003 00:39:58

Eldred,

I posted up above but you may not want to upgrade to anything past 2003 if
you download financial transactions from your financial institution.

--
Scott B. Husted
PA-Scott
ICQ# 4395450
http://www.Husted.cc




> >It seems that some really pissed off computer users who do their taxes on
> >their computers are voting with their wallets, and telling Intuit exactly
> >where they can stick their troublesome, intrusive "Product Activation"
copy
> >protection.

> Did they change something with ALL their software, or just tax stuff?  I
run
> Quicken 2001 Deluxe.  Although I don't have any reason to change at the
> moment(software runs great), I'd be concerned if I needed to upgrade...

> Eldred
> --
> Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
> GPLRank:-0.381
> N2002 Rank:+17.59

> Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats
you
> with experience...
> Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Eldre

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Eldre » Wed, 05 Feb 2003 02:16:33

Ok.  I don't download currently, and the program I have seems to be working
fine.  It's probably a 'non-issue' for me...

Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank:-0.381
N2002 Rank:+17.59

Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Tim Mise

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Tim Mise » Wed, 05 Feb 2003 05:12:51

Quicken 2003 does not contain any copy protection.

-Tim


KC

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by KC » Wed, 05 Feb 2003 12:44:47

I don't believe QuickTax has the C-Dilla program.  I was ticked off also and
did alot of reading.  You still have to activate the software, but I believe
it works like XP.  If you can find it on the quicktax.ca site(which sucks)
it says the product does not include C-Dilla.

And as far as TaxWiz, I think Intuit bought them, so in Canada we don't have
much choice.  I guess I'll just get my pencil out again.




> > This is way OT, but I found it very interesting...
>  snip
> > I went to CompUSA today for the dreaded yearly purchase of Tax software,
> and
> > I saw something that really caught my eye.
>  snip
> > It seems that some really pissed off computer users who do their taxes
on
> > their computers are voting with their wallets, and telling Intuit
exactly
> > where they can stick their troublesome, intrusive "Product Activation"
> copy
> > protection.

> Same here in Canada with Intuit's Quicktax for Canadian taxes (also CanTax
> is a Intuit product as well with activation). I happened to read the
*inner*
> flap of the box where they tell you about Product Activation (its not on
the
> outside where you can read it before you buy) before I clicked the "I
> accept"  in the product agreement. Returned it for a refund which is
> difficult in Canada for an opened box.

> If software houses are going towards using product activation schemes then
> they need to get their act together and provide "one stop shopping". They
> should all use the same criteria as Windows XP and I shpould be able to
get
> clearance for use with one toll free phone call. It would save them money
> and save me having to hassle with amatuer help.

> Since all the offline tax software in Canada is controlled by Intuit I'm
> going the online route this year with Ufile at http://www.ufile.ca/. It
will
> convert the previous years Quicktax personal data too. Just
> have to remember to do it before the big end of April rush.

> David

Larr

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Larr » Thu, 06 Feb 2003 05:07:46

It looks like the TaxCut people weren't _totally_ ready for their new-found
success.  The other night it took me 5 HOURS to get through to their update
servers to get the latest code and forms update.

And their auto-updater from within the program is just plain stupid.  It
doesn't know if it gets a "Server Not Found" error (due to the server
overload) when it tries to download the data, and the internal update engine
tries to execute/apply the 147 bytes or so of failure text that it does
grab.

LOL!

Larry


<snip>

Larr

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Larr » Thu, 06 Feb 2003 05:15:11

Pardon my french, but HORSE-SHIT!

I have a perfectly legal copy of  Windows XP Home and the stupid activation
process has triggered on me FIVE times so far, always at the worse possible
time.

Three of the five times not ONE SINGLE PIECE of hardware was changed.  It
occured after simple driver updates.

And none of the times would it re-activate over the Internet.  I had to call
the 1-800 number and plead my case with the clerk on the other end of the
phone.  It was a total waste of my time.

