rec.autos.simulators

OT: Question about network cards

Fatbo

OT: Question about network cards

by Fatbo » Thu, 04 Dec 2003 02:17:54

Sorry for the OT post, but I know that most of you simmers race online,
there fore you might know a thing or two about network cards.

I finally signed up for high-speed internet (Bell Canada's Symaptico), and
they do not provide the network card. So before I go off to buy my network
card, I was wondering if I should simply go with a no name brand NIC at $15
or is it better to go with a brand name (e.g. D-Link DFE-530TX at $20)? I'm
not on a network so I'm don't care for fancy features such as Wake-On-Lan,
and stuff, it's simply to interface with the DSL modem.

Thanks!

Darryl Johnso

OT: Question about network cards

by Darryl Johnso » Thu, 04 Dec 2003 03:43:19


Go with a brand name card. The no-name card *may* work perfectly
well, but if it doesn't, it can take you more than $5 worth of time
and aggrevation to get things diagnosed and fixed. I tend to go with
3Com cards exclusively, but I'm sure there are others out there that
are just as good.

--
  Darryl

TDRacin

OT: Question about network cards

by TDRacin » Thu, 04 Dec 2003 06:47:24

Look for a sale on a Netgear or Linksys.


Knekt

OT: Question about network cards

by Knekt » Thu, 04 Dec 2003 09:38:27

I have been using all 3Com and Linksys cards for years in hundreds of PC's
and have never had any problems.
The cheap no-name cards may be fine, but I don't want to be the one to find
out that they aren't.
I have always thought that quality and performance are worth a few extra
bucks in the end.

You can usually find the Linksys LNETX100 pretty cheap now days.
I have about twenty of these cards that have been running for a year with no
problems.

Hope this helps.

Dave


Dale Gree

OT: Question about network cards

by Dale Gree » Thu, 04 Dec 2003 11:33:07

Get the cheapest name-brand card that can do 10/100 speeds (in case you ever
have a home network) and goes in a PCI slot.  Look on the box for
compatibility with your operating system.

You're going to be looking at D-Link, Linksys or Netgear probably.  They
will all be fine.

Eldre

OT: Question about network cards

by Eldre » Thu, 04 Dec 2003 13:56:14



>Go with a brand name card. The no-name card *may* work perfectly
>well, but if it doesn't, it can take you more than $5 worth of time
>and aggrevation to get things diagnosed and fixed. I tend to go with
>3Com cards exclusively, but I'm sure there are others out there that
>are just as good.

Interesting.  Maybe I just got lucky.  I have a RealTek card.  It's made the
move through at least 3 different machines over about 5 years, and is still
going strong...
I think I paid about $29 for it at the time.
But I would agree that you cna't go wrong with 3Com.

Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Member
Screamers Racing League
IICC League
GPLRank -2.4    MoGPL rank +302.38
ChallengeRank +54.48   MoC +743.77
Hist. +82.82  MoH in progress
N2k3 rank:in progress

Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Jan Verschuere

OT: Question about network cards

by Jan Verschuere » Thu, 04 Dec 2003 20:47:35

I experienced some serious compatibility problems with 3Com cards now 6
years ago, so I switched to using RealTek chipset based KTI network cards
(one of those no-name brands) and have had no problems since.

Jan.
=---

Fatbo

OT: Question about network cards

by Fatbo » Fri, 05 Dec 2003 00:16:25

Thanks for all the replies guys!

I think I will be going with the D-Link DFE 538TX. It's the cheapest name
brand NIC I could find in my area at $19.99 CND (funny, the DFE 530TX was
the same price). That $15 no name brand had some many complaints of
disconnects and other issues.

So I have GPL, F1C, now maybe I should get NR2003 or NT2004.

Hope to race you guys online ASAP.


Darryl Johnso

OT: Question about network cards

by Darryl Johnso » Fri, 05 Dec 2003 00:50:23

Jan Verschueren wrote in

RealTek had some issues with their cards a number of years ago -- I
forget exactly how long ago it was. Everyone was crying the blues
over them in various hardware forums at the time. Obviously, they
have improved since then.

My only point was that for $5, buy the brand name card rather than
the no-name clone. If the difference had been $20, I would have said,
try the no-name card. You can return it if it doesn't work. However,
since it's gong to cost me more than $5 just in gas, to go back to
the store for a new card, why take a chance for such a small savings?

--
  Darryl

Larr

OT: Question about network cards

by Larr » Sat, 06 Dec 2003 03:52:51

NIC cards are a pet peeve of mine.  I HATE cheap NIC cards!

Like memory, this is an area I don't skimp in.  I buy only 3COM or Intel
corporate-class cards.  They are not that expensive, and support any feature
you might care to ever use.

Currently, I use the Intel Pro/1000 MT.  They are around $55 the last time I
looked.  Enterprise-class card with Enterprise-class performance for $55.
I'll probably own that card until Ethernet is replaced in the future
sometime :)

-Larry


Larr

OT: Question about network cards

by Larr » Sat, 06 Dec 2003 03:55:22

Another consideration...

NIC cards are not something you want to have to change a lot, especially if
you use Microsoft or other products that have that draconian "Product
Activation Feature".  NIC cards are one of the main components this ***
sinks it's claws in to for the authorization.

Hell, I can't even update the DRIVERS half the time without it pissing off
the Product Activation, and requiring a phone call to Microsoft.

Larry


Larr

OT: Question about network cards

by Larr » Sat, 06 Dec 2003 03:58:41

IMHO... You couldn't GIVE me a LinkSys NIC card.

Everytime someone at that place takes a breath, they change the friggin
chipset vendor they use, and they all take different drivers.

If you need a driver update for thier 10/100 card, you actually have to look
at pictures on their web site to find out which of the 5-7 (I forget the
exact count) chipsets your card has so you can get the right driver.

And the boxes all have the same exact part number.

I once bought three of these cards at CompUSA, and I'll be damned if they
all didn't have a DIFFERENT chipset, and require a different set of drivers.
All identical boxes with the same identical part number.

Screw LinkSys NIC cards :)

-Larry



> Look for a sale on a Netgear or Linksys.



> > Sorry for the OT post, but I know that most of you simmers race online,
> > there fore you might know a thing or two about network cards.

> > I finally signed up for high-speed internet (Bell Canada's Symaptico),
and
> > they do not provide the network card. So before I go off to buy my
network
> > card, I was wondering if I should simply go with a no name brand NIC at
> $15
> > or is it better to go with a brand name (e.g. D-Link DFE-530TX at $20)?
> I'm
> > not on a network so I'm don't care for fancy features such as
Wake-On-Lan,
> > and stuff, it's simply to interface with the DSL modem.

> > Thanks!


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.