I have had friends get locked out of Office XP for no apparant reason (which
has been documented in news stories) while on travel, and were unable to
complete their work in time to meet deadlines.

No one has a snowball's chance in hell of changing my mind about this
subject.  Product activation treats good customers as guilty criminals from
the start, invades on your time, reduces or complicates your upgrade
process, and is a general all-around pain in the ass.

I done now.

Larry


> XP's product activation is not difficult, extremely easy (couple of mouse
> clicks online big deal) and they actually have people on the phone that
you
> can talk to to fix things.



> > "Uwe hoover Schuerkamp" wrote...
> > > <snip>
> > > I wish everybody would take Dave's advice and done
> > > the same about Windows XP... tell Billy to stick it
> > > up his rear and stop their invasion on user privacy.
> > > The world (or taker culture, for that matter ;-)
> > > would probably be a better place.

> > Hey, I'm not big on privacy and even I haven't upgraded yet! <g>

> > Jan.
> > =---

Larr

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Larr » Thu, 06 Feb 2003 05:16:57

Yeah, 2002 works just dandy.

But MS will figure out a way to break it with a Windows update eventually.

Larry


> From everything I've read, Quicken2003 isn't worth upgrading to in any
event....


> > They have instituted an online product activation system that makes the
one
> > in Windows XP look tame by comparision.

> > It's causing no end of problems for people, especially since those that
have
> > already bought it had no warning.

> > One person I read about bought it, had to replace the computer two weeks
> > later due to a failure in the old one, and now it won't run because it's
> > calling him a thief saying he already uses it on another computer!  As
far
> > as I know he has gotten no satisfaction from Intuit, and he ended up
buying
> > another copy.

> > Not to mention people are asking what will happen when years down the
road,
> > when they have most likely changed computers, they have to re-install
this
> > years version to submit an updated tax return or something and the
damned
> > thing won't run because it thinks they are cheating.

> > It's an awful mess, and Intuit is trying politicaly to wiggle themselves
out
> > of it with lip-service, but no one is buying.

> > And get this.  When you remove TurboTax, the Macrovision Activation
based
> > Copy-Protection is NOT removed.

> > BTW... In case you didn't know, from what I hear Quicken 2003 contains
the
> > same Activation-based copy protection but I have not been able to verify
> > this.

> > I will not be upgrading beyond Quicken 2002 for this very reason.

> > Larry



> > > I will be sending Intuit a fairly scathing letter about
> > > > their practices and next year I'll be using some other product.
> > > > dave henrie

> > > What are they doing now thats makin everyone mad?

Larr

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Larr » Thu, 06 Feb 2003 05:18:03

No, I can't.

I didn't install it.  I knew about it early and avoided TurboTax in the
first place, opting for TaxCut instead for the first time ever.

It ain't hard to find stories about this though.  A good Google search
should net a weeks worth of material :)

Larry


> Larry,

> Can you elaborate a bit on the Macrovision based copy protection that's
left on
> your system even after Turbotax is removed?  What are the possible
problems that
> it could cause on a PC?  Possible CD-reading problems (similar to what
some
> users experienced with N4), or something else?

> Just trying to get the complete picture on this.

> Thanks!
> Bert


> > They have instituted an online product activation system that makes the
one
> > in Windows XP look tame by comparision.

> > It's causing no end of problems for people, especially since those that
have
> > already bought it had no warning.

> > One person I read about bought it, had to replace the computer two weeks
> > later due to a failure in the old one, and now it won't run because it's
> > calling him a thief saying he already uses it on another computer!  As
far
> > as I know he has gotten no satisfaction from Intuit, and he ended up
buying
> > another copy.

> > Not to mention people are asking what will happen when years down the
road,
> > when they have most likely changed computers, they have to re-install
this
> > years version to submit an updated tax return or something and the
damned
> > thing won't run because it thinks they are cheating.

> > It's an awful mess, and Intuit is trying politicaly to wiggle themselves
out
> > of it with lip-service, but no one is buying.

> > And get this.  When you remove TurboTax, the Macrovision Activation
based
> > Copy-Protection is NOT removed.

> > BTW... In case you didn't know, from what I hear Quicken 2003 contains
the
> > same Activation-based copy protection but I have not been able to verify
> > this.

> > I will not be upgrading beyond Quicken 2002 for this very reason.

> > Larry



> > > I will be sending Intuit a fairly scathing letter about
> > > > their practices and next year I'll be using some other product.
> > > > dave henrie

> > > What are they doing now thats makin everyone mad?

Larr

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Larr » Thu, 06 Feb 2003 05:19:02

I have _read_ that Quicken 2003 also has Product Activation but since 2002
is working just fine for me I have no desire to upgrade and haven't seen
2003 personally.

Larry




> >It seems that some really pissed off computer users who do their taxes on
> >their computers are voting with their wallets, and telling Intuit exactly
> >where they can stick their troublesome, intrusive "Product Activation"
copy
> >protection.

> Did they change something with ALL their software, or just tax stuff?  I
run
> Quicken 2001 Deluxe.  Although I don't have any reason to change at the
> moment(software runs great), I'd be concerned if I needed to upgrade...

> Eldred
> --
> Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
> GPLRank:-0.381
> N2002 Rank:+17.59

> Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats
you
> with experience...
> Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Larr

OT: Saw something interesting at CompUSA today...

by Larr » Thu, 06 Feb 2003 05:20:44

I'd say Intuit sounds like they are trying to reduce themselves down to a
smaller company :)

I can do without them.

Larry



> Just another little tidbit...   Starting with Quicken 2004, it will no
> longer support .QIF file formats for downloading your online banking
> transactions.   They are forcing financial institutions to purchase very
> expensive licensing for their download products to integrate with their
> online banking system.

> I'm a Manager at a $92 million asset credit union and it's extremely cost
> prohibitive for us to pay for their licensing which means any of our
members
> who will upgrade to 2004 when it is released will no longer be able to
> import the QIF format we offer.   If you have thousands of online banking
> users paying fees, then you may be able to justify the cost - but for a
> financial institution our size, it's just not possible.  They already took
> the QFX format away from us last year with an outrageous licensing fee so
we
> are down to OFC (MS Money),  OFX, QIF for Quicken 99 and later,  QIF for
> Quicken 98 and earlier, and CSV (Comma separated variables).

> It's all about the licensing $$$$.     =)

> --
> Scott B. Husted
> PA-Scott
> ICQ# 4395450
> http://www.Husted.cc



> > They have instituted an online product activation system that makes the
> one
> > in Windows XP look tame by comparision.

> > It's causing no end of problems for people, especially since those that
> have
> > already bought it had no warning.

> > One person I read about bought it, had to replace the computer two weeks
> > later due to a failure in the old one, and now it won't run because it's
> > calling him a thief saying he already uses it on another computer!  As
far
> > as I know he has gotten no satisfaction from Intuit, and he ended up
> buying
> > another copy.

> > Not to mention people are asking what will happen when years down the
> road,
> > when they have most likely changed computers, they have to re-install
this
> > years version to submit an updated tax return or something and the
damned
> > thing won't run because it thinks they are cheating.

> > It's an awful mess, and Intuit is trying politicaly to wiggle themselves
> out
> > of it with lip-service, but no one is buying.

> > And get this.  When you remove TurboTax, the Macrovision Activation
based
> > Copy-Protection is NOT removed.

> > BTW... In case you didn't know, from what I hear Quicken 2003 contains
the
> > same Activation-based copy protection but I have not been able to verify
> > this.

> > I will not be upgrading beyond Quicken 2002 for this very reason.

> > Larry



> > > I will be sending Intuit a fairly scathing letter about
> > > > their practices and next year I'll be using some other product.
> > > > dave henrie

> > > What are they doing now thats makin everyone mad?


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